Kafala system
≈ 14 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
has been linked to labor abuses that occurred during the construction of the venues for the 2022 FIFA World Cup (pictured here, Al Thumama Stadium; one of the World Cup stadiums, under construction in 2013). The kafala system or kefala system ( , ) is a system in the Middle East that involves binding the residency and employment status of a migrant worker to a specific employer throughout the period of their residence in a country.
Under this arrangement, the employer holds substantial authority over the worker, including the ability to approve or deny job changes, and permission to leave the country. This dependency creates a significant power imbalance that heightens the risk of exploitation and abusive practices. It currently exists in many Arab countries, especially those in the Arabian Peninsula, with Lebanon, Jordan and Kuwait also being very prominent.
A similar "binding system" existed in Israel until 2006, when the Israeli Supreme Court struck it down, though it continues to be heavily practiced in certain industries. The system, which blocks domestic competition for overseas workers in the Arab countries of the Persian Gulf, requires migrant workers to have an in-country sponsor, usually their employer, who is responsible for their visa and legal status.…
has been linked to labor abuses that occurred during the construction of the venues for the 2022 FIFA World Cup (pictured here, Al Thumama Stadium; one of the World Cup stadiums, under construction in 2013). The kafala system or kefala system ( , ) is a system in the Middle East that involves binding the residency and employment status of a migrant worker to a specific employer throughout the period of their residence in a country.
Under this arrangement, the employer holds substantial authority over the worker, including the ability to approve or deny job changes, and permission to leave the country. This dependency creates a significant power imbalance that heightens the risk of exploitation and abusive practices. It currently exists in many Arab countries, especially those in the Arabian Peninsula, with Lebanon, Jordan and Kuwait also being very prominent.
A similar "binding system" existed in Israel until 2006, when the Israeli Supreme Court struck it down, though it continues to be heavily practiced in certain industries. The system, which blocks domestic competition for overseas workers in the Arab countries of the Persian Gulf, requires migrant workers to have an in-country sponsor, usually their employer, who is responsible for their visa and legal status.
This practice has been criticized by human rights organizations for creating easy opportunities for the exploitation of workers, as many employers confiscate their migrant workers' passports and abuse them with little chance of legal repercussions and even repatriation. In 2014, the International Trade Union Confederation estimated that there were 2.4 million enslaved domestic workers in the Arab Gulf countries and the Levant. Virtually all of these enslaved workers were from West Africa, South Asia and Southeast Asia.
Per country
Bahrain
In 2009, Bahrain was the first country in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) to repeal the kafala system. In a public statement, the Labour Minister likened the system to slavery. Changes to the Labour Market Regulatory Law were made in April 2009 and implemented starting 1 August 2009. Under the new law, migrants are sponsored by the Labour Market Regulation Authority and can change from one employer to another without their employer's agreement. Three months' notice is required to quit from an employer. However, in November 2009 Human Rights Watch stated that "authorities do little to enforce compliance" with "employers who withhold wages and passports from migrant employees ... practices [which] are illegal under Bahraini law."
Israel
For years through the year 2006, Israel effectively maintained a kafala system, which in Israel was called the "binding system". As with the kafala system, migrant laborers in Israel were tied to a specific employer for the duration of their visas. Over the years when Israel maintained this system, passport confiscation and other abuses were systematic and effectively went unpunished. The Israeli Supreme Court struck down the Israeli version of the kafala system in a landmark March 2006 decision, Kav LaOved Worker's Hotline v.
Government of Israel, with the Court citing human rights concerns. While the 2006 decision removed the Israeli version of the kafala system in a formal sense, a 2014 study by Israeli labour scholars Adriana Kemp and Rebeca Raijman claimed that the binding system still applied to migrant domestic workers, though not to migrant workers in general.
Abuses of migrant non-domestic workers in Israel remained widespread ; a 2015 study by Human Rights Watch found that almost all Thai migrant workers on kibbutzim in Israel lived in squalor, were denied regular days off, and were worked beyond, and paid below, legally mandated requirements.
Kuwait
The kafala system is practiced in Kuwait. In 2018, Kuwait became involved in a diplomatic crisis with the Philippines, which ended in a May 2018 labor deal which prohibited common practices under the kafala against Filipino migrant workers, including the confiscation of passports and guaranteeing one day off a week from work.
Qatar
In 2026, both Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International stated that foreign labourers in Qatar faced widespread abuses under the Kafala system, which they describe as "restrictive" and "exploitative". Human Rights Watch 's report said that reforms had had "limited impact", and that Qatar had failed to address serious violations against workers, who still "face[d] wage theft, unexplained deaths, dangerous working conditions and continued exploitation".
Saudi Arabia
From 1991 to 2019, 300,000 Bangladeshi women went to Saudi Arabia under the kafala system. In early November 2019, protests took place in Dhaka in response to the case of Sumi Akter, who claimed "merciless sexual assaults", being locked up for 15 days, and having her hands burnt by hot oil by her Saudi employers. The case of another Bangladeshi, Nazma Begum, who claimed being tortured, also attracted media attention. Both had been promised jobs as hospital cleaning staff but were tricked into becoming household servants.
Begum died in Saudi Arabia of an untreated illness. According to a 2008 HRW report, under the kafala system in Saudi Arabia, "an employer assumes responsibility for a hired migrant worker and must grant explicit permission before the worker can enter Saudi Arabia, transfer employment, or leave the country.
The kafala system gives the employer immense control over the worker." HRW stated that "some abusive employers exploit the kafala system and force domestic workers to continue working against their will and forbid them from returning to their countries of origin" and that this is "incompatible with Article 13 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights".
HRW stated that "the combination of the high recruitment fees paid by Saudi employers and the power granted them by the kafala system to control whether a worker can change employers or exit the country made some employers feel entitled to exert 'ownership' over a domestic worker" and that the "sense of ownership ... creates slavery-like conditions". In 2018, France 24 and ALQST reported on the use of Twitter and other online social networks by kafala system employers, "kafeels", to "sell" domestic workers to other kafeels, in violation of Saudi law.
ALQST described the online trading as "slavery 2.0". During 2015–2018, Several Indonesian domestic workers were executed in Saudi Arabia. Siti Zaeneb and Karni were beheaded in April 2015. Muhammad Zaini Misin was executed in March 2018 for having killed his employer. On 29 October 2018, Tuti Tursilawati, also an Indonesian domestic worker in Saudi Arabia, was executed for having killed her employer, an action which she claimed had been in self-defense in relation to sexual abuse.
Indonesian Foreign Minister Retno Marsudi lodged an official complaint concerning the execution, which was carried out without warning and despite an appeal against the sentence. On 4 November 2020, as part of its 2030 vision, Saudi Arabia announced a reformation plan for its labour law. Effective on 14 March 2021, the new measures are meant to curb the kafala system through: Mandatory digital documentation of labor contracts.
Dropping the stipulation of sponsor consent for exit visas, final exit visas, re-entry visas, and change of sponsor, so long as they are to be applied for after the end of a contractual term or an appropriate notice period previously specified in the contract. Other requirements may still apply in case of applying within a contractual term. The changes were to be implemented in the Absher and Qiwa portals, both being part of the e-government in Saudi Arabia.
In March 2021, Saudi Arabia introduced new labour reforms, allowing some migrant workers to change jobs without their employer's consent. Human Rights Watch claimed that the reforms did not dismantle the abuses of the kafala system, "leaving migrant workers at high risk of abuse". Many domestic workers and farmers who are not covered by the labour law are still vulnerable to multifold abuses, including passport confiscation, delayed wages and even forced labour.
Although migrant workers are allowed to request an exit permit without their employer's permission, the need to have an exit permit in order to leave the country is a human rights violation. An investigation by France 24 in April 2021 documented abuses of female migrant workers in Saudi Arabia. A 22-year-old woman migrant worker from Madagascar was murdered by the underground prostitution mafia she used to work for after running away from her employer's home and buried without a coffin in al-Jubail.
Due to the practice of some sponsors who confiscate the passports of migrant workers, young women from East Africa find it difficult to return home after perceived mistreatment by their employers. The women often end up falling into prostitution. In June 2025, Saudi Arabia made an announcement declaring the abolishment of the kafala system, as part of the Saudi Vision 2030 reform program.
The Times of India interpreted the announcement as aiming to attract foreign investment, "modernise" Saudi Arabia's reputation, and also as a response to criticism by human rights groups, Western governments and corporations of labour rights abuses in GCC member states. Prior to the June 2025 announcement, Amnesty International criticised abuses of workers' rights in the preparations for the 2034 FIFA World Cup, to be held in Saudi Arabia.
However, it has been claimed the existence of this announcement abolishing the kafala system is spin, which is to say disinformation.
United Arab Emirates
The United Arab Emirates has a work visa sponsorship system to issue work permits for certain foreign nationals who wish to migrate for work in the UAE. Most of the visas are sponsored by institutions and companies. A person looking to enter the UAE for work obtains a work permit, valid for two months, from the Ministry of Human Resources. The sponsor is responsible for medical testing and obtaining identity cards, documents and stamps. The employee can then sponsor his or her family members and bring them into the UAE.
Per Article 1 of Ministerial Decree No. 766 of 2015, an employee whose contract expires can obtain a new permit and may remain in the UAE on a 6-month job seeker visa. A new work permit is also issued if the employer fails legal and contractual obligations such as not paying wages for 60 days. A worker may request his contract to be terminated after at least 6 months of employment. A worker whose employment is terminated unfairly has the right to receive a new work permit without the six-month condition.
The right of alien residence and work permit is protected by the UAE Federal law No. 6 of 1973 on the Entry and Residence of aliens. Per UAE law, an employer may not deny an employee on a work visa right to an annual leave, regular paid wage, 45 days maternity leave, right to resign, resign gratuity, and a 30-day grace period to find a new job.
An employer is also prohibited by law from confiscating an employee's passport, forcing the employee to pay for his or her residency visa fees, or forcing the employee to work more than eight hours a day or 45 hours a week without compensation. An employee who wishes to leave needs to complete his or her legal notice period, which is usually 30 days or less, before leaving their job or risk being banned to work in UAE for up to one year.
Alien widows or divorced women whose legal presence in the country was sponsored by their husband's work status are given a one-year visa to stay in the country without the need for a work permit or a sponsor. In October 2014, Human Rights Watch estimated that there were 146,000 female migrant domestic workers in the UAE whose work visa was sponsored by employers in the UAE.
In an interview with 99 female domestic workers, HRW listed abuses claimed by their interviewees: most had their passports confiscated by their employers; in many cases, wages were not fully paid, overtime (up to 21 hours per day) was required, or food, living conditions or medical treatment was insufficient. 24 had been physically or sexually abused. HRW criticized the UAE government for failing to adequately protect domestic workers from exploitation and abuse and made many recommendations to the UAE, including repeal or amendment of Federal Law No.
6 of 1973 on the Entry and Residence of Foreigners, so that domestic workers can decide on their own to change between employers without losing their immigration status. The UAE introduced Ministerial Decree No.
766 of 2015, which allows a worker to terminate his contract without losing their immigration status if the employer has treated him or her unfairly and be issued a new work permit, or to request the contract to be terminated without losing immigration status and receive a new work permit after at least 6 months of employment provided they have found a new employer. The act of confiscating passports is illegal under UAE law.
In June 2017, the UAE adopted a new bill to bring its labour law into consistency with the International Labour Organization's (ILO) Domestic Workers Convention, providing migrant domestic workers with the same labour protections as other UAE employees. The bill requires employers to provide domestic workers with accommodation and food, an annual minimum of 30 days paid leave, 15 days of paid sick leave, 15 days of unpaid sick leave, compensation for work-related injuries or illnesses, and 12 hours' daily rest.
See also
Middle East and Islamic world History of slavery in the Muslim world Islamic views on slavery Human rights in Muslim-majority countries Migrant workers in the Gulf Cooperation Council region Treatment of South Asian labourers in the Gulf Cooperation Council region Criticism of Islam General Debt bondage Exit visa, visa required to exit the host country Illegal emigration, departure from a country in violation of emigration laws Illegal immigration, arrival in a country in violation of emigration laws Workforce nationalization, government policy of mandatory employment of native-born population
References
External links
Qatar Labour Law (Kafala) full text
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1377661370 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.