False diffusion

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 7 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

False diffusion is a type of error observed when the upwind scheme is used to approximate the convection term in convection–diffusion equations. The more accurate central difference scheme can be used for the convection term, but for grids with cell Peclet number more than 2, the central difference scheme is unstable and the simpler upwind scheme is often used. The resulting error from the upwind differencing scheme has a diffusion-like appearance in two- or three-dimensional co-ordinate systems and is referred as "false diffusion". False-diffusion errors in numerical solutions of convection-diffusion problems, in two- and three-dimensions, arise from the numerical approximations of the convection term in the conservation equations. Over the past 20 years many numerical techniques have been developed to solve convection-diffusion equations and none are problem-free, but false diffusion is one of the most serious problems and a major topic of controversy and confusion among numerical analysts.

Definition

edit edit source

False diffusion is defined as an error having a diffusion-like appearance, obtained when the upwind scheme is used in multidimensional cases to solve for the distribution of transported properties flowing non-orthogonally to one or more of the system's major axes. The error is absent when the flow is orthogonal or parallel to each major axis.

Example

edit edit source

In figure 1, u = 2 and v = 2 m/s everywhere so the velocity field is uniform and perpendicular to the diagonal (XX). The boundary conditions for temperature on north and west wall is 100 ̊C and for east and south wall is 0 ̊C. This region is meshed into 10×10 equal grids. Take two cases, (i) with diffusion coefficient ≠ 0 and, case (ii) with diffusion coefficient = 0.

Case (i)

edit edit source

In this case, heat from west and south walls is carried by convection flow towards north and east walls. Heat is also diffused across the diagonal XX from upper to lower triangle. Figure 2 shows the approximate temperature distribution.

Case (ii)

edit edit source

In this case heat from west and south walls is convected by flow towards north and east. There will be no diffusion across the diagonal XX but, when the upwind scheme is applied the results are similar to case (i) where actual diffusion is occurring. This error is known as false diffusion.

Background

edit edit source

In early approaches, derivatives in the differential form of the governing transport equation were replaced by finite difference approximations, usually central differencing approximations with second order accuracy. However, for large Peclet numbers (generally > 2) this approximation gave inaccurate results. It was recognized independently by several investigators[1][2] that the less expensive but only first order accurate upwind scheme can be employed but that this scheme produces results with false diffusion for multidimensional cases. Many new schemes have been developed to counter false diffusion but a reliable, accurate and economical discretisation scheme is still unavailable.

Reducing errors

edit edit source

Finer mesh

edit edit source

False diffusion with the upwind scheme is reduced by increasing the mesh density. In the results of figure 3 and 4 the false diffusion error is lowest in figure 4(b) with finer mesh size.

Other schemes

edit edit source

False diffusion error also can be reduced by using schemes such as the power law scheme, QUICK scheme, exponential scheme, and SUCCA, and others.[3][4]

Improving the upwind scheme

edit edit source

False diffusion with the simple upwind scheme occurs because the scheme does not take into account grid/flow direction inclination. An approximate expression for the false-diffusion term in two dimensions has been given by de Vahl Davis and Mallinson(1972)[5]

τfc⋆=ρ UΔxΔysin⁡2θ4(Δysin3θ+Δxcos3θ) 1

where U is the resultant velocity and θ is the angle made by the velocity vector with the x direction. False diffusion is absent when the resultant flow is aligned with either of the sets of grid lines and is greatest when the flow direction is 45˚ to the grid lines.

Determining the accuracy of approximation for the convection term

edit edit source

Using Taylor series for ϕW and ϕP at the time t + kt are

ϕWk=ϕwk−(δxi2)(∂ϕ∂x)wk+12!(δxi2)2(∂2ϕ∂x2)wk+⋯. 2a
ϕPk=ϕwk−(δxi2)(∂ϕ∂x)wk+12!(δxi2)2(∂2ϕ∂x2)wk+⋯. 2b

according to the upwind approximation for convection (UAC),ϕwk=ϕWk. Neglecting the higher order in equation (2a), the error of convected flux due to this approximation is −ρwuwδyi(δxi2)(∂ϕ∂x)wk. It has the form of flux of ϕ by false diffusion with a diffusion co-efficient[6]

τfc,UAC⋆=ρwuw(Δxi2) 3

The subscript fc is a reminder that this is a false diffusion arising from the estimate of the convected flux at the instant t+kΔt using UAC.

Skew upwind corner convection algorithm (SUCCA)

edit edit source

SUCCA takes the local flow direction into account by introducing the influence of upwind corner cells into the discretized conservation equation in the general governing transport equation. In Fig 5, SUCCA is applied within nine cell grid cluster. Considering the SW corner inflow for cell P, the SUCCA equations for the convective transport of the conserved species ϕ are

CPϕP=(m˙w−(m˙s)2m˙w)ϕW+(m˙s+(m˙s)2m˙w)ϕSW+0.ϕS for 0<θ≤45 4

i.e.,

CPϕP=CwϕW+CswϕSW 5
CPϕP=(m˙s−(m˙w)2m˙s)ϕW+(m˙w+(m˙w)2m˙s)ϕSW+0.ϕW for 45<θ<90 6

i.e.,

CPϕP=CsϕS+CswϕSW 7

This formulation satisfies all the criteria of convergence and stability.[7]

In Fig. 6, as mesh is refined, the upwind scheme gives more accurate results but SUCCA offers a nearly exact solution and is more useful in avoiding multidimensional false diffusion errors.

See also

edit edit source

References

edit edit source
  1. ^ Courant, Richard; Isaacson, Eugene; Rees, Mina (August 1952). "On the solution of nonlinear hyperbolic differential equations by finite differences". Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics. 5 (3): 243–255. doi:10.1002/cpa.3160050303.
  2. ^ Torrance, Kenneth E. (1968). "Comparison of finite difference computations of natural convection". Journal of Research of the National Bureau of Standards: Mathematics and Mathematical Physics. 72B: 281–301.
  3. ^ Versteeg, H.K.; Malalasekera, W. (2007). An introduction to computational fluid dynamics : the finite volume method (2nd ed.). Harlow: Prentice Hall. ISBN 9780131274983.
  4. ^ Patankar, Suhas V. (1980). Numerical heat transfer and fluid flow (14. printing. ed.). Bristol, PA: Taylor & Francis. ISBN 9780891165224.
  5. ^ Patankar, Suhas V. (1980). Numerical heat transfer and fluid flow page no:108 (14. printing. ed.). Bristol, PA: Taylor & Francis. ISBN 9780891165224.
  6. ^ Raithby, G. D. (1976-09-01). "A critical evaluation of upstream differencing applied to problems involving fluid flow". Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering. 9 (1): 75–103. Bibcode:1976CMAME...9...75R. doi:10.1016/0045-7825(76)90078-5. ISSN 0045-7825.
  7. ^ Carey, C.; Scanlon, T. J.; Fraser, S. M. (1993-05-01). "SUCCA—an alternative scheme to reduce the effects of multidimensional false diffusion". Applied Mathematical Modelling. 17 (5): 263–270. doi:10.1016/0307-904X(93)90048-L. ISSN 0307-904X.

Further reading

edit edit source

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1373508971 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.