Lee thesis
≈ 5 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
In political philosophy and development studies, the Lee thesis, also known as the full-belly thesis or development without freedom, is an economic hypothesis that holds that authoritarianism can result in greater economic growth. Named after the first prime minister of Singapore, Lee Kuan Yew, the thesis holds that the recognition of civil and human rights by a government will sometimes impair economic growth, and that economic efficiency and more rapid economic development should, and often will, be facilitated by the denial of some political liberties. Weak forms of the Lee thesis argue for a prioritisation of economic development before freedom, which can be introduced at a certain level economic and social development. Strong forms hold that democracy and economic growth are incompatible, such that constitutional systems of authoritarian government have a direct economic advantage over democratic ones, ceteris paribus. The Lee thesis assumes that if a person or society in poverty had to pick between a strong economy and political liberties, they have a better reason to choose the former over the latter, and a government should act in accordance with the overall social welfare function to prefer reducing poverty and improving material conditions.…
In political philosophy and development studies, the Lee thesis, also known as the full-belly thesis or development without freedom, is an economic hypothesis that holds that authoritarianism can result in greater economic growth. Named after the first prime minister of Singapore, Lee Kuan Yew, the thesis holds that the recognition of civil and human rights by a government will sometimes impair economic growth, and that economic efficiency and more rapid economic development should, and often will, be facilitated by the denial of some political liberties. Weak forms of the Lee thesis argue for a prioritisation of economic development before freedom, which can be introduced at a certain level economic and social development. Strong forms hold that democracy and economic growth are incompatible, such that constitutional systems of authoritarian government have a direct economic advantage over democratic ones, ceteris paribus. The Lee thesis assumes that if a person or society in poverty had to pick between a strong economy and political liberties, they have a better reason to choose the former over the latter, and a government should act in accordance with the overall social welfare function to prefer reducing poverty and improving material conditions. Lee's thesis also relates to his theory of Asian values, which held that liberal Western values of welfarism and equality are inapplicable in East Asian societies that prefer stability and progress. Similar arguments in favour of a pluralist conception of rights, which emphasise economic and property rights over social and political ones, have also been advocated in African countries. As a theory of soft authoritarianism or benevolent dictatorship, the Lee thesis also holds that that economic growth under authoritarian capitalism is facilitated by specific constitutional and institutional mechanisms, such as efficient law enforcement; strong public institutions; restraint and deference in judicial review; legal exceptionalism, particularly in regard to national security issues; and the use of social engineering and policy to achieve consensus and maintain popularity. Proponents point to the rapid economic development of Asian economies that adopted authoritarian policies at various points in their development, including Singapore, South Korea, Taiwan, and China, comparing these jurisdictions to less economically-developed democracies, such as India. Both statistically and methodologically, it is difficult to prove broader statements of the Lee hypothesis across countries. Empirical evidence establishing a link between democracy and growth is mixed, with Daron Acemoglu and Amartya Sen arguing against such a correlation, and Robert Barro and Samuel P Huntington providing arguments for some elements of the thesis.
Asian values
The Lee thesis, as part of Lee Kuan Yew's broader political philosophy, was closely related to his Asian values argument, which held that the value system of Asian countries, particularly East Asian countries, prioritised order, stability, and moral conduct over liberty, democracy, and human rights. Proponents of the argument regard democracies as conducive to social disorder, criminality, and the destruction of entire communities for the sake of individual rights. Lee's view, however, has been criticised as ahistorical and athoretical, misrepresenting and misconstruing Confucianism for politically expedient purposes. Proposals for international human rights law to accommodate variations of the Lee thesis and Asian values have generally been rejected by international institutions. According to the Lee thesis, rights are subject to two trade offs: economy over liberty (i.e. citizens prefer economically efficient rights-ignoring government over inefficient, rights-affirming ones); and community over individual (i.e. citizens would prefer for an entire society to benefit at the expense of an individual, rather than an individual benefitting at the expense of society).
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1375268564 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.