Huayan
The Huayan school of Buddhism ( , Wade–Giles: Hua-Yen, "Flower Garland," from the Sanskrit "Avataṃsaka") is a Mahayana Buddhist tradition that developed in China during the Tang dynasty (618–907).
≈ 40 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
The Huayan school of Buddhism ( , Wade–Giles: Hua-Yen, "Flower Garland," from the Sanskrit "Avataṃsaka") is a Mahayana Buddhist tradition that developed in China during the Tang dynasty (618–907). The Huayan worldview is based primarily on the Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra ( , Flower Garland Sūtra) as well as on the works of Huayan patriarchs, like Zhiyan (602–668), Fazang (643–712), Chengguan (738–839), Zongmi (780–841) and Li Tongxuan (635–730).
Another name for this tradition is the Xianshou school (賢首, Xianshou being another name for patriarch Fazang). The Huayan School is known as Hwaŏm in Korea, Kegon in Japan and Hoa Nghiêm in Vietnam. The Huayan tradition considers the Flower Garland Sūtra to be the ultimate teaching of the Buddha.
It also draws on other sources, like the Mahayana Awakening of Faith, and the Madhyamaka and Yogacara philosophies. Huayan teachings, especially its doctrines of universal interpenetration, nature origination (which sees all phenomena as arising from a single ontological source), and the omnipresence of Buddhahood, were very influential on Chinese Buddhism and also on the rest of East Asian Buddhism.
Huayan thought was especially influential on Chan (Zen) Buddhism, and some scholars even see Huayan as the main Buddhist philosophy behind Chan/Zen.
History
, Datong, built during the Jin dynasty (1115–1234)
Tang dynasty patriarchs
, Nara, Japan The founding of the Huayan school proper is traditionally attributed to a series of five patriarchs who were instrumental in developing the school's doctrines during the Tang dynasty (618 to 907). These Huayan "patriarchs" (though they did not call themselves as such) were erudite scholar-practitioners who created a unique tradition of exegesis, study and practice through their writings and oral teachings.
They were particularly influenced by the works of the Dilun and Shelun schools of Chinese Yogacara. These five patriarchs are: Dushun ( , c. 557–640), a monk who was known as a meditator master and who was devoted to the Huayan sūtra. He wrote several works.
The Discernments of the Huayan Dharmadhātu (Huayan fajie guanmen) has been attributed to him, but this is questioned by modern scholars. His base was at Xi'an and the Zhongnan mountains. Zhiyan ( , c. 602–668), was a student of Dushun who is considered to have established most of the main doctrines of Huayan thought and is thus a crucial figure in the foundation of Huayan.
Zhiyan also studied with various masters from the Dilun and Shelun schools, which were branches of Chinese Yogacara, and synthesized their ideas. Zhiyan's key contribution was the theory of the "dependent arising from the dharma realm" (法界缘起), which he saw as the essence of Huayan Sūtra.
He also taught the doctrine of the ten mysterious gates (十玄门), which are principles that explain dependent arising and the interfusion of all phenomena. Fazang ( , c. 643–712), who was the disciple of Zhiyan and the Buddhist teacher of the Empress Wu Zetian (684–705). He is often considered the real founder of the school.
He wrote numerous works on Huayan thought and practice including several commentaries on the Avatamsaka. He developed the doctrinal classification system of Huayan and the doctrine of the perfect interfusion of six characteristics (六相圓融). He also worked on a new translation of the Avatamsaka Sūtra (in collaboration with various figures, including Śikṣānanda) in 80 fascicles.
Chengguan ( , c. 738–839), though he was not a direct student of Fazang (who died 25 years before Chengguan's birth), Chengguan further developed the Huayan teachings in innovative directions in his various commentaries and treatises. He was a student of Fashen (718–778), who was a student of Fazang's student Huiyuan.
Chengguan's voluminous commentary to the new 80 fascicle Avatamsaka (the Da fang-guang fo huayan jing shu, 大方廣佛華嚴經疏, T. 1735), along with his sub-commentary to it (T. 1736), soon became the authoritative commentaries to the sūtra in East Asia. Guifeng Zongmi ( , c. 780–841), who is also known for also being a patriarch of Chinese Chán and for also writing on Daoism and Confucianism.
His writings include works on Chan (such as the influential Chan Prolegomenon) and various Huayan commentaries. He was particularly fond of the Sūtra of Perfect Enlightenment, writing a commentary and sub-commentary to it.
While the above list is the most common one, other Huayan patriarchal lists add different figures, such as Nagarjuna, Asvaghosa, Vasubandhu, and the lay master Li Tongxuan ( , 635?–730), the author of the Xin Huayan Jing Lun (新華嚴經論, Treatise on the new translation of the Avatamsaka Sūtra), a popular and lengthy commentary on the Avatamsaka. Li Tongxuan's writings on the Huayan sūtra were particularly influential on later Chan Buddhists, who often preferred his interpretations.
Another important Huayan figure of the Tang era was Fazang's main disciple Huiyuan (慧苑, 673–743) who also wrote a commentary on the Avatamsaka Sūtra. Because Huiyuan modified some of Fazang's interpretations, he was retroactively sidelined from the Huayan lineage of patriarchs by later figures like Chengguan who criticized some of his doctrinal positions.
According to Imre Hamar, Huiyuan compared the Daoist teachings on the origination of the world to the Huayan teaching on the dependent arising of the tathagatagarbha. Huiyuan also incorporated Daoism and Confucianism into his panjiao (doctrinal classification) system. Chengguan disagreed with this.
Liao and Xia developments
After the time of Zongmi and Li Tongxuan, Chinese Huayan generally stagnated in terms of new developments, and then eventually began to decline. The school, which had been dependent upon the support it received from the government, suffered severely during the Great Buddhist Persecution of the Huichang era (841–845), initiated by Emperor Wuzong of Tang.
The Huichang persecution caused significant destruction of temples and scriptures, disrupting the formal transmission lineage of the Huayan School. After this, the history of the school became more about the transmission of Huayan doctrine within the broader Buddhist landscape rather than a strict lineage.
The middle and late Tang also saw the unity of Chan and doctrines, including Huayan. During this time Huayan philosophy was absorbed into Chan, with some figures considered patriarchs of both schools. Xiqian's (700–790) Can Tong Qi (参同契) is an example of Chan absorbing Huayan theory.
The school stagnated even further in the conflicts and confusion of the late Tang dynasty and the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms (907–979) era. After the fall of the Tang dynasty several Huayan commentaries were lost.
However, during the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms era, Huayan remained influential, being part of the "Huayan-Chan" lineages influenced by Zongmi which were very popular in the north, especially in the Khitan Liao Empire (916–1125) and the Tangut kingdom (1038–1227) of the Western Xia. Various masters from these non-Chinese kingdoms are known, such as Xianyan (1048–1118) from Kailong temple in Khitan Upper capital, Hengce (1049–1098), Tongli dashi from Yanjing, Daoshen (1056?–1114?), Xianmi Yuantong, from Liao Wutaishan, Zhifu (fl. during the reign of Liao Daozong, 1055–1101).
The Liao and Xia Huayan traditions were more syncretic, adopting elements of Zongmi's Heze Chan influenced Huayan, as well as Chinese Esoteric Buddhism (zhenyan), Hongzhou Chan, and even Tibetan Buddhism in some cases. Several texts from the Liao Huayan tradition have survived, such as master Daochen's (道㲀) Chan influenced Account of Mirroring Mind (Jingxin lu, 鏡心錄) and his esoteric influenced Collection of Essentials for Realization of Buddhahood in the Perfect Penetration of the Exoteric and Secret Teachings (Xianmi Yuantong chengfo xinyao, 顯密圓通成佛心要 T no. 1955).
Another important Huayan esoteric source of this period is Jueyuan's sub-commentary on Yixing's commentary to the Mahāvairocana sūtra. According to Daochen, the best approach to Buddhahood is the "combined practice of the exoteric and esoteric" (xianmi shuangxiu, 顯密雙修) which is for those of the highest capacity.
However, he also recommended that those of "middling and lesser faculties...can choose to practice a single method according to their preference, be it the exoteric or esoteric." Daochen's esoteric teachings focused on the dharani of Cundi which he saw as "the mother of all Buddhas and the life of all bodhisattvas" and also drew on the Mani mantra.
The combined use of both of these is found in the Kāraṇḍavyūha sūtra. Another Liao Tangut work which survives from this period is The Meaning of the Luminous One-Mind of the Ultimate One Vehicle (Jiujing yicheng yuan-ming xinyao 究竟一乘圓明心要) by Tongli Hengce (通理恆策, 1048–1098).
The works of the Liao tradition are important because they served as one of the sources of the later Huayan revival during the Song. Several new Huayan Buddhist organizations have been established since the latter half of the 20th century.
In contemporary times, the largest and oldest of the Huayan-centered organizations in Taiwan is the Huayan Lotus Society (Huayan Lianshe 華嚴蓮社), which was founded in 19521 by the monk Zhiguang and his disciple Nanting, who were both part of the network fostered by the Huayan University. Since its founding, the Huayan Lotus Society has been centered on the study and practice of the Huayan Sūtra.
It hosts a full recitation of the sūtra twice each year, during the third and tenth months of the lunar calendar. Each year during the eleventh lunar month, the society also hosts a seven-day Huayan Buddha retreat (Huayan foqi 華嚴佛七), during which participants chant the names of the buddhas and bodhisattvas in the text.
The society emphasizes the study of the Huayan Sūtra by hosting regular lectures on it. In recent decades, these lectures have occurred on a weekly basis. Like other Taiwanese Buddhist organizations, the Society has also diversified its propagation and educational activities over the years.
It produces its own periodical and runs its own press. It also now runs a variety of educational programs, including a kindergarten, a vocational college, and short-term courses in Buddhism for college and primary-school students, and offers scholarships. One example is their founding of the Huayan Buddhist College (Huayan Zhuanzong Xueyuan 華嚴專宗學院) in 1975.
They have also established branch temples overseas, most notably in California's San Francisco Bay Area. In 1989, they expanded their outreach to the United States of America by formally establishing the Huayan Lotus Society of the United States (Meiguo Huayan Lianshe 美國華嚴蓮社).
Like the parent organization in Taiwan, this branch holds weekly lectures on the Huayan Sūtra and several annual Huayan Dharma Assemblies where it is chanted. It also holds monthly memorial services for the society's spiritual forebears. In Mainland China, Huayan teachings began to be more widely re-propagated after the end of the Cultural Revolution.
Various monks from the network of monks fostered by the original Huayan University, such as Zhenchan (真禪) and Mengcan (夢參), were the driving factors behind the re-propagation as they travelled widely throughout China as well as other countries such as the United States and lectured on Huayan teachings. In 1996, one of Mengcan's tonsured disciples, the monk Jimeng (繼夢), also known as Haiyun (海雲), founded the Huayan Studies Association (Huayan Xuehui 華嚴學會) in Taipei, which was followed in 19991 by the founding of the larger Caotangshan Great Huayan Temple (Caotangshan Da Huayansi 草堂山大華嚴寺).
This temple hosts many Huayan-related activities, including a weekly Huayan Assembly. Since 2000, the association has grown internationally, with branches in Australia, Canada, and the United States.
Huayan sūtra
The Huayan school's central text is the Avataṃsaka Sūtra (Flower Garland Sūtra, Ch. Huāyán Jīng), which is considered the supreme Buddhist revelation in this tradition. There are three different translations of the work in Chinese and other related sūtras as well.
According to Paul Williams, the Avataṃsaka Sūtra is not a systematic philosophical work, though it does contain various Mahayana teachings reminiscent of Madhyamaka and Yogacara, as well as mentioning a pure untainted awareness or consciousness (amalacitta). The sūtra is filled with mystical and visionary imagery, focusing on figures like the bodhisattvas Samantabhadra and Manjushri, and the Buddhas Shakyamuni, and Vairocana.
Vairocana is the universal Buddha, whose body is the entire universe and who is said to pervade every atom in the universe with his light, wisdom, teachings, and magical emanations. According to the Huayan sūtra: The realm of the Buddhas is inconceivable, no sentient being can fathom it....The Buddha constantly emits great beams of light, in each light beam are innumerable Buddhas....The Buddha-body is pure and always tranquil, the radiance of its light extends throughout the world....The Buddha's freedom cannot be measured— It fills the cosmos and all space....With various techniques it teaches the living, sound like thunder, showering the rain of truth....All virtuous activities in the world come from the Buddha's light....In all atoms of all lands Buddha enters, each and every one, producing miracle displays for sentient beings: Such is the way of Vairocana....In each atom are many oceans of worlds, their locations each different all beautifully pure.
Thus does infinity enter into one, yet each unit's distinct, with no overlap....In each atom are innumerable lights pervading the lands of the ten directions, all showing the Buddhas' enlightenment practices. The same in all oceans of worlds.
In each atom the Buddhas of all times appear, according to inclinations; While their essential nature neither comes nor goes, by their own power they pervade the worlds. All these awakened activities and skillful techniques (upaya) are said to lead all living beings through the bodhisattva stages and eventually to Buddhahood.
These various stages of spiritual attainment are discussed in various parts of the sūtra (book 15, book 26). An important doctrine that the Huayan school drew from this sūtra is the idea that all levels of reality are interrelated, interpenetrated and interfused, and so "inside everything is everything else."
As the Huayan sūtra states: They ... perceive that the fields full of assemblies, the beings and aeons which are as many as all the dust particles, are all present in every particle of dust. They perceive that the many fields and assemblies and the beings and the aeons are all reflected in each particle of dust.
According to Dumoulin, the Huayan vision of "unity in totality allows every individual entity of the phenomenal world its uniqueness without attributing an inherent nature to anything." According to Williams, this interfused vision of the cosmos is the total realm of all phenomena, the "Dharma realm" (Dharmadhatu) as seen from the point of view of a Buddha.
The focus of the Huayan sūtra is thus how to attain this contemplative universal vision of ultimate reality, as well as the miraculous powers of Buddhas and bodhisattvas with which they communicate their vision of the ultimate truth. Furthermore, because all things are interconnected and interfused, the Buddha (and his cosmic body and universal light) is present everywhere and so is his wisdom, which is said to be all pervasive.
As chapter 32 of the sūtra states: "in the class of living beings there is no place where the wisdom of Tathagata is not present."
Other key scriptures
The Awakening of Faith in the Mahayana (Dasheng Qixin Lun, 大乘起信論) was another key scriptural source for Huayan masters like Fazang and Zongmi, both of whom wrote commentaries on this treatise. The Lotus Sūtra was also seen as an important scripture in Huayan. Various Huayan masters saw the Lotus sūtra as a sūtra of definitive (ultimate) meaning alongside the Avatamsaka.
Fazang also considered the Lankavatara Sūtra to be a definitive sūtra, and he wrote a commentary on it. The Sūtra of Perfect Enlightenment was also particularly important for the Huayan patriarch Zongmi.
Doctrine
Huayan thought seeks to explain the nature of the Dharmadhatu (法界, fajie, the realm of phenomena, the Dharma realm), which is the world as it is ultimately, from the point of view of a fully awakened being. In East Asian Buddhism, the Dharmadhatu is the whole of reality, the totality of all things. Thus, Huayan seeks to provide a holistic metaphysics that explains all of reality.
Huayan philosophy is influenced by the Huayan sūtra, other Mahayana scriptures like the Awakening of Faith and the Lotus Sūtra, as well as by the various Chinese Buddhist traditions like Chinese Yogacara, the buddha-nature schools like Shelun and Dilun, and Madhyamaka (Sanlun). Huayan patriarchs were also influenced by non-buddhist Chinese philosophy.
Some key elements of Huayan philosophy are: the interpenetration and interfusion (yuanrong) of all phenomena (dharmas), "nature origination" (xingqi) - how phenomena arise out of an ultimate principle, which is buddha-nature, or the "One Mind," how the ultimate principle (li) and all phenomena (shi) are mutually interpenetrated, the relation between parts and the whole (understood through the six characteristics), a unique Huayan interpretation of the Yogacara framework of the three natures (sanxing) and a unique view of Vairocana Buddha as an all pervasive cosmic being.
Interpenetration
A key doctrine of Huayan is the mutual containment and interpenetration (xiangru) of all phenomena (dharmas), also known as "perfect interfusion" (yuanrong, 圓融). This is associated with what is termed "dharmadhatu pratityasamutpada" (法界緣起, fajie yuanqi, the dependent arising of the whole realm of phenomena), which is Huayan's unique interpretation of dependent arising.
This doctrine is described by Wei Daoru as the idea that "countless dharmas (all phenomena in the world) are representations of the wisdom of Buddha without exception" and that "they exist in a state of mutual dependence, interfusion and balance without any contradiction or conflict." According to the doctrine of interpenetration, any phenomenon exists only as part of the total nexus of reality, its existence depends on the total network of all other things, which are all equally connected to each other and contained in each other.
According to Fazang, since the sum of all things determines any individual thing, "one is many, many is one" (yi ji duo, duo ji yi). Furthermore, according to Fazang "one in many, many in one" (yi zhong duo, duo zhong yi), because any dharma penetrates and is penetrated by the totality of all things.
Thomas Cleary explains this Buddhist holism as one which sees the universe "as one single nexus of conditions in which everything simultaneously depends on, and is depended on by, everything else. Seen in this light, then, everything affects and is affected by, more or less immediately or remotely, everything else; just as this is true of every system of relationships, so is it true of the totality of existence."
In this worldview, all dharmas are so interconnected that they are fused together without any obstructions in a perfectly harmonious whole (which is the entire universe, the Dharmadhatu). In the Huayan school, the teaching of interpenetration is depicted through various metaphors, such as Indra's net, a teaching which may have been influenced by the Gandhavyuha chapter's climax scene in Vairocana's Tower.
Indra's net is an infinite cosmic net that contains a multifaceted jewel at each vertex, with each jewel being reflected in all of the other jewels, ad infinitum. Thus, each jewel contains the entire net of jewels reflected within. Other Huayan metaphors included a hall of mirrors, the rafter and the building, and the world text.
The rafter-building metaphor can be found in Fazang's famous "Rafter Dialogue." Fazang argues that any rafter (any part) is essential to the existence of its building (standing in for the universe, the dharmadhatu). Likewise, the identity and existence of any rafter is also dependent on it being part of a building (otherwise it would not be a rafter).
Therefore, any phenomenon is necessarily dependent upon all phenomena in the universe, and because of this, all phenomena lack any metaphysical independence or essential nature (svabhava).
Nature origination
Nature origination (xingqi) is a key idea in Huayan thought. The term derives from chapter 32 of the Avataṃsaka Sūtra, titled "Nature Origination of the Jewel King Tathāgata" (Baowang rulai xingqi pin, Skt. ). Nature origination refers to the manifestation of the ultimate nature in the phenomenal world and its interfusion with it.
That is to say, the ultimate, pure nature, is interdependent on and interpenetrates the entire phenomenal universe, while also being its source. For Huayan patriarchs like Fazang, the ultimate nature is thus seen as non-dual with all relative phenomena.
Because the ultimate source of all things is also interdependent and interconnected with them, it remains a ground which is empty of self-existence (svabhava) and thus it is not an independent essence, like some views of a monotheistic God. In the preface to his Hsing yüan p'in shu, Chengguan wrote, "How great the true dhatu (ta-tsai chen-chieh)!
The myriad dharmas owe their inception to it (wan-fa tzu-shih)." Zongmi elaborates on this, laying out his explanation of nature origination. For Zongmi, the "true dhatu" refers to the essential nature of the mind of the one dharmadhātu (yi fajie xin), while the myriad dharmas refer to its phenomenal appearances.
"The one true dharmadhātu" is thus the pure mind that is the source of both buddhas and sentient beings. As Zongmi says, "There is not a single dharma that is not a manifestation of the original mind. Nor is there a single dharma that does not conditionally arise from the true dhatu."
Zongmi explains that this one dharmadhātu gives rise to all phenomena through two orders of causation: [1] nature origination (xingqi), and [2] conditioned origination (yuanqi). Regarding the former, where "nature" (xing) refers to the source qua the pure mind, "origination" (qi) refers to its manifestation as phenomenal appearances.
This also refers to "the arising of functioning (yung) based on the essence (t'i)." For Zongmi, this means that "the entire essence of the dharmadhatu as the nature arises (ch'i) to form all dharmas." Conditioned origination, on the other hand, refers to the manner in which phenomena arise contingent upon other phenomena.
As each phenomenon is linked to every other phenomenon, all phenomena are infinitely contingent. But while every phenomenon is connected to every other phenomenon, nature origination means that each of these phenomena is simultaneously based on the nature (xing), which is the ultimate source. In this way, conditioned origination is made possible by nature origination.
Shifting emphasis from phenomena to principle
Huayan teachings underwent a shift in emphasis in the Tang from the doctrine of shih-shih wu-ai to li-shih wu-ai, or from the unobstructed interpenetration of phenomenon and phenomenon to the unobstructed interpenetration of principle and phenomena. Although Fazang had taught that all phenomena were manifestations of an intrinsically pure mind, thus articulating his metaphysics within the ontological framework of li-shih wu-ai, he nonetheless held that shih-shih wu-ai, the unobstructed interpenetration of phenomenon and phenomenon, was the ultimate teaching.
For Fazang, li-shih wu-ai is transcended in shih-shih wu-ai. This position of seeing the interfusion of phenomena as being the highest perspective is also found in the works of the earlier Huayan patriarchs, Dushun and Zhiyan.
On the other hand, while Chengguan upheld Fazang's position that shih-shih wu-ai represents the highest teaching of the Buddha, he emphasized li-shih wu-ai, the unobstructed interpenetration of principle and phenomena, as that which made shih-shih wu-ai possible. That is, it is only because all phenomena (shih) are formed from principle, or the absolute (li), that phenomena do not obstruct one another.
Zongmi went even further than his teacher Chengguan in emphasizing li-shih wu-ai over shih-shih wu-ai, excluding the perfect teaching (referring to shih-shih wu-ai) from his panjiao scheme, or classification of Buddhist doctrines, altogether. As an example of this shift in emphasis, where Chengguan understands the ten profundities, or ten mysteries (shi xuan), to be the paradigmatic expression of shih-shih wu-ai and subjects them to an extensive analysis, Zongmi gives them little attention, mentioning them only in passing without bothering to list or discuss them any further.
Moreover, where Chengguan had made use of the vocabulary of shih and li to elaborate his theory of the fourfold dharmadhātu (that of: [1] phenomena, shih; [2] principle, li; [3] the non-obstruction of principle and phenomena, li-shih wu-ai; and [4] the non-obstruction of phenomenon and phenomenon, shih-shih wu-ai), Zongmi eschews the language of li and shih altogether. Zongmi instead refers to a passage in which Chengguan emphasized the "one true dharmadhātu" (i-chen fa-chieh) as the essential reality and source of the four.
This one true dharmadhātu is the One Mind embacing manifold existence. Zongmi identifies this with the tathāgatagarbha, the highest teaching in his doctrinal classification system. For Zongmi, the principal teaching of the Avataṃsaka Sūtra is the tathāgatagarbha, or buddha-nature, and not the unobstructed interpenetration of phenomena.
However, he says the principal teaching which "reveals the nature" makes up only one part of the Avataṃsaka. Zongmi accordingly displaces the Avataṃsaka in favor of the Awakening of Faith (which emphasizes the One Mind). For Zongmi, the unobstructed interpenetration of all phenomena is seen as less important than the one true dharmadhātu upon which those phenomena are based.
In emphasizing li-shih wu-ai over shih-shih wu-ai, as well as nature origination over conditioned origination, Zongmi was also concerned to provide an ontological basis for Chan practice, thus reflecting the wider context of Zongmi's thought.
Understanding of the trisvabhāva
Huayan has a unique interpretation of the three natures (trisvabhāva) of classical Yogācāra. According to Fazang, the three natures are ultimately identical, as each of the three natures has dual aspects of emptiness and truth on the one hand, and existence and falsity on the other.
For the perfected nature (pariniṣpanna), its true/empty aspect is that it is immutable, while its false/existing aspect is that it obeys conditions. The dependent nature (paratantra) has essencelessness for its true/empty aspect, while it has seeming reality for its false/existing aspect.
Finally, the true/empty aspect of the imagined nature (parikalpita) is its nonexistence in reality, while its false/existing aspect is that it exists to the senses. Regarding their true/empty aspects, Fazang regards the immutability of the perfected, the essencelessness of the dependent, and the nonexistence of the imagined to be identical.
He also regards their false/existing aspects to all be identical as well, namely the conditionedness of the perfected, the seeming reality of the dependent, and the existing to the senses of the imagined. For Fazang, the aspects in the true/empty category are "root," while the aspects in the false/existing category are "limbs." The limbs develop from the root.
Thus, where the limbs are derivative, the root is their source. Fazang also differs from standard Yogācāra "pivot" models of the three natures, in which the imagined and the perfected pivot on the dependent. That is, in the Yogācāra pivot model, the imagined and perfected are merely different ways of apprehending the dependent.
For Fazang, on the other hand, the dependent and the imagined natures pivot on the perfected (which is equated with the One Mind), as its unconditioned and conditioned aspects.
Differences with classical Yogācāra
The cosmogonic role of self-cognition Fazang identified the notion of "karmic appearance" (yexiang) in the Awakening of Faith with self-cognition, a concept which can be found in Yogācāra. Self-cognition is the mind's awareness of being aware.
However, unlike a certain Yogācāra view, such as that of Dignāga, which regards self-cognition as an effect of consciousness' subjective aspect perceiving its objective aspect, Huayan follows the Awakening of Faith and treats self-cognition/karmic appearance as the cause of both the subjective aspect of consciousness as well as the illusory objective world. Where the effect model is concerned with epistemology, the cause model is cosmogony-oriented.
That is, according to the latter position, self-cognition/karmic appearance, referring to a state in which the mind is aware only of itself, is the cause of the delusive world of samsāra with all its suffering. As Zhihua Yao explains, "It is not contributed by an external agency because the arising or awareness is inherent to the mind or reality itself."
However, although this arising is based on reality itself, Fazang says it is karmic since [1] it is an action and [2] it is the cause of suffering. Of this karmic activity, Fazang states that, "Although this is (a form of) active conceptualization, it is exceedingly subtle and in a dependently originated single characteristic, that which can (cause) and that which is (caused) are not divided."
The active role of suchness Fazang explains the karmic consciousness in terms of the essence of mind having become activated by the perfuming of ignorance. According to Fazang, based on delusion, a semblance of suchness arises which stirs the Mind-as-Suchness to produce the karmic consciousness.
At the same time, he also clarifies the view that based on the storehouse consciousness, there exists ignorance. For Fazang, there are two aspects which are simultaneous: [1] based on a semblance of suchness (i.e. the "enlightenment" aspect of the storehouse consciousness) there arises delusion, and [2] based on delusion there arises a semblance of suchness (as ignorance perfumes the pure mind, forming the storehouse consciousness).
Additionally, Fazang explains that, as the tathāgatagarbha does not preserve a self-nature, the absolute transforms into the various consciousnesses and their objects. He says: The proposition of consciousness-only with respect to the establishment of phenomena through the transformation of the Absolute means that the tathāgatagarbha does not preserve its self-nature, but in accordance with conditions it manifests the eight consciousnesses, the mind, the mind associates, the objects of perception, and various appearances.
In this way, Fazang held that suchness plays an active role in creating the realm of perception and the world of phenomena. This is unlike the Yogācāra view of Xuanzang, for whom suchness is inactive, playing only a passive role in the evolution of the phenomenal world.
According to the faxiang ("dharma characteristics") view associated with Xuanzang's Yogācāra, the relationship of phenomena to suchness is that of "house and ground" in which the house (phenomena) is supported by the ground (suchness), but the two are nonetheless distinct. On the other hand, according to the faxing ("dharma nature") view of Huayan, the relationship between suchness and phenomena is one of "water and wave" in which the wind of ignorance stirs the water (suchness) to produce waves (phenomena).
The singular nature of the shared sensory world Other differences between Huayan and classical Yogācāra were highlighted during Ming dynasty debates over the nature of the bhājanaloka, or container world (i.e. the shared world of sensory experience). According to the classical Yogācāra view of intersubjectivity, each being, experiencing its own mental representations, necessarily occupies its own sensory world.
Although these sensory worlds overlap when a suitable karmic connection is shared between them, according to this view there are strictly speaking as many sensory worlds as there are beings. As Ernest Billings Brewster explains, "every sentient being possesses a 'storehouse consciousness' that contains a sensory world unique to each being."
Huayan exegetes such as Kongyin Zhencheng (1547–1617) in the Ming dynasty rejected this. Drawing on Huayan notions, such as that of an all-encompassing holistic dharmadhātu, Zhencheng argued that there is just a single sensory world which is shared by all beings.
Objective idealism versus subjective idealism According to Fung Yu-lan, where Xuanzang's classical Yogācāra is a system of subjective idealism, Huayan is one of objective idealism. Regarding the Huayan position, Fung says, "the central element in Fa-tsang's philosophy is a permanently immutable 'mind' which is universal or absolute in its scope, and is the basis for all phenomenal manifestations.
That is to say, his philosophy is a system of objective idealism. As such, it approaches realism more closely than does an idealism which is purely subjective. This is because, in a system of objective idealism, it is possible for the objective world to survive even when separated from a subject."
Regarding the Yogācāra and Huayan schools, Wing-Tsit Chan says, "in both schools, the external world, called external sphere by Hsüan-tsang and the Realm of Facts by Fa-tsang, is considered manifestations of the mind. In both schools, these manifestations have universal and objective validity, although the degree of validity is higher in Hua-yen.
The interesting thing is that Hua-yen presupposes a preestablished harmony while the Consciousness-Only School does not."
Visualization meditations
The lay scholar-practitioner Li Tongxuan (635–730) writes of a meditative practice based on the 9th chapter of the Avatamsaka sūtra. The practice, named "the contemplation of Buddhalight" (foguang guan), focused on contemplating and visualizing the universal light which is radiated by the Buddha in one's mind and expanding one's contemplation further and further outwards until it fills the entire universe.
This contemplation of the Buddha's light leads to a state of joyful tranquility which leads to insight into emptiness. The meditative teachings of Li Tongxuan were especially influential on the Japanese Kegon monk Myōe, who promoted a similar practiced that he termed "the Samadhi of Contemplating the Buddha's Radiance" (Japanese: , ).
Another visualization type meditation was promoted by the Korean Huayan monk Ch'ewŏn. Ch'ewŏn taught visualization meditation (kwansang 觀想) on bodhisattva Avalokiteshvara. According to Ch'ewŏn, this is effective because Avalokiteśvara's sphere of realization, the essence of one's own mind and Avalokiteśvara and one's own body are mutually interfused and interpenetrating.
Meditation and the fourfold Dharmadhatu
Various Huayan texts provide different frameworks for the practice of meditation and the development of samadhi. Huayan sources mentions two key samadhis, the ocean-seal samadhi (Ch. haiyin sanmei) and the huayan samadhi (huayan sanmei).
Some key Huayan sources which discuss meditation include Dushun's Contemplation of the Realm of Reality (Fajie guanmen) and The Ending of Delusion and the Return to the Source (Wangjin huanyuan) attributed to Fazang. Dushun's meditative framework was based on three main stages of contemplation: (1) seeing all dharmas as empty, (2) the harmony of all dharmas with the ultimate principle, and (3) seeing all dharmas as equally containing each other without obstruction.
Another key Huayan contemplative text is the "Cessation and Contemplation in the Five Teachings of Huayan" (Huayan wujiao zhiguan 華嚴五教止觀). The theory of the "fourfold Dharmadhatu" (sifajie, 四法界) eventually became the central meditative framework for the Huayan tradition.
This doctrinal and meditative framework is explained in Chengguan's meditation manual titled "Meditative Perspectives on the Huayan Dharmadhatu" (Huayan Fajie Guanmen, 華嚴法界觀門) and its commentaries. The Dharmadhatu is the goal of the bodhisattva's practice, the ultimate nature of reality which must be known or entered into.
According to Fox, the Fourfold Dharmadhatu is "four cognitive approaches to the world, four ways of apprehending reality." These four ways of seeing reality are: All dharmas are seen as particular separate events or phenomena (shi 事). This is the mundane way of seeing and is not a contemplation or meditation, but the pre-meditative perspective.
All events are an expression of li (理, the ultimate principle), which is associated with the concepts of "true emptiness," "One Mind" (yi xin 一心) and Buddha nature. This is the first level of Huayan meditation. This is the "non-obstruction of principle and phenomena" (lishi wuai 理事無礙), i.e. their interpenetration and interfusion.
All events / phenomena interpenetrate (shishi wuai 事事無礙), which refers to how "all distinct phenomenal dharmas interfuse and penetrate in all ways" (Zongmi). This is also described as "universal pervasion and complete accommodation."
According to Fox, "these dharmadhatus are not separate worlds – they are actually increasingly more holographic perspectives on a single phenomenological manifold...they more properly represent four types or orders of perspectives on experience." Furthermore, for Huayan, this contemplation is the solution to the problem of suffering which lies in the "fixation or attachment to a particular perspective.
What we think are the essences of objects are really therefore nothing but mere names, mere functional designations, and none of these contextual definitions need necessarily interfere with any of the others." Regarding the practical application of this teaching, Baiting Xufa correlated the practice of nianfo with the fourfold Dharmadhatu as follows: Nianfo on the level of the realm of phenomena refers to reciting the name of the Buddha as if the Buddha was external to oneself.
Nianfo on the level of the ultimate principle refers to reciting nianfo while knowing it as mind-only (cittamatra). Nianfo practice on the level of "non-obstruction of principle and phenomena" refers to a nianfo practice which has transcended notions like "buddha," "mind" and "name of the buddha."
Nianfo on the level of the interpenetration of all dharmas refers to the realization that the name of Buddha and the mind is all pervasive throughout the one true dharmadhatu.
Esoteric practices
, a central figure in Huayan esotericism Fazang promoted the practice of several dharanis, such as the Xuanzang's version of the Dhāraṇī of Avalokiteśvara-ekadaśamukha. The synthesis of Huayan with Chinese Esoteric Buddhist practices was a feature of the Buddhism of the Khitan Liao Dynasty.
Jueyuan, a Huayan monk from Yuanfu Temple during the Liao Dynasty and author of the Dari jing yishi yanmi chao, practiced esoteric rituals like Homa and Abhiseka based on the Vairocanābhisaṃbodhi Sūtra and the tradition of Yixing. Furthermore, according to Sorensen, the iconography of the Huayan Vairocana Buddha and the Esoteric Mahavairocana also became fused during the post-Tang period.
Perhaps the most important figure in the synthesis of Huayan and Chinese Esoteric Buddhism was the 11th century monk Daoshen (道蝗), author of the Xianmi yuantong chengfo xinyao ji (顯密圓通成佛心要集 Collection of Essentials for the Attainment of Buddhahood by Total [Inter-]Penetration of the Esoteric and the Exoteric, T1955). The work is divided into three parts.
Part one summarizes the Huayan philosophy, which Daoshen sees as the highest form of the explicit or manifest Buddhist teachings. It also discusses the praxis of Huayan, here called "cultivating the ocean of Samantabhadra's practices," which includes numerous exoteric Buddhist practices such as breath meditation, meditation on emptiness, prostrations, offerings, confession rites, vows, and buddha name recitation.
The second part of this work teaches esoteric Buddhism or mantra method (Mijiao, Zhenyan), with a focus on the Cundi dharani and other mantras (like the Mani mantra) which are said to have many powerful effects and is recommended even for laypersons. Finally, the third part promotes "the systematic integration of exoteric doctrine and occult practice, arguing that each is incomplete without the other, whether they are practised in sequence or in tandem."
According to Gimello: Daozhen's central thesis in the work is that the "body" of Huayan doctrine and the envisaged image of Cundi are somehow co-inherent, and that by invoking the presence of the goddess we somehow confirm the truth of the doctrines and render them practically efficacious. In other words, Daozhen holds that if one recites Cundi dharani and/or visualizes the dharani in its graphic form as an array of Sanskrit letters or Chinese characters, and then imagines the goddess's anthropomorphic bodily image emerging from the intoned and envisioned syllables of the spell, all the while performing the corresponding manual gestures (mudra), one will thereby both quicken and verify the truth of the doctrines, and one will do this not merely allegorically but also, if I may say so, sacramentally.
Important esoteric texts used in the Liao tradition included the: Cundī-dhāraṇī, the Usṇīsavijayā-dhāranī, the Nīlakaṇthaka-dhāranī and the Sūtra on the Great Dharma Torch Dhāraṇī ( 大法炬陀羅尼 經, Da faju tuoluoni jing) among others. In the Liao, stupas, pagodas and statues were often empowered with dharanis and mantras.
These structures would often be filled or inscribed with dharanis, sūtras, or mantras like the Six syllable mantra of Avalokiteshvara. Pillars inscribed with dhāraṇīs and mantras were also common. The synthesis of Esoteric Buddhist practice with Huayan Buddhism remained popular during the Jin dynasty (1115–1234), where Usṇīsavijayā and Cundī practices were some of the most popular.
A similar synthesis of Huayan-Chan Buddhism (derived from Zongmi) with esoteric Buddhist teachings and practices from Tibetan Buddhism (mainly Sakya and Kagyu) also occurred in Buddhism of the Western Xia (1038–1227) dynasty. Dharanis like the Cundī-dhāraṇī, the Usṇīsavijayā-dhāranī, and the Nīlakaṇthaka-dhāranī remain important in modern Huayan Buddhism and are chanted in modern Dharma assemblies.
Another dharani / esoteric practice in modern Huayan is the contemplation of the 42 Avatamsaka syllables (a version of the arapacana alphabet, which is a contemplation found in various Mahayana sources). The Japanese Kegon school was known for adopting many esoteric mantras and practices from the Shingon school.
The Kegon monk Myōe was known for his widespread promotion of the popular Mantra of Light ( , ). Due to influence from the Shingon school, today's Kegon school retains numerous esoteric Buddhist elements.
The path and sudden awakening
's Pilgrimage in the Gandhavyuha sūtra, from the Heian period, Nara National Museum, Japan The Huayan school defended a sudden awakening view. This is because the buddha-nature is already present in all sentient beings, and also because their theory of universal interpenetration entails that Buddhahood is interfused with the very first stage of a bodhisattva's path.
Thus, according to patriarch Fazang, "when one first arouses the thought of enlightenment [ bodhicitta] one also becomes perfectly enlightened." Similarly, according to Gimello, Huayan master Li Tongxuan understands the path as follows: The first access of faith in the mind of the practitioner is in itself the culmination of the entire path, the very realization of final Buddhahood....
'Faith' or confidence in the possibility of enlightenment is nothing but enlightenment itself, in an anticipatory and causative modality. This interpenetration of all elements of the path to awakening is also a consequence of the Huayan view of time, which sees all moments as interfused (including a sentient being's present practice and their eventual future Buddhahood aeons from now).
Since time itself is empty, all moments (past, present, and future) are interfused with each other. As Fazang writes, "beginning and end Interpenetrate. On each [bodhisattva] stage, one is thus both a Bodhisattva and a Buddha."
As such, Huayan does not understand a bodhisattva's progress through the bodhisattva stages (bhumis) as being linear. Instead, as soon as one reaches the earlier stages of "perfection of faith" (which is part of Huayan's 52 bhumi model), one has also acquired all the stages, as well as Buddhahood.
This doctrine of "enlightenment at the stage of faith" (信滿成佛, xinman cheng fo) was a unique feature of Huayan and was first introduced by Fazang though it has a precedent in a passage of the Avatamsaka Sūtra. In Huayan, Buddhahood transcends all concepts, times and stages.
Because practice cannot create something that is not immanent, Huayan sees the bodhisattva path as simply revealing what is already there (buddha-nature, which is buddhahood itself concealed within sentient beings). In spite of this doctrine, Huayan patriarchs also argued that the gradual practices of the bodhisattva stages are still necessary.
This is because all stages retain their particularity even while being wholly interfused and only through the practice of the bodhisattva path does the immanent Buddhahood manifest. Thus, according to Li Tongxuan "there is no other enlightenment" than simply following the bodhisattva path, and furthermore: Primordial wisdom is made manifest through meditation; cultivation does not create it or bring it into being.
If one simply follows the Bodhisattva Path and learns the bodhisattva practices, primordial wisdom will shine forth of itself.... Similarly, patriarch Zongmi held that Buddhahood is reached through "sudden awakening followed by gradual cultivation" and he also held that "sudden and gradual are not only not contradictory, but are actually complementary."
Sources
Cleary, Thomas, trans. (1993). The Flower Ornament Scripture: A Translation of the Avatamsaka Sūtra.
Gimello, Robert; Girard, Frédéric; Hamar, Imre (2012). Avataṃsaka Buddhism in East Asia: Huayan, Kegon, Flower Ornament Buddhism; origins and adaptation of a visual culture, Asiatische Forschungen: Monographienreihe zur Geschichte, Kultur und Sprache der Völker Ost- u. Zentralasiens, Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, .
Further reading
Cleary, Thomas (1995). Entry Into the Inconceivable: An Introduction to Hua-Yen Buddhism, University of Hawaii Press; Reprint edition. (Essays by Tang Dynasty Huayen masters) Fa Zang (2014).
"Rafter Dialogue" and "Essay on the Golden Lion," in Justin Tiwald and Bryan W. Van Norden, eds., Readings in Later Chinese Philosophy. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing. Gregory, Peter N. (1983).
The place of the Sudden Teaching within the Hua-Yen tradition:an investigation of the process of doctrinal change, Journal of the International Association of Buddhist Studies 6 (1), 31 - 60 Haiyun Jimeng (2006). The Dawn of Enlightenment - The Opening Passage of Avatamsaka Sūtra with a Commentary, Kongting Publishing.
Prince, Tony (2020), Universal Enlightenment - An introduction to the Teachings and Practices of Huayen Buddhism (2nd edn.).
External links
Buddhism in a nutshell - Hua-yen Chang Chung-Yuan, The World of Shih & Li of Tung-Shan Flower Adornment Sūtra - Hua Yan Jing - Avatamsaka Original Text Articles by Imre Hamar
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378320571 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “Huayan” date of foundation (×2) · confidence 0.95 revision URL