Dialectical materialism
Dialectical materialism is a philosophy of nature and philosophy of science developed in the late 19th century from the writings of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels.
≈ 10 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Dialectical materialism is a philosophy of nature and philosophy of science developed in the late 19th century from the writings of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. By synthesising Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel's dialectic with philosophical materialism, it proposes that the world is material, that all phenomena are the result of matter in motion, and that the world's evolution is the product of a dialectical process driven by internal contradiction.
It posits a set of general laws—most notably the transformation of quantity into quality, the interpenetration of opposites, and the negation of the negation—that are claimed to govern nature, society, and thought. The intellectual origins of dialectical materialism can be traced to 19th-century German idealism, particularly Hegel's theory of the dialectic as a logical process of development.
Marx and Engels inverted Hegel's idealist system, proposing that the dialectic was not a process of the "Concept" or "Idea" but of the real, material world. While Marx never used the term "dialectical materialism", he applied some of its principles in his critique of political economy and his theory of history, historical materialism.
After Marx's death, Engels extended the dialectical method to the natural sciences in works such as Anti-Dühring (1878) and Dialectics of Nature, formulating what he saw as its general laws.…
Dialectical materialism is a philosophy of nature and philosophy of science developed in the late 19th century from the writings of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. By synthesising Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel's dialectic with philosophical materialism, it proposes that the world is material, that all phenomena are the result of matter in motion, and that the world's evolution is the product of a dialectical process driven by internal contradiction.
It posits a set of general laws—most notably the transformation of quantity into quality, the interpenetration of opposites, and the negation of the negation—that are claimed to govern nature, society, and thought. The intellectual origins of dialectical materialism can be traced to 19th-century German idealism, particularly Hegel's theory of the dialectic as a logical process of development.
Marx and Engels inverted Hegel's idealist system, proposing that the dialectic was not a process of the "Concept" or "Idea" but of the real, material world. While Marx never used the term "dialectical materialism", he applied some of its principles in his critique of political economy and his theory of history, historical materialism.
After Marx's death, Engels extended the dialectical method to the natural sciences in works such as Anti-Dühring (1878) and Dialectics of Nature, formulating what he saw as its general laws. The term "dialectical materialism" was coined in 1887 by Joseph Dietzgen, though it was the Russian Marxist Georgi Plekhanov who introduced it to Marxist literature in the 1890s. In the 20th century, dialectical materialism was further developed by Vladimir Lenin, who adapted it for his revolutionary political project.
In Materialism and Empirio-criticism (1909), Lenin redefined matter in purely epistemological terms as "objective reality" and introduced the principle of "partisanship", which asserted that all philosophy is inherently political and tied to class struggle. The doctrine was codified by Joseph Stalin in his 1938 essay Dialectical and Historical Materialism, which became the mandatory ideological framework for scientific and philosophical inquiry in the Soviet Union.
In this form, often referred to as "diamat", it was taught as the official philosophy of the Soviet Union (and other Marxist–Leninist states) and used to justify state policy. After Stalin's death, a period of "de-Stalinization" led to critiques of its dogmatism and a "thaw" in Soviet philosophy. The doctrine has been subject to extensive criticism.
A central debate concerns the work of Engels, whom critics in the Western Marxist tradition, such as Georg Lukács, accused of distorting Marx's thought with a positivist and metaphysical "dialectics of nature". Other commentators have argued that the doctrine evolved from a philosophical project into a rigid, quasi-religious "political cosmology" under Soviet rule, serving primarily as an instrument of ideological control.
Engels debate and critiques of Soviet "diamat"
The formalization of dialectical materialism gave rise to a long-running debate, particularly concerning the role of Friedrich Engels. The controversy began in socialist circles in the 1890s with critiques from figures like Eduard Bernstein, but it became a central issue with the publication of Georg Lukács's History and Class Consciousness in 1923.
Lukács famously argued that "Engels—following Hegel’s mistaken lead—extended the [dialectical] method also to the knowledge of nature," a move he considered illegitimate. He maintained that the crucial determinants of dialectics—such as the interaction of subject and object and the unity of theory and practice—were absent from the natural world.
In the Communist International, the works of Lukács and Karl Korsch were condemned for their rejection of the dialectics of nature and their "Menshevizing idealist" tendencies. This initiated the "Engels debate", which has often framed subsequent interpretations of Marxism.
Critics in the Western Marxist tradition, such as Herbert Marcuse and Jean-Paul Sartre, have argued that Engels distorted Marx's thought by introducing a positivist and metaphysical "dialectics of nature" that was alien to Marx's own humanistic and critical method. Another tradition of British and French Marxist scientists, including J. D. Bernal, J. B. S. Haldane, and Paul Langevin, vigorously defended the dialectics of nature, viewing it as an integral part of a comprehensive, scientific worldview.
According to Z. A. Jordan, the historical development of dialectical materialism from Engels to Stalin marked a transition from a cognitive, metaphysical project to a "political cosmology". Engels's original formulation was a genuine attempt to create a metaphysical theory of the universe that would reflect the nature of the physical world.
Plekhanov began the process of subordinating this cosmology to political and social considerations. In Lenin's work, cosmology gives way to a "socio-cosmic" worldview, and in Stalin's, it becomes a purely political tool, an instrument for justifying practical decisions and maintaining ideological control. This evolution produced two distinct conceptions of dialectical materialism.
The "minimalistic" conception, represented by Engels, is a set of metaphysical presuppositions intended to provide a foundation for an empirical theory of social and historical development. The "maximalistic" conception, initiated by Lenin and completed by Stalin, elevates the laws of dialectics to the status of ultimate laws of a nature, from which all other laws can be derived.
In this view, the validity of all knowledge is determined by its compatibility with these fundamental laws, and the philosophical interpretation of science is transferred to the jurisdiction of political authority. Gustav Wetter argues that Soviet dialectical materialism is an "eclectic medley" of diverse elements, often borrowed from philosophical positions at variance with one another.
He identifies a fundamental contradiction within the system between its dialectical component and its materialist dogma. The dialectical aspect acknowledges qualitative distinctions and the emergence of higher, spiritual forms of existence, while the materialist aspect denies the existence of anything beyond matter.
This contradiction, he suggests, poisons the entire system and leads to a "continual self-violation of the causal principle". Wetter also highlights the "religious" character of the system, with its "classics" functioning as "holy scriptures", the Communist Party as an infallible "church", and the dialectic itself serving as an element of "mysticism" that enabled Marxism to achieve such success in Russia.
Recent interpretations and re-evaluations
Within Western Marxism, the "Engels question" prompted a more nuanced engagement with the problem of nature. Lukács, in his later years, repudiated his earlier rejection of the dialectics of nature, conceding that he had violated the "very roots of Marxian ontology" by treating nature as a purely social category.
This later self-critique, however, did not fully resolve the Kantian-style dualism in his thought between the social and natural realms. In recent decades, the growth of Marxist ecology has led to a renewed defence of the dialectics of nature, arguing that it is essential for understanding the complex, co-evolutionary relationship between society and nature.
This perspective seeks to recover the "natural praxis" and Epicurean materialism in Marx's own thought, which sees human beings as "a part of nature" engaged in a "metabolic exchange" with their environment. Other recent interpretations, such as that of Bertell Ollman, have re-focused on Marx's own writings, presenting his dialectic not as a set of metaphysical laws but as a practical method of inquiry and exposition.
Ollman argues that many long-standing interpretive debates in Marxism—such as those on crisis theory or the nature of the capitalist state (e.g., the Miliband–Poulantzas debate)—are the result of the participants using different, unacknowledged "abstractions". Different thinkers may be focusing on different levels of generality or viewing the same issue from different vantage points (such as that of the ruling class versus that of socioeconomic structures) without being aware of it, leading to seemingly irreconcilable disagreements.
Another significant line of interpretation distinguishes between "historical dialectic" and "systematic dialectic". Alfred Schmidt, in his analysis of pre-capitalist societies, argues that their history has a "nature-like" or "elemental" character, and that only with the emergence of capitalism does a truly "historical" dialectic of productive forces and relations of production come into being.
Similarly, critics like Christopher Arthur argue that Engels's "logical-historical" method, which presents the categories of Capital as a reflection of historical development, was a misreading of both Marx and Hegel. According to this view, Marx's major works, like Hegel's, employ a "systematic dialectic".
This method does not trace a historical sequence but instead reconstructs the conceptual structure of a "given whole"—such as the capitalist mode of production—by tracing the "logic of mutual presupposition" among its constituent parts or "moments".
See also
Alexander Spirkin Chinese Marxist philosophy Dialectical Materialism and Historical Materialism Dialectical monism Fundamentals of Marxism–Leninism Ludovico Geymonat Maurice Cornforth Methodological naturalism Parametric determinism Shulamith Firestone Teodor Oizerman
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378829514 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.