comprised of

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Q19862976Snapshot

≈ 7 min read

Names in other languages

  • Englishcomprised of
  • 日本語Comprised of

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

Comprised of is an expression in English that means "which consists of". For instance, one might say that "A string quartet is comprised of two violinists, a violist, and a cellist". The phrase is notable for being the subject of a usage controversy because the word "comprise", when used on its own as an active verb, traditionally assigns the opposite thematic roles. For instance, one can say that "A string quartet comprises two violinists, a violist, and a cellist".

As a result, some prescriptivists object to the phrase, viewing it as an erosion of the distinction between "compose" and "comprise". The usage controversy has been ongoing since the mid-20th century. Objections to the phrase have been severely criticized by linguists including Mark Liberman, who notes examples of its use by highly regarded writers dating back to the 1700s.

The phrase was added to the Oxford English Dictionary in 1874 and is generally regarded as standard by dictionaries and style guides, though some (including Merriam-Webster OnLine) observe that its use may invite criticism from language purists. One Wikipedia editor's efforts to remove every occurrence of "comprised of" from Wikipedia received widespread media coverage in 2015.

Comprised of is an expression in English that means "which consists of". For instance, one might say that "A string quartet is comprised of two violinists, a violist, and a cellist". The phrase is notable for being the subject of a usage controversy because the word "comprise", when used on its own as an active verb, traditionally assigns the opposite thematic roles. For instance, one can say that "A string quartet comprises two violinists, a violist, and a cellist".

As a result, some prescriptivists object to the phrase, viewing it as an erosion of the distinction between "compose" and "comprise". The usage controversy has been ongoing since the mid-20th century. Objections to the phrase have been severely criticized by linguists including Mark Liberman, who notes examples of its use by highly regarded writers dating back to the 1700s.

The phrase was added to the Oxford English Dictionary in 1874 and is generally regarded as standard by dictionaries and style guides, though some (including Merriam-Webster OnLine) observe that its use may invite criticism from language purists. One Wikipedia editor's efforts to remove every occurrence of "comprised of" from Wikipedia received widespread media coverage in 2015.

In US patents

Comprised of is used in US patents as a transition phrase that means "consisting at least of". It is a less-common form of comprises. 134,000 U.S. patents included the phrase.

In US law

In the context of legal usage, the American lexicographer Bryan A. Garner writes that "The phrase is comprised of is always wrong and should be replaced by either is composed of or comprises." (American linguist Mark Liberman points out that the U.S. Code "apparently includes some 1,880 instances of 'comprised of', and changing them will require many acts of Congress..." )

Evaluations

Comprised of is often deprecated. The authors of The Blue Book of Grammar and Punctuation state that comprised of is never correct because the word comprise by itself already means "composed of". CliffsNotes says "don't use the phrase 'is comprised of'" and does not include an explanation. The acceptance of the phrase has increased in recent decades. In the 1960s, 53 percent of the writers and editors on the Usage Panel of the American Heritage Dictionary found comprised of unacceptable.

In 1996, this percentage had declined to 35 percent, and by 2011, only 32 percent of the Usage Panel's membership objected to the use of comprised of. As one of "7 grammar rules you really should pay attention to", University of Delaware journalism and English professor Ben Yagoda says "Don't use comprised of.

Instead use composed of/made up of." The style guide for the British newspaper The Guardian says that "The one thing [about comprise, consist, compose or constitute] to avoid, unless you want people who care about such things to give you a look composed of, consisting of and comprising mingled pity and contempt, is 'comprised of . Reuters' style guide also advises against using the phrase, as does the IBM style guide.

Simon Heffer elaborated on a short warning in his book Strictly English with a longer one in his Simply English: "A book may comprise fifteen chapters, but it is not comprised of them. Those who say or write such a thing are confusing it with composed of.

Another correct way to make the point would be to say that the book 'was constituted of fifteen chapters' or that 'the fifteen chapters constituted the book'." Certain usage guides warn their readers about the meaning of comprise – despite the appearance within respected dictionaries of the use they deprecate (see "Semantics") – but do not mention comprised of. These include Gowers and Fraser's The Complete Plain Words and the style guides of The Economist and The Times. Other usage compendia have no comment on either comprised of or comprise.

Although the Oxford English Dictionary notes that certain usages of other words are disparaged, it does not comment on the acceptability of comprised of (which it glosses as "To be composed of, to consist of"). Overt defenses of comprised of are uncommon, but Harvard University psychology professor Steven Pinker considers its deprecation to be one of "a few fuss-budget decrees you can safely ignore".

Oliver Kamm defends it, together with the verb comprise used in the active voice: "Merriam-Webster observes that this disputed usage has been in existence for more than a century. The active version of the disputed usage is older still. Neither is unclear in the context; both are legitimate." Conversely, Edinburgh University linguistics professor Geoffrey K. Pullum writes "I'd happily comply with an edict limiting comprise to its original sense ... I see no reason to favor the inverted sense.

There's nothing virtuous about the ambiguity and auto-antonymy it promotes. It's easier than you'd think for unclarity to arise about whether an author is saying some abstract X makes up Y or that it consists of Y."

Variants

According to the Oxford Dictionaries, the related construction "x comprises of y and z" is considered incorrect.

Removal from Wikipedia

In 2015, many media outlets, starting with Backchannel, reported that Wikipedia editor Bryan Henderson had manually removed tens of thousands of instances of the phrase comprised of from Wikipedia. Some coverage praised the work as a uniquely focused effort for correctness, but others criticized it as grammatically misguided. Linguist Geoffrey K. Pullum expressed approval of the principle but also doubt about its practicality, saying he would be happy for the editor's "clarifying mission" to succeed. However, Pullum said he "wouldn't bet a dime on his success". Fellow linguist Geoffrey Nunberg has described Henderson's ongoing efforts against the use of the phrase as a "jihad" and an "example of the pedant's veto", and said that the Wikipedia community was "resigned to letting him have his way" despite his mission being illogical.

External links

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378801646 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

No external citation was extracted for this revision. That is a statement about the source, not a claim that none exists.