Eminent domain

Eminent Domain may refer to: * Eminent domain, the power of a state to take private property for public use **Eminent domain in the United States * Eminent Domain (film), 1990 * "Eminent Domain" (Hell on Wheels), a 2013 episode of the TV…

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 14 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

Eminent Domain may refer to: * Eminent domain, the power of a state to take private property for public use **Eminent domain in the United States * Eminent Domain (film), 1990 * "Eminent Domain" (Hell on Wheels), a 2013 episode of the TV drama * "Eminent Domain" (The Killing), a 2013 episode of the TV drama * Pax Imperia: Eminent Domain, a video game

in China led to the displacement of over 1.3 million people, highlighting the potential social and environmental costs of large-scale development projects using eminent domain. Eminent domain, also known as land acquisition, compulsory purchase, resumption, compulsory acquisition, or expropriation, is the compulsory acquisition of private property for public use.

It does not include the power to take and transfer ownership of private property from one property owner to another private property owner without a valid public purpose and the payment of just compensation. This power can be legislatively delegated by the state to municipalities, government subdivisions, or even to private persons or corporations, when they are authorized to exercise the functions of a public character.

The most common uses of property taken by eminent domain have been for roads, government buildings and public utilities. Many railroads were given the right of eminent domain to obtain land or easements in order to build and connect rail networks.

In the mid-20th century, a new application of eminent domain was pioneered, in which the government could take the property and transfer it to a private third party for redevelopment. This was initially done only on properties that had been deemed "blighted" or a "development impediment", on the principle that such properties had a negative impact upon surrounding property owners, but was later expanded to allow the taking of any private property when the new third-party owner could develop the property in such a way as to bring in increased tax revenues.

Some jurisdictions require that the taker make an offer to purchase the subject property before resorting to the use of eminent domain. However, once the property is taken and the judgment is final, the condemnor owns it in fee simple, and may put it to uses other than those specified in the eminent domain action.

Takings may be of the subject property in its entirety (total take) or in part (partial take), either quantitatively or qualitatively (either partially in fee simple or, commonly, an easement, or any other interest less than the full fee simple title).

Meaning

The term "eminent domain" was taken from the legal treatise De jure belli ac pacis (On the Law of War and Peace), written in 1625 by the Dutch jurist Hugo Grotius, which used the term (Latin for "supreme ownership") and described the power as follows: The property of subjects is under the eminent domain of the state, so that the state or those who act for it may use and even alienate and destroy such property, not only in the case of extreme necessity, in which even private persons have a right over the property of others, but for ends of public utility, to which ends those who founded civil society must be supposed to have intended that private ends should give way. But, when this is done, the state is bound to make good the loss to those who lose their property.

The exercise of eminent domain is not limited to real property. Condemnors may also take personal property, even intangible property such as contract rights, patents, trade secrets, and copyrights.

Even the taking of a professional sports team's franchise has been held by the California Supreme Court to be within the purview of the "public use" constitutional limitation; although eventually, that taking (of the Oakland Raiders' NFL franchise) was not permitted because it was deemed to violate the Interstate Commerce Clause of the U.S. Constitution. A taking of property must be accompanied by payment of "just compensation" to the [former] owner.

In theory, this is supposed to put the owner in the same position that he would have been in had his property not been taken. But in practice U.S. Courts have limited compensation to the property's fair market value, considering its highest and best use.

But though rarely granted, this is not the exclusive measure of compensation; see Kimball Laundry Co. v. United States (business losses in temporary takings) and United States v. Pewee Coal Co. (operating losses caused by government operations of a mine seized during World War II). In most takings owners are not compensated for a variety of incidental losses caused by the taking of their property that, though incurred and readily demonstrable in other cases, are deemed by U.S. courts to be noncompensable in eminent domain.

The same is true of attorneys' and appraisers' fees. However, as a matter of legislative grace rather than constitutional requirement, some of these losses (e.g., business goodwill) have been made compensable by state legislative enactments, and in the U.S. may be partially covered by provisions of the federal Uniform Relocation Assistance Act.

Zimbabwe

In the 1980s, 4,400 white Rhodesians owned 51% of the country's land while 4.3 million black Rhodesians owned 42%, with the remainder being non-agricultural land. Since the 1990s, the Zimbabwean government under Robert Mugabe has compulsorily purchased a great deal of land and homes of mainly white farmers in the course of the land reform movement in Zimbabwe.

The government argued that such land reform was necessary to redistribute the land to Zimbabweans dispossessed of their lands during colonialism. Compensation has been delayed, though in 2022 the Zimbabwean government agreed to pay US$3.5 billion in compensation to farmers who lost their land during land reform.

Europe

In many European nations, the European Convention on Human Rights provides protection from an appropriation of private property by the state. Article 8 of the Convention provides that "Everyone has the right to respect for his private and family life, his home, and his correspondence" and prohibits interference with this right by the state, unless the interference is in accordance with law and necessary in the interests of national security, public safety, economic well-being of the country, prevention of disorder or crime, protection of health or morals, or protection of the rights and freedoms of others.

This right is expanded by Article 1 of the First Protocol to the Convention, which states that "Every natural person or legal person is entitled to the peaceful enjoyment of his possessions." Again, this is subject to exceptions where state deprivation of private possessions is in the general or public interest, is in accordance with law, and, in particular, to secure payment of taxes.

Settled case-law of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) provides that just compensation must be paid in cases of expropriation.

France

In France, the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen similarly mandates just and preliminary compensation before expropriation and a is commonly required, to demonstrate a public benefit. Notably, in 1945, by decree of General Charles de Gaulle based on unproven accusations of collaboration with the Nazi occupier, the Renault company was expropriated from Louis Renault posthumously and nationalised as , without compensation.

Germany

The Basic Law for the Federal Republic of Germany states in its Article 14 (3) that "an expropriation is only allowed for the public good" and just compensation must be made. It also provides for the right to have the amount of the compensation checked by a court.

Italy

– or more formally ("expropriation for public utility") – in Italy takes place within the frame of civil law, as an expression of the ( power). The law regulating expropriation is the D.P.R. n.327 of 2001, amended by D.Lgs. n.302 of 2002; it supersedes the old expropriation law, the Royal Decree n.2359 of 1865.

Other national and regional laws may apply, not always giving full compensation to the owner. Expropriation can be total (the whole property is expropriated) or partial; permanent or temporary. Article 42 of the Italian Constitution and article 834 of the Italian Civil Code state that any private goods can be expropriated for public utility.

Furthermore, the article 2 of the Constitution binds Italian citizens to respect their "mandatory duties of political, economic and social solidarity". The implementation of eminent domain follows two principles: legality: a public institution can expropriate private goods only in the cases law allows it and respecting its procedures (following article 23 of the Italian Constitution); compensation: (art. 42/III) the State must provide a certain amount of money as compensation, which is determined by law.

According to the Italian Constitutional Court, this compensation is not required to be equal to the market value of the expropriated good, although this sum must not be merely symbolic. Nazionalizzazione ("nationalization"), instead, is provided for by article 43 of the Constitution.

It transfers to governmental authority and property a whole industrial sector, if it is deemed to be a natural or 'de facto' monopoly, and an essential service of public utility. The most famous nationalization in Italy was the 1962 nationalization of the electrical power sector.

Spain

Article 33.3 of the Spanish Constitution of 1978 allows forced expropriation ( ) only where justified on the grounds of public utility or social interest and subject to the payment of appropriate compensation as provided for by law.

Sweden

The right of the state or a municipality to buy property when it is determined to be of "particular public interest" is regulated in (1972:719). The government purchases the property at an estimated market value plus a 25% premium. The law also states that the property owner shall not suffer economic harm because of the expropriation.

England and Wales

After his victory in 1066, William the Conqueror seized virtually all land in England. Although he maintained absolute power over the land, he granted fiefs to landholders who served as stewards, paying fees and providing military services. During the Hundred Years' War in the 14th century, Edward III used the Crown's right of purveyance for massive expropriations.

Chapter 28 of Magna Carta required that immediate cash payment be made for expropriations. As the king's power was broken down in the ensuing centuries, tenants were regarded as holding ownership rights rather than merely possessory rights over their land. In 1427, a statute was passed granting Commission of sewers in Lincolnshire the power to take land without compensation.

After the early 16th century, however, Parliamentary takings of land for roads, bridges, and other infrastructure generally did require compensation. The common practice was to pay 10% more than the assessed value. However, as the voting franchise was expanded to include more non-landowners, the bonus was eliminated.

Despite contrary statements found in some American law, in the United Kingdom, compulsory purchase valuation cases were tried by juries well into the 20th century, such as Attorney-General v De Keyser's Royal Hotel Ltd (1919). In England and Wales, and other jurisdictions that follow the principles of English law, the related term compulsory purchase is used.

The landowner is compensated with a price agreed or stipulated by an appropriate person; where agreement on price cannot be achieved, the value of the taken land is determined by the Upper Tribunal. The operative law is a patchwork of statues and case law.

The principal acts are the Lands Clauses Consolidation Act 1845 (8 & 9 Vict. c. 18), the Land Compensation Act 1961, the Compulsory Purchase Act 1965, the Land Compensation Act 1973, the Acquisition of Land Act 1981, part IX of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, the Planning and Compensation Act 1991, and the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004.

Australia

The term resumption is used in Australia for compulsory acquisition, reflecting the fact that, as a matter of Australian law, all land was originally owned by the Crown before it was sold, leased or granted. Through an act of compulsory acquisition, the Crown is therefore seen to be "resuming" possession.

In Australia, section 51 (xxxi) of the Australian Constitution permits the Commonwealth Parliament to make laws with respect to "the acquisition of property on just terms from any State or person for any purpose in respect of which the Parliament has power to make laws". This has been construed as meaning that just compensation may not always include monetary or proprietary recompense, rather it is for the court to determine what is just.

It may be necessary to imply a need for compensation in the interests of justice, lest the law be invalidated. Property subject to resumption is not restricted to real estate, as authority from the Federal Court has extended the States' power to resume property to any form of physical property.

For the purposes of section 51 (xxxi), money is not property that may be compulsorily acquired. The Commonwealth must also derive some benefit from the property acquired, that is, the Commonwealth can "only legislate for the acquisition of Property for particular purposes".

Accordingly, the power does not extend to allow legislation designed merely to seek to extinguish the previous owner's title. The states and territories' powers of resumption on the other hand are not so limited. Section 43(1) of the Lands Acquisition Act 1998 (NT) grants the Minister the power to acquire land 'for any purpose whatever'.

The High Court of Australia interpreted this provision literally, relieving the Territory government of any public purpose limitation on the power. This finding permitted the Territory government to acquire land subject to Native Title, effectively extinguishing the Native Title interest in the land.

Kirby J in dissent, along with a number of commentators, viewed this as a missed opportunity to comment on the exceptional nature of powers of resumption exercised in the absence of a public purpose limitation.

The Bahamas

In the Bahamas, the Acquisition of Land Act operates to permit the acquisition of land where it is deemed likely to be required for a public purpose. The land can be acquired by private agreement or compulsory purchase (s7 of the Act). Under section 24 of the Acquisition of Land Act, the purchaser may purchase the interest of the mortgagee of any land acquired under the Act.

To do so, the purchaser must pay the principal sum and interest, together with costs and charges plus six months' additional interest.

Panama

In Panama, the government must pay a fair amount of money to the owner of the property to be expropriated.

Brazil

Brazil's expropriation laws are governed by the Presidential Decree No. 3365 of June 21, 1941.

Chile

Art. 19, No. 24, of the Chilean Constitution says in part, "In no case may anyone be deprived of his property, of the assets affected or any of the essential faculties or powers of ownership, except by virtue of a general or a special law which authorizes expropriation for the public benefit or the national interest, duly qualified by the legislator. The expropriated party may protest the legality of the expropriation action before the ordinary courts of justice and shall, at all times, have the right to indemnification for patrimonial harm actually caused, to be fixed by mutual agreement or by a sentence pronounced by said courts in accordance with the law."

Catholicism

Since 1967, the encyclical Populorum progressio, an encyclical on Catholic social teaching by Pope Paul VI, allows the expropriation of land estates for common good needs.

See also

Angary: during wars Confiscation Individual reclamation Inverse condemnation Land bonds Law of the land (Jewish) Legal plunder Navigable servitude: waterways regulation Water law Manifest destiny Compulsory purchase order Georgism

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1164463455 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

31 named source(s) extracted from the cited revision. A source with no author is shown by its publication; nothing is invented.