Klein paradox

In relativistic quantum mechanics, the Klein paradox was an unexpected effect of relativity on the predictions of quantum tunneling theory for particles encountering high potential-energy barriers.

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 8 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

In relativistic quantum mechanics, the Klein paradox was an unexpected effect of relativity on the predictions of quantum tunneling theory for particles encountering high potential-energy barriers. The phenomenon itself is now known as Klein tunneling. It is named after physicist Oskar Klein who discovered it in 1929.

Originally, Klein obtained a paradoxical result by applying the Dirac equation to the familiar problem of electron scattering from a potential barrier. In nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, electron tunneling into a barrier is observed, with exponential damping.

However, Klein's result showed that if the potential is at least of the order of the electron mass Ve\approx mc^2 (where V is the electric potential, e is the elementary charge, m is the electron mass and c is the speed of light), the barrier is nearly transparent. Moreover, as the potential approaches infinity, the reflection diminishes and the electron is always transmitted.

The immediate application of the paradox was to Rutherford's proton–electron model for neutral particles within the nucleus, before the discovery of the neutron, which made the model obsolete. The paradox presented a quantum mechanical objection to the notion of an electron confined within a nucleus.

This clear and precise paradox suggested that an electron could not be confined within a nucleus by any potential well.…

In relativistic quantum mechanics, the Klein paradox was an unexpected effect of relativity on the predictions of quantum tunneling theory for particles encountering high potential-energy barriers. The phenomenon itself is now known as Klein tunneling. It is named after physicist Oskar Klein who discovered it in 1929.

Originally, Klein obtained a paradoxical result by applying the Dirac equation to the familiar problem of electron scattering from a potential barrier. In nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, electron tunneling into a barrier is observed, with exponential damping.

However, Klein's result showed that if the potential is at least of the order of the electron mass Ve\approx mc^2 (where V is the electric potential, e is the elementary charge, m is the electron mass and c is the speed of light), the barrier is nearly transparent. Moreover, as the potential approaches infinity, the reflection diminishes and the electron is always transmitted.

The immediate application of the paradox was to Rutherford's proton–electron model for neutral particles within the nucleus, before the discovery of the neutron, which made the model obsolete. The paradox presented a quantum mechanical objection to the notion of an electron confined within a nucleus.

This clear and precise paradox suggested that an electron could not be confined within a nucleus by any potential well. The meaning of this paradox was intensely debated by Niels Bohr and others at the time. For massive particles, the electric field strength required to observe the effect is enormous.

The electric potential energy change similar to the rest energy of the incoming particle, m c^2 , would need to occur over the Compton wavelength of the particle, \hbar /mc , which works out to 10^{16}~\text{V}/\text{cm} for electrons. For electrons, such extreme fields might only be relevant in Z>170 nuclei or evaporation at the event horizon of black holes, but for 2-D quasiparticles at graphene p-n junctions, for which the required electric fields are on the order of 10^5~\text{V}/\text{cm} , the effect has been studied both theoretically and experimentally.

The Klein result was widely discussed immediately after its publication. Niels Bohr thought the result was related to the abrupt step and as a result Arnold Sommerfeld asked Fritz Sauter to investigate sloped steps.

Sauter was able to confirm Bohr's conjecture: the paradoxical result only appeared for a step of \Delta V > 2m c^2 over a distance similar to the electrons Compton wavelength, \lambda = h/mc , about 2 × 10 −12 m. Throughout 1929 and 1930, a series of papers by different physicists attempted to understand Dirac's extra states. Hermann Weyl suggested they corresponded to recently discovered protons, the only elementary particle other than the electron known at the time.

Dirac pointed out Klein's negative electrons could not convert themselves to positive protons and suggested that the extra states were all filled with electrons already. Then a proton would amount to a missing electron in these lower states. Robert Oppenheimer and separately Igor Tamm showed that this would make atoms unstable.

Finally in 1931 Dirac concluded that these states must correspond to a new "anti-electron" particle. In 1932 Carl Anderson experimentally observed these particles, renamed positrons. Consider a relativistic particle with mass m and energy E approaching a potential step of height V_0 > E+mc^2 located at x=0 at normal incidence.

We can consider this problem using the time-independent Dirac equation. This derivation uses the two-dimensional version of the Dirac equation because it is simpler and still retains the paradox. \hat H \Psi = E\Psi , where the wave function is a two-component spinor \Psi=\begin{pmatrix}\psi_1\\ \psi_2\end{pmatrix} , and the Hamiltonian is \hat H=-i \hbar \hat \vec \sigma \nabla + V(\vec{x}) \hat I_2 + mc^2 \hat \sigma_z , where the \hat \sigma 's are the Pauli matrices, \hat I_2 is the identity matrix, and c is the speed of light.

Taking the particle to propagate in the x-direction, these equations reduce to i\hbar c \frac{d\psi_2}{dx}=[E-mc^2-V(x)]\psi_1 , i\hbar c \frac{d\psi_1}{dx}=[E+mc^2-V(x)]\psi_2 . Assuming the particle is propagating from the left, we obtain two solutions — one before the step, in region (I) and one under the potential, in region (II): \Psi_\text{I}=e^{ikx}\left( \begin{matrix} 1 \\ \alpha\end{matrix} \right)+re^{-ikx}\left( \begin{matrix} 1 \\ -\alpha\end{matrix} \right) , \Psi_\text{II}=te^{iqx}\left( \begin{matrix} 1 \\ 1/\beta\end{matrix} \right) , where the coefficients and are complex numbers representing the reflection and transmission respectively, k=\frac{\sqrt{E^2-m^2c^4}}{\hbar c} is the wave vector before the potential step, q=-\frac{\sqrt{(V_0-E)^2-m^2c^4}}{\hbar c} is the wave vector after the potential step (it is negative because the group velocity for a particle with E+mc^2 is opposite, requiring the minus-sign to ensure it is moving from left-to-right), \alpha=\sqrt{\frac{E-mc^2}{E+mc^2}} , and \beta = \sqrt{\frac{V_0-E-mc^2}{V_0-E+mc^2}} .

From the continuity of the wave function, we can find that 1+r=t , \alpha(1-r)=t/\beta . Solving this system of equations gives r=\frac{\alpha \beta-1}{\alpha \beta + 1} .

Then, the reflection coefficient (which can be interpreted as the probability that an incoming particle is reflected by the potential step) is given by R=r^2=\left( \frac{\alpha \beta-1}{\alpha \beta + 1} \right)^2 , and the transmission coefficient can be calculated as T=1-R=1-\left( \frac{\alpha \beta-1}{\alpha \beta + 1} \right)^2 . The transmission thus remains finite when V_0 \rightarrow \infty .

This is a counterintuitive result compared to non-relativistic quantum mechanics (where one would expect the transmission to go to zero), which is why this phenomenon was named the Klein paradox. One result from this equation is that, for massless particles, the transmission probability is always exactly one, regardless of the height of the potential barrier.

This result is especially relevant given that electrons in graphene behave as massless particles that obey the Dirac equation. A full resolution uses particle–anti-particle pair production in the context of quantum field theory.

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1365396220 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Provenance

snapshot enwiki-001365396220 · captured 2026-07-22 · not yet sealed in the ledger · verify the chain · version history

Cite this page as: encyclopegia.org, “Klein paradox”, snapshot enwiki-001365396220. https://encyclopegia.org/a/klein-paradox

Sources cited in this revision

9 named source(s) extracted from the cited revision. A source with no author is shown by its publication; nothing is invented.