Critical rationalism

Critical rationalism is Karl Popper's answer to what he considered the most important problems of epistemology and philosophy of science: the problems of the growth of knowledge, notably by induction, and the demarcation of science.

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 4 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

Critical rationalism is Karl Popper's answer to what he considered the most important problems of epistemology and philosophy of science: the problems of the growth of knowledge, notably by induction, and the demarcation of science. He adopted a fallibilist approach to these problems, especially that of induction, without falling into skepticism.

His approach was to put in perspective the distinctive role of deductive logic in the development of knowledge, especially in science, in the context of a less rigorous methodology based on critical thinking. The central technical concept in the application of critical rationalism to science is falsifiability.

Popper first mentioned the term "critical rationalism" in The Open Society and Its Enemies (1945) and also later in Conjectures and Refutations (1963), Unended Quest (1976), and The Myth of the Framework (1994).

Critical thinking, not support

Popper distinguished between trusting a theory because it is true and preferring a theory because it has been more severely tested. Some have argued that, indirectly, Popper was adopting an inductive principle when he proposed to "prefer" a more severely tested theory.

For Popper, the term "induction" refers to a logical method of justification, and he emphasized that this preference does not result from such a logical process whose premises would be the results of rigorous tests. For Popper, results of rigorous tests are rather used in critical discussions.

He wrote: Moreover, critical discussions must consider how much the theory prohibits and thus is unlikely to survive the tests, as well as whether the theory supersedes previous theories by generalizing them as when speaking of all heavenly bodies instead of only planets. Popper regularly emphasized that criticism in critical discussions requires the use of background knowledge, but rejected the view there will always be a set of assumptions beyond rational assessment.

In particular, Popper brought this point in the context of the empirical basis of science, which he compared to a swamp into which it is always possible to drive pillars deeper if a more solid foundation is needed. The critical rationalism approach to evaluating scientific theories can be generalized to non-scientific domains.

Critical rationalists hold that any claims to knowledge can and should be rationally criticized, and, if they have empirical content, can and should be subjected to tests which may falsify them. They are either falsifiable and thus empirical (in a very broad sense), or not falsifiable and thus non-empirical.

The general principle of critical rationalism is the same in both cases: we critically analyze the hypotheses using our "background knowledge". In the case of scientific hypotheses, background knowledge is used while observation statements are discussed or analysed.

Variations

William Warren Bartley developed a variation of critical rationalism that he called pancritical rationalism. The Argentine-Canadian philosopher of science Mario Bunge criticized Popper's critical rationalism, while drawing on it to formulate an account of scientific realism.

See also

Münchhausen trilemma Positivism dispute

People

Hans Albert David Deutsch John Eccles Ernest Gellner Hans Adolf Krebs Reinhold Zippelius

Further reading

Maxwell, Nicholas (2017) Karl Popper, Science and Enlightenment, UCL Press, London. Free online. Niemann, Hans-Joachim.

Lexikon des Kritischen Rationalismus, (Encyclopaedia of Critical Rationalism), Tübingen (Mohr Siebeck) 2004, . More than a thousand headwords about critical rationalism, the most important arguments of K.R. Popper and H. Albert, quotations of the original wording. Edition for students in 2006, .

Parusniková, Zuzana & Robert S. Cohen (2009). Rethinking Popper, Description and contents. Springer.

Reinhold Zippelius. Die experimentierende Methode im Recht (trial and error in jurisprudence), (Academy of Science, Mainz) 1991,

Critical Rationalism: a personal account Critical Rationalism Blog: Discusses critical rationalism from a libertarianist political point of view Justified True Belief and Critical Rationalism

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1376892108 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

No external citation was extracted for this revision. That is a statement about the source, not a claim that none exists.