K-stability

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 19 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

In mathematics, and especially differential and algebraic geometry, K-stability is an algebro-geometric stability condition, for complex manifolds and complex algebraic varieties. The notion of K-stability was first introduced by Gang Tian and reformulated more algebraically later by Simon Donaldson. The definition was inspired by a comparison to geometric invariant theory (GIT) stability. In the special case of Fano varieties, K-stability precisely characterises the existence of Kähler–Einstein metrics. More generally, on any compact complex manifold, K-stability is conjectured to be equivalent to the existence of constant scalar curvature Kähler metrics (cscK metrics).

In mathematics, and especially differential and algebraic geometry, K-stability is an algebro-geometric stability condition, for complex manifolds and complex algebraic varieties. The notion of K-stability was first introduced by Gang Tian and reformulated more algebraically later by Simon Donaldson. The definition was inspired by a comparison to geometric invariant theory (GIT) stability. In the special case of Fano varieties, K-stability precisely characterises the existence of Kähler–Einstein metrics. More generally, on any compact complex manifold, K-stability is conjectured to be equivalent to the existence of constant scalar curvature Kähler metrics (cscK metrics). In 1954, Eugenio Calabi formulated a conjecture about the existence of Kähler metrics on compact Kähler manifolds, now known as the Calabi conjecture. One formulation of the conjecture is that a compact Kähler manifold X admits a unique Kähler–Einstein metric in the class c_1(X) . In the particular case where c_1(X)=0 , such a Kähler–Einstein metric would be Ricci flat, making the manifold a Calabi–Yau manifold. The Calabi conjecture was resolved in the case where c_1(X) by Thierry Aubin and Shing-Tung Yau, and when c_1(X)=0 by Yau. In the case where c_1(X)>0 , that is when X is a Fano manifold, a Kähler–Einstein metric does not always exist. Namely, it was known by work of Yozo Matsushima and André Lichnerowicz that a Kähler manifold with c_1(X)>0 can only admit a Kähler–Einstein metric if the Lie algebra H^0(X, TX) is reductive. However, it can be easily shown that the blow up of the complex projective plane at one point, \text{Bl}_p \mathbb{CP}^2 is Fano, but does not have reductive Lie algebra. Thus not all Fano manifolds can admit Kähler–Einstein metrics. After the resolution of the Calabi conjecture for c_1(X)\le 0 attention turned to the loosely related problem of finding canonical metrics on vector bundles over complex manifolds. In 1983, Donaldson produced a new proof of the Narasimhan–Seshadri theorem. As proved by Donaldson, the theorem states that a holomorphic vector bundle over a compact Riemann surface is stable if and only if it corresponds to an irreducible unitary Yang–Mills connection. That is, a unitary connection which is a critical point of the Yang–Mills functional \operatorname{YM}(\nabla) = \int_X \|F_{\nabla}\|^2 \, d \operatorname{vol} . On a Riemann surface such a connection is projectively flat, and its holonomy gives rise to a projective unitary representation of the fundamental group of the Riemann surface, thus recovering the original statement of the theorem by M. S. Narasimhan and C. S. Seshadri. During the 1980s this theorem was generalised through the work of Donaldson, Karen Uhlenbeck and Yau, and Jun Li and Yau to the Kobayashi–Hitchin correspondence, which relates stable holomorphic vector bundles to Hermitian–Einstein connections over arbitrary compact complex manifolds. A key observation in the setting of holomorphic vector bundles is that once a holomorphic structure is fixed, any choice of Hermitian metric gives rise to a unitary connection, the Chern connection. Thus one can either search for a Hermitian–Einstein connection, or its corresponding Hermitian–Einstein metric. Inspired by the resolution of the existence problem for canonical metrics on vector bundles, in 1993 Yau was motivated to conjecture the existence of a Kähler–Einstein metric on a Fano manifold should be equivalent to some form of algebro-geometric stability condition on the variety itself, just as the existence of a Hermitian–Einstein metric on a holomorphic vector bundle is equivalent to its stability. Yau suggested this stability condition should be an analogue of slope stability of vector bundles. In 1997, Tian suggested such a stability condition, which he called K-stability after the K-energy functional introduced by Toshiki Mabuchi. The K originally stood for kinetic due to the similarity of the K-energy functional with the kinetic energy, and for the German kanonisch for the canonical bundle. Tian's definition was analytic in nature, and specific to the case of Fano manifolds. Several years later Donaldson introduced an algebraic condition described in this article called K-stability, which makes sense on any polarised variety, and is equivalent to Tian's analytic definition in the case of the polarised variety (X, -K_X) where X is Fano. x_0 = \lim_{t\to 0} \lambda(t) \cdot x . This is a fixed point of the action of the 1-PS \lambda , and so the line over x in the affine space \mathbb{C}^{N+1} is preserved by the action of \lambda . An action of the multiplicative group \mathbb{C}^* on a one dimensional vector space comes with a weight, an integer we label \mu(x,\lambda) , with the property that \lambda(t) \cdot \tilde{x} = t^{\mu(x,\lambda)} \tilde{x} for any \tilde{x} in the fibre over x_0 . The Hilbert-Mumford criterion says: The point x is semistable if \mu(x,\lambda)\le 0 for all 1-PS \lambda . The point x is stable if \mu(x,\lambda) for all 1-PS \lambda . The point x is unstable if \mu(x,\lambda) >0 for any 1-PS \lambda . If one wishes to define a notion of stability for varieties, the Hilbert-Mumford criterion therefore suggests it is enough to consider one parameter deformations of the variety. This leads to the notion of a test configuration. By definition an action of \Complex^* on a polarised scheme comes with an action of \Complex^* on the ample line bundle \mathcal{L}_0 , and therefore induces an action on the vector spaces H^0(\mathcal{X}_0, \mathcal{L}_0^k) for all integers k\ge 0 . An action of \Complex^* on a complex vector space V induces a direct sum decomposition V=V_1\oplus \cdots \oplus V_n into weight spaces, where each V_i is a one dimensional subspace of V , and the action of \mathbb{C}^* when restricted to V_i has a weight w_i . Define the total weight of the action to be the integer w=w_1+\cdots + w_n . This is the same as the weight of the induced action of \Complex^* on the one dimensional vector space \bigwedge^n V where n=\dim V . Define the weight function of the test configuration (\mathcal{X},\mathcal{L}) to be the function w(k) where w(k) is the total weight of the \Complex^* action on the vector space H^0(\mathcal{X}_0,\mathcal{L}_0^k) for each non-negative integer k \ge 0 . Whilst the function w(k) is not a polynomial in general, it becomes a polynomial of degree n+1 for all k>k_0\gg 0 for some fixed integer k_0 , where n = \dim X . This can be seen using an equivariant Riemann-Roch theorem. Recall that the Hilbert polynomial \mathcal{P}(k) satisfies the equality \mathcal{P}(k)=\dim H^0(X, L^k) = \dim H^0(\mathcal{X}_0,\mathcal{L}_0^k) for all k>k_1\gg 0 for some fixed integer k_1 , and is a polynomial of degree n . For such k\gg 0 , let us write \mathcal{P}(k) = a_0 k^n + a_1 k^{n-1} + O(k^{n-2}), \quad w(k) = b_0 k^{n+1} + b_1 k^n + O(k^{n-1}) . The Donaldson-Futaki invariant of the test configuration (\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L}) is the rational number \operatorname{DF}(\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L}) = \frac{b_0a_1-b_1a_0}{a_0^2} . In particular \operatorname{DF}(\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L}) = -f_1 where f_1 is the first order term in the expansion \frac{w(k)}{k \mathcal{P}(k)} = f_0 + f_1 k^{-1} + O(k^{-2}) . The Donaldson-Futaki invariant does not change if L is replaced by a positive power L^r , and so in the literature K-stability is often discussed using \mathbb{Q} -line bundles. It is possible to describe the Donaldson-Futaki invariant in terms of intersection theory, and this was the approach taken by Tian in defining the CM-weight. Any test configuration (\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L}) admits a natural compactification (\bar{\mathcal{X}}, \bar{\mathcal{L}}) over \mathbb{P}^1 (e.g., see ), then the CM-weight is defined by CM({\mathcal{X}},{ \mathcal{L}})=\frac { 1 }{ 2(n+1)\cdot L^{ n } } \left( \mu \cdot n{ (\bar {\mathcal{L}} ) }^{ n+1 }+(n+1){ K }_{ \bar { \mathcal{X}} /{ \mathbb{P} }^{ 1 }} \cdot { (\bar {\mathcal{L}} ) }^{ n } \right) where \mu= -\frac{L^{n-1}\cdot K_X}{L^n} . This definition by intersection formula is now often used in algebraic geometry. It is known that \operatorname{ DF } (\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L}) coincides with \operatorname {CM} (\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L}) , so we can take the weight \mu(\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L}) to be either \operatorname{ DF } (\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L}) or \operatorname {CM}(\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L}) . The weight \mu(\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L}) can be also expressed in terms of the Chow form and hyperdiscriminant. In the case of Fano manifolds, there is an interpretation of the weight in terms of new \beta -invariant on valuations found by Chi Li and Kento Fujita. For a test configuration (\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L}) , define the norm as follows. Let A_k be the infinitesimal generator of the \mathbb{C}^* action on the vector space H^0(X,L^k) . Then \operatorname{Tr}(A_k)=w(k) . Similarly to the polynomials w(k) and \mathcal{P}(k) , the function \operatorname{Tr}(A_k^2) is a polynomial for large enough integers k , in this case of degree n+2 . Let us write its expansion as \operatorname{Tr}(A_k^2) = c_0 k^{n+2} + O(k^{n+1}). The norm of a test configuration is defined by the expression \|(\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L})\|^2 = c_0 - \frac{b_0^2}{a_0}. According to the analogy with the Hilbert-Mumford criterion, once one has a notion of deformation (test configuration) and weight on the central fibre (Donaldson-Futaki invariant), one can define a stability condition, called K-stability. Let (X,L) be a polarised algebraic variety. We say that (X,L) is: K-semistable if \operatorname{\mu }(\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L})\ge 0 for all test configurations (\mathcal{X},\mathcal{L}) for (X,L) . K-stable if \operatorname{\mu }(\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L})\ge 0 for all test configurations (\mathcal{X},\mathcal{L}) for (X,L) , and additionally \operatorname{\mu}(\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L})> 0 whenever \|(\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L})\|>0 . K-polystable if (X,L) is K-semistable, and additionally whenever \operatorname{\mu}(\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L})=0 , the test configuration (\mathcal{X}, \mathcal{L}) is a product configuration. K-unstable if it is not K-semistable. The setting where L=-K_X is ample so that X is a Fano manifold is of particular importance, and in that setting many tools are known to verify the K-stability of Fano varieties. For example using purely algebraic techniques it can be proven that all Fermat hypersurfaces F_{n,d} = \{z\in \mathbb{CP}^{n+1}\mid z_0^d + \cdots z_{n+1}^d = 0\} \subset \mathbb{CP}^{n+1} are K-stable Fano varieties for 3 \le d \le n+1 . \operatorname{DF}(\mathcal{X},\mathcal{L}) = \frac{1}{2} \mathcal{L}(f) = \frac{1}{2} \left( \int_{\partial P} f \,d\sigma - a \int_{P} f\, d\mu\right) , where d\mu is the Lebesgue measure on P , d\sigma is the canonical measure on the boundary of P arising from its description as a moment polytope (if an edge of P is given by a linear inequality h(x) \le a for some affine linear functional h on \mathbb{R}^n with integer coefficients, then d\mu = \pm dh \wedge d\sigma ), and a = \operatorname{Vol}(\partial P, d\sigma)/\operatorname{Vol}(P, d\mu) . Additionally the norm of the test configuration can be given by \left\|(\mathcal{X},\mathcal{L}) \right\| = \left\|f - \bar{f}\right\|_{L^2} , where \bar{f} is the average of f on P with respect to d\mu . It was shown by Donaldson that for toric surfaces, it suffices to test convex functions of a particularly simple form. We say a convex function on P is piecewise-linear if it can be written as a maximum f = \max (h_1, \dots, h_n) for some affine linear functionals h_1,\dots,h_n . Notice that by the definition of the constant a , the Donaldson-Futaki invariant \mathcal{L}(f) is invariant under the addition of an affine linear functional, so we may always take one of the h_i to be the constant function 0 . We say a convex function is simple piecewise-linear if it is a maximum of two functions, and so is given by f = \max (0, h) for some affine linear function h , and simple rational piecewise-linear if h has rational cofficients. Donaldson showed that for toric surfaces it is enough to test K-stability only on simple rational piecewise-linear functions. Such a result is powerful in so far as it is possible to readily compute the Donaldson-Futaki invariants of such simple test configurations, and therefore computationally determine when a given toric surface is K-stable. An example of a K-unstable manifold is given by the toric surface \mathbb{F}_1 = \operatorname{Bl}_0\mathbb{CP}^2 , the first Hirzebruch surface, which is the blow up of the complex projective plane at a point, with respect to the polarisation given by L = \frac{1}{2}(\pi^* \mathcal{O}(2) - E) , where \pi: \mathbb{F}_1 \to \mathbb{CP}^2 is the blow up and E the exceptional divisor. . The measure d\sigma on the horizontal and vertical boundary faces of the polytope are just dx and dy . On the diagonal face x+y=2 the measure is given by (dx-dy)/2 . Consider the convex function f(x,y)=x+y on this polytope. Then \int_P f\, d\mu = \frac{11}{6},\qquad \int_{\partial P} f\, d\sigma = 6 , and \operatorname{Vol}(P, d\mu)=\frac{3}{2},\qquad \operatorname{Vol}(\partial P, d\sigma) = 5 , Thus \mathcal{L}(f) = 6-\frac{55}{9} = -\frac{1}{9} and so the first Hirzebruch surface \mathbb{F}_1 is K-unstable. Take a polarised variety (X,L) with Hilbert polynomial \mathcal{P} , and fix an r>0 such that L^r is very ample with vanishing higher cohomology. The pair (X,L^r) can then be identified with a point in the Hilbert scheme of subschemes of \mathbb{P}^{\mathcal{P}(r)-1} with Hilbert polynomial \mathcal{P}'(K) = \mathcal{P}(Kr) . This Hilbert scheme can be embedded into projective space as a subscheme of a Grassmannian (which is projective via the Plücker embedding). The general linear group \operatorname{GL}(\mathcal{P}(r), \mathbb{C}) acts on this Hilbert scheme, and two points in the Hilbert scheme are equivalent if and only if the corresponding polarised varieties are isomorphic. Thus one can use geometric invariant theory for this group action to give a notion of stability. This construction depends on a choice of r>0 , so one says a polarised variety is asymptotically Hilbert stable if it is stable with respect to this embedding for all r>r_0\gg0 sufficiently large, for some fixed r_0 . There is another projective embedding of the Hilbert scheme called the Chow embedding, which provides a different linearisation of the Hilbert scheme and therefore a different stability condition. One can similarly therefore define asymptotic Chow stability. Explicitly the Chow weight for a fixed r>0 can be computed as \operatorname{Chow}_r(\mathcal{X},\mathcal{L}) = \frac{rb_0}{a_0} - \frac{w(r)}{\mathcal{P}(r)} for r sufficiently large. Unlike the Donaldson-Futaki invariant, the Chow weight changes if the line bundle L is replaced by some power L^k . However, from the expression \operatorname{Chow}_{rk}(\mathcal{X},\mathcal{L^k}) = \frac{krb_0}{a_0} - \frac{w(kr)}{\mathcal{P}(kr)} one observes that \operatorname{DF}(\mathcal{X},\mathcal{L}) = \lim_{k\to\infty} \operatorname{Chow}_{rk}(\mathcal{X},\mathcal{L^k}) , and so K-stability is in some sense the limit of Chow stability as the dimension of the projective space X is embedded in approaches infinity. One may similarly define asymptotic Chow semistability and asymptotic Hilbert semistability, and the various notions of stability are related as follows: Asymptotically Chow stable \implies Asymptotically Hilbert stable \implies Asymptotically Hilbert semistable \implies Asymptotically Chow semistable \implies K-semistable It is however not know whether K-stability implies asymptotic Chow stability. I=I_0 + t I_1 + t^2 I_2 + \cdots + t^{r-1} I_{r-1} + (t^r)\subset \mathcal{O}_X \otimes \mathbb{C}[t], where t is the coordinate on \mathbb{C} . By taking the support of the ideals this corresponds to blowing up along a flag of subschemes Z_{r-1} \subset \cdots \subset Z_2 \subset Z_1 \subset Z_0 \subset X inside the copy X\times \{0\} of X . One obtains this decomposition essentially by taking the weight space decomposition of the invariant ideal I under the \mathbb{C}^* action. In the special case where this flag of subschemes is of length one, the Donaldson-Futaki invariant can be easily computed and one arrives at slope K-stability. Given a subscheme Z\subset X defined by an ideal sheaf I_Z , the test configuration is given by \mathcal{X} = \operatorname{Bl}_{Z\times\{0\}} (X\times \mathbb{C}) , which is the deformation to the normal cone of the embedding Z\hookrightarrow X . If the variety X has Hilbert polynomial \mathcal{P}(k) = a_0 k^n + a_1 k^{n-1} + O(k^{n-2}) , define the slope of X to be \mu(X) = \frac{a_1}{a_0} . To define the slope of the subscheme Z , consider the Hilbert-Samuel polynomial of the subscheme Z , \chi(L^r \otimes I_Z^{xr}) = a_0(x) r^n + a_1(x)r^{n-1} + O(r^{n-2}) , for r\gg 0 and x a rational number such that xr \in \mathbb{N} . The coefficients a_i(x) are polynomials in x of degree n-i , and the K-slope of I_Z with respect to c is defined by \mu_c(I_Z) = \frac{\int_0^c \big(a_1(x) + \frac{a_0'(x)}{2}\big)\, dx}{\int_0^c a_0(x) \, dx}. This definition makes sense for any choice of real number c\in (0,\epsilon(Z)] where \epsilon(Z) is the Seshadri constant of Z . Notice that taking Z=\emptyset we recover the slope of X . The pair (X,L) is slope K-semistable if for all proper subschemes Z\subset X , \mu_c(I_Z) \le \mu(X) for all c\in (0,\epsilon(Z)] (one can also define slope K-stability and slope K-polystability by requiring this inequality to be strict, with some extra technical conditions). It was shown by Ross and Thomas that K-semistability implies slope K-semistability. However, unlike in the case of vector bundles, it is not the case that slope K-stability implies K-stability. In the case of vector bundles it is enough to consider only single subsheaves, but for varieties it is necessary to consider flags of length greater than one also. Despite this, slope K-stability can still be used to identify K-unstable varieties, and therefore by the results of Stoppa, give obstructions to the existence of cscK metrics. For example, Ross and Thomas use slope K-stability to show that the projectivisation of an unstable vector bundle over a K-stable base is K-unstable, and so does not admit a cscK metric. This is a converse to results of Hong, which show that the projectivisation of a stable bundle over a base admitting a cscK metric, also admits a cscK metric, and is therefore K-stable. R = \bigoplus_{k\ge 0} H^0(X, L^k) of the polarised variety (X,L) . The filtrations considered must be compatible with the grading on the coordinate ring in the following sense: A filtation \chi of R is a chain of finite-dimensional subspaces \mathbb{C} = F_0 R \subset F_1 R \subset F_2 R \subset \dots \subset R such that the following conditions hold: The filtration is multiplicative. That is, (F_iR)(F_jR) \subset F_{i+j}R for all i,j\ge 0 . The filtration is compatible with the grading on R coming from the graded pieces R_k = H^0(X, L^k) . That is, if f\in F_iR , then each homogenous piece of f is in F_iR . The filtration exhausts R . That is, we have \bigcup_{i\ge0} F_iR = R . Given a filtration \chi , its Rees algebra is defined by \operatorname{Rees}(\chi) = \bigoplus_{i\ge 0} (F_i R)t^i \subset R[t]. We say that a filtration is finitely generated if its Rees algebra is finitely generated. It was proven by David Witt Nyström that a filtration is finitely generated if and only if it arises from a test configuration, and by Székelyhidi that any filtration is a limit of finitely generated filtrations. Combining these results Székelyhidi observed that the example of Apostolov-Calderbank-Gauduchon-Tønnesen-Friedman would not violate the Yau–Tian–Donaldson conjecture if K-stability was replaced by filtration K-stability. This suggests that the definition of K-stability may need to be edited to account for these limiting examples.

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1376148347 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

Extracted from the cited revision's reference blocks; absent citations are not invented.