Group decision-making

Group decision-making (also known as collaborative decision-making or collective decision-making) is a situation faced when individuals collectively make a choice from the alternatives before them.

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 9 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

Group decision-making (also known as collaborative decision-making or collective decision-making) is a situation faced when individuals collectively make a choice from the alternatives before them. The decision is then no longer attributable to any single individual who is a member of the group.

This is because all the individuals and social group processes such as social influence contribute to the outcome. The decisions made by groups are often different from those made by individuals. In workplace settings, collaborative decision-making is one of the most successful models to generate buy-in from other stakeholders, build consensus, and encourage creativity.

According to the idea of synergy, decisions made collectively also tend to be more effective than decisions made by a single individual. In this vein, certain collaborative arrangements have the potential to generate better net performance outcomes than individuals acting on their own.

Under normal everyday conditions, collaborative or group decision-making would often be preferred and would generate more benefits than individual decision-making when there is the time for proper deliberation, discussion, and dialogue. This can be achieved through the use of committee, teams, groups, partnerships, or other collaborative social processes.

However, in some cases, there can also be drawbacks to this method.…

Group decision-making (also known as collaborative decision-making or collective decision-making) is a situation faced when individuals collectively make a choice from the alternatives before them. The decision is then no longer attributable to any single individual who is a member of the group.

This is because all the individuals and social group processes such as social influence contribute to the outcome. The decisions made by groups are often different from those made by individuals. In workplace settings, collaborative decision-making is one of the most successful models to generate buy-in from other stakeholders, build consensus, and encourage creativity.

According to the idea of synergy, decisions made collectively also tend to be more effective than decisions made by a single individual. In this vein, certain collaborative arrangements have the potential to generate better net performance outcomes than individuals acting on their own.

Under normal everyday conditions, collaborative or group decision-making would often be preferred and would generate more benefits than individual decision-making when there is the time for proper deliberation, discussion, and dialogue. This can be achieved through the use of committee, teams, groups, partnerships, or other collaborative social processes.

However, in some cases, there can also be drawbacks to this method. In extreme emergencies or crisis situations, other forms of decision-making might be preferable as emergency actions may need to be taken more quickly with less time for deliberation.

On the other hand, additional considerations must also be taken into account when evaluating the appropriateness of a decision-making framework. For example, the possibility of group polarization also can occur at times, leading some groups to make more extreme decisions than those of its individual members, in the direction of the individual inclinations.

There are also other examples where the decisions made by a group are flawed, such as the Bay of Pigs invasion, the incident on which the groupthink model of group decision-making is based. Factors that impact other social group behaviours also affect group decisions.

For example, groups high in cohesion, in combination with other antecedent conditions (e.g. ideological homogeneity and insulation from dissenting opinions) have been noted to have a negative effect on group decision-making and hence on group effectiveness. Moreover, when individuals make decisions as part of a group, there is a tendency to exhibit a bias towards discussing shared information (i.e. shared information bias), as opposed to unshared information.

Social decision schemes

Sometimes, groups may have established and clearly defined standards for making decisions, such as bylaws and statutes. However, it is often the case that the decision-making process is less formal, and might even be implicitly accepted. Social decision schemes are the methods used by a group to combine individual responses to come up with a single group decision.

There are a number of these schemes, but the following are the most common: Delegation: An individual, subgroup or external party makes the decision on behalf of the group. For instance, in an "authority scheme", the leader makes the decision or, in an oligarchy, a coalition of leading figures makes the decision.

Averaging: Each group member makes their own private and independent decision and all are later "averaged" to produce a decision. Elections: Group members vote on their preferences, either privately or publicly. These votes are then used to select a decision, either by plurality, simple majority, supermajority or other more or less complicated criterion.

Unanimity: A consensus scheme whereby the group discusses the issue until it reaches a unanimous agreement. This decision rule is what dictates the decision-making for most juries. Random: The group leaves the choice to chance.

For example, picking a number between 1 and 10 or flipping a coin. There are strengths and weaknesses to each of these social decision schemes. Delegation saves time and is a good method for less important decisions, but ignored members might react negatively.

Averaging responses will cancel out extreme opinions, but the final decision might disappoint many members. Plurality is the most consistent scheme when superior decisions are being made, and it involves the least amount of effort.

Voting, however, may lead to members feeling alienated when they lose a close vote, especially if the winner has less than half the votes, or to internal politics, or to conformity to other opinions. Consensus schemes involve members more deeply, and tend to lead to high levels of commitment. But, it might be difficult for the group to reach such decisions.

Normative model of decision-making

Groups have many advantages and disadvantages when making decisions. Groups, by definition, are composed of two or more people, and for this reason naturally have access to more information and have a greater capacity to process this information.

However, they also present a number of liabilities to decision-making, such as requiring more time to make choices and by consequence rushing to a low-quality agreement in order to be timely. Some issues are also so simple that a group decision-making process leads to too many cooks in the kitchen: for such trivial issues, having a group make the decision is overkill and can lead to failure.

Because groups offer both advantages and disadvantages in making decisions, Victor Vroom developed a normative model of decision-making that suggests different decision-making methods should be selected depending on the situation. In this model, Vroom identified five different decision-making processes.

Decide: The leader of the group uses other group members as sources of information, but makes the final decision independently and does not explain to group members why s/he required that information. Consult (individual): The leader talks to each group member alone and never consults a group meeting. S/he then makes the final decision in light of the information obtained in this manner.

Consult (group): The group and the leader meet and s/he consults the entire group at once, asking for opinions and information, then comes to a decision. Facilitate: The leader takes on a cooperative holistic approach, collaborating with the group as a whole as they work toward a unified and consensual decision.

The leader is non-directive and never imposes a particular solution on the group. In this case, the final decision is one made by the group, not by the leader. Delegate: The leader takes a backseat approach, passing the problem over to the group.

The leader is supportive, but allows the group to come to a decision without their direct collaboration.

"Sins of commission"

The misuse, abuse and/or inappropriate use of information, including: Belief perseverance : A group utilises information in their decision-making that has already been deemed inaccurate. Sunk cost bias: A group remains committed to a given plan primarily due to the investment already made in that plan, regardless of how inefficient and/or ineffective it may have become.

Extra-evidentiary bias : A group choosing to use some information despite having been told it should be ignored. Hindsight bias : Group members falsely over-estimate the accuracy of and/or the relevance of their past knowledge of a given outcome.

"Sins of omission"

Overlooking useful information. This can include: Base rate bias : Group members ignore applicable information they have concerning basic trends/tendencies. Fundamental attribution error: Group members base their decisions on inaccurate appraisals of individuals' behavior—namely, overestimating internal factors (e.g., personality) and underestimating external or contextual factors.

(Note: This phenomenon is reliably observed in individualist cultures, not in collectivist cultures. )

"Sins of imprecision"

Relying too heavily on heuristics that over-simplify complex decisions. This can include: Availability heuristic: Group members rely on information that is readily available.

Conjunctive bias : When groups are not aware that the probability of a given event occurring is the least upper bound on the probability of that event and any other given event occurring together; thus if the probability of the second event is less than one, the occurrence of the pair will always be less likely than the first event alone. Representativeness heuristic : Group members rely too heavily on decision-making factors that seem meaningful but are, in fact, more or less misleading.

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1375735350 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

7 named source(s) extracted from the cited revision. A source with no author is shown by its publication; nothing is invented.