Lesson plan
Karintamil
Karintamil is a term used to refer to the western coastal dialect of Middle Tamil spoken in ancient Kerala until the 9th century CE or possibly later. It is thought to be the earliest predecessor of the modern Malayalam language. The Sangam literature can be considered as the ancient predecessor of Malayalam. The term Karintamil was first coined by T. K. Krishna Menon in his 1939 book "A Primer of Malayalam Literature". Menon proposed that Karintamil was spoken in Kerala between 3100 BCE and 100 BCE and was distinct from the Tamil spoken in neighboring kingdoms. However, the concept of Karintamil has been largely rejected by mainstream linguistics. Critics view it as a term with propagandist and ideologically driven nature. The oldest available inscription in Old Malayalam, the Quilon Syrian copper plates (dated to 850 CE), is itself debated by scholars. Many linguists regard the language of these Chera Perumal inscriptions (early Kerala rulers) as a diverging dialect or variety of Middle Tamil, not a separate language. This late date for the oldest inscription believed to be in Old Malayalam (850 CE) further weakens the case for its proposed predecessor, Karintamil, especially considering the proposed timeline of 3100 BCE to 100 BCE.…
Article summary
Karintamil is a term used to refer to the western coastal dialect of Middle Tamil spoken in ancient Kerala until the 9th century CE or possibly later. It is thought to be the earliest predecessor of the modern Malayalam language. The Sangam literature can be considered as the ancient predecessor of Malayalam. The term Karintamil was first coined by T. K. Krishna Menon in his 1939 book "A Primer of Malayalam Literature". Menon proposed that Karintamil was spoken in Kerala between 3100 BCE and 100 BCE and was distinct from the Tamil spoken in neighboring kingdoms. However, the concept of Karintamil has been largely rejected by mainstream linguistics. Critics view it as a term with propagandist and ideologically driven nature. The oldest available inscription in Old Malayalam, the Quilon Syrian copper plates (dated to 850 CE), is itself debated by scholars. Many linguists regard the language of these Chera Perumal inscriptions (early Kerala rulers) as a diverging dialect or variety of Middle Tamil, not a separate language. This late date for the oldest inscription believed to be in Old Malayalam (850 CE) further weakens the case for its proposed predecessor, Karintamil, especially considering the proposed timeline of 3100 BCE to 100 BCE.…
Key claims
No claims recorded.
Discussion questions
- Summarise the article in your own words. Which single claim would you verify first, and why?
- Which claim in this article is most likely to be revised as the sources update? How would you check its current status?
- If two sources disagreed about one of these facts, what would you need in order to trust one over the other?
Bibliography
No sources recorded.
Key claims and bibliography are generated from the same tracked claims and sources as the article page.