Lesson plan

Conservativity

In formal semantics conservativity is a proposed linguistic universal which states that any determiner D must obey the equivalence D(A,B) \leftrightarrow D(A, A\cap B) . For instance, the English determiner "every" can be seen to be conservative by the equivalence of the following two sentences, schematized in generalized quantifier notation to the right. # Every aardvark bites. \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \rightsquigarrow every(A,B) # Every aardvark is an aardvark that bites. \ \ \rightsquigarrow every(A,A\cap B) Conceptually, conservativity can be understood as saying that the elements of B which are not elements of A are not relevant for evaluating the truth of the determiner phrase as a whole. For instance, truth of the first sentence above does not depend on which biting non-aardvarks exist. Conservativity is significant to semantic theory because there are many logically possible determiners which are not attested as denotations of natural language expressions. For instance, consider the imaginary determiner shmore defined so that shmore(A,B) is true iff |A|>|B| . If there are 50 biting aardvarks, 50 non-biting aardvarks, and millions of non-aardvark biters, shmore(A,B) will be false but shmore(A, A\cap B) will be true. Some potential counterexamples to conservativity have been observed, notably, the English expression "only".…

Back to article

Article summary

In formal semantics conservativity is a proposed linguistic universal which states that any determiner D must obey the equivalence D(A,B) \leftrightarrow D(A, A\cap B) . For instance, the English determiner "every" can be seen to be conservative by the equivalence of the following two sentences, schematized in generalized quantifier notation to the right. # Every aardvark bites. \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \rightsquigarrow every(A,B) # Every aardvark is an aardvark that bites. \ \ \rightsquigarrow every(A,A\cap B) Conceptually, conservativity can be understood as saying that the elements of B which are not elements of A are not relevant for evaluating the truth of the determiner phrase as a whole. For instance, truth of the first sentence above does not depend on which biting non-aardvarks exist. Conservativity is significant to semantic theory because there are many logically possible determiners which are not attested as denotations of natural language expressions. For instance, consider the imaginary determiner shmore defined so that shmore(A,B) is true iff |A|>|B| . If there are 50 biting aardvarks, 50 non-biting aardvarks, and millions of non-aardvark biters, shmore(A,B) will be false but shmore(A, A\cap B) will be true. Some potential counterexamples to conservativity have been observed, notably, the English expression "only".…

Key claims

No claims recorded.

Discussion questions

  1. Summarise the article in your own words. Which single claim would you verify first, and why?
  2. Which claim in this article is most likely to be revised as the sources update? How would you check its current status?
  3. If two sources disagreed about one of these facts, what would you need in order to trust one over the other?

Bibliography

No sources recorded.

Key claims and bibliography are generated from the same tracked claims and sources as the article page.