False pretenses

False Pretenses is a 1935 American romantic comedy film directed by Charles Lamont and starring Irene Ware.

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 7 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

False Pretenses is a 1935 American romantic comedy film directed by Charles Lamont and starring Irene Ware.

In criminal law, property is obtained by false pretenses when the acquisition results from the intentional misrepresentation of a past or existing fact.

Elements

The elements of false pretenses are: a false representation of a material past or existing fact which the person making the representation knows is false made for the purpose of causing and which does cause the victim to pass title to his property False pretenses is a statutory offense in most jurisdictions; subject matter covered by statute varies accordingly, and is not necessarily limited to tangible personal property - some statutes include intangible personal property and services. For example, the North Carolina false pretense statute applies to obtaining "any money, goods, property, services, choses in action, or any other thing of value ..."

Under common law, false pretense is defined as a representation of a present or past fact, which the thief knows to be false, and which he intends will and does cause the victim to pass title of his property. That is, false pretense is the acquisition of title from a victim by fraud or misrepresentation of a material past or present fact.

"A false representation..."

There must be a description or portrayal of something that is false. If a person makes a statement about something that he mistakenly believes to be untrue there is no false representation.

For example, if a person represents that the stone in a ring is a diamond when he believes that is in fact made of cubic zirconia, he is not guilty of false pretenses if it turns out that the ring was in fact a diamond. The representation must be false at the time title passes.

Thus if the representation was false when made but is true at the time title to the property passes there is no crime. For example, representing to a seller that you have funds available in your bank account to pay for the goods when in fact your account has a zero balance is not false pretenses if at the time the transaction takes place adequate funds are present in the account.

The representation may be oral or written. The misrepresentation has to be affirmative. A failure to disclose a fact does not fit this misrepresentation in common law, unless there is a fiduciary duty between the thief and victim.

Moreover, opinion and puffing are not considered misrepresentation as they color the facts but do not misrepresent them.

"...of a material past or existing fact..."

The representation must relate to a material past or existing fact. A representation concerning a future state of facts is not sufficient. Nor is merely an expression of opinion.

"...which the person making the representation knows is false..."

A mistaken representation about some past or existing state of facts is not sufficient for false pretense.

"...made for the purpose of causing and which does cause..."

It is essential that the victim of the false pretenses must actually be deceived by the misrepresentation: the victim must transfer title to the property in reliance on the representation; and the victim being deceived must be a major (if not the only) reason for the victim's transferring title to the defendant. Simply making a false promise or statement is not sufficient.

It is not a defense to false pretenses charge that a reasonable person would not have been deceived by the false representation. No matter how gullible the victim, if they were in fact deceived then the offense has been committed. On the other hand, the offense requires the victim believe the representation to be true.

If the person to whom the representation has been made has doubts or serious misgivings about the truth of the representation but nonetheless goes through with the transaction, they have not been deceived - they have basically assumed the risk of a false representation.

History

The first "modern" false pretense statute, the Obtaining Money by False Pretences, etc. Act 1757 (30 Geo. 2. c. 24) was enacted by Parliament in 1757. The statute prohibited obtaining "money, goods, wares, or merchandise" by "false pretence."

The first general embezzlement statute, the Embezzlement Act 1799 (39 Geo. 3. c. 85), was enacted by Parliament in 1799. Neither of these statutes were part of the American common law.

However, most states passed laws similar to the English statutes.

The three major theft offences were larceny, embezzlement and false pretences. Larceny was a common law offence (created by judicial action) while embezzlement and false pretences were statutory offences (created by legislative action). Larceny is by far the oldest.

The elements of larceny were "well-settled" by the 13th century. The only other theft offence then existing was cheat which was a misdemeanor. Cheat was a primitive version of the crime of false pretences and involved obtaining property by the use of false weights or measures.

In 1541 a statute, the Counterfeit Letters, etc. Act 1541 (33 Hen. 8. c. 1) was enacted by Parliament that made it a misdemeanor to obtain property by a false token or a counterfeit letter "made in any other man's name." This statute did not cover obtaining property by the use false spoken words.

The first "modern" false pretence statute, the Obtaining Money by False Pretences, etc. Act 1757 (30 Geo. 2. c. 24), was enacted by Parliament in 1757. The statute prohibited obtaining "money, goods, wares, or merchandise" by "false pretence."

The first general embezzlement statute, the Embezzlement Act 1799 (39 Geo. 3. c. 85), was enacted by Parliament in 1799. The broad distinction between this offence and larceny is that in the former the owner intends to part with his property, in the latter he does not.

This offence dates as a statutory crime practically from 1756. At common law the only remedy originally available for an owner who had been deprived of his goods by fraud was an indictment for the crime of cheating, or a civil action for deceit.

These remedies were insufficient to cover all cases where money or other properties had been obtained by false pretences, and the offence was first partially created by a statute of Henry VIII, the Counterfeit Letters, etc. Act 1541 (33 Hen. 8. c. 1), which enacted that if any person should falsely and deceitfully obtain any money, goods, etc., by means of any false token or counterfeit letter made in any other man's name, the offender should suffer any punishment other than death, at the discretion of the judge.

The scope of the offence was enlarged to include practically all false pretences by the Obtaining Money by False Pretences, etc. Act 1757, the provisions of which were embodied in the Larceny Act 1861. The pretence must be a false pretence of some existing fact, made for the purpose of inducing the prosecutor to part with his property (e.g. it was held not to be a false pretence to promise to pay for goods on delivery), and it may be by either words or conduct.

The property, too, must have been actually obtained by the false pretence. The owner must be induced by the pretence to make over the absolute and immediate ownership of the goods, otherwise it is larceny by means of a trick. It is not always easy, however, to draw a distinction between the various classes of offences.

In the case where a man goes into a restaurant and orders a meal, and, after consuming it, says that he has no means of paying for it, it was usual to convict for obtaining food by false pretences. But in R v Jones , an English court found that it is neither larceny nor false pretences, but an offence under the Debtors Act 1869, of obtaining credit by fraud.

R v Danger revealed a lacuna in the law. This was remedied by section 90 of the Larceny Act 1861. That section was replaced by section 32(2) of the Larceny Act 1916.

Section 32 of the Larceny Act 1916 read: The offence of obtaining by false pretences, contrary to section 32(1) of the Larceny Act 1916, was replaced by the offence of obtaining property by deception, contrary to section 15 of the Theft Act 1968. Section 32(2) of the Larceny Act 1916 was replaced by section 20(2) of the Theft Act 1968.

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1368318560 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

3 named source(s) extracted from the cited revision. A source with no author is shown by its publication; nothing is invented.