Julian Simon
Julian Lincoln Simon (February 12, 1932 – February 8, 1998) was an American economist.
≈ 14 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Julian Lincoln Simon (February 12, 1932 – February 8, 1998) was an American economist. He was a professor of economics and business administration at the University of Illinois from 1963 to 1983 before later moving to the University of Maryland, where he taught for the remainder of his academic career.
Simon wrote many books and articles, mostly on economic subjects, from an optimistic viewpoint. He is best known for his work on population, natural resources, and immigration. Simon is sometimes associated with cornucopian views and as a critic of Malthusianism.
Rather than focus on the abundance of nature, Simon focused on lasting economic benefits from continuous population growth, even despite limited or finite physical resources, primarily by the power of human ingenuity to create substitutes, and from technological progress. He is also known for the famous Simon–Ehrlich wager, a bet he made with ecologist Paul R. Ehrlich.
Ehrlich bet that the prices for five metals would increase over a decade, while Simon took the opposite stance. Simon won the bet, as the prices for the metals sharply declined during that decade.
Wagers with Ehrlich
(pictured in 1974) predicted that multiple crises would occur in the 1970s, including a dramatic decrease in life expectancy and the need for food rationing. Simon and Paul R. Ehrlich first directly encountered each other in the summer of 1980, when Simon vehemently debunked claims by Newsweek and the United Nations, both of which had overestimated the death toll caused by a drought in West Africa from 19681 to 1973.
His rebuttals, published in Science journal and The Washington Post, were also aimed at environmental doomers. Simon rejected Ehrlich's claim in The Population Bomb that limited food supply may necessarily require population control and also rejected that humanity was reaching its ecological limit, a claim popularized by The Limits of Growth.
He blamed the popularity for such exaggerated assertions as "bad news sells books, newspapers, and magazines." Simon explained that technological advancements would alleviate scarcity because "we find new lodes, invent better production methods, and discover new substitutes."
In December 1980, Ehrlich and his wife, Anne Ehrlich, along with colleagues John Holdren and John Harte, issued criticisms in Science of Simon's rebuttals. Arguing that technology was not sufficient to replace essential ecological systems, they asserted that a scarcity of energy and minerals remained a present danger.
They dismissed Simon's writing as being a "tired old argument" with "striking misconceptions" which reflected economists "who know nothing about geology." Biologist Wayne Davis at the University of Kentucky disputed a claim made by Simon's article that oil prices would decrease, saying it "defies logic."
Ehrlich and Simon's dispute would continue into the next year, with additional publications against each other in Social Science Quarterly. Simon wrote in 1981, "How often does a prophet have to be wrong before we no longer believe that he or she is a true prophet?"
Simon believed that Ehrlich's assumptions about demographics were erroneous and that his public statements had not experienced the "consequences of being wrong." In 1969, Ehrlich said that "If I were a gambler, I would take even money that England will not exist in the year 2000."
He predicted that in the absence of global population control, widespread nuclear war, disease, scarcity, or dire resource scarcity would occur as a result of overpopulation. Ehrlich garnered broad public attention for his views and disseminated his concerns in the Saturday Review, Playboy, Penthouse, and on The Tonight Show Starring Johnny Carson, where he was a frequent guest and had at least 20 appearances.
In 1970, Ehrlich delivered 100 public lectures and appeared on 200 radio and television shows. His highly publicized engagements earned him celebrity status as a scientist. Simon later recalled of Ehrlich: "Here was a guy reaching a vast audience, leading his juggernaut of environmentalist hysteria, and I felt utterly helpless."
Wanting to "put my money where my mouth is," Simon challenged Ehrlich to a scientific wager to test their theories regarding future resource abundance, betting on the future prices of raw material. If Ehrlich's belief that population growth would increase scarcity was correct, then the prices of the metals would increase due to heightened demand.
Simon believed that technological advancements would reduce scarcity and so he predicted a decrease in prices over time. Ehrlich agreed to the offer. He commented that he would accept Simon's "astonishing offer before other greedy people jump in."
He consulted Harte and Holdren to devise a basket of five metals that they thought would rise in price with increasing scarcity and depletion. They chose chromium, copper, nickel, tin, and tungsten. Simon ultimately won the bet, with all five metals dropping in price.
The price of tin went down because of an increased use of aluminium, a much more abundant, useful and inexpensive material. Better mining technologies allowed for the discovery of vast nickel lodes, which ended the near monopoly that was enjoyed on the market. Tungsten fell due to the rise of the use of ceramics in cookware.
The price of chromium fell due to better smelting techniques. The price of copper began to fall due to the invention of fiber-optic cable (which is derived from sand), which serves a number of the functions once reserved only for copper wire.
In all of these cases, better technology allowed for either more efficient use of existing resources, or substitution with a more abundant and less expensive resource, as Simon predicted.
Proposed second wager
In 1995, Simon issued a challenge for a second bet. Ehrlich declined, and proposed instead that they bet on a metric for human welfare. Ehrlich offered Simon a set of 15 metrics over 10 years, victor to be determined by scientists chosen by the president of the National Academy of Sciences in 2005.
There was no meeting of minds, because Simon felt that too many of the metrics measured attributes of the world that were not directly related to human welfare, e.g. the amount of nitrous oxide in the atmosphere. For such indirect, supposedly bad indicators to be considered "bad", they would ultimately have to have some measurable detrimental effect on actual human welfare.
Ehrlich refused to leave out measures considered by Simon to be immaterial. Simon summarized the bet with the following analogy:
Theory
Simon's 1981 book The Ultimate Resource is a criticism of what was then the conventional wisdom on resource scarcity, published within the context of the cultural background created by the best-selling and highly influential book The Population Bomb in 1968 by Paul R. Ehrlich and The Limits to Growth analysis published in 19721. The Ultimate Resource challenged the conventional wisdom on population growth, raw-material scarcity and resource consumption.
Simon argues that our notions of increasing resource scarcity ignore the long-term declines in wage-adjusted raw material prices. Viewed economically, he argues, increasing wealth and technology make more resources available; although supplies may be limited physically they may be regarded as economically indefinite as old resources are recycled and new alternatives are assumed to be developed by the market.
Simon challenged the notion of an impending Malthusian catastrophe—that an increase in population has negative economic consequences; that population is a drain on natural resources; and that we stand at risk of running out of resources through over-consumption. Simon argues that population is the solution to resource scarcities and environmental problems, since people and markets innovate.
His ideas were praised by Nobel Laureate economists Friedrich Hayek and Milton Friedman, the latter in a 1998 foreword to The Ultimate Resource II, but they have also attracted critics such as Paul R. Ehrlich, Albert Allen Bartlett and Herman Daly. Simon examined different raw materials, especially metals and their prices in historical times.
He assumed that besides temporary shortfalls, in the long run prices for raw materials remain at similar levels or even decrease. E.g. aluminium was never as expensive as before 1886 and steel used for medieval armor carried a much higher price tag in current dollars than any modern parallel. A recent discussion of commodity index long-term trends supported his positions.
His 1984 book The Resourceful Earth (co-edited by Herman Kahn), is a similar criticism of the conventional wisdom on population growth and resource consumption and a direct response to the Global 2000 report. For example, it predicted that "There is no compelling reason to believe that world oil prices will rise in the coming decades. In fact, prices may well fall below current levels".
Indeed, oil prices trended downward for nearly the next 2 decades, before rising above 1984 levels in about 2003 or 2004. Oil prices have subsequently risen and fallen, and risen again. In 2008, the price of crude oil reached $100 per barrel, a level last attained in the 1860s (inflation adjusted).
Later in 2008, the price again sharply fell, to a low of about $40, before rising again to a high around $125. Since mid-2011, prices were slowly trending downward until the middle of 2014, but falling dramatically until the end of 2015 to ca. $30. Since then prices were relatively stable (below $50).
Simon was skeptical, in 1994, of claims that human activity caused global environmental damage, notably in relation to CFCs, ozone depletion and climate change. Simon also claimed that numerous environmental damage and health dangers from pollution were "definitely disproved".
These included lead pollution & IQ, DDT, PCBs, malathion, Agent Orange, asbestos, and the chemical contamination at Love Canal. He dismissed such concerns as a mere "value judgement."
Influence
Simon was one of the founders of free-market environmentalism. An article entitled "The Doomslayer" profiling Julian Simon in Wired magazine inspired Danish Bjørn Lomborg to write the book The Skeptical Environmentalist.
Simon was also the first to suggest that airlines should provide incentives for travelers to give up their seats on overbooked flights, rather than arbitrarily taking random passengers off the plane (a practice known as "bumping"). Although the airline industry initially rejected it, his plan was later implemented with resounding success, as recounted by Milton Friedman in the foreword to The Ultimate Resource II.
Economist James Heins said in 2009 that the practice had added $100 billion to the United States economy in the last 30 years. Simon gave away his idea to federal de-regulators and never received any personal profit from his solution.
Although not all of Simon's arguments were universally accepted, they contributed to a shift in opinion in the literature on demographic economics from a strongly Malthusian negative view of population growth to a more neutral view. More recent theoretical developments, based on the ideas of the demographic dividend and demographic window, have contributed to another shift, this time away from the debate viewing population growth as either good or bad.
Simon wrote a memoir, A Life Against the Grain, which was published by his wife after his death.
Legacy
The Institute for the Study of Labor established the annual Julian L. Simon Lecture to honor Simon's work in population economics. The University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign held a symposium discussing Simon's work on April 24, 2002. The university also established the Julian Simon Memorial Faculty Scholar Endowment to fund an associate faculty member in the business school.
India's Liberty Institute also holds a Julian Simon Memorial Lecture. The Competitive Enterprise Institute gives the Julian Simon Memorial Award annually to an economist in the vein of Simon; the first recipient was Stephen Moore, who had served as a research fellow under Simon in the 1980s.
Personal life
Simon was remembered as a traditionalist Jew who did not work on the Sabbath. He emphasized empirical data in arguments and had a combative personality which enjoyed rhetorical exchanges. His wife, Rita James, was a former socialist activist; they met while students at the University of Chicago and married during that period.
She was a longtime member of the faculty at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and later became a public affairs professor at American University. They had three children: David, Judith, and Daniel. For a long time, Simon experienced debilitating depression, which allowed him to work only a few productive hours in a day.
He also studied the psychology of depression and wrote a book on overcoming it. He died on February 8, 1998. The cause was a heart attack at his home in Chevy Chase in 1998; he died at age 65.
Honors
Doctor honoris causa, University of Navarra, (Spain), Economics, 1998
Works
The Resourceful Earth: A Response to "Global 2000" (1984), , Julian Simon & Herman Kahn, eds The Economic Consequences of Immigration into the United States Effort, Opportunity, and Wealth: Some Economics of the Human Spirit Good Mood: The New Psychology of Overcoming Depression (Forewords by Albert Ellis and Kenneth Colby) The Hoodwinking of a Nation (hard), (soft) A Life Against the Grain: The Autobiography of an Unconventional Economist Scarcity or Abundance? A Debate on the Environment (1994), (with Norman Myers), The Philosophy and Practice of Resampling Statistics Basic research methods in social sciences: The art of empirical investigation, Resampling: A Better Way to Teach (and Do) Statistics (with Peter C. Bruce) The Science and Art of Thinking Well in Science, Business, the Arts, and Love Economics of Population: Key Modern Writings, The State of Humanity, It's Getting Better All the Time : 100 Greatest Trends of the Last 100 Years by Stephen Moore, Julian Lincoln Simon manuscript finished posthumously by Stephen Moore
Further reading
Desrochers, Pierre and Vincent Geloso, "Snatching the Wrong Conclusions from the Jaws of Defeat: A Historical/Resourceship Perspective on Paul Sabin's The Bet: Paul Ehrlich, Julian Simon, and Our Gamble over Earth's Future (Yale University Press, 2013), Part 2: The Wager: Protagonists and Lessons ." New Perspectives on Political Economy, vol. 12, no. 1-2 (2016), pp. 42–64.
Desrochers, Pierre and Vincent Geloso, "Snatching the Wrong Conclusions from the Jaws of Defeat: A Historical/Resourceship Perspective on Paul Sabin's The Bet: Paul Ehrlich, Julian Simon, and Our Gamble over Earth's Future (Yale University Press, 2013). Part 1: The Missing History of Thought: Depletionism vs Resourceship ."
New Perspectives on Political Economy, vol. 12, no. 1-2 (2016), pp. 5–41. Books critical of Julian Simon: Ehrlich, Paul R. Betrayal of Science and Reason: How Anti-Environmental Rhetoric Threatens Our Future, 1996. Grant, Lindsey.
Elephants in the Volkswagen, 1992. Hardin, Garrett. The Ostrich Factor: Our Population Myopia, 1998.
External links
Writings by Julian L. Simon, juliansimon.org The Ultimate Resource II: People, Materials, and Environment, juliansimon.org Julian Simon papers at the University of Maryland libraries Liberty Institute First Annual Julian L. Simon Memorial Lecture Julian Simon's Bet With Paul Ehrlich Julian Simon's bet with David South "Julian Simon Remembered: It's A Wonderful Life" FMN and Heartland: "Remembering Julian Simon" Reason Magazine: "David Foreman vs. the Cornucopians" MIT Technology Review: Environmental Heresies The Julian L. Simon Memorial Award MercatorNet: Population Julian L. Simon papers at the American Heritage Center Critique of 'The Ultimate Resource' by Herman Daly, 1991 Ernest Partridge, "Perilous Optimism", 2007, gadfly.igc.org—a criticism of Simon and Sagoff; "Prof. Simon's ideas have been universally dismissed by environmental scientists as crackpot, and yet he was something of a hero among libertarians, neo-classical economists, and their political disciples." Simon, Julian L., encyclopedia.com Simon, Julian (1932-1998), libertarianism.org CV
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1377270062 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
1 claim could not be tied to a specific sentence and is listed in the table below instead.
- ↩Wikipedia “Julian Simon” publication date (×2) · confidence 0.95 revision URL