Cube root law
≈ 5 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
The cube root law is an observation in political science that the number of members of a unicameral legislature, or of the lower house of a bicameral legislature, is about the cube root of the population being represented. The rule was devised by Estonian political scientist Rein Taagepera in his 1972 paper "The size of national assemblies". The cube root law has been cited in proposals for legislative resizing in the United States and in the 2020 Italian constitutional referendum. Large deviations between the data and the cube root curve, the inclusion of authoritarian governments in the data, as well as problems with how the cube root curve is derived from underlying postulates, have led researchers to question the cube root law.
The cube root law is an observation in political science that the number of members of a unicameral legislature, or of the lower house of a bicameral legislature, is about the cube root of the population being represented. The rule was devised by Estonian political scientist Rein Taagepera in his 1972 paper "The size of national assemblies". The cube root law has been cited in proposals for legislative resizing in the United States and in the 2020 Italian constitutional referendum. Large deviations between the data and the cube root curve, the inclusion of authoritarian governments in the data, as well as problems with how the cube root curve is derived from underlying postulates, have led researchers to question the cube root law. Taagepera's theoretical model says that as the number of legislators expands, the number of constituents per legislator dwindles, and the two numbers must be reconciled. He assumed that for maximum effectiveness the two numbers should be equal. From this theoretical model he derived the equation A=(2k)^{1/3}{P_0}^{1/3} with A as the number of legislators and k as the politically active fraction of the total population P_0 . Assuming that half of the population is politically active led to the simple equation with no coefficient: A={P_0}^{1/3} Giorgio Margaritondo argued in 2021 that fitting the cube-root equation to the experimental dataset originally used by Taagepera in 1972 leads to the equation: A = 0.66{P_0}^{1/3} This leads to the problematic result that the politically active population is 14%, which is too low. He said that although the cube root rule included governments that were corrupt, ineffective, or authoritarian, the rule has been misused as an argument for "optimal" legislature size. Actually, even Taagepera himself said, "there does not seem to be any clear difference in size (at equal population size) between assemblies which are considered representative and those which are considered to be of the rubber-stamp type." He said his model applies to both because "assemblies which are not used for interest aggregation may be used for transmitting government orders to the population." In 2012, researchers Emmanuelle Auriol and Robert J. Gary-Bobo derived a square-root law and empirically supported it from recent data for 100 countries. Margaritondo agreed that the data actually fits better to a function with a higher exponent, closer to a square-root law, and that the data's deviation from the cube root rule makes the cube root statistically inferior. In this regard, he gives an optimal formula of: A = 0.1{P_0}^{0.45\pm0.03} Margaritondo said that actually any power law equation would be so sensitive to the uncertainty in the exponent that the uncertainty in the result is large enough to accommodate most preferences. Applying this formula to the U.S. House of Representatives as of the 2020 Census would give a House of between 379 and 1231 members1, while using an exponent of 0.4507 gives 693 (the same result using the cube root rule). In 2015 researchers Kristof Jacobs and Simon Otjes questioned the cause-effect sequence used to derive the cube root rule. Likewise Margaritondo said that Taagepera should have compared the number of constituents for one legislator with the same legislator's connections to other legislators instead of using the total connections between all legislators. Margaritondo said that the correct logic leads not to a cube-root law but a square-root law.
Historical US House sizes
The following table describes how the US House of Representatives would have looked historically under the cube root rule according to the Huntington–Hill method.
See also
List of legislatures by number of members United States congressional apportionment Wyoming Rule Apportionment in the European Parliament
References
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1360803460 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “Cube root law” members (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL