Harding Street raid
On January 28, 2019, in the Pecan Park area in the East End district of Houston, Texas, United States, Houston Police Department (HPD) officers initiated a no-knock raid on a house, killing the two homeowners, a husband and wife: Dennis…
≈ 7 min read
Harding Street raid. encyclopegia.org, snapshot enwiki-001376863766. /a/harding-street-raid
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
On January 28, 2019, in the Pecan Park area in the East End district of Houston, Texas, United States, Houston Police Department (HPD) officers initiated a no-knock raid on a house, killing the two homeowners, a husband and wife: Dennis Wayne Tuttle and Rhogena Ann Nicholas. They were aged 59 and 58, respectively. Five HPD officers sustained injuries.
St. John Barned-Smith and Keri Blakinger of the Houston Chronicle described the event as "one of the worst [scandals] to hit HPD in years".
Incident
The raid was precipitated by calls from next-door neighbor Patricia Ann Garcia after multiple bitter disagreements. She made a "swatting" call to police on January 8, 2019, reporting that her 25 year-old daughter was doing heroin at the couple's house. She also reported seeing that they had machine guns in the home.
In reality, there were no machine guns or heroin found and Garcia did not even have a daughter. Based on this false information, Goines, an officer with the Houston Police Department, obtained a no-knock search warrant for the residence. To bolster the case, he lied, saying a confidential informant had obtained black tar heroin in a hand-to-hand buy at their house.
However, the named informant denied having made such a buy as did all other informants Goines had worked with. Three weeks after Garcia's initial calls, police officers raided the home of Tuttle and Nicholas on January 28, 2019. After the officers entered the home, they shot a dog owned by the couple.
According to the HPD report, Tuttle was armed with a revolver and engaged the officers before being killed by return fire. Nicholas was unarmed but was shot by a backup officer when she allegedly reached for a wounded officer's shotgun. There is no video footage of the raid.
Four of the police suffered gunshot wounds, though there was some doubt early on that they were all from Tuttle's revolver.
Investigations
Police reportedly found 18 grams of marijuana and 1.5 grams of cocaine in the house, which were user amounts but not distributor levels; the small amount and type of drugs were consistent with the toxicology findings. KHOU-TV received the reports on May 2. On May 15, 2019, HPD chief Art Acevedo announced that the investigation had concluded, with the information given to prosecutors.
The Tuttle and Nicholas families hired a forensic team headed by Mick Maloney formerly of Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS). The team processed the crime scene on May 10, 2019, three months after the raid. They were surprised and troubled to find significant evidence left behind or uncollected by the earlier Houston Forensic Science Center police investigation.
They mapped out the trajectories from the bullet holes in the walls with the goal to reconstruct the shooting by matching bloodstains and bullet trajectories in the house to the wounds of the victims. The team spent four days reviewing the evidence.
Attorney Chuck Bourque told the Houston Chronicle they found no evidence anyone in the house fired toward the door nor that Tuttle's two rifles and two shotguns had even been fired. This did not account for the .357 revolver and shell casings reportedly collected by police, though a revolver was not listed in the inventory of confiscated items after the raid.
The team did find evidence that suggests police outside the house fired blindly through the walls. Evidence also suggested that some of the officers' injuries were from friendly fire.
Reaction
Radley Balko of The Washington Post wrote a criticism of no-knock raids based on this incident. The Houston Chronicle editorial board criticized HPD, stating that it lost the trust of Houstonians. In light of the shooting, Texas House of Representatives member Gene Wu and Texas Senate member Borris Miles proposed a bill that would make no-knock warrants unlawful in Texas.
The group We the People Organize, formed after the incident, created a mural in honor of the victims, which was unveiled in 20221. As a result of the raid, HPD began requiring approval from the department head or a designee of that head before any no-knock raid.
Families of Tuttle and Nicholas sue
The families of those killed in the Harding Street raid filed lawsuits against the city in January 2021. They allege that the officers involved had violated the civil rights of Tuttle and Nicholas.
On January 16, 2024, while announcing his resignation from the Aurora Colorado police department, Art Acevedo said he'd recently been served with a subpoena to testify in a federal lawsuit the victims' families filed against the City of Houston. A week later the Houston City Council approved $1.7 million to defend itself and former Police Chief Art Acevedo against the lawsuit.
This was in addition to $1.25 million paid to law firm Beck Redden, to file a motion for summary judgment to dismiss the lawsuit.
Reexamination of Goines' cases
Due to the false statements made by Goines and Bryant concerning the raid, Houston police began a systematic review of some combined 14,000 cases which had been handled by the officers in Goines's squad. In February 2020, the Houston District Attorney's office had identified 69 cases in which information provided by Goines had led to a wrongful conviction.
By the end of 2021, more than 160 pending cases had been dismissed. George Floyd, who grew up and spent most of his life in Houston, had been convicted of a drug charge in 2004. Goines had participated in this case, which was among those reviewed.
Based on a parole board's findings, Floyd was one of two dozen people scheduled to be pardoned in December 2021 by Governor Greg Abbott before the parole board abruptly withdrew their recommendation due to "unexplained departures" in its process. In , Houston resident Frederick Jeffery was released on bond after findings that Goines had falsified evidence and perjured himself.
His conviction was overturned by the appeals court in November 2022. Another Houston resident, Monique Davis, had her conviction for possession of cocaine overturned on February 5, 2025 after Goines and Bryant were found to have fabricated evidence.
The National Registry of Exonerations has recorded at least 38 overturned convictions which resulted from misconduct by Goines, the earliest of them in 2007. To date, neither Goines nor anyone else has been prosecuted for these specific cases of false testimony.
In 2024, both Goines and the city of Houston were sued in a federal lawsuit by James Ybarra, whom Goines had arrested on false drug charges in 2014.
See also
Lists of killings by law enforcement officers in the United States
Further reading
Dennis Wayne Tuttle Autopsy Archived Rhogena Ann Nicholas Autopsy Archived
External links
Thread at Twitter by the official Houston Police Department account 4 Houston police officers shot while serving warrant Archived 4 HPD officers shot in southeast Houston narcotics operation, a fifth injured Archived 5 Houston Officers Hurt in Shootout at Suspected Drug House Archived Four Houston police officers shot while serving warrant Archived
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1376863766 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “Harding Street raid” date of formation (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL