Drake equation
The Drake equation is a probabilistic argument used to estimate the number of active, communicative extraterrestrial civilizations in the Milky Way Galaxy.
≈ 17 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
The Drake equation is a probabilistic argument used to estimate the number of active, communicative extraterrestrial civilizations in the Milky Way Galaxy. The equation was formulated in 1961 by Frank Drake, not for purposes of quantifying the number of civilizations, but as a way to stimulate scientific dialogue at the first scientific meeting on the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI).
The equation summarizes the main concepts which scientists must contemplate when considering the question of other radio-communicative life. It is more properly thought of as an approximation than as a serious attempt to determine a precise number.
Criticism related to the Drake equation focuses not on the equation itself, but on the fact that the estimated values for several of its factors are highly conjectural, the combined multiplicative effect being that the uncertainty associated with any derived value is so large that the equation cannot be used to draw firm conclusions.
Equation
The Drake equation is: N = R_* \cdot f_\mathrm{p} \cdot n_\mathrm{e} \cdot f_\mathrm{l} \cdot f_\mathrm{i} \cdot f_\mathrm{c} \cdot L where = the number of civilizations in the Milky Way galaxy with which communication might be possible (i.e. which are on the current past light cone); and = the average rate of star formation in our galaxy. = the fraction of those stars that have planets. = the average number of planets that can potentially support life per star that has planets. = the fraction of planets that could support life that actually develop life at some point. = the fraction of planets with life that go on to develop intelligent life (civilizations). = the fraction of civilizations that develop a technology that releases detectable signs of their existence into space. = the length of time for which such civilizations release detectable signals into space. This form of the equation first appeared in Drake's 1965 paper.
History
In September 1959, physicists Giuseppe Cocconi and Philip Morrison published an article in the journal Nature with the provocative title "Searching for Interstellar Communications". Cocconi and Morrison argued that radio telescopes had become sensitive enough to pick up transmissions that might be broadcast into space by civilizations orbiting other stars.
Such messages, they suggested, might be transmitted at a wavelength of 21 cm (1,420.4 MHz). This is the wavelength of radio emission by neutral hydrogen, the most common element in the universe, and they reasoned that other intelligences might see this as a logical landmark in the radio spectrum.
Two months later, Harvard University astronomy professor Harlow Shapley speculated on the number of inhabited planets in the universe, saying "The universe has 10 million, million, million suns (10 followed by 18 zeros) similar to our own. One in a million has planets around it.
Only one in a million million has the right combination of chemicals, temperature, water, days and nights to support planetary life as we know it. This calculation arrives at the estimated figure of 100 million worlds where life has been forged by evolution."
Seven months after Cocconi and Morrison published their article, Drake began searching for extraterrestrial intelligence in an experiment called Project Ozma. It was the first systematic search for signals from communicative extraterrestrial civilizations.
Using the dish of the National Radio Astronomy Observatory, Green Bank in Green Bank, West Virginia, Drake monitored two nearby Sun-like stars: Epsilon Eridani and Tau Ceti, slowly scanning frequencies close to the 21 cm wavelength for six hours per day from April to July 1960. The project was well designed, inexpensive, and simple by today's standards. It detected no signals.
Soon thereafter, Drake hosted the first search for extraterrestrial intelligence conference on detecting their radio signals. The meeting was held at the Green Bank facility in 1961. The equation that bears Drake's name arose out of his preparations for the meeting.
The ten attendees were conference organizer J. Peter Pearman, Frank Drake, Philip Morrison, businessman and radio amateur Dana Atchley, chemist Melvin Calvin, astronomer Su-Shu Huang, neuroscientist John C. Lilly, inventor Barney Oliver, astronomer Carl Sagan, and radio-astronomer Otto Struve. These participants called themselves "The Order of the Dolphin" (because of Lilly's work on dolphin communication), and commemorated their first meeting with a plaque at the observatory hall.
Usefulness
for SETI The Drake equation results in a summary of the factors affecting the likelihood that we might detect radio-communication from intelligent extraterrestrial life. The last three parameters, , , and , are not known and are very difficult to estimate, with values ranging over many orders of magnitude (see ).
Therefore, the usefulness of the Drake equation is not in the solving, but rather in the contemplation of all the various concepts which scientists must incorporate when considering the question of life elsewhere, and gives the question of life elsewhere a basis for scientific analysis. The equation has helped draw attention to some particular scientific problems related to life in the universe, for example abiogenesis, the development of multi-cellular life, and the development of intelligence itself.
Within the limits of existing human technology, any practical search for distant intelligent life must necessarily be a search for some manifestation of a distant technology. After about 50 years, the Drake equation is still of seminal importance because it is a 'road map' of what we need to learn in order to solve this fundamental existential question.
It also formed the backbone of astrobiology as a science; although speculation is entertained to give context, astrobiology concerns itself primarily with hypotheses that fit firmly into existing scientific theories. Some 50 years of SETI have failed to find anything, even though radio telescopes, receiver techniques, and computational abilities have improved significantly since the early 1960s. SETI efforts since 1961 have conclusively ruled out widespread alien emissions near the 21 cm wavelength of the hydrogen frequency.
Original estimates
There is considerable disagreement on the values of these parameters, but the 'educated guesses' used by Drake and his colleagues in 1961 were: = 1 yr −1 (1 star formed per year, on the average over the life of the galaxy; this was regarded as conservative) = 0.2 to 0.5 (one fifth to one half of all stars formed will have planets) = 1 to 5 (stars with planets will have between 1 and 5 planets capable of developing life) = 1 (100% of these planets will develop life) = 1 (100% of which will develop intelligent life) = 0.1 to 0.2 (10–20% of which will be able to communicate) = somewhere between 10001 and 100,000,000 years Inserting the above minimum numbers into the equation gives a minimum N of 20 (see: Range of results). Inserting the maximum numbers gives a maximum of 50,000,000.
Drake states that given the uncertainties, the original meeting concluded that , and there were probably between 1000 and 100,000,000 planets with civilizations in the Milky Way Galaxy.
Current estimates
This section discusses and attempts to list the best current estimates for the parameters of the Drake equation.
Range of results
As many skeptics have pointed out, the Drake equation can give a very wide range of values, depending on the assumptions, as the values used in portions of the Drake equation are not well established. In particular, the result can be , meaning we are likely alone in the galaxy, or , implying there are many civilizations we might contact.
One of the few points of wide agreement is that the presence of humanity demonstrates that the probability of intelligence arising is greater than zero. As an example of a low estimate, combining NASA's star formation rates, the rare Earth hypothesis value of , Mayr's view on intelligence arising, Drake's view of communication, and Shermer's estimate of lifetime: , , , [Drake, above] , and years gives: (0.00000000000091 in non scientific notation) i.e., suggesting that we are probably alone in this galaxy, and possibly in the observable universe.
On the other hand, with larger values for each of the parameters above, values of can be derived that are greater than 1. The following higher values that have been proposed for each of the parameters: , , , , , [Drake, above] , and years Use of these parameters gives: civilizations in the Milky Way with which communication might be possible Monte Carlo simulations of estimates of the Drake equation factors based on a stellar and planetary model of the Milky Way have resulted in the number of civilizations varying by a factor of 100.
Possible former technological civilizations
In 2016, Adam Frank and Woodruff Sullivan modified the Drake equation to determine just how unlikely the event of a technological species arising on a given habitable planet must be, to give the result that Earth hosts the only technological species that has ever arisen, for two cases: (a) this Galaxy, and (b) the universe as a whole. By asking this different question, one removes the lifetime and simultaneous communication uncertainties.
Since the numbers of habitable planets per star can today be reasonably estimated, the only remaining unknown in the Drake equation is the probability that a habitable planet ever develops a technological species over its lifetime. For Earth to have the only technological species that has ever occurred in the universe, they calculate the probability of any given habitable planet ever developing a technological species must be less than .
Similarly, for Earth to have been the only case of hosting a technological species over the history of this Galaxy, the odds of a habitable zone planet ever hosting a technological species must be less than (about 1 in 60 billion). The figure for the universe implies that it is extremely unlikely that Earth hosts the only technological species that has ever occurred.
On the other hand, for this Galaxy one must think that fewer than 1 in 60 billion habitable planets develop a technological species for there not to have been at least a second case of such a species over the past history of this Galaxy.
Modifications
As many observers have pointed out, the Drake equation is a very simple model that omits potentially relevant parameters, and many changes and modifications to the equation have been proposed. One line of modification, for example, attempts to account for the uncertainty inherent in many of the terms.
Combining the estimates of the original six factors by major researchers via a Monte Carlo procedure leads to a best value for the non-longevity factors of 0.85 per year. This result differs insignificantly from the estimate of unity given both by Drake and the Cyclops report.
Others note that the Drake equation ignores many concepts that might be relevant to the odds of contacting other civilizations. For example, Glen David Brin states: "The Drake equation merely speaks of the number of sites at which ETIs spontaneously arise. The equation says nothing directly about the contact cross-section between an ETIS and contemporary human society".
Because it is the contact cross-section that is of interest to the SETI community, many additional factors and modifications of the Drake equation have been proposed. Colonization : Brin proposed to generalize the Drake equation to include additional effects of alien civilizations colonizing other star systems.
Each original site expands with an expansion velocity , and establishes additional sites that survive for a lifetime . The result is a more complex set of 3 equations. Reappearance factor : The Drake equation may furthermore be multiplied by how many times an intelligent civilization may occur on planets where it has happened once.
Even if an intelligent civilization reaches the end of its lifetime, life may still prevail on the planet for billions of years, permitting the next civilization to evolve. Thus, several civilizations may come and go during the lifespan of one and the same planet.
Thus, if is the average number of times a new civilization reappears on the same planet where a previous civilization once has appeared and ended, then the total number of civilizations on such a planet would be , which is the actual reappearance factor added to the equation. METI factor : Alexander Zaitsev said that to be in a communicative phase and emit dedicated messages are not the same.
For example, humans are in a communicative phase, but are not a communicative civilization; there are no purposeful and regular transmission of interstellar messages. For this reason, he suggested introducing the METI factor (messaging to extraterrestrial intelligence) to the classical Drake equation.
He defined the factor as " = The fraction of communicative civilizations with clear and non-paranoid planetary consciousness (that is, those which actually engage in deliberate interstellar transmission)". Biogenic gases : Astronomer Sara Seager proposed a revised equation that focuses on the search for planets with biosignature gases.
These gases are produced by living organisms that can accumulate in a planet atmosphere to levels that can be detected with remote space telescopes. The Seager equation looks like: N = N_* \cdot F_\mathrm{Q} \cdot F_\mathrm{HZ} \cdot F_\mathrm{O} \cdot F_\mathrm{L} \cdot F_\mathrm{S} where: = the number of planets with detectable signs of life = the number of stars observed = the fraction of stars that are quiet = the fraction of stars with rocky planets in the habitable zone = the fraction of those planets that can be observed = the fraction that have life = the fraction on which life produces a detectable signature gas Carl Sagan's version of the Drake equation:American astronomer Carl Sagan made some modifications in the Drake equation and presented it in the 1980 program Cosmos: A Personal Voyage.
The modified equation is: N = N_\mathrm{*} \cdot f_\mathrm{p} \cdot n_\mathrm{e} \cdot f_\mathrm{l} \cdot f_\mathrm{i} \cdot f_\mathrm{c} \cdot f_\mathrm{L} where: = the number of civilizations in the Milky Way galaxy with which communication might be possible (i.e. which are on the current past light cone); = Number of stars in the Milky Way Galaxy = the fraction of those stars that have planets. = the average number of planets that can potentially support life per star that has planets. = the fraction of planets that could support life that actually develop life at some point. = the fraction of planets with life that go on to develop intelligent life (civilizations). = the fraction of civilizations that develop a technology that releases detectable signs of their existence into space. = fraction of a planetary lifetime graced by a technological civilization Plate tectonics factor Robert J. Stern and Taras V. Gerya proposed to add plate tectonics factors in the 2024 paper:
Criticism
Criticism of the Drake equation is varied. Firstly, many of the terms in the equation are largely or entirely based on conjecture. Star formation rates are well-known, and the incidence of planets has a sound theoretical and observational basis, but the other terms in the equation become very speculative.
The uncertainties revolve around the present day understanding of the evolution of life, intelligence, and civilization, not physics. No statistical estimates are possible for some of the parameters, where only one example is known.
The net result is that the equation cannot be used to draw firm conclusions of any kind, and the resulting margin of error is huge, far beyond what some consider acceptable or meaningful. Others point out that the equation was formulated before our understanding of the universe had matured.
Astrophysicist Ethan Siegel, said: One reply to such criticisms is that even though the Drake equation currently involves speculation about unmeasured parameters, it was intended as a way to stimulate dialogue on these topics. Then the focus becomes how to proceed experimentally.
Indeed, Drake originally formulated the equation merely as an agenda for discussion at the Green Bank conference.
Fermi paradox
A civilization lasting for tens of millions of years could be able to spread throughout the galaxy, even at the slow speeds foreseeable with present-day technology. However, no confirmed signs of civilizations or intelligent life elsewhere have been found, either in this Galaxy or in the observable universe of 2 trillion galaxies.
According to this line of thinking, the tendency to fill (or at least explore) all available territory seems to be a universal trait of living things, so the Earth should have already been colonized, or at least visited, but no evidence of this exists. Hence Fermi's question "Where is everybody?".
A large number of explanations have been proposed to explain this lack of contact; a book published in 20151 elaborated on 75 different explanations. In terms of the Drake Equation, the explanations can be divided into three classes: Few intelligent civilizations ever arise. This is an argument that at least one of the first few terms, , has a low value.
The most common suspect is , but explanations such as the rare Earth hypothesis argue that is the small term. Intelligent civilizations exist, but we see no evidence, meaning is small.
Typical arguments include that civilizations are too far apart, it is too expensive to spread throughout the galaxy, civilizations broadcast signals for only a brief period of time, communication is dangerous, and many others. The lifetime of intelligent, communicative civilizations is short, meaning the value of is small.
Drake suggested that a large number of extraterrestrial civilizations would form, and he further speculated that the lack of evidence of such civilizations may be because technological civilizations tend to disappear rather quickly. Common explanations include the nature of intelligent life to destroy itself and/or others, and that intelligent life may be destroyed by natural events.
These lines of reasoning lead to the Great Filter hypothesis, which states that since there are no observed extraterrestrial civilizations despite the vast number of stars, at least one step in the process must be acting as a filter to reduce the final value. According to this view, either it is very difficult for intelligent life to arise, or the lifetime of technologically advanced civilizations, or the period of time they reveal their existence must be relatively short.
An analysis by Anders Sandberg, Eric Drexler and Toby Ord suggests "a substantial ex ante (predicted) probability of there being no other intelligent life in our observable universe".
In popular culture
The equation was cited by Gene Roddenberry as supporting the multiplicity of inhabited planets shown on Star Trek, the television series he created. However, Roddenberry did not have the equation with him, and he was forced to "invent" it for his original proposal.
The fictitious equation that Roddenberry created is: Ff^2 (MgE)-C^1 Ri^1 \cdot M=L/So Regarding this fictional version of the equation, Drake himself commented that a number raised to the first power is just the number itself. A commemorative plate on NASA's Europa Clipper mission, which launched October 14, 2024, features a poem by the U.S. Poet Laureate Ada Limón, waveforms of the word 'water' in 103 languages, a schematic of the water hole, the Drake equation, and a portrait of planetary scientist Ron Greeley on it.
See also
The Search for Life: The Drake Equation, BBC documentary
External links
Interactive Drake Equation Calculator Frank Drake's 2010 article on "The Origin of the Drake Equation" "Only a matter of time, says Frank Drake". A Q&A with Frank Drake in February 2010 Macromedia Flash page allowing the user to modify Drake's values from PBS's Nova "The Drake Equation", Astronomy Cast episode #23; includes full transcript Animated simulation of the Drake equation.
( ) "The Alien Equation", BBC Radio program Discovery (22 September 2010) "Reflections on the Equation" (PDF), by Frank Drake, 2013
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1376865219 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “Drake equation” publication date (×2) · confidence 0.95 revision URL