Binding problem
≈ 5 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
The unity of consciousness and (cognitive) binding problem is the problem of how objects, background, and abstract or emotional features are combined into a single experience. The binding problem refers to the overall encoding of our brain circuits for the combination of decisions, actions, and perception. It is considered a "problem" because no complete model exists.
The binding problem can be subdivided into the four areas of perception, neuroscience, cognitive science, and the philosophy of mind. It includes general considerations on coordination, the subjective unity of perception, and variable binding.
The unity of consciousness and (cognitive) binding problem is the problem of how objects, background, and abstract or emotional features are combined into a single experience. The binding problem refers to the overall encoding of our brain circuits for the combination of decisions, actions, and perception. It is considered a "problem" because no complete model exists.
The binding problem can be subdivided into the four areas of perception, neuroscience, cognitive science, and the philosophy of mind. It includes general considerations on coordination, the subjective unity of perception, and variable binding. An implication of these approaches is that sensory data such as color or motion may not normally exist in "unallocated" form.
For Merker: "The 'red' of a red ball does not float disembodied in an abstract color space in V4." If color information allocated to a point in the visual field is converted directly, via the instantiation of some form of propositional logic (analogous to that used in computer design) into color information allocated to an "object identity" postulated by a top-down signal as suggested by Purves and Lotto (e.g. There is blue here + Object 1 is here = Object 1 is blue) no special computational task of "binding together" by means such as synchrony may exist.
(Although Von der Malsburg poses the problem in terms of binding "propositions" such as "triangle" and "top", these, in isolation, are not propositional.) How signals in the brain come to have propositional content, or meaning, is a much larger issue.
However, both Marr and Barlow suggested, on the basis of what was known about neural connectivity in the 1970s that the final integration of features into a percept would be expected to resemble the way words operate in sentences. The role of synchrony in segregational binding remains controversial.
Merker has recently suggested that synchrony may be a feature of areas of activation in the brain that relates to an "infrastructural" feature of the computational system analogous to increased oxygen demand indicated via BOLD signal contrast imaging. Apparent specific correlations with segregational tasks may be explainable on the basis of interconnectivity of the areas involved.
As a possible manifestation of a need to balance excitation and inhibition over time it might be expected to be associated with reciprocal re-entrant circuits as in the model of Anil Seth. (Merker gives the analogy of the whistle from an audio amplifier receiving its own output.)
Shared intentionality and binding
According to bioengineer Igor Val Danilov, the mother–fetus neurocognitive model —knowledge about neurophysiological processes during shared intentionality—can reveal insights into the binding problem and even the perception of object development since intentionality succeeds before organisms confront the binding problem. Indeed, at the beginning of life, the environment is the cacophony of stimuli: electromagnetic waves, chemical interactions, and pressure fluctuations.
Because the environment is uncategorised for the organisms at this beginning stage of development, the sensation is too limited by the noise to solve the cue problem—the relevant stimulus cannot overcome the noise magnitude if it passes through the senses. While very young organisms need to combine objects, background and abstract or emotional features into a single experience for building the representation of the surrounded reality, they cannot distinguish relevant sensory stimuli independently to integrate them into object representations.
Even the embodied dynamical system approach cannot get around the cue to noise problem. The application of embodied information requires an already categorised environment onto objects—holistic representation of reality—which occurs through (and only after the emergence of) perception and intentionality.
In short, properties of the mother's heart—the electromagnetic and acoustic oscillations—converge the neuronal activity of both nervous systems in an ensemble, shaping synchrony. During the mother's intentional acts with her environment, these interchanges provide clues to the fetus's nervous system, binding synaptic activity with relevant stimuli, occurring due to brain wave interaction between the mother's and fetal nervous systems.
See also
Artificial Intelligence Frame problem Hard problem of consciousness Neural coding Philosophy of perception Problem of mental causation Symbol grounding Vertiginous question Synesthesia
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378737862 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.