Andrew Malcolm (author)
Andrew Malcolm (born 10 October 1948) is a British author and campaigner.
≈ 6 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Andrew Malcolm (born 10 October 1948) is a British author and campaigner. He pursued a seven-year-long breach-of-contract claim against Oxford University Press, which he won with a landmark legal judgment in the Court of Appeal in 1990.
Reporting on the verdict in The Observer, Laurence Marks wrote, "It is the first time in living memory that Grub Street has won such a victory over its oppressors". The case ended in July 1992 with a Tomlin order, a damages settlement under the terms of which the servants and agents of Oxford University are permanently barred from denigrating Malcolm or his work Making Names.
Making Names is the first book in literary history to be afforded such legal protection. Malcolm campaigned against the charitable status and tax exemption of the Oxford University Press, and was described by Private Eye as "the scourge of OUP".
Authors' royalties and 'sheet dealing'
While the contract case clarified and in certain respects extended authors' rights, the ensuing assessment of damages proceedings (1991–1992) shed light on modern royalty agreements. In particular, the assessment dealt with 'sheet dealing'.
Rather than, as formerly, paying royalties based on a book's cover price, publishers nowadays often prefer to pay royalties based on the publisher's net receipts, a practice which facilitates, amongst other things, multinational 'sheet dealing'. One of Malcolm's witnesses, author and former publishing executive Frederick Nolan, explained how this could benefit publishers at the expense of authors:
Borders incident
Malcolm was invited by Borders in Oxford to hold a talk and book-signing session there on 4 October 2002. At the last minute, the event was cancelled by store management. According to a report in the Daily Telegraph, the event then "turned into farce when the management called the police, who arrived in three squad cars.
Eight officers escorted the author and his audience from the shop, which said they were trespassing." Malcolm told the Oxford Mail, "this must have been the oddest invited book-signing in history: no window display, no poster, just an author quietly addressing his peaceable audience, while a team of security men solemnly requisitioned their table and chairs.
It was not so much Nazi Germany as Monty Python. Now we know what free speech means in Oxford. In a way it's flattering.
I never realised that what I have to say is so dangerous." Following complaints from the public, Borders' international president Vin Altruda and UK managing director Philip Downer apologised: "We sincerely regret and apologise for the cancellation of Andrew Malcolm's event in Oxford, which should have gone ahead."
Under heavy security, Malcolm's talk "Where is the university?" was rescheduled and held at a Borders store in Charing Cross Road, London, on 30 January 2003. Private Eye reported, "Andrew Malcolm, the scourge of OUP (Eyes passim), returned in triumph last week to the chain's Charing Cross Road store in London to pick up where he had left off."
Akme Literary, Charity and Student Law libraries
In 1997 Malcolm launched an online law library posting various legal resources concerning publishing law. In 2006, www.akme was cited by the UK Charity Commission's consultation as having been influential in the new 'public benefit' requirement of the 2006 Charities Act with respect to the status of the university presses.
The Act provoked fresh debate about the likely reform of the presses' tax liability. In 2009, The Guardian invited Malcolm to write an article on the subject. In January 2006, Oxford became the first UK university to require enrolling students to sign contracts setting out a series of obligations.
In response, Malcolm launched the Akme Student Law Library, providing a free archive of cases and other materials relating to university-student and college-student contract law. It is claimed on the website that in October 2013, all the site's search links were erased from Google and the other internet search engines.
Campaign for Oxford chancellor
In March 2003, following the death of Roy Jenkins, Malcolm ran for the post of Chancellor of Oxford University. According to a report in The Guardian, he put himself forward as a "hands-on reformer", promising to save Oxford's "battered reputation for integrity and academic excellence and help it regain its lost place amongst the front rank of the world's universities."
Malcolm said he would "eradicate corruption, cash-for-places, croneyism, fustian bureaucracy and the many other such problems that have bedevilled and lately publicly disgraced the university." Malcolm was later forced to withdraw from the contest because the university registry claimed that eight of his nominators had not received an Oxford degree.
The Remedy 3.0 and The Remedy 3.1
In 20251, more than 20 years after the second edition of The Remedy, Malcolm, via Amazon KDP, published an expanded third edition, The Remedy 3.0. Its 37 new chapters brought the story up to date, widening its scope to include more recent OUP and Oxford University controversies.
The book included a table, based on OUP’s archive of annual accounts, showing that in the eleven years from 2008 to 2019 the press had amassed untaxed profits of over £1 billion. After the book’s publication, OUP withdrew its archive and from 2020 to 2023 it stopped publishing its accounts. In November 2025, this prompted Malcolm to launch his own archive of OUP’s accounts.
In February 20261, Malcolm published a fourth edition, The Remedy 3.1: How Oxford turned Scofflaw. This included two new chapters. 'Casualties' looked at Oxford's use of casual 'Deliveroo-style' service-provider contracts for academics.
A second new chapter 'Accountability' told the story of OUP's withdrawal of its internet archive of annual accounts, in breach of the 2011 Charities Act. Malcolm concluded, "We have witnessed Oxford's contempt for publishing law and employment law. Now we have its breach of UK charity law.
It has turned scofflaw."
Works
Andrew Malcolm, Making Names, AKME publications, 1992 (Hardback), 1993 (Paperback) and Andrew Malcolm, The Remedy, AKME publications, published 19991, second edition 2002. Andrew Malcolm, The Remedy 3.0, AKME publications, published 2025. Andrew Malcolm, The Remedy 3.1: How Oxford Turned Scofflaw, AKME publications, published 2026.
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378735554 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
1 claim could not be tied to a specific sentence and is listed in the table below instead.
- ↩Wikipedia “Andrew Malcolm (author)” publication date (×3) · confidence 0.95 revision URL