Duns Scotus
John Duns Scotus ( ; , 'Duns the Scot'; – 8 November 1308) was a Scottish Catholic priest and Franciscan friar, university professor, philosopher and theologian.
≈ 12 min read
Duns Scotus. encyclopegia.org, snapshot enwiki-001373954588. /a/duns-scotus
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
John Duns Scotus ( ; , 'Duns the Scot'; – 8 November 1308) was a Scottish Catholic priest and Franciscan friar, university professor, philosopher and theologian. He is considered among the most important philosopher-theologians in Western Christendom during the last part of the medieval period, together with Thomas Aquinas, Bonaventure and William of Ockham.
The intellectual tradition derived from Scotus's work is called Scotism. Duns Scotus has had considerable influence on both Catholic and secular thought.
The doctrines for which he is best known are the "univocity of being", that existence is the most abstract concept we have, applicable to everything that exists; the formal distinction, a way of distinguishing between different formalities of the same thing; and the idea of haecceity, the property supposed to be in each individual thing that makes it an individual (i.e., a certain "thisness"). Duns Scotus also developed a complex argument for the existence of God, and argued for the Immaculate Conception of Mary.
Duns Scotus was given the scholastic accolade ('the subtle Doctor') for his penetrating and subtle manner of thought. He was beatified by Pope John Paul II in 1993.
John Duns Scotus ( ; , 'Duns the Scot'; – 8 November 1308) was a Scottish Catholic priest and Franciscan friar, university professor, philosopher and theologian. He is considered among the most important philosopher-theologians in Western Christendom during the last part of the medieval period, together with Thomas Aquinas, Bonaventure and William of Ockham.
The intellectual tradition derived from Scotus's work is called Scotism. Duns Scotus has had considerable influence on both Catholic and secular thought.
The doctrines for which he is best known are the "univocity of being", that existence is the most abstract concept we have, applicable to everything that exists; the formal distinction, a way of distinguishing between different formalities of the same thing; and the idea of haecceity, the property supposed to be in each individual thing that makes it an individual (i.e., a certain "thisness"). Duns Scotus also developed a complex argument for the existence of God, and argued for the Immaculate Conception of Mary.
Duns Scotus was given the scholastic accolade ('the subtle Doctor') for his penetrating and subtle manner of thought. He was beatified by Pope John Paul II in 1993.
Metaphysical argument for the existence of God
Duns Scotus argued that it is better to construct a metaphysical argument for the existence of God, rather than the more common physical argument from motion favoured by Aquinas, following Aristotle. Though the version in De Primo Principio is the most complete and final version, the Ordinatio proof is usually offered.
However, the De Primo version gives a wider understanding of the argument as well as Scotus's metaphysical underpinnings for his argument for God's existence, but the Ordinatio version will be followed here. Briefly, Scotus begins his proof by explaining that there are two angles we must take in arguing for the existence of an actually infinite being.
First from the view of the Relative Properties of God and second from the Absolute Properties of God. Relative properties are those which are predicable of God in relation to creation; absolute properties are those which belong to God whether or not He chose to create.
Under the first heading of Relative Properties, Scotus argues for a triple primacy of efficiency, finality and pre-eminence. From there he shows that one primacy implies the others, and finally there can only be one nature that is the First Efficient Cause, Ultimate End, and the Most Perfect Nature. From there the Subtle Doctor discusses the Absolute Properties of God.
The First Being is intellectual and volitional, and the intellect and will are identical with the essence of this supreme nature. The First Being is also infinite being. While discussing the infinity of God, Scotus resurrects Anselm's argument and responds to the criticism that Anselm makes an illicit leap from concept to reality.
Finally, he gives a definite answer of "yes" to the question of whether there exists an actually infinite being. The very next question of the Ordinatio deals with the unicity of the nature thus proved to exist. However, the De Primo Principio version concludes with this argument.
The proof for the conclusion that "some efficient cause is simply first such that neither can it be an effect nor can it, by virtue of something other than itself, cause an effect" Ordinatio I.2.43 runs like this: Something can be produced. It is produced either by itself, nothing, or another. Not by nothing, for nothing causes nothing.
Not by itself, for an effect never causes itself. Therefore, by another; call it A. If A is first, then we have reached the conclusion. If A is not first, but also an effect, we return to 2).
A is produced either by itself, nothing, or another. From 3) and 4), we say another, B. The ascending series will either continue infinitely or we finally reach something which has nothing prior to it. An infinite ascending series is impossible.
Therefore, etc. Scotus acknowledges two objections and deals with them accordingly. First is that he begs the question in assuming a first in the series. Here he argues that while many admit an infinite regress in an accidentally ordered series of causes, no philosopher admits infinite regress in an essentially ordered series.
Scotus explains the differences between the two and offers proofs for the conclusion that an infinity of essentially ordered causes in a series is impossible. Second, it is objected that his proof is not really a demonstration since it begins with a contingent premise. That something is produced is contingent and not necessary.
Therefore, the proof proceeds from a contingent and not a necessary premise. Scotus says that while that is true, it is utterly manifest that things are produced or effected. But in order to respond, Scotus makes a modal move and reworks the argument.
Now he argues from the possibility of production. "It is possible that something can be produced" is a necessary proposition. From there he is able to conclude that it is possible that the first efficient cause exists, and if it is possible that it exists, then it does exist.
He asserts that the last claim will be proved later in the argument. In the Lectura proof, Scotus argues the following way: For more on this argument, see especially "Authors/Duns Scotus/Ordinatio/Ordinatio I/D2/Q2B".
Sixteenth to nineteenth centuries
His reputation suffered during the English reformation, probably due to its association with the Franciscans. In a letter to Thomas Cromwell about his visit to Oxford in 1535, Richard Layton described how he saw the court of New College full of pages from Scotus's work, "the wind blowing them into every corner."
John Leland described the Oxford Greyfriar's library in 1538 (just prior to its dissolution) as an accumulation of "cobwebs, moths and bookworms." Critics of Scotus' work described his followers as "dunces"; the "dunce cap" was later used as a form of punishment in schools and the word "dunce" has come to be used as a term to describe someone dull-witted.
When in the sixteenth century the Scotists argued against Renaissance humanism, the term duns or dunce became, in the mouths of humanists and reformers, a term of abuse and a synonym for one incapable of scholarship. Despite this, Scotism grew in Catholic Europe. Scotus's works were collected into many editions, particularly in the late fifteenth century with the advent of printing.
His school was probably at the height of its popularity at the beginning of the seventeenth century; during the sixteenth and the seventeenth centuries there were special Scotist chairs, e.g. at Paris, Rome, Coimbra, Salamanca, Alcalá, Padua, and Pavia. New ideas were included pseudographically in later editions of his work, such as the principle of explosion, now attributed to Pseudo-Scotus .
Scotism flourished well into the seventeenth century, and its influence can be seen in such writers as Descartes and Bramhall. Interest dwindled in the eighteenth century, and the revival of scholastic philosophy, known as neo-Scholasticism, was essentially a revival of Thomistic thinking.
Gerard Manley Hopkins was able to reconcile his religious calling and his vocation as a poet thanks to his reading of Duns Scotus. His poem As Kingfishers Catch Fire expresses Duns Scotus's ideas on "haecceity".
In popular media
In 2012 Fernando Muraca directed for TVCO and the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate the biopic Blessed Duns Scotus: Defender of the Immaculate Conception in Italian. It centers on the debate at the Paris University with glimpses of his infancy and Franciscan vocation. Adriano Braidotti played the adult Scotus and Emanuele Maria Gamboni played Scotus as a child.
OPERA OMNIA. (Vatican Edition = VE) Civitas Vaticana: Typis Polyglottis Vaticanis, 1950–. ORDINATIO (complete critical edition) I, De Ordinatione Ioannis Duns Scoti disquisitio historico critica.
Prologus totius operis, 1950. II, Ordinatio. Liber Primus.
Distinctiones 1–2, 1950. III, Ordinatio. Liber Primus.
Distinctio 3, 1954. IV, Ordinatio. Liber Primus.
Distinctiones 4–10, 1956. V, Ordinatio. Liber Primus.
Distinctiones 11–25, 1959. VI, Ordinatio. Liber Primus.
Distinctiones 26–48, 1963. VII, Ordinatio. Liber Secundus.
Distinctiones 1–3, 1973. VIII, Ordinatio. Liber Secundus.
Distinctiones 4–44, 2001. IX, Ordinatio. Liber Tertius.
Distinctiones 1–17, 2006. X, Ordinatio. Liber Tertius.
Distinctiones 26–40, 2007. XI, Ordinatio. Liber Quartus.
Distinctiones 1–7, 2008. XII, Ordinatio. Liber Quartus.
Distinctiones 8–13, 2010. XIII, Ordinatio. Liber Quartus, Distinctiones 14–42, 2011.
XIV, Ordinatio. Liber Quartus, Distinctiones 43–49, 2013. LECTURA XVI, Lectura in Librum Primum Sententiarum.
Prologus et Distinctiones 1–7, 1960. XVII, Lectura in Librum Primum Sententiarum. Distinctiones 8–45, 1966.
XVIII, Lectura in Librum Secundum Sententiarum. Distinctiones 1–6, 1982. XIX, Lectura in Librum Secundum Sententiarum.
Distinctiones 7–44, 1993. XX, Lectura in Librum Tertium Sententiarum. Distinctiones 1–17, 2003.
XXI, Lectura in Librum Tertium Sententiarum. Distinctiones 18–40, 2004. OPERA PHILOSOPHICA (= OP). St. Bonaventure, NY: The Franciscan Institute:, 1997–2006: Vol. I: Quaestiones super Porphyrius Isagoge et Aristoteles Categoriae, Franciscan Institute Publications, 1999.
Vol. II: Quaestiones super Peri hermeneias et Sophistici Elenchis (along with) Theoremata, Franciscan Institute Publications, 2004, . Vol. III-IV: Quaestiones super libros Metaphysicorum Aristotelis Franciscan Institute Publications, 2004. . Vol. V: Quaestiones super Secundum et Tertium de Anima.
Franciscan Institute Publications, 2006. . The Examined Report of the Paris Lecture, Reportatio I-A, Volume 1, edited and translated by Allan B. Wolter, OFM and Oleg Bychkov. Franciscan Institute Publications, 2004 The Examined Report of the Paris Lecture, Reportatio I-A, Volume 2, edited and translated by Allan B. Wolter, OFM and Oleg Bychkov.
Franciscan Institute Publications, 2008. English translations John Duns Scotus, A Treatise on God as First Principle. Chicago: Franciscan Herald Press 1982.
A Latin text and English translation of the De Primo Principio. Second edition, revised, with a commentary by Allan Wolter, (First edition 1966). John Duns Scotus, God and Creatures.
The Quodlibetal Questions, Translated by Wolter, Allan B., OFM, and Felix Alluntis, Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press, 1975. Duns Scotus on the Will and Morality, Translated by Wolter, Allan B., OFM, Washington, DC: The Catholic University of America Press, 1986.
Duns Scotus: Philosophical Writings, Translated by Wolter, Allan B., OFM, Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, 1987. Duns Scotus' Parisian Proof for the Existence of God, edited By Allan B. Wolter and Marilyn McCord Adams, Franciscan Studies 42, 1982, pp. 248–321. (Latin text and English translation).
John Duns Scotus, Contingency and Freedom. Lectura I 39, translation, commentary and introduction by A. Vos Jaczn, H. Veldhuis, A.H. Looman-Graaskamp, E. Dekker and N.W. den Bok. The New Synthese Historical Library 4.
Dordrecht/Boston/London: Kluwer, 1994. Questions on the Metaphysics of Aristotle by John Duns Scotus, Translated by Etzkorn, Girard J., and Allan B. Wolter, OFM, St. Bonaventure, NY: The Franciscan Institute, 1997–1998. John Duns Scotus.
Four Questions on Mary, Introduction with Latin text and English translation and notes by Allan B. Wolter, OFM, Franciscan Institute Publications, 2000. John Duns Scotus. A Treatise on Potency and Act.
Questions on the Metaphysics of Aristotle Book IX, Introduction with Latin text and English translation and notes by Allan B. Wolter, OFM, Franciscan Institute Publications, 2000. John Duns Scotus. Political and Economic Philosophy, Introduction with Latin text and English translation and notes by Allan B. Wolter, OFM, Franciscan Institute Publications, 2001.
Duns Scotus on Divine Love: Texts and Commentary on Goodness and Freedom, God and Humans, translated by A. Vos, H. Veldhuis, E. Dekker, N.W. den Bok and A.J. Beck (ed.). Aldershot: Ashgate 2003. John Duns Scotus. Early Oxford Lecture on Individuation, Introduction with Latin text and English translation and notes by Allan B. Wolter, OFM, Franciscan Institute Publications, 2005.
John Duns Scotus. Questions on Aristotle's Categories, Translated by Lloyd A. Newton, Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press, 2014. Duns Scotus on Time and Existence: The Questions on Aristotle's "De interpretatione", Translated with Introduction and Commentary by Edward Buckner and Jack Zupko, Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press, 2014.
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1373954588 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.