Colonial Advocate

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 9 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

The Colonial Advocate was a weekly political journal published in Upper Canada during the 1820s and 1830s. First published by William Lyon Mackenzie on May 18, 1824, the journal frequently attacked the Upper Canada aristocracy known as the "Family Compact", which governed the province. Over its twelve years in publication, Mackenzie explicitly advocated constitutional change to resemble a more American government with the principles of responsible government, and working for the greater good of the people.

The Colonial Advocate was used as a voice for constitutional reform, educating and inspiring citizens to take action against their government, making Mackenzie and his paper an important leader in the formation of the Upper Canada Rebellion of 1837.

The Colonial Advocate was a weekly political journal published in Upper Canada during the 1820s and 1830s. First published by William Lyon Mackenzie on May 18, 1824, the journal frequently attacked the Upper Canada aristocracy known as the "Family Compact", which governed the province. Over its twelve years in publication, Mackenzie explicitly advocated constitutional change to resemble a more American government with the principles of responsible government, and working for the greater good of the people.

The Colonial Advocate was used as a voice for constitutional reform, educating and inspiring citizens to take action against their government, making Mackenzie and his paper an important leader in the formation of the Upper Canada Rebellion of 1837.

Constitutional reform

During the decade preceding the rebellion, Mackenzie advocated many reforms relating to the banking system, custom dues, heavy legal fees, education, the postal service, jury selection. He criticized the powers of the appointed justices, the granting of corporate privileges ultimately leading to the bitter relationship between Mackenzie and the group of officials named "The Family Compact".

At the beginning of his political career, Mackenzie called himself a "whig of 88" which represented the particular British constitutional idea of government known as Whiggery—which is largely what we have in Canada today. It is the idea that responsible government is an essential part of a constitutional monarchy.

However his political views begin to change and began to admire the American political regime. In the first edition of the Colonial Advocate, he writes, "we would never wish to see British America an appendage of the American presidency; yet we would wish to see British American thrive and prosper as well does that presidency."

Having lived there for a few years, Mackenzie got to experience first hand this sort of democracy. On January 3, 1828, he published article titled "We The People" further discussing constitutional reform, ""the constitution of a country is not the act of its government, nor of any distant authority, but of the people constituting a government suited to their necessities -- a constitution contains the principles on which the government shall be established" once again displaying his desire to have a government that supports the people.

Public education

As society was developing, there became a higher demand for education. Based on the principles of responsible government, education was a struggle. This was for two main reasons.

First, one of the main arguments arguing against responsible government was that there were not enough educated people who should be a part of government. On September 22, 1831, the Colonial Advocate published, "we have been informed that in the most populous country township in the home district there is not at this time of the year more than one school of ten scholars, altho' the number of persons between 6 and 16 is over 600!!!"

Mackenzie then highlighted how this was part of the Family Compact's plan to stay in control, "this is the best practical commentary upon Dr. Strachan's system of education for keeping the great mass of people in ignorance and educating and instructing a few sons of pensioners and placement to hold them in the chains of mental bondage." Second, keeping education under the rule of the Church of England sustained English rule in Canada.

Strachan obtained permission from the Colonial Office to create a university, he saw it is as a place to "groom the ruling elite". However Mackenzie immediately sent a letter to the Governor General of Canada at the time, Lord Dalhousie, to get it revoked.

He believed that education should be open to everyone, and as described in his is political pamphlet, "Catechisms of Education", he claimed "political education consists in a right understanding of the science of government… an agent employed in the forming the character of man...the strength of the whole depends on it". Mackenzie ensued the Colonial Advocate once again to attack Strachan and the Family Compact's ideals, and voiced these opinions through his papers and other publications.

Response to Types Riot

Although more of an attack than a "riot", the damages were plentiful. There were many witnesses, yet the eight men prosecuted went without criminal charges. This was believed to be due to their socioeconomic status.

Mackenzie did not sit back and let this group of men go unpunished. He wrote a letter to the "Honourable Knights Citizens of Burgesses, representing the Commons of the United Kingdom and Britain and Ireland" describing the details of the riot, and the unfair results of the judiciary.

After going back and suing the rioters, this time with more witnesses and with a legal team, he was able to succeed, earning Mackenzie enough money to repair the damage and more. This money re-established the Colonial Advocate. All this negative press was creating a bad image for the Family Compact members.

Soon after, Samuel Jarvis, a member of the Family Compact and a convicted rioter, published "The Statement of Facts Relating to the Trespass on the Printing Press in the Possession of Mr. William Lyon Mackenzie" which addressed the public and particularly the subscribers of the Colonial Advocate. Afraid of the reputation he had gained from these riots, he felt it upon himself to try and excuse his actions.

"I cannot, in justice to myself, or to those implicated through my indiscretion, remain longer silent, and quietly witness this second attempt at imposition, without an effort to counteract its wicked and mischievous tendency" and continues, "I had sufficient experience of the uncompromising baseness of Mr. Mackenzie's disposition, and could not doubt he would descend to the meanest and most contemptible artifices, and use the most strenuous exertions to paralyze the effect which a candid and indgenuous relation of facts was calculated to produce on the minds of a generous and impartial public." This publication demonstrates the believed power of the Colonial Advocate.

Members of the Family Compact feared its ability to influence readers and the general public, and for this they decided the need to attack it in attempts to scare it away.

The end of the Colonial Advocate

The Colonial Advocate began as Mackenzie's first political endeavour. It became a voice for him to display his own political agenda and thoughts, made him known throughout Upper Canada (although not necessarily well-liked among all groups), as well as allowed him to gain a support group for constitutional reform.

The Colonial Advocate created new stream of thought for the citizens of Upper Canada, bringing to attention the government of the United States to highlight different ways of governance for the benefit of the people, as well as displaying the injustices and inequalities condoned by The Family Compact. The Colonial Advocate became a "vehicle for theoretical sovereignty" instigating resulting in activism in Upper Canada.

The last issue of Colonial Advocate was published in November 18341. A year before the 1837 Upper Canada Rebellion, Mackenzie wrote what would summarize his belief on newspapers and politics: "one thing is certain, no free popular government can exist unless people are informed. An ignorant republic would surely degenerate into a most corrupt and hateful government."

References

Bibliography Craig, G. M. "The American Impact on the Upper Canadian Reform Movement Before 1837." Canadian Historical Review 29.4 (1948): 333–52. University of Toronto Press.

Web. October 11, 2011. Gates, Lillian F. "The Decided Policy of William Lyon Mackenzie."

Canadian Historical Review 40.3 (1959): 185–208. University of Toronto Press. Web.

October 11, 2011. Jarvis, Samuel Peters. Statement of Facts Relating to the Trespass on the Printing Press in the Possession of Mr. William Lyon Mackenzie, in June 1826 Addressed to the Public Generally and Particularly to the Subscribers and Supporters of the Colonial Advocate.

Ancaster, Ont.?: S.n., 1828. Microfilm. Web.

November 14, 2011. . Kilbourn, William. Firebrand: William Lyon Mackenzie & the Rebellion in Upper Canada.

Toronto, Ont.: Dundurn, 2008. Print. Lindsey, Charles.

William Lyon Mackenzie. 2004. Google Books MacKay, R. A. "The Political Ideas of William Lyon Mackenzie."

The Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science 3.1 (1937): 1-22. Google Scholar. Web.

October 11, 2011 Mackenzie, William Lyon. "The History of the Destruction of the Colonial Advocate Press by Officers of the Provincial Government of Upper Canada and Law Students of the Attorney & Solicitor General in Open Day: and in Presence of the Honourable William Allan, a Police Magistrate and Collector of the Customs and Stephen Heward Esquire, Auditor General of the Colony Part II."

Hume Tracts (1827): 1-26. Print. Rasporich, Anthony W. Canadian History Through the Press Series: William Lyon Mackenzie.

Toronto: Holt, Rinehart and Winston of Canada, 1972. Print. Valpy, Michael.

"SMC315." Class Lecture SMC315. Alumni Hall, Toronto.

November 28, 2011. Lecture. "William Lyon Mackenzie."

Canadian History. Electric Scotland. Web.

October 10, 2011. Wilton, Carol. "Lawless Law."

Law and History Review 13.1 (1995): 111–36. JSTOR. Web.

October 11, 2011. . Notes

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1355791755 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

References

1 claim could not be tied to a specific sentence and is listed in the table below instead.

  1. ↩Wikipedia “Colonial Advocate” revision 1355791755 · retrieved 2026-10-20 publication date (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL