Diaspora Revolt
Jewish-Roman conflict (115-117 CE)
≈ 13 min read
Diaspora Revolt. encyclopegia.org, snapshot diaspora-revolt-000710-a1ca4b75aafe25f0. /a/diaspora-revolt
Names in other languages
- ΕλληνικάΔεύτερος Ιουδαϊκός Πόλεμος
- DeutschDiasporaaufstand
- bgВавилонски бунт
- caGuerra de Kitus
- EnglishDiaspora Revolt
- Françaisguerre de Kitos
- NederlandsKitosoorlog
- EnglishKitos War
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
The Diaspora Revolt (115–117 CE), sometimes known as the Second Jewish–Roman War, was a series of uprisings launched by Jewish diaspora communities in several eastern provinces of the Roman Empire during the final years of Emperor Trajan's reign. Hostilities began while Trajan was engaged in his Parthian campaign in Mesopotamia, creating a favorable opportunity for rebellion.
Ancient sources do not specify the motivations, but they were likely shaped by the Roman destruction of the Second Temple during the First Jewish Revolt in 70 CE, long-standing tensions between Jews and Greeks, the fiscus Judaicus tax, messianic expectations, and hopes for a return to the Jewish homeland, Judaea. The uprisings broke out almost simultaneously in Egypt, Cyrenaica, and Cyprus.
Rebel attacks were directed mainly against locals rather than Roman authorities, with ancient authors such as Cassius Dio and Eusebius, as well as epigraphic evidence, reporting extreme violence. There is also a reference in Eusebius to Roman actions against Jews in Mesopotamia, though these events appear to have formed part of a broader local resistance to the Roman invasion of the Parthian Empire, rather than another Jewish uprising.
Marcius Turbo, one of Trajan's top generals, was dispatched to suppress the uprisings in Egypt and Cyrenaica. Literary sources suggest that the Jewish population in these regions faced severe reprisals. Meanwhile, General Lusius Quietus quelled the rebellion in Mesopotamia and was subsequently appointed governor of Judaea.
Death and legacy
It was during this period that the poorly understood Kitos War may have occurred in Judaea, apparently involving unrest among the Jewish population. The diaspora uprisings were likely suppressed before autumn 117, just prior to Trajan's death; however, some unrest may have persisted into the winter of 117–118.
The Diaspora Revolt led to the devastation, and in some cases the annihilation, of Jewish communities in Egypt, Cyrenaica, and Cyprus. Significant damage to buildings, temples, and roads is well attested in Cyrene and other parts of Cyrenaica. A festival celebrating victory over the Jews was still being observed eighty years later in the Egyptian city of Oxyrhynchus.
Career
The war is also believed to have ended Alexandria's early Christian community, which was largely of Jewish origins; the later non-Jewish Christian community adopted traditions that had originated in the city's Jewish population. Thirteen years after the diaspora uprisings, perhaps seeking to eradicate the seat of Jewish unrest, Emperor Hadrian re-founded Jerusalem as a Roman colony; in response, the Jews of Judaea launched the catastrophic Bar Kokhba Revolt.
In the aftermath of the Diaspora Revolt, the largest Jewish diaspora communities were concentrated in Mesopotamia, Asia Minor and Italy. Jewish communities reestablished themselves in Egypt, Cyprus, and Cyrenaica during the 3rd–4th centuries CE, though they never reached their former prominence. in 70 CE (1626).
This event contributed to the sense of unrest and messianic expectations that played a significant role in the Diaspora Revolt.|alt=Painting showing battle and destruction around a large columned temple, with soldiers looting objects, including a menorah The motivations behind the diaspora uprisings are complex and difficult to discern, owing to the lack of direct sources on their underlying causes. The Roman destruction of the Second Temple in Jerusalem in 70 CE, at the height of the First Jewish Revolt, was a deeply traumatic event whose effect was exacerbated by the simultaneous introduction of the , a humiliating, punitive tax imposed on all Jews across the empire.
The post-revolt period also saw widespread messianic expectations—a belief in the imminent coming of a redeemer, a descendant of David, who would bring transformative change and restore the Davidic kingdom in Israel —as well as a longing for the re-establishment of the Jewish state. Contemporary Jewish texts, such as the Third Sibylline Oracle, 4 Ezra, and 2 Baruch, reflect these themes, emphasizing anticipation of a messianic figure, the ingathering of the exiles (the biblical promise that Jews dispersed in exile will be restored to their ancestral land) and the eventual rebuilding of the Temple.
The messianic aspect of the revolt is perhaps suggested by Eusebius's reference to Lukuas—the leader of the Jewish rebels in Roman Libya—as "king", suggesting that the uprising evolved from an ethnic conflict into a nationalist movement with messianic ambitions for political independence. Inter-ethnic tensions and local conditions also fueled the unrest, especially in Egypt, where longstanding social, economic, political, and ideological frictions between Jews and Greeks had intensified since the 3rd century BCE.
The situation deteriorated under Roman rule, leading to sporadic violence in various eastern cities, including severe riots in Alexandria in 29 BCE, 38 CE, 41 CE, and 66 CE. The Jewish defeat in the First Jewish Revolt amplified hostility toward the Jews of Egypt, leading to their violent exclusion from civic positions and the imposition of higher business fees.
It also intensified anti-Jewish rhetoric in Egypt, greatly exacerbating tensions between Jews and Egyptians. In the years leading up to the Diaspora Revolt, incidents of anti-Jewish violence by Greeks occurred in 112 and the summer of 115 CE. These attacks, especially the latter, were likely direct catalysts for the Jewish uprising in Egypt.
Reception
In Cyrenaica, earlier disturbances in 73 CE, which resulted in the deaths and dispossession of many wealthy Jews, may have weakened the moderating influence of the Jewish elite, allowing more radical elements in Jewish society to gain prominence and push for revolt. Additionally, the destruction of the Jewish landholding aristocracy exacerbated economic hardships for Jewish tenant farmers, pushing them into cities and worsening their plight.
Works
William Horbury wrote that the revolt was influenced by a strong national hope and local interpretations of messianic expectations, particularly the return of the exiles and the rebuilding of the Temple. He added that Jews in the diaspora may have been influenced by the ideals of "liberty" and "redemption", which were central to the First Jewish Revolt and spread to communities in Egypt, Cyrene, and possibly Cyprus through refugees and traders from Judaea in its aftermath.
This idea is supported by Josephus's account of Jews belonging to the radical Sicarii faction who migrated to Cyrene after the war, the discovery of First Jewish Revolt coinage in Memphis, Egypt, and near Cyrene, as well as traces of these themes in diasporic literature. Classicist E. Mary Smallwood suggested that the revolutionary movement during the Diaspora Revolt can be viewed as an early form of Zionism, seeking the return of Jewish exiles from North Africa to Palestine.
She posits that the movement of Jewish rebels from Cyrenaica east into Egypt may have been intended as the first phase of a large-scale migration further east to Judaea. Archaeologist Shimon Applebaum wrote that the movement aimed at "the setting up of a new Jewish commonwealth, whose task was to inaugurate the messianic era."
Christian biblical scholar and historian John M. G. Barclay likewise argued that the extensive damage to Cyrenaica's infrastructure during the uprising implies that the Jews involved intended to leave the province, probably aiming ultimately to reach Judaea. Horbury similarly concludes that the Jewish forces likely aimed to return to and defend Judaea. .
The city's center was extensively damaged during the revolt, with public baths, the Caesareum, and several temples destroyed.|alt=Ruins of stone walls and columns at Cyrene, Libya Dio's account described the Jews of Cyrenaica as engaging in shockingly violent and cruel behavior. He writes that the Jews engaged in cannibalism, mutilation, and other atrocities, including using the victims' skins and entrails for make clothing and belts and staging gladiatorial and wild beast shows.
Dio wrote that the Jewish rebels in Cyrenaica were responsible for approximately 220,000 deaths, though this figure is likely exaggerated for rhetorical effect. Historian Miriam Pucci Ben Zeev argued that this portrayal should be viewed within the broader context of how "barbarian" revolts against Rome were typically described in contemporary historiography, adding that the atrocities Dio attributes to the Jews are no more egregious than those he ascribes to the Celtic Britons during the Boudican revolt in 61 CE or to the Bucoli, a group of Nile Delta herdsmen, during their uprising in Egypt in 171 CE.
Archaeological evidence points to extensive destruction in Cyrenaica attributed to Jewish rebels. Inscriptions record attacks on religious and civic structures, including temples and statues.
At Cyrene, for instance, the sanctuary of Apollo and its surroundings saw the destruction and burning of the baths, porticoes, ball-courts, and other nearby buildings; the temple of Hecate was burned down during the uprising, and significant damage is also recorded at the Caesareum and the temple of Zeus. Classicist Joyce Reynolds noted significant damage to the sanctuary of Asclepius at Balagrae, west of Cyrene, which was rebuilt in the following decades.
The destruction of a small 2nd-century temple near modern El Dab'a in Marmarica is likely also attributable to the Jewish rebels. Damage is also attested along major roads, possibly resulting from deliberate rebel strategy.
A Hadrianic milestone commemorates the repair of the road linking Cyrene with its port, Apollonia, which according to its inscription, "had been overturned and smashed up in the Jewish revolt," perhaps in anticipation of a Roman military advance from the sea. The presence of a deeply incised seven-branched menorah, a prominent Jewish symbol, on a road northwest of Balagrae may indicate, according to Reynolds, that Jews deliberately sought to disrupt the route connecting Cyrene with neighboring regions to the west. in Alexandria, erected in the late 3rd century CE, standing on the site of the former Serapeum, which was damaged during the war|alt=Tall Roman column known as Pompey's Pillar standing at the site of the Serapeum of Alexandria, with a stone sphinx in the foreground Appian wrote that the Jews destroyed the shrine of Nemesis, the Greek goddess of retribution, near Alexandria.
He added that this was done "for the needs of the war", suggesting an effort to remove a strategic point of advantage for the enemy, possibly by reusing the stone to strengthen Jewish defenses. Since the shrine housed the buried head of Pompey, its destruction may also have been motivated by a desire to avenge his desecration of the Temple during his conquest of Jerusalem in 63 BCE.
This attack, together with other assaults on pagan temples in Egypt and Cyrenaica, may help explain the description of "impious Jews" found in some papyri. Appian noted that the Jews seized control of waterways near Pelusium, located at the eastern edge of the Nile Delta, a region of critical strategic value.
Further evidence of military activity in Egypt's waterways is found in another papyrus, CPJ II 441, and in a 7th-century chronicle by Coptic bishop John of Nikiû. The latter mentions the Babylon Fortress, a fort situated at the entrance of , a canal constructed under Trajan which facilitated connections between the Nile and the Red Sea.
Papyri indicate that the Greeks, led by , retaliated against the Jews, with assistance from Egyptian peasants and Romans. Prefect Rutilius Lupus is noted to have personally participated in these engagements.
Some efforts were successful, as evidenced by the recorded "victory and success" of Apollonios near Memphis; however, due to many Roman forces being deployed in Mesopotamia, the remaining troops, including the Legio XXII Deiotariana and part of the Legio III Cyrenaica, were insufficient to restore order effectively. Following the devastation caused by the revolt, the Roman authorities initiated a large-scale recolonization of Cyrenaica, sending 3,000 veterans under the command of the prefect of Legio XV Apollinaris to settle in the region.
Some of these veterans were stationed in Cyrene itself, while others were relocated to other sites, including the newly founded city of Hadrianopolis on the Mediterranean coast. Eusebius's Chronicon and Orosius also report extensive destruction in Salamis and Alexandria, with Orosius noting that Libya would have remained depopulated without Hadrian's resettlement efforts. , near Cyrene, on display at Anu – Museum of the Jewish People.
It bears an inscription documenting the repair of a road damaged during the Jewish uprising, carried out under Hadrian.|alt=Tall stone milestone with a worn Latin inscription, displayed upright in a museum setting In Egypt, the aftermath of the revolts caused agricultural decline, shortages of slave labor and textiles, and an economic crisis with unstable prices and a shortage of essentials like bread. Roman troops in Egypt suffered significant losses, with some units experiencing casualties of 30–40 percent.
Egypt's agricultural hinterlands were heavily impacted by the war, and many farmlands remained unrecovered and underproductive for decades. Despite this, census data do not show a major demographic disruption in the overall population. In Alexandria, the damage was less extensive than was claimed by Eusebius, according to whom the city was "overthrown" and required rebuilding by Hadrian.
The primary loss was the sanctuary of Nemesis. The Serapeum and other structures were likely damaged later by Egyptian and Cyrenaican Jews, rather than by Alexandrian Jews.
The total destruction of the Cypriot city of Salamis has also been questioned, since it received the title of metropolis in 123, only a few years after the Jewish uprising, suggesting that not all damage was as severe as reported. Some Roman actions, such as Trajan's colony in Libya and Hadrian's edict improving conditions for the Egyptian peasantry, may likewise not be directly linked to the uprisings but instead reflect pre-existing circumstances.
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1374470907 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.