0.999...
alternative decimal expansion of 1
≈ 21 min read
0.999.... encyclopegia.org, snapshot 0-999-081726-371ae1e24e7ca944. /a/0-999
Names in other languages
- Françaisdéveloppement décimal de l'unité
- English0.999...
- עברית0.999...
- 한국어0.999…
- 简体中文0.999…
- 繁體中文0.999…
- 中文0.999…
- be0,(9)
- Polski0,(9)
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
0.999... is a repeating decimal that represents the number 1. The three dots represent an infinite list of "9" digits. Following the standard rules for representing real numbers in decimal notation, its value is the smallest number greater than or equal to every number in the sequence 0.9, 0.99, 0.999, and so on.
It can be proved that this number is 1; that is, 0.999\ldots = 1. Despite common misconceptions, 0.999... is not "almost exactly 1" or "very, very nearly but not quite 1"; rather, "0.999..." and "1" represent the same number. There are many ways of showing this equality, from intuitive arguments to mathematically rigorous proofs.
The intuitive arguments are generally based on properties of finite decimals that are extended without proof to infinite decimals. An elementary but rigorous proof is given below that involves only elementary arithmetic and the Archimedean property: for each real number, there is a natural number that is greater (for example, by rounding up).
Other proofs generally involve basic properties of real numbers and methods of calculus, such as series and limits. Why some people reject this equality is a question studied in mathematics education. The equality is a special case of the fact that every non-zero terminating decimal has two equal representations (for example, 8.32000... and 8.31999...).
Everything that precedes refers to the decimal number system, that is to base 10. For other bases, everything remains true with 9 replaced with the largest digit. For example, in the binary number system, one has .
In some other number systems, 0.999... can have the same meaning, a different definition, or be undefined. : any point before the finish line lies between two of the points (inclusive).|class=skin-invert-image It is possible to prove the equation using just the mathematical tools of comparison and addition of (finite) decimal numbers, without any reference to more advanced topics. The proof given below is a direct formalization of the intuitive fact that, if one draws 0.9, 0.99, 0.999, etc. on the number line, there is no room left for placing a number between them and 1.
The meaning of the notation 0.999... is the least point on the number line lying to the right of all of the numbers 0.9, 0.99, 0.999, etc. Because there is ultimately no room between 1 and these numbers, the point 1 must be this least point, and so . The end of the proof requires that there be no positive number that is less than \frac{1}{10^n} for all .
This follows from the Archimedean property, which can be expressed as, "for every real number, there is a natural number that is greater". By computing the reciprocal, this implies that for every positive real number, there are natural numbers whose reciprocals are smaller. Therefore, for any positive real number, there must be some such that \frac{1}{10^n} is smaller.
This property implies that if for all , then can only be equal to 0. So, and 1 is the smallest number that is greater than all 0.9, 0.99, 0.999, etc. That is, , as claimed. This proof relies on the Archimedean property of rational and real numbers.
Real numbers may be enlarged into number systems, such as hyperreal numbers, with infinitely small numbers (infinitesimals) and infinitely large numbers (infinite numbers). When using such systems, the notation 0.999... is generally not used, as there is no smallest number among the numbers larger than all 0.(9) .
Algebraic arguments
Simple algebraic illustrations of equality are a subject of pedagogical discussion and critique. discusses the argument that, in elementary school, one is taught that , so, ignoring all essential subtleties, "multiplying" this identity by 3 gives . He further says that this argument is unconvincing, because of an unresolved ambiguity over the meaning of the equals sign; a student might think, "It surely does not mean that the number 1 is identical to that which is meant by the notation 0.999... ."
Most undergraduate mathematics majors encountered by Byers feel that while 0.999... is "very close" to 1 on the strength of this argument, with some even saying that it is "infinitely close", they are not ready to say that it is equal to 1. discusses how "this argument gets its force from the fact that most people have been indoctrinated to accept the first equation [i.e., that ] without thinking", but also suggests that the argument may lead skeptics to question this assumption. Byers also presents the following argument.
Students who did not accept the first argument sometimes accept the second argument, but, in Byers's opinion, still have not resolved the ambiguity, and therefore do not understand the representation of infinite decimals. , presenting the same argument, also state that it does not explain the equality, indicating that such an explanation would likely involve concepts of infinity and completeness. , citing , also conclude that the treatment of the identity based on such arguments as these, without the formal concept of a limit, is premature. concurs, arguing that knowing one can multiply 0.999... by 10 by shifting the decimal point presumes an answer to the deeper question of how one gives a meaning to the expression 0.999... at all. The same argument is also given by , who notes that skeptics may question whether x is cancellable that is, whether it makes sense to subtract x from both sides. similarly argues that both the multiplication and subtraction which removes the infinite decimal require further justification.
Analytic proofs
Real analysis is the study of the logical underpinnings of calculus, including the behavior of sequences and series of real numbers. The proofs in this section establish using techniques familiar from real analysis. b_0 . b_1 b_2 b_3 b_4 \ldots = b_0 + b_1\left({\tfrac{1}{10}}\right) + b_2\left({\tfrac{1}{10}}\right)^2 + b_3\left({\tfrac{1}{10}}\right)^3 + b_4\left({\tfrac{1}{10}}\right)^4 + \cdots .
For 0.999... one can apply the convergence theorem concerning geometric series, stating that if , then ar + ar^2 + ar^3 + \cdots = \frac{ar}{1-r}. Since 0.999... is such a sum with a = 9 and common ratio , the theorem makes short work of the question: 0.999\ldots = 0 + 9\left(\tfrac{1}{10}\right) + 9\left({\tfrac{1}{10}}\right)^2 + 9\left({\tfrac{1}{10}}\right)^3 + \cdots = \frac{9\left({\tfrac{1}{10}}\right)}{1-{\tfrac{1}{10}}} = 1.
This proof appears as early as 1770 in Leonhard Euler's Elements of Algebra. fraction sequence converging to 1.|class=skin-invert-image The sum of a geometric series is itself a result even older than Euler. A typical 18th-century derivation used a term-by-term manipulation similar to the algebraic proof given above, and as late as 1811, Bonnycastle's textbook An Introduction to Algebra uses such an argument for geometric series to justify the same maneuver on 0.999... .
A 19th-century reaction against such liberal summation methods resulted in the definition that still dominates today: the sum of a series is defined to be the limit of the sequence of its partial sums. A corresponding proof of the theorem explicitly computes that sequence; it can be found in several proof-based introductions to calculus or analysis.
A sequence has the value x as its limit if the distance \left\vert x - x_n \right\vert becomes arbitrarily small as n increases. The statement that can itself be interpreted and proven as a limit: 0.999\ldots \ \overset{\underset{\mathrm{def}}{}}{=} \ \lim_{n\to\infty}0.\underbrace{ 99\ldots9 }_{n} \ \overset{\underset{\mathrm{def}}{}}{=} \ \lim_{n\to\infty}\sum_{k = 1}^n\frac{9}{10^k} = \lim_{n\to\infty}\left(1-\frac{1}{10^n}\right) = 1-\lim_{n\to\infty}\frac{1}{10^n} = 1 - 0 = 1.
The first two equalities can be interpreted as symbol shorthand definitions. The remaining equalities can be proven. The last step, that 10 approaches 0 as n approaches infinity ( ), is often justified by the Archimedean property of the real numbers.
This limit-based attitude towards 0.999... is often put in more evocative but less precise terms. For example, the 1846 textbook The University Arithmetic explains, ".999 +, continued to infinity = 1, because every annexation of a 9 brings the value closer to 1"; the 1895 Arithmetic for Schools says, "when a large number of 9s is taken, the difference between 1 and .99999... becomes inconceivably small".
Such heuristics are often incorrectly interpreted by students as implying that 0.999... itself is less than 1. x = b_0.b_1b_2b_3 \ldots . In this formalism, the identities and reflect, respectively, the fact that 1 lies in both . and , so one can choose either subinterval when finding its digits.
To ensure that this notation does not abuse the "=" sign, one needs a way to reconstruct a unique real number for each decimal. This can be done with limits, but other constructions continue with the ordering theme.
One straightforward choice is the nested intervals theorem, which guarantees that given a sequence of nested, closed intervals whose lengths become arbitrarily small, the intervals contain exactly one real number in their intersection. So , , , ... is defined to be the unique number contained within all the intervals , , and so on.
0.999... is then the unique real number that lies in all of the intervals , , , and for every finite string of 9s. Since 1 is an element of each of these intervals, . The nested intervals theorem is usually founded upon a more fundamental characteristic of the real numbers: the existence of least upper bounds or suprema.
To directly exploit these objects, one may define ... to be the least upper bound of the set of approximants , , , ... . One can then show that this definition (or the nested intervals definition) is consistent with the subdivision procedure, implying again.
Tom Apostol concludes, "the fact that a real number might have two different decimal representations is merely a reflection of the fact that two different sets of real numbers can have the same supremum."
Proofs from the construction of the real numbers
Some approaches explicitly define real numbers to be certain structures built upon the rational numbers, using axiomatic set theory. The natural numbers begin with 0 and continue upwards so that every number has a successor. One can extend the natural numbers with their negatives to give all the integers, and to further extend to ratios, giving the rational numbers.
These number systems are accompanied by the arithmetic of addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division. More subtly, they include ordering, so that one number can be compared to another and found to be less than, greater than, or equal to another number. The step from rationals to reals is a major extension.
There are at least two popular ways to achieve this step, both published in 18721: Dedekind cuts and Cauchy sequences. Proofs that that directly uses these constructions are not found in textbooks on real analysis, where the modern trend for the last few decades has been to use an axiomatic analysis.
Even when a construction is offered, it is usually applied toward proving the axioms of the real numbers, which then support the above proofs. However, several authors express the idea that starting with a construction is more logically appropriate, and the resulting proofs are more self-contained. 1-\frac{1}{10^n} = 0.(9)_n = 0.\underbrace{99\ldots 9}_{n\text{ nines}}.
Every element of 0.999... is less than 1, so it is an element of the real number 1. Conversely, all elements of 1 are rational numbers that can be written as \frac{a}{b} with b > 0 and .
This implies 1-\frac{a}{b} = \frac{b-a}{b} \ge \frac{1}{b} > \frac{1}{10^b}, and thus \frac{a}{b} Since 1-\frac{1}{10^b} = 0.(9)_b by the definition above, every element of 1 is also an element of 0.999..., and, combined with the proof above that every element of 0.999... is also an element of 1, the sets 0.999... and 1 contain the same rational numbers, and are therefore the same set, that is, . The definition of real numbers as Dedekind cuts was first published by Richard Dedekind in 1872.
The above approach to assigning a real number to each decimal expansion is due to an expository paper titled "Is ?" by Fred Richman in Mathematics Magazine. Richman notes that taking Dedekind cuts in any dense subset of the rational numbers yields the same results; in particular, he uses decimal fractions, for which the proof is more immediate.
He also notes that typically the definitions allow to be a cut but not (or vice versa). A further modification of the procedure leads to a different structure where the two are not equal.
Although it is consistent, many of the common rules of decimal arithmetic no longer hold, for example, the fraction \frac{1}{3} has no representation; see below. \left(1 - 0, 1 - {9 \over 10}, 1 - {99 \over 100}, \ldots\right) = \left(1, {1 \over 10}, {1 \over 100}, \ldots \right) has a limit 0. Considering the th term of the sequence, for , it must therefore be shown that \lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}\frac{1}{10^n} = 0.
This can be proved by the definition of a limit. So again, . The definition of real numbers as Cauchy sequences was first published separately by Eduard Heine and Georg Cantor, also in 1872.
The above approach to decimal expansions, including the proof that , closely follows Griffiths & Hilton's 1970 work A comprehensive textbook of classical mathematics: A contemporary interpretation. \frac{1}{7} = 0. and . \frac{1}{73} = 0. and . E. Midy proved a general result about such fractions, now called Midy's theorem, in 1836.
The publication was obscure, and it is unclear whether his proof directly involved 0.999..., but at least one modern proof by William G. Leavitt does. If it can be proved that if a decimal of the form ... is a positive integer, then it must be 0.999..., which is then the source of the 9s in the theorem.
Investigations in this direction can motivate such concepts as greatest common divisors, modular arithmetic, Fermat primes, order of group elements, and quadratic reciprocity. Returning to real analysis, the base-3 analogue plays a key role in the characterization of one of the simplest fractals, the middle-thirds Cantor set: a point in the unit interval lies in the Cantor set if and only if it can be represented in ternary using only the digits 0 and 2.
The th digit of the representation reflects the position of the point in the th stage of the construction. For example, the point \frac{2}{3} is given the usual representation of 0.2 or 0.2000..., since it lies to the right of the first deletion and the left of every deletion thereafter.
The point \frac{1}{3} is represented not as 0.1 but as 0.0222..., since it lies to the left of the first deletion and the right of every deletion thereafter. Repeating nines also turns up in yet another of Georg Cantor's works. They must be taken into account to construct a valid proof, applying his 1891 diagonal argument to decimal expansions, of the uncountability of the unit interval.
Such a proof needs to be able to declare certain pairs of real numbers to be different based on their decimal expansions, so one needs to avoid pairs like 0.2 and 0.1999... A simple method represents all numbers with nonterminating expansions; the opposite method rules out repeating nines.
A variant that may be closer to Cantor's original argument uses base 2, and by turning base-3 expansions into base-2 expansions, one can prove the uncountability of the Cantor set as well. The elementary argument of multiplying by 3 can convince reluctant students that 0.999... = 1.
Still, when confronted with the conflict between their belief in the first equation and their disbelief in the second, some students either begin to disbelieve the first equation or simply become frustrated. Nor are more sophisticated methods foolproof: students who are fully capable of applying rigorous definitions may still fall back on intuitive images when they are surprised by a result in advanced mathematics, including 0.999... .
For example, one real analysis student was able to prove that using a supremum definition but then insisted that based on her earlier understanding of long division. Others still can prove that , but, upon being confronted by the fractional proof, insist that "logic" supersedes the mathematical calculations. tells the tale of an otherwise brilliant calculus student of his who "challenged almost everything I said in class but never questioned his calculator", and who had come to believe that nine digits are all one needs to do mathematics, including calculating the square root of 23.
The student remained uncomfortable with a limiting argument that , calling it a "wildly imagined infinite growing process". As part of the APOS Theory of mathematical learning, propose that students who conceive of 0.999... as a finite, indeterminate string with an infinitely small distance from 1 have "not yet constructed a complete process conception of the infinite decimal".
Other students who have a complete process conception of 0.999... may not yet be able to "encapsulate" that process into an "object conception", like the object conception they have of 1, and so they view the process 0.999... and the object 1 as incompatible. They also link this mental ability of encapsulation to viewing \frac{1}{3} as a number in its own right and to dealing with the set of natural numbers as a whole.
A 2003 edition of the general-interest newspaper column The Straight Dope discusses 0.999... via \frac{1}{3} and limits, saying of misconceptions, A Slate article reports that the concept of 0.999... is "hotly disputed on websites ranging from World of Warcraft message boards to Ayn Rand forums". 0.999... features also in mathematical jokes, such as: The fact that 0.999... is equal to 1 has been compared to Zeno's paradox of the runner.
The runner paradox can be mathematically modeled and then, like 0.999..., resolved using a geometric series. However, it is not clear whether this mathematical treatment addresses the underlying metaphysical issues Zeno was exploring.
In alternative number systems
Although the real numbers form an extremely useful number system, the decision to interpret the notation "0.999..." as naming a real number is ultimately a convention, and Timothy Gowers argues in Mathematics: A Very Short Introduction that the resulting identity is a convention as well: 0.d_1d_2d_3 \ldots;\ldots d_{\infty - 1}d_\infty d_{\infty + 1}\ldots, indexed by the hypernatural numbers. While he does not directly discuss 0.999..., he shows the real number \frac{1}{3} is represented by 0.333...;...333..., which is a consequence of the transfer principle.
As a consequence the number . With this type of decimal representation, not every expansion represents a number. In particular "0.333...;...000..." and "0.999...;...000..." do not correspond to any number.
The standard definition of the number 0.999... is the limit of the sequence 0.9, 0.99, 0.999, ... . A different definition involves an ultralimit, i.e., the equivalence class of this sequence in the ultrapower construction, which is a number that falls short of 1 by an infinitesimal amount.
More generally, the hyperreal number , with last digit 9 at infinite hypernatural rank , satisfies a strict inequality . Accordingly, an alternative interpretation for "zero followed by infinitely many 9s" could be 0.\underbrace{999\ldots}_H = 1 - \frac{1}{10^{H}}. All such interpretations of "0.999..." are infinitely close to 1.
Ian Stewart characterizes this interpretation as an "entirely reasonable" way to rigorously justify the intuition that "there's a little bit missing" from 1 in 0.999.... Along with , also questions the assumption that students' ideas about are erroneous intuitions about the real numbers, interpreting them rather as nonstandard intuitions that could be valuable in the learning of calculus.
Combinatorial game theory provides a generalized concept of number that encompasses the real numbers and much more besides. For example, in 1974, Elwyn Berlekamp described a correspondence between strings of red and blue segments in Hackenbush and binary expansions of real numbers, motivated by the idea of data compression.
For example, the value of the Hackenbush string LRRLRLRL... is However, the value of LRLLL... (corresponding to 0.111... 2 ) is infinitesimally less than 1.
The difference between the two is the surreal number \frac{1}{\omega} , where \omega is the first infinite ordinal; the relevant game is LRRRR... or 0.000... 2 . This is true of the binary expansions of many rational numbers, where the values of the numbers are equal but the corresponding binary tree paths are different.
For example, , which are both equal to , but the first representation corresponds to the binary tree path LRLRLLL..., while the second corresponds to the different path LRLLRRR... . \ldots999 = 9 + 9(10) + 9(10)^2 + 9(10)^3 + \cdots = \frac{9}{1-10} = -1. Compare with the series in the section above.
A third derivation was invented by a seventh-grader who was doubtful over her teacher's limiting argument that but was inspired to take the multiply-by-10 proof above in the opposite direction: if , then , so , hence again. In the 10-adics, is not a meaningful expansion, because the partial sums do not converge.
As a final extension, since (in the reals) and (in the 10-adics), then by "blind faith and unabashed juggling of symbols" one may add the two equations and arrive at . This equation does not make sense either as a 10-adic expansion or an ordinary decimal expansion, but it turns out to be meaningful and true in the doubly infinite decimal expansion of the 10-adic solenoid, with eventually repeating left ends to represent the real numbers and eventually repeating right ends to represent the 10-adic numbers.
This book gives a "careful rigorous" introduction to real analysis. It gives the axioms of the real numbers and then constructs them (pp. 27–31) as infinite decimals with 0.999... = 1 as part of the definition. A textbook for an advanced undergraduate course.
"Experience has convinced me that it is pedagogically unsound (though logically correct) to start off with the construction of the real numbers from the rational ones. At the beginning, most students simply fail to appreciate the need for doing this.
Accordingly, the real number system is introduced as an ordered field with the least-upper-bound property, and a few interesting applications of this property are quickly made. However, Dedekind's construction is not omitted. It is now in an Appendix to Chapter 1, where it may be studied and enjoyed whenever the time is ripe."
(p. ix) This book aims to "assist students in discovering calculus" and "to foster conceptual understanding". (p. v) It omits proofs of the foundations of calculus. .999999... = 1? from Cut-the-Knot Why does 0.9999... = 1 ?
Proof of the equality based on arithmetic from Math Central David Tall's research on mathematics cognition What is so wrong with thinking of real numbers as infinite decimals? Theorem 0.999... on Metamath
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378555664 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “0.999...” publication date (×3) · confidence 0.95 revision URL