Electoral reform
Electoral reform is a change in electoral systems that alters how public desires, usually expressed by cast votes, produce election results.
≈ 9 min read
Electoral reform. encyclopegia.org, snapshot enwiki-001374725504. /a/electoral-reform
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Electoral reform is a change in electoral systems that alters how public desires, usually expressed by cast votes, produce election results.
South Africa
In 1948, when the National Party won a majority of seats with only a minority of votes, it instituted a herrenvolk democracy and prevented blacks from voting. With the end of apartheid in 1994, South Africa switched to more universal suffrage and a form of proportional representation. Since 1994, successive commissions recommended electoral reform for South Africa.
Following the 2024 election, the Electoral Reform Consultation Panel saw a need to bring representatives closer to voters and recommended reducing the size of districts. The districts are the provinces themselves and their representation ranges from 5 seats to 47 seats.
Late 20th century
With the rise of the SDP-Liberal Alliance following 1981's Limehouse Declaration, Britain gained a popular third-party bloc that supported significant reform of the voting and parliamentary systems. Several polls throughout the early 1980s placed the Alliance in front of Labour and the Conservatives, and nearly all had them within contention.
The continuing Liberal Party had until then received minimal support at elections and little influence on government, with the brief exception of the Lib–Lab pact in the late 1970s, but in which their influence was limited. Despite receiving roughly a quarter of the popular vote in both the 1983 and 1987 elections, however, few SDP-Liberal candidates were elected owing to FPTP requiring a plurality in each constituency and their vote being spread far more evenly geographically than the main parties.
Therefore, the Conservatives, who benefited from overrepresentation of their vote and underrepresentation of the Alliance vote, won large majorities in the House of Commons during this period and reform remained off the agenda. Elections to the European Parliament in mainland Britain used FPTP from their start in 1979 but were switched to a closed party list before the 1999 elections through the European Parliamentary Elections Act 1999 because the European Parliament mandated the use of proportional representation (more specifically either a party list or single transferable vote) in their elections.
21st century
When Labour regained power in 1997, they had committed in their manifesto to a slew of new reformist policies relating to modernisation and democratisation of various institutions through electoral reform. For general elections, they had committed to implementing the findings of the Jenkins Commission, which was set up to evaluate flaws in FPTP and propose a new electoral system that would suit the quirks of British politics.
The commission reported back, including a proposal for AV+, but its findings were not embraced by the government and were never put before the House of Commons; therefore, FPTP remained in place for subsequent elections. They introduced a number of new assemblies, in London, Wales and Scotland, and opted for additional-member systems of PR in all of these.
They also adopted the supplementary vote system for directly elected mayors. While not specifically committing to elections by name, they had promised to abolish all hereditary peers in the House of Lords and establish a system by which representation in the Lords "more accurately reflected the proportion of votes cast at the previous election".
Having faced continual pressure against any reform from the Lords themselves, Prime Minister Tony Blair was forced to water-down his proposals and agree to a settlement with the Conservative leader in the Lords in which 92 hereditary peers would remain, along with faith-based peers, and all others would be life peers appointed by either the prime minister directly, or on the recommendation of an independent panel. In Scotland, a Labour / Liberal Democrat coalition in the new Scottish Parliament later introduced STV for local elections.
However, such reforms encountered problems. When 7 percent of votes (over 140,000) were discounted or spoilt in the 2007 Scottish Parliamentary and local council elections, Scottish first minister Alex Salmond protested that "the decision to conduct an STV election at the same time as a first-past-the-post ballot for the Scottish Parliament was deeply mistaken".
In the 2010 general election campaign, the possibility of a hung parliament and the earlier expenses scandal pushed electoral reform up the agenda, something long supported by the Liberal Democrats. There were protests in favour of electoral reform organised by Take Back Parliament.
The Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition government held a referendum on introducing AV for the Commons on 5 May 2011, which, despite commitments to review the voting system for "fair vote reforms" in the Conservative manifesto, and an unequivocal backing of AV from the Labour Party in their manifesto, was met by campaigning for No, and indifference with no clear or consistent party position, respectively. It was comprehensively defeated.
The result of the referendum has had long-lasting political repercussions, being cited by later Conservative governments as proof that public opinion was decidedly against any reform of the voting system. As the Conservatives continued to be in government in some form or another until 2024, electoral reform was never seriously close to implementation post-2011.
The coalition had also committed to reforming the House of Lords into a primarily elected body, and a bill proposing elections under PR determining the majority of membership was put before the House in 2012. The bill was pulled before passage however, as while the government imposed a three-line whip on its MPs to support the measure, a large rebellion among Conservatives was developing.
Matters were not helped by the Labour Party promising to vote against the measures, despite having promised to support similar such measures in the manifesto in 2010. To avoid a painful and humiliating defeat, Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg, who had instigated the bill's passage and whose Liberal Democrat party had long-since supported the reform, was forced to back down.
Clegg accused the Conservatives of breaking the coalition agreement, and Prime Minister David Cameron was said to be furious at his backbenchers for endangering the government's stability and authority. (See main article: House of Lords Reform Bill 2012) The 2015 general election was expected to deliver a hung parliament.
However, the Conservative Party won a narrow majority, winning 51 percent of the seats on 37 percent of the national vote, but the Green Party, UKIP and the Liberal Democrats were under-represented and the Scottish National Party over-represented in the results compared to a proportional system. As a result, both during the campaign and after, there were various calls for electoral reform.
Nigel Farage, leader of UKIP, declared support for AV+. Gus O'Donnell, the Cabinet Secretary from 2005 to 2011, argued that FPTP is not fit for purpose given the move towards multi-party politics seen in the country. Journalist Jeremy Paxman also supported a move away from FPTP.
In 2016, it was reported that in a conversation with a Labour peer in 1997, the Queen had expressed her opposition to changing the voting system to proportional representation. In 2021 home secretary Priti Patel proposed replacing the supplementary vote method used in some elections in England and Wales with FPTP.
The posts affected were the Mayor of London, elected mayors in nine combined authorities in England, and police and crime commissioners in England and Wales. In the Queen's Speech of May that year, the Government proposed the introduction of compulsory Photo ID for voters in England and in UK-wide elections. These measures were implemented with the Elections Act 2022.
A number of groups in the United Kingdom are campaigning for electoral reform, including the Electoral Reform Society (ERS), Make Votes Matter, Make Votes Count Coalition, Fairshare, and the Labour Campaign for Electoral Reform. In the lead up to, and especially since, the 2019 general election, various anti-Brexit pressure groups and online political influencers have moved to a position supporting and calling for widespread tactical voting to bring about more favourable election results under FPTP to those parties that support reform, most notably Best for Britain.
In its most comprehensive form, such proposals include a national roll-out of the Unite to Remain pact in 2019, in which the Liberal Democrats, Greens, and Plaid Cymru stood down in some constituencies and endorsed each other for election, but on a much wider scale and including the Labour Party, with the expressed aim of building a rainbow coalition that could enact PR in a new parliament. Their campaign for soft-left cooperation is ongoing and has primarily focused on social media initiatives and sponsoring research into voting patterns.
While the idea of a progressive alliance has seen significant discourse in left-leaning spaces, particularly on Twitter, it is thought unlikely to ever happen. The Labour Party does not support electoral reform and has a clause in their constitution (section 5, clause IV) requiring them to stand candidates in every parliamentary seat bar Northern Ireland.
Senior figures in Labour, the Liberal Democrats, and Greens have, with varying degrees of explicitness, all dismissed the idea. There is also concern that such a proposal would not function as intended if implemented, as none of the 92 constituencies Unite to Remain operated in were successful, and some believe both that voters would react negatively to what could be perceived as "backroom deals" and "stitch-ups", or that association with the other parties would harm each one's reputation with target voters.
In Wales, the Senedd Cymru (Members and Elections) Act 2024 changed the electoral system for the Senedd from additional member using the D'Hondt method to proportional representation using closed lists. The UK Labour government elected in July 2024 has a manifesto commitment to restrict donations to political parties and reduce the minimum voting age from 18 to 16.
In December 2024, Liberal Democrat MP Sarah Olney introduced the Elections (Proportional Representation) Bill to the Commons under the ten minute rule, where it passed its first reading. The bill fell before its second reading at the prorogation of the 2024–2026 parliamentary session.
Further reading
Dummett, Michael (1997). Principles of Electoral Reform. New York: Oxford University Press.
International
A Handbook of Electoral System Design from International IDEA ACE Project
United States
AEI-Brookings Election Reform Caltech/MIT Voting Technology Project Fairvote
Canada
Election Districts Voting Fair Vote Canada Paul McKeever's Testimony to the Select Committee on Electoral Reform (Canada) : No electoral system is more "democratic" than any other Electoral Reform Canada Voting Reform Canada FPTP ... It Works for Canada / Notre Systeme Electoral ... Ca March pour Moi (Facebook group)
Australia
PR Society of Australia
United Kingdom
Electoral Reform Society (UK) Guide to different types of Electoral Reform – New Statesman (UK) Guardian Special Report – Electoral Reform
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1374725504 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.