Lesson plan

Implied weighting

Implied weighting describes a group of methods used in phylogenetic analysis to assign the greatest importance to characters that are most likely to be homologous. These are a posteriori methods, which include also dynamic weighting, as opposed to a priori methods, which include adaptive, independent, and chemical categories. The first attempt to implement such a technique was by Farris (1969), which he called successive approximations weighting, whereby a tree was constructed with equal weights, and characters that appeared as homoplasies on this tree were downweighted based on the CI (consistency index) or RCI (rescaled consistency index), which are measures of homology. The analysis was repeated with these new weights, and characters were again re-weighted; subsequent iteration was continued until a stable state was reached. Farris suggested that each character could be considered independently with respect to a weight implied by frequency of change. However, the final tree depended strongly on the starting weights and the finishing criteria. The most widely used and implemented method, called implied weighting, follows from Goloboff (1993). The first time a character changes state on a tree, this state change is given the weight '1'; subsequent changes are less 'expensive' and are given smaller weights as the characters tendency for homoplasy becomes more apparent.…

Back to article

Article summary

Implied weighting describes a group of methods used in phylogenetic analysis to assign the greatest importance to characters that are most likely to be homologous. These are a posteriori methods, which include also dynamic weighting, as opposed to a priori methods, which include adaptive, independent, and chemical categories. The first attempt to implement such a technique was by Farris (1969), which he called successive approximations weighting, whereby a tree was constructed with equal weights, and characters that appeared as homoplasies on this tree were downweighted based on the CI (consistency index) or RCI (rescaled consistency index), which are measures of homology. The analysis was repeated with these new weights, and characters were again re-weighted; subsequent iteration was continued until a stable state was reached. Farris suggested that each character could be considered independently with respect to a weight implied by frequency of change. However, the final tree depended strongly on the starting weights and the finishing criteria. The most widely used and implemented method, called implied weighting, follows from Goloboff (1993). The first time a character changes state on a tree, this state change is given the weight '1'; subsequent changes are less 'expensive' and are given smaller weights as the characters tendency for homoplasy becomes more apparent.…

Key claims

No claims recorded.

Discussion questions

  1. Summarise the article in your own words. Which single claim would you verify first, and why?
  2. Which claim in this article is most likely to be revised as the sources update? How would you check its current status?
  3. If two sources disagreed about one of these facts, what would you need in order to trust one over the other?

Bibliography

No sources recorded.

Key claims and bibliography are generated from the same tracked claims and sources as the article page.