just compensation
U.S.
≈ 4 min read
Names in other languages
- cacompensació justa
- Englishjust compensation
- Türkçeadil tazminat
- EspañolJustiprecio
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Just compensation is a right enshrined in the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution (and counterpart state constitutions), which is invoked whenever private property is taken by eminent domain by the government. Under some state constitutions, it is also owed when the government "damages" private property.
Usually, the government files an eminent domain action to take private property for public use and just compensation is determined at trial if the landowner does not settle with the government. However, when the government fails to file an eminent domain action and pay for the taking, the owner may seek compensation in an action called inverse condemnation.
For reasons of expedience, courts generally use fair market value as the measure of just compensation. The primary evidence of fair market value in almost all eminent domain are appraisal reports created by the appraisers hired by both sides.
Because of the difficulty in stopping the eminent domain process, and the sole issue typically being what just compensation is owed to a landowner, an eminent domain trial is often called a "battle of the appraisers."
Estimating just compensation, generally
Market value is the prevailing, but not exclusive measure of determining the just compensation owed to a landowner under the Fifth Amendment. Fair Market Value is defined by appraisers as the most probable price, in terms of cash that would be paid by a willing buyer to a willing seller, each being fully informed of the property's good and bad features, with the property being exposed on the market for an adequate time to attract offers.
But in eminent domain cases, fair market value is defined as the highest price obtainable in the open market with the value not being influenced by the imminence of the eminent domain taking. In other words, the property must be valued as if the project for which it is being taken did not exist — this is known as the "project influence" doctrine.
Market value does not include incidental losses (e.g., cost of moving), but some of these losses are made compensable in part by statutes, such as the federal Uniform Relocation Assistance Act (Code of Federal Regulations 49) and its state counterparts. As for business losses, the Supreme Court has held that an "exercise of the power of eminent domain which has the inevitable effect of depriving the owner of the going-concern value of his business is a compensable 'taking' of property."
Nevertheless, many lower courts deny compensation for business losses on the theory that such losses are "speculative" or that the fair market value of the land should already account for the value of a business located on the land. The judicial denial of compensation for business losses inflicted when a business conducted on the taken land is destroyed by the taking, has been the subject of much controversy and severe criticism by legal commentators.
Alaska, Minnesota, New Mexico, and Pennsylvania, allow for recovery of business losses. Depending on the jurisdiction, the property owner's attorneys' and appraisers' fees may be paid by the condemnor. In California and New York an award of such fees is discretionary with the court while in others like South Carolina it is mandated.
Moreover, property owners are always entitled to receive interest on the just compensation owed to them if the payment is delayed.
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1372827248 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.