Crisis theory

Crisis theory, concerning the causes and consequences of the tendency for the rate of profit to fall in a capitalist system, is associated with Marxian critique of political economy, and was further popularised through Marxist economics.

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

≈ 19 min read

Cite, export and learn8 citation formats · 8 exports · lesson and quiz

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

Crisis theory, concerning the causes and consequences of the tendency for the rate of profit to fall in a capitalist system, is associated with Marxian critique of political economy, and was further popularised through Marxist economics.

Causes of crises

, production, consumption, and investment in the USA The concept of periodic crises within capitalism dates back to the works of the Utopian socialists Charles Fourier and Robert Owen and the Swiss economist Léonard de Sismondi. Karl Marx considered his crisis theory to be his most substantial theoretical achievement.

He presents it in its most developed form as Law of Tendency for the Rate of Profit to Fall combined with a discussion of various counter tendencies, which may slow or modify its impact." Roman Rosdolsky observed that "Marx concludes by saying that the law of the tendency of the rate of profit to fall is in every respect the most important law of modern political economy ... despite its simplicity, it has never before been grasped and even less consciously articulated ...

It is from the historical standpoint the most important law." A key characteristic of these theoretical factors is that none of them are natural or accidental in origin but instead arise from systemic elements of capitalism as a mode of production and basic social order. In Marx's words, "The real barrier of capitalist production is capital itself".

The law of the falling rate of profit, the unexpected consequence of the profit motive, is described by Marx as a "two-faced law with the same causes for a decrease in the rate of profits and a simultaneous increase of the mass of profits". "In short, the same development of the social productivity of labour expresses itself in the course of capitalist development on the one hand in a tendency to a progressive fall of the rate of profit, and on the other hand in a progressive increase of the absolute mass of the appropriated surplus value, or profit; so that on the whole a relative decrease of variable capital and profit is accompanied by an absolute increase of both."

Similarities (and differences) in the work of J. S. Mill and Marx

There are several elements in Marx's presentation which attest to his familiarity with Mill's formulations, notably Mill's treatment of what Marx would subsequently call counteracting tendencies: destruction of capital through commercial revulsions §5, improvements in production §6, importation of cheap necessaries and instruments §7, and emigration of capital §8. "In Marx's system, as in Mill's the falling rate of profit is a long-run tendency precisely because of the "counteracting influences at work which thwart and annul the effects of this general law, leaving to it merely the character of a tendency."

These counteracting forces are as follows: (1) An increase in the intensity of exploitation (via intensification of labor or the extension of the working day); (2) Depression of wages below their value ... (3) Cheapening of the elements of constant capital (via increased productivity); (4) Relative overproduction (which keeps many workers employed in relatively backward industries, such as luxury goods, where the organic composition of capital is low); (5) Foreign trade (which offers cheaper commodities and more profitable channels of investment); and (6) The increase of "stock capital" (interest bearing capital, whose low rate of return is not averaged with others).

Again, like Mill, Marx indicates the post-crisis waste of capital which restores profitability, but this is not mentioned specifically as a counter-tendency until the cyclical nature of the system is demonstrated. On the other hand, Mill does not refer to depression of wages below their value, relative overpopulation, or the increase in "stock capital".

But on the most important counter-tendencies, that is, the effects of increasing productivity at home in cheapening commodities and of foreign trade in providing both cheaper goods and greater profits, Marx and Mill are in accord."

Application

It is a tenet of many Marxist groupings that crises are inevitable and will be increasingly severe until the contradictions inherent in the mismatch between the relations of production and the development of productive forces reach the final point of failure, determined by the quality of their leadership, the development of the consciousness of the various social classes, and other "subjective factors". Thus, according to this theory, the degree of "tuning" necessary for intervention in otherwise "perfect" market mechanisms will become more and more extreme as the time in which the capitalist order is a progressive factor in the development of productive forces recedes further and further into the past.

But the subjective factors are the explanation for why purely objective factors such as the severity of a crisis, the rate of exploitation, etc., do not alone determine the revolutionary upsurge. A common example is the contrast of the oppression of the working classes in France in centuries prior to 1789 which although greater did not lead to social revolution as it did once the complete correlation of forces appeared.

Kuruma in his 19291 Introduction to the Study of Crisis ends by noting "... my use of the term "theory of crisis" is not limited to the theory of economic crisis. This term naturally also encompasses the study of the necessity of imperialist world war as the explosion of the contradictions peculiar to modern capitalism. Imperialist world war itself is precisely crisis in its highest form.

Thus, the theory of imperialism must be an extension of the theory of crisis." David Yaffe, in his application of the theory in the conditions of the end of the Post War Boom in the early 1970s, made an influential link to the expanding role of the state's interventions into economic relations as a politically critical element in attempts by capital to counteract the tendency and find new ways to make the working class pay for the crisis.

Influence

Crisis theory is central to Marx's writings; it helps underpin Marxists' understanding of a need for systemic change. It is controversial; Roman Rosdolsky said "The assertion that Marx did not propose a 'breakdown theory' is primarily attributable to the revisionist interpretation of Marx before and after the First World War.

Rosa Luxemburg, Henryk Grossman [and Kuruma Samezō] rendered inestimable theoretical services by insisting, as against the revisionists, on the breakdown theory." More recently David Yaffe 1972,1978 and Tony Allen et al. 1978,19811 in using the theory to explain the conditions at the end of the post-war boom of the 1970s and 1980s re-introduced the theory to a new generation and gained new readers for Grossman's 1929 presentation of Marx's Crisis theory.

Rosa Luxemburg lectured on the 'History of Theories of Economic Crises' at the SPD's Party School in Berlin (possibly in 1911, since the typescript includes a reference to statistics from 1911). Henryk Grossman's re-presentation of both the central importance of the theory for Marx and the working out of its elements in a partially mathematical form was published in 1929.

Central to the argument is the claim that, within a given business cycle, the accumulation of surplus from year to year leads to a kind of top-heaviness, in which a relatively fixed number of workers have to add profit to an ever-larger lump of investment capital. This observation leads to what is known as Marx's law of the tendency of the rate of profit to fall.

Unless certain countervailing possibilities are available, the growth of capital out-paces the growth of labour, so the profits of economic activity have to be shared out more thinly among capitals, i.e., at a lower profit rate. When countervailing tendencies are unavailable or exhausted, the system requires the destruction of capital values in order to return to profitability.

Hence creating the underlying preconditions for post-war boom. Paul Mattick's Economic Crisis and Crisis Theory (published by Merlin Press in 1981) is an accessible introduction and discussion derived from Grossman's work.

François Chesnais's (1984, chapter Marx's Crisis Theory Today, in Christopher Freeman ed. Design, Innovation and Long Cycles in Economic Development Frances Pinter, London), discussed the continuing relevance of the theory. Andrew Kliman has made major new contributions with a thorough and trenchant philosophical and logical defence of the consistency of the theory in Marx's work, against a number of the criticisms proposed against important aspects of Marx's theory since the seventies.

Francois Chesnais has provided an important exploration of the 'fictitious capital' or 'Finance Capital' aspects of the theory in a review of both historical and contemporary empirical research. Guglielmo Carchedi and Michael Roberts in their edited collection World in Crisis [2018] provide a valuable review of the empirical analyses that support and defend the thesis, with contributions from authors in the UK, Greece, Spain, Argentina, Mexico, Brazil, Australia and Japan.

Difference between Marxist economists and Keynesians

Keynesian economics, which attempts a "middle way" between laissez-faire, unadulterated capitalism and state guidance and partial control of economic activity, such as in the French dirigisme or the policies of the Golden Age of Capitalism, attempts to address such crises with the policy of having the state actively supplying the deficiencies of unaltered markets. Marx and Keynesians approach and apply the concept of economic crisis in distinct and opposite ways.

The Keynesian approach attempts to stay strictly within the economic sphere and describes 'boom' and 'bust' cycles that balance out. Marx observed and theorised economic crisis as necessarily developing out of the contradictions arising from the dynamics of capitalist production relations. "Where Marx differs from Keynes is precisely on the question of the falling rate of profit.

It is not the propensity to consume or subjective expectations about future profitability that is crucial for Marx. It is the rate of exploitation and the social productivity of labour that are the key considerations and these in relation to the existing capital stock.

While for Keynes the low marginal productivity of capital has its cause in an over-abundance of capital in relation to profit expectations, and therefore to a 'potential' over-production of commodities (the capitalist will not invest). For Marx the overproduction of capital is only relative to the social productivity of labour and the existing exploitation conditions.

It represents an insufficient mass of surplus-value in relation to total capital. So that for Marx the crisis is, and can only be, resolved by expanding profitable production and accumulation, while for Keynes, it can supposedly be remedied by increasing 'effective demand' and this allows for government induced-production."

Yaffe noted in 1972 that "... passages in Volume III referring to the underconsumption of the masses in no way can be interpreted as an underconsumptionist theory of crisis. The citation usually given in support of an 'underconsumptionist theory of crisis' is Marx's statement that "The last cause of all real crises always remains the poverty and restricted consumption of the masses as compared to the tendency of capitalist production to develop the productive forces in such a way, that only the absolute power of consumption of the entire society would be their limit."

The above passage contains within it no more than a description or a restatement of the capitalist relations of production. Marx called it a tautology to explain the crisis by lack of effective consumption ..." Other explanations have been formulated, and much debated, including: The tendency of the rate of profit to fall.

The accumulation of capital, the general advancement of techniques and scale of production, and the inexorable trend to oligopoly by the victors of capitalist market competition, all involve a general tendency for the degree of capital intensity, i.e., the "organic composition of capital" of production to rise. All else constant, this is claimed to lead to a fall in the rate of profit, which would slow down accumulation.

Full employment profit squeeze. Capital accumulation can pull up the demand for labor power, raising wages. If wages rise "too high," it hurts the rate of profit, causing a recession.

The interaction between the employment rate and the wage share has been mathematically formalised by the Goodwin model. Overproduction.

If the capitalists win the class struggle to push wages down and labor effort up, raising the rate of surplus value, then a capitalist economy faces regular problems of excess producer supply and thus inadequate aggregate demand and its corollary the underconsumptionist theory. On which Engels comments "the underconsumption of the masses, the restriction of the consumption of the masses to what is necessary for their maintenance and reproduction, is not a new phenomenon.

It has existed as long as there have been exploiting and exploited classes. The underconsumption of the masses is a necessary condition of all forms of society based on exploitation, consequently also of the capitalist form; but it is the capitalist form of production which first gives rise to crises.

The underconsumption of the masses is therefore also a prerequisite condition for crises, and plays in them a role which has long been recognised. But it tells us just as little why crises exist today as why they did not exist before" The Post Keynesian economics debt-crisis theory of Hyman Minsky.

A variety of theories of Monopoly Capitalism have also been propounded as attempts to explain through exogenous factors, why the tendency might not become apparently manifest in periods of capital accumulation, under various historical circumstances.

See also

Capital, Volume III Tendency of the rate of profit to fall Theories of imperialism Dependency theory Super-exploitation Criticisms of Marxism Economic collapse Late capitalism List of economic crises Marxism Neoliberalism Organic crisis Underconsumption Critique of political economy

Further reading

Allen, Tony et al. [1978] The Recession: Capitalist Offensive and the Working Class RCP 3, July 1978, Junius Allen, Tony [1981] World in Recession in RCP 7, July 1981, Junius Balomenos, Christos [2023] Did Marx Have Second Thoughts about the Law of the Falling Rate of Profit? An Archival Rejection of Heinrich's Arguments in Science & Society, Vol. 87, No. 4, October 2023, 556–581 Balomenos, Christos [2024] Did Engels’ editing of Capital, Volume 3 distort Marx's analysis of the ‘tendency of the rate of profit to fall’? in Capital & Class 1–21 2024

Beverley Best [2024] The Automatic Fetish: The Law of Value in Marx's Capital Verso Bell, Peter and Cleaver, Harry [1982] Marx's Theory of Crisis as a Theory of Class Struggle first published in 'Research in Political Economy', Vol 5(5): 189–261, 1982

Brooks, Mick [2012] Capitalist Crisis Theory and Practice: A Marxist Analysis of the Great Recession 2007–11 eXpedia Bullock, Paul and Yaffe, David [1975] Inflation, the Crisis and the Post-War Boom RC 3/4 November 1975, RCG Guglielmo Carchedi & Michael Roberts eds. [2018] World in Crisis: A Global Analysis of Marx's Law of Profitability Haymarket Books, Chicago, Illinois Chesnais, François [1984] Marx's Crisis Theory Today in Christopher Freeman ed. Design, Innovation and Long Cycles in Economic Development 2nd ed. 1984 Frances Pinter, London Chesnais, François [Feb 2012] World Economy -

The Roots of the World Economic Crisis in International Viewpoint Online magazine : IV445 Chesnais, François [first ed 2016] Finance Capital Today: Corporations and Banks in the Lasting Global Slump Haymarket Books Chicago, IL, 2017

Clarke, Simon [1994] Marx's Theory of Crisis Macmillan Daum, Walter [1990] The Life and Death of Stalinism Socialist Voice Publishing Co., New York Day, Richard B. [1981] The 'Crisis' and the 'Crash': Soviet Studies of the West (1917–1939) NLB Day, Richard B. & Daniel Gaido (trans. & eds) [2012] Discovering Imperialism: Social Democracy to World War I, Haymarket Grossman, Henryk [1922] The Theory of Economic Crises Grossman, Henryk [1929,1992] The Law of Accumulation and Breakdown of the Capitalist System Pluto, new full English translation: Jairus Banaji : Henryk Grossman Works, Volume 3: The Law of Accumulation and Breakdown of the Capitalist System, Being Also a Theory of Crises: Edited and introduced Rick Kuhn (Historical Materialism Book Series) Brill 2021, Haymarket 2022.

Grossman, Henryk [1941] Marx, Classical Political Economy and the Problem of Dynamics Grossman, Henryk [1932,2013] Fifty years of struggle over Marxism 1883‐1932 Grossman, Henryk [2017] Capitalism's Contradictions: Studies in Economic Theory before and after Marx Ed. Rick Kuhn Trans. Birchall, Kuhn, O'Callaghan.

Haymarket, Chicago H.M. Hyndman [1892] Commercial Crises of the Nineteenth Century, London H.M. Hyndman [1896] Economics of Socialism, The Twentieth Century Press, London Kliman, Andrew [2007] Reclaiming "Marx's 'Capital': A Refutation of the Myth of Inconsistency, Lexington, Lanham Kliman, Andrew [2011] The Failure of Capitalist Production: Underlying Causes of the Great Recession, London, Pluto Kliman, Andrew [2015] The Great Recession and Marx's Crisis Theory. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 74: 236–277.

The Great Recession and Marx's Crisis Theory - Kliman - 2015 - The American Journal of Economics and Sociology - Wiley Online Library Kuhn, Rick Economic Crisis and Socialist Revolution: Henryk Grossman's Law of accumulation, Its First Critics and His Responses, postprint, originally published in Paul Zarembka and Susanne Soederberg (eds) Neoliberalism in Crisis, Accumulation, and Rosa Luxemburg's Legacy Elsevier Jai, Amsterdam, Research in Political Economy, 21, 20041 pp. 181–221 (series). Kuhn, Rick [2007] Henryk Grossman and the Recovery of Marxism Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press.

Kuhn, Rick [2007] Henryk Grossman Capitalist Expansion and Imperialism in ISR Issue 56 November–December 2007 Kuhn, Rick [2013] Marxist crisis theory to 1932 and to the present: reflections on Henryk Grossman's 'Fifty years of struggle over Marxism paper to Society of Heterodox Economists Conference, University of New South Wales, Sydney, 2–3 December 2013 Kuhn, Rick [2017] Introduction: Grossman and His Studies of Economic Theory in Henryk Grossman [2017] Capitalism's Contradictions: Studies in Economic Theory before and after Marx Haymarket, Chicago Kuruma,

Samezō [1929] An Introduction to the Study of Crisis Sep. 1929 issue of Journal of the , (vol. VI, no. 1) Translated by Michael Schauerte Kuruma, Samezō [1930] An Inquiry into Marx's Theory of Crisis Sep. 1930 issue of the Journal of the Ohara Institute for Social Research, (Vol. VII, No. 2) Translated by Michael Schauerte Kuruma,

Samezō [19361] An Overview of Marx's Theory of Crisis first published in August 1936 issue of 'Journal of the Ohara Institute for Social Research'. Translated by Michael Schauerte Kuruma Samezō [2024] In Pursuit of Marx's Theory of Crisis trans: Edward Michael Schauerte Historical Materialism, Brill: Chicago Lenin V.I. [1916] Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism Luxemburg, Rosa [2013] (Peter Hudis ed.) The Complete Works of Rosa Luxemburg: Volume I: Economic Writings 1, Verso Marini, Ruy Mauro (2022) The Dialectics of Dependency Trans. and Introduction Latimer,

Amanda Monthly Review Press, New York.

Marx, Karl Marx's Economic Manuscript of 1864–1865 Edited & introduced by Fred Moseley Translated Ben Fowkes, Haymarket 2017 Mattick, Paul [1974] Marx and Keynes Merlin Mattick, Paul [1981] Economic Crisis and Crisis Theory Merlin Press Mattick, Paul [2008]. Review of David Harvey's The Limits to Capital in Historical Materialism 16 (4):213-224.

Norfield, Tony [2016] The City: London and the Global Power of Finance, Verso, London de Paula, João Antonio[2015] with Hugo Eduardo da Gama Cerqueira, Leonardo Gomes de Deus, Carlos Eduardo Suprinyak, Eduardo da Motta e Albuquerque Investigating Financial Innovation and Stock Exchanges. Marx’s Notebooks on the crisis of 1866 and structural changes in capitalism in 'Beiträge zur Marx-Engels-Forschung.

Neue Folge 2014/15'(p194-217) Pradella, Lucia [2009] Globalisation and the Critique of Political Economy: New insights from Marx's writings. Routledge' Michael Roberts|Roberts, Michael 2018 Marx 200 - a review of Marx's economics 200 years after his birth Lulu.com Rosdolsky, Roman [1980] The Making of Marx's 'Capital Pluto Rubin, Isaak Illich [1979] A History of Economic Thought, InkLinks, London Shaikh, Anwar [1978] An Introduction to the History of Crisis Theories in 'U.S. Capitalism in Crisis', URPE, New York Schauerte, E. Michael [2007] Kuruma Samezō's Life As A Marxist Economist in 'Transitions in Latin America and in Poland and Syria: Research in Political Economy', Vol 24 281–294 Shaxson, Nicholas 2012 Treasure Islands: Tax Havens and the Men Who Stole The World Vintage Books, London Shoul, Bernice [1947] The Marxian Theory of Capitalist Breakdown Joseph A. Schumpeter History of Economic Analysis Allen & Unwin 1954 Ticktin, Hillel, 'A Marxist Political Economy of Capitalist Instability and the Current Crisis', Critique, Vol.37.

Vort-Ronald, Pat, [1974] Marxist Theory of Economic Crisis, Australian Left Review, 1(43), 1974, 6-13. Yaffe, David [1972] The Marxian Theory of Crisis, Capital and the State, Bulletin of the Conference of Socialist Economists, Winter 1972, pp 5–58 Yaffe, David [1978] State and the Capitalist Crisis 2nd ed RCG Reprint

Capital, Volume 1, "Chapter 1" by Karl Marx "Crisis of Capitalism" by MIA Encyclopedia of Marxism Chesnais, François [1984] Marx's Crisis Theory Today in Christopher Freeman ed. Design, Innovation and Long Cycles in Economic Development 2nd ed. 1984 Frances Pinter, London. Audio Recording of Francois Chesnais's presentation published in the above Marx's Crisis Theory Today [19831](audio .mp3) "Economic crisis and the responsibility of socialists" by Rick Kuhn "Crisis and Hope: Theirs and Ours" Noam Chomsky, 2009 A Critique of Crisis Theory From a Marxist perspective Current specialist blog and discussion with resources by Sam Williams from January 2009 For a short video presentation of the theory, Cliff Bowman's video introduction to 'Marx's Theory of Economic Crisis', Cranfield University, School of Management, posted to YouTube 2009 [Andy Higginbottom|Higginbottom, Andy] 2020 Lecture series on Capital Vol3 Capital Vol. 3: The Andy Higginbottom lectures series

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1365897642 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Words in each sectionFurther readingFurther readingFurther reading: 1,229 words1,229Difference between Marx…Difference between Marxist economists and KeynesiansDifference between Marxist economists and Keynesians: 773 words773InfluenceInfluenceInfluence: 516 words516ApplicationApplicationApplication: 336 words336Causes of crisesCauses of crisesCauses of crises: 318 words318Similarities (and diffe…Similarities (and differences) in the work of J. S. Mill and MarxSimilarities (and differences) in the work of J. S. Mill and Marx: 299 words299See alsoSee alsoSee also: 37 words37
Words in each section. Measured from the stored article body; sections below the minimum are not plotted.

References

1 claim could not be tied to a specific sentence and is listed in the table below instead.

  1. ↩Wikipedia “Crisis theory” revision 1365897642 · retrieved 2026-10-20 publication date (×5) · confidence 0.95 revision URL

Provenance

snapshot enwiki-001365897642 · captured 2026-07-25 · ledger · version history

Cite this page as: encyclopegia.org, “Crisis theory”, snapshot enwiki-001365897642. https://encyclopegia.org/a/crisis-theory