Gu Jiegang

Gu Jiegang (8 May 1893 – 25 December 1980) was a Chinese historian, philologist, and folklorist, noted for his critiques of traditional historiography.

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 10 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

Gu Jiegang (8 May 1893 – 25 December 1980) was a Chinese historian, philologist, and folklorist, noted for his critiques of traditional historiography. Born to a family of scholars in Suzhou, he developed a great interest in philology and the Chinese classics from an early age.

He became involved in radical politics following the 1911 Revolution, but grew disillusioned and began to focus on historical studies. He was admitted to Peking University, where became interested in critique of the classical histories, inspired by academics such as Wang Guowei and Hu Shih.

After graduating in 1920, he was hired by the university; he became active in the study of folk songs and folklore while continuing his classical philological studies. He initiated a wave of scholarly controversy between the Doubting Antiquity School and conservative academics in 1923 after he published letters criticizing legendary ancient figures such as Emperor Yao and Emperor Shun as unhelpful Confucian myths.

He later edited the large volume of responses he received in the aftermath into the first volume of the ( ), a seven-volume work published from 19261 to 1944. Political and economic tensions forced Gu to leave Beijing in 1926.…

Gu Jiegang (8 May 1893 – 25 December 1980) was a Chinese historian, philologist, and folklorist, noted for his critiques of traditional historiography. Born to a family of scholars in Suzhou, he developed a great interest in philology and the Chinese classics from an early age.

He became involved in radical politics following the 1911 Revolution, but grew disillusioned and began to focus on historical studies. He was admitted to Peking University, where became interested in critique of the classical histories, inspired by academics such as Wang Guowei and Hu Shih.

After graduating in 1920, he was hired by the university; he became active in the study of folk songs and folklore while continuing his classical philological studies. He initiated a wave of scholarly controversy between the Doubting Antiquity School and conservative academics in 1923 after he published letters criticizing legendary ancient figures such as Emperor Yao and Emperor Shun as unhelpful Confucian myths.

He later edited the large volume of responses he received in the aftermath into the first volume of the ( ), a seven-volume work published from 1926 to 1944. Political and economic tensions forced Gu to leave Beijing in 1926.

After only a few months at Xiamen University, where he feuded with novelist Lu Xun, he was employed by his former roommate Fu Ssu-nien at Sun Yat-sen University, where he continued to study folklore while managing a research and history department. He moved to Yenching University in 1929, where he taught philology courses and edited several periodicals, including a historical geography journal he founded with a student.

Initially a staunch critic of the Kuomintang's nationalistic view of history, he grew more sympathetic towards it following the outbreak of the Second Sino-Japanese War in 1937 and the university's evacuation to Chongqing. He served in various educational and editorial positions following the war.

In 1950, he was forced to condemn his former colleague Hu Shih under pressure from the incipient Communist government; possibly in exchange for his criticism of himself and Hu, he was appointed to head the Institute of History of the Chinese Academy of Sciences in Beijing in 1954. He was condemned during the Cultural Revolution; while nominally still a professor, his position was demoted to janitorial duties.

Despite being barred from his own library, he continued his studies of the Book of Documents in secret. He returned to academics after he was tasked by Zhou Enlai to participate in the production of modern punctuated versions of the orthodox histories. He was gradually rehabilitated during the 1970s, and continued academic work until his death in 1980.

Early life and education

On 8 May 1893, Gu Jiegang was born in Daoyi, a village in eastern Suzhou, Jiangsu. Suzhou was a center of scholarship during the late Qing dynasty; both his father and grandfather were prominent local academics, descended from the 17th-century scholar-official Gu Yanwu.

As Gu was the eldest child in his family, his paternal grandfather took a strong interest in his education from an early age; an expert in classical literature and textual criticism, he instructed Gu in a traditional manner with a strong focus on the classics and histories. Gu had developed a strong interest in literature by six or seven, to which he later attributed a speech disorder and a lack of artistic skill.

Gu was fascinated by historical texts such as the Zuo Zhuan, although his grandfather forbid him from reading them until he was first taught the Odes and the Book of Rites (two of the Five Classics) by a private tutor. The focus on the most archaic and difficult classics immensely frustrated Gu, who later wrote that his instructor "had sacrificed me on the altar of his pedagogy."

After his family subscribed to the in 1903, Gu read the essays of the political theorist Liang Qichao. Gu was introduced to modern critiques of classical works through books brought home by his father, including a scathing critique of Han Yu's Yuandao by Yan Fu. and Wang Boxiang, ]] After the imperial examination system was abolished in 1905, Gu entered private school, attending a class taught by his father at a residence north of Suzhou.

After his father was admitted to Peking University (abbreviated Beida), the class was taught by a rapid succession of teachers, and he became essentially self-taught. In 1906, he transferred to a grammar school in Suzhou, which taught a mix of traditional and western-style material; disappointed in this modernized education, his grandfather continued giving him separate instruction in the Classics.

He later graduated into a local secondary school. Gu bemoaned private school as "paltry and vulgar", but also valued its focus on science and field research. In 1909, he took entrance exams into a prominent academy in Suzhou, but failed due to an entrance essay which criticized Zheng Xuan's interpretations of the Classics.

His grandfather died around this time, leaving Gu to pursue increasingly heterodox study material, taking particular inspiration from the work of Tan Sitong. On 27 January 1911, Gu was entered into an arranged marriage with Wu Zhenglan. Wu was four years older than Gu, and largely illiterate, although Gu attempted to teach her to read and write.

They had two daughters. In 1912, Gu published an article under Wu's name in the Funü Shibao, a prominent early Chinese women's magazine. The teenage Gu was greatly inspired by the 1911 Revolution and joined the Socialist Party of China, declaring that the revolution was not finished until it "had abolished government, had discarded the family system, and had made currency unnecessary".

However, he was quickly frustrated by cynicism within the party and left. The deteriorating political situation in China in the years following the revolution disillusioned many academics, including Gu. Yuan Shikai rose to power as a dictator in the aftermath of the revolution, leading to a conservative crackdown on academia.

Gu wrote that "of all the joyous emotions and fervent hopes that we had heaped up in previous years, we now had left only melancholy memories."

Historical thought

Through Hu, who studied under the American educational reformer John Dewey, Gu's historical methods were indirectly influenced by western historiography and philosophy; although he described his historical arguments as an independent invention. Likely aware of the general currents of international historical studies and Sinology, Gu does not directly reference any foreign-language texts or studies, despite some knowledge of French, English, Japanese, and German.

Although sympathetic to aspects of historical materialism and Marxist historiography, particularly the incorporation of socioeconomic factors into historical analysis, Gu was opposed to the concept of economic determinism and a distinct progression through varying modes of production. He instead advocated for a pluralistic approach to historical studies incorporating a variety of sources.

In his 1971 biography of Gu, historian Laurence Schneider described him as an empiricist with a "unquenchable, though far from crippling, skepticism". Gu greatly respected 18th- and 19th-century scholars such as Zhang Xuecheng and , but saw their work as tarnished by Confucian ideals.

He was strongly critical of the idea of a golden age in China's ancient past, and saw the Five Classics not as authentic documents from the purported ancient past, but as lenses through which to analyze the Warring States and Han dynasty societies which produced the texts. Gu embraced the spurious Old Texts, often dismissed as Han forgeries, as valuable reflections of the Han dynasty.

He wrote that prior to the formalization of these texts, the Hundred Schools of Thought during the Warring States period offered a relatively free and open scholarly discourse. He dismissed the Qin dynasty's burning of books and burying of scholars as the main reason for this decline in scholarly discourse, instead positing that it had become too profitable for scholars not to work alongside the state; this led to scholars increasingly working to provide legitimacy and means of social control to the ruling class, leading to the domination of Confucianism as a state orthodoxy.

Gu believed that the history and rulers of the Xia dynasty stemmed from myth. He was sympathetic to skeptical historians such as Chen Mengjia and Yang Kuan, who argued against its existence, but wrote that it was difficult to assert that its existence was entirely falsified.

In a 1923 letter to Qian Xuantong, he theorized that the mythical founder of the Xia dynasty, Yu the Great, was a deified animal depicted on the Nine Tripod Cauldrons who was later reimagined as a human ruler. He changed his theories on Yu's origins several times, alternatively attributing the myth to the Western Zhou or the Warring States period, but maintained that he originated as a mythological figure.

Gu strongly differentiated the "people of China" ( ) from the Han ethnicity, stating that the latter were only able to survive historically due to the steady arrival of other ethnic groups into China, such as the Wuhu, Khitan, Jurchen, and Mongols. He was strongly supportive of the incorporation of minority ethnic groups within the Chinese nation, although opposed historically to the concept of the Five Races descended from common mythic ancestors.

He theorized that the Han ethnicity formed from the Qin dynasty's unification of China and use of commanderies as administrative divisions on the frontiers.

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378086856 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

References

  1. ↩Wikipedia “Gu Jiegang” revision 1378086856 · retrieved 2026-10-20 publication date (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL