{
  "id": "enwiki-001368395486",
  "slug": "double-bind",
  "title": "Double bind",
  "qid": "",
  "lead": "A double bind is a dilemma in communication in which an individual (or group) receives two or more mutually conflicting messages. In some scenarios (such as within families or romantic relationships), this can be emotionally distressing, creating a situation in which a successful response to one message results in a failed response to the other (and vice versa), such that the person responding will automatically be perceived as in the wrong, no matter how they respond. Double bind theory was first stated by Gregory Bateson and his colleagues in the 1950s, in a theory on the origins of schizophrenia. It was theorized that schizophrenic responses were a reaction to an individual facing competing demands, leaving them with no clear way of responding. Double binds are often utilized as a form of control without open coercion—the use of confusion makes them difficult both to respond to and to resist. In many of these choice situations or dilemmas, it's not possible to carry out both instructions given at once. A double bind generally includes different levels of abstraction in the order of messages and these messages can either be stated explicitly or implicitly within the context of the situation, or they can be conveyed by tone of voice or body language.…",
  "body": "A double bind is a dilemma in communication in which an individual (or group) receives two or more mutually conflicting messages. In some scenarios (such as within families or romantic relationships), this can be emotionally distressing, creating a situation in which a successful response to one message results in a failed response to the other (and vice versa), such that the person responding will automatically be perceived as in the wrong, no matter how they respond. Double bind theory was first stated by Gregory Bateson and his colleagues in the 1950s, in a theory on the origins of schizophrenia. It was theorized that schizophrenic responses were a reaction to an individual facing competing demands, leaving them with no clear way of responding. Double binds are often utilized as a form of control without open coercion—the use of confusion makes them difficult both to respond to and to resist. In many of these choice situations or dilemmas, it's not possible to carry out both instructions given at once. A double bind generally includes different levels of abstraction in the order of messages and these messages can either be stated explicitly or implicitly within the context of the situation, or they can be conveyed by tone of voice or body language. Further complications arise when frequent double binds are part of an ongoing relationship to which the person or group is committed. More recent theoretical scholarship and empirical research have suggested that double bind communication may be a feature of personality disorder, specifically borderline personality disorder. ==Explanation== The double bind is often misunderstood to be a simple contradictory situation, where the subject is trapped by two conflicting demands. While it is true that the core of the double bind is two conflicting demands, the difference lies in how they are imposed upon the subject, what the subject's understanding of the situation is, and who (or what) imposes these demands upon the subject. Unlike the usual no-win situation, the subject has difficulty in defining the exact nature of the paradoxical situation in which they are caught. The contradiction may be unexpressed in its immediate context and therefore invisible to external observers, only becoming evident when a prior communication is considered. Typically, a demand is imposed upon the subject by someone whom they respect (such as a parent, teacher, or doctor) but the demand itself is inherently impossible to fulfill because some broader context forbids it. For example, this situation arises when a person in a position of authority imposes two contradictory conditions but there exists an unspoken rule that one must never question authority. Gregory Bateson and his colleagues defined the double bind as follows (paraphrased): Thus, the essence of a double bind is two conflicting demands, each on a different logical level, neither of which can be ignored or escaped. This leaves the subject torn both ways, so that whichever demand they try to meet, the other demand cannot be met. \"I must do it, but I can't do it\" is a typical description of the double-bind experience. For a double bind to be effective, the subject must be unable to confront or resolve the conflict between the demand placed by the primary injunction and that of the secondary injunction. In this sense, the double bind differentiates itself from a simple contradiction to a more inexpressible internal conflict, where the subject really wants to meet the demands of the primary injunction, but fails each time through an inability to address the situation's incompatibility with the demands of the secondary injunction. Thus, subjects may express feelings of extreme anxiety in such a situation, as they attempt to fulfill the demands of the primary injunction albeit with obvious contradictions in their actions. This was a problem in United States legal circles prior to the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution being applied to state action. A person could be subpoenaed to testify in a federal case and given Fifth Amendment immunity for testimony in that case. However, since the immunity did not apply to a state prosecution, the person could refuse to testify at the Federal level despite being given immunity, thus subjecting the person to imprisonment for contempt of court, or the person could testify, and the information they were forced to give in the Federal proceeding could then be used to convict the person in a state proceeding. Sukaina Hirji (utilizing the interpretation of Marilyn Frye) defines the \"oppressive double bind\" as follows (paraphrased): A double bind is a choice situation with few options that all lead to a form of punishment or deprivation. The resulting situation is the option to maintain invisibility through compliance of structural oppression or to challenge societal norms, leaving the individual with blame due to their identity. Frye emphasizes that the context of social barriers as a form of reinforcing to the immobilization and success of certain members of society is a key element to understanding and interpreting the double bind. These societal barriers often favor specific groups, leaving those not associated ostracized from societal success. Societal barriers in society manifest in the form of stereotypes regarding race, class, gender, sexuality, etc. A key element - both options in the situation leave the individual in a stale position. The individual often has a moral choice and prudential choice, either one robbing them of some sort of pride or benefit. Even if the individual resists the oppressive norm, they will most likely face punishment. Their individual success or survival in a society that enforces this oppressive system is a form resistance but their experience being punished degrades their progress towards the goal of dismantling the oppressive system. ===Example=== The classic example given of a negative double bind is of a parent telling their child they love them, while at the same time turning away in disgust, or inflicting corporal punishment as discipline: the words are socially acceptable; the body language is in conflict with it. The child does not know how to respond to the conflict between the words and the body language and, because the child is dependent on the parent for basic needs, they are in a quandary. Small children have difficulty articulating contradictions verbally and can neither ignore them nor leave the relationship. ==Double binds in society== === Gender stereotypes=== Societal expectations of gender can create situations where people are viewed negatively regardless of the actions or decisions they make. For example, the belief that masculinity means decisiveness can cause men who are cautious to be seen as less manly. Double binds can be used by those with influence to use stereotypes to cause harm to less powerful groups. In the case of gender, this means using gender stereotypes to force, typically women and nonbinary people, into boxes related to stereotypes. This is done by creating a contradiction of roles and then asserting that no person can be more complicated than those two options. This creates a no-win situation where a person cannot overcome the stereotypical expectations and create a third category or role. The most common way this shows up is related to gender in women in roles of power. When women are assertive in business positions, politics, or personal lives, they are seen as too assertive and unpleasant. However, if women revert to socially acceptable and proper ways of being, they are seen as weak and undeserving of their accomplishments. This creates a no-win situation. Women also exist in a social construct that places unspoken responsibilities on females that males don't have. They are expected to give care, attention, and validation to men which can influence their decisions and increase the pressure in double bind situations. Kate Manne suggests that dominant groups in society act as a sort of \"law enforcement\" patrolling those who aren't in the \"in-group\" - another gendered factor that influences choice situations. In a patriarchal society, women are associated with certain beauty ideals and expectations surrounding their role in the societal structure. Those who reject this construct risk not being accepted or being disregarded. However, since frameworks of female beauty standards for women in society create norms where women are forced into restrictive roles as, for example, sexual objects, compliance with these roles also involves alienation and disregard. This forms a very broad double bind often remarked on in feminist scholarship. == Girard's mimetic double bind == René Girard, in his literary theory of mimetic desire, proposes what he calls a \"model-obstacle\", a role model who demonstrates an object of desire and yet, in possessing that object, becomes a rival who obstructs fulfillment of the desire. According to Girard, the \"internal mediation\" of this mimetic dynamic \"operates along the same lines as what Gregory Bateson called the 'double bind'.\" Girard found in Sigmund Freud's psychoanalytic theory, a precursor to mimetic desire. \"The individual who 'adjusts' has managed to relegate the two contradictory injunctions of the double bind—to imitate and not to imitate—to two different domains of application. This is, he divides reality in such a way as to neutralize the double bind.\" While critical of Freud's doctrine of the unconscious mind, Girard sees the ancient Greek tragedy, Oedipus Rex, and key elements of Freud's Oedipus complex, patricidal and incestuous desire, to serve as prototypes for his own analysis of the mimetic double bind . ==See also== ==Notes== ==References== Bateson, Gregory. (1972, 1999) Steps to an Ecology of Mind: Collected Essays in Anthropology, Psychiatry, Evolution, and Epistemology.Part III: Form and Pathology in Relationship. University of Chicago Press, 1999, originally published, San Francisco: Chandler Pub. Co., 1972. Gibney, Paul (May 2006) The Double Bind Theory: Still Crazy-Making After All These Years. in Psychotherapy in Australia. Vol. 12. No. 3. https://web.archive.org/web/20110706111135/http://www.psychotherapy.com.au/TheDoubleBindTheory.pdf Koopmans, Matthijs (1998) Schizophrenia and the Family II: Paradox and Absurdity in Human Communication Reconsidered. https://www.goertzel.org/dynapsyc/1998/KoopmansPaper.htm Zysk, Wolfgang (2004), \"Körpersprache – Eine neue Sicht\", Doctoral Dissertation 2004, University Duisburg-Essen (Germany). ==External links== https://web.archive.org/web/20080211090234/http://www.mri.org/dondjackson/brp.htm https://www.behavenet.com/double-bind https://web.archive.org/web/20080215124155/http://laingsociety.org/cetera/pguillaume.htm Reference in Encyclopedia of NLP Double-bind loop feeding on itself, an illustration by chart (and a poem)",
  "categories": [
    "107141658",
    "1510778",
    "22906782",
    "22919451",
    "22949727",
    "23118434",
    "23603337",
    "24043274",
    "26696181",
    "26696190",
    "26865060",
    "28065828",
    "37160764",
    "44873516",
    "48128016"
  ],
  "license": "CC BY-SA 4.0",
  "source_uri": "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1368395486",
  "content_hash": "",
  "created_at": null,
  "updated_at": 1786214327.0,
  "claims": [],
  "contradictions": [],
  "confidence": 0.6,
  "csl": {
    "id": "enwiki-001368395486",
    "type": "webpage",
    "title": "Double bind",
    "author": [
      {
        "family": "Anticloud FZ LLE",
        "literal": "Anticloud FZ LLE"
      }
    ],
    "container-title": "encyclopegia.org",
    "publisher": "Anticloud FZ LLE",
    "publisher-place": "Dubai, United Arab Emirates",
    "URL": "https://encyclopegia.org/a/double-bind",
    "issued": {
      "date-parts": [
        [
          2026,
          11,
          22
        ]
      ]
    },
    "accessed": {
      "date-parts": [
        [
          2026,
          11,
          22
        ]
      ]
    },
    "license": "CC BY-SA 4.0",
    "DOI": "eo1:enwiki-001368395486",
    "isBasedOn": "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1368395486",
    "note": "Immutable snapshot enwiki-001368395486"
  }
}