LK-99

LK-99, also called PCPOSOS, is a gray–black (or purple ), polycrystalline compound, identified as a copper-doped lead‒oxyapatite.

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 6 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

LK-99, also called PCPOSOS, is a gray–black (or purple ), polycrystalline compound, identified as a copper-doped lead‒oxyapatite. A team from Korea University led by Lee Sukbae ( ) and Kim Ji-Hoon ( ) began studying this material as a potential superconductor in 1999, and in July 2023 published preprints claiming that it acted as a room-temperature superconductor at temperatures of up to at ambient pressure.

Many different researchers attempted to replicate the work, and were able to reach initial results within weeks. By mid-August 2023, the consensus was that LK-99 is not a superconductor at room temperature, and is an insulator in pure form.

A number of replication attempts identified non-superconducting ferromagnetic and diamagnetic causes for observations that suggested superconductivity. A prominent cause was a copper sulfide impurity occurring during the proposed synthesis, which can produce resistance drops, lambda transition in heat capacity, and magnetic response in small samples.

After the initial preprints were published, Lee claimed they were incomplete, and coauthor Kim Hyun-Tak ( ) said one of the papers contained flaws. There were a number of problems with the above synthesis from the initial paper. The reaction is not balanced, and others reported the presence of copper(I) sulfide ( ) as well.

For x=1 a balanced reaction might be: 5 . Many syntheses produced fragmentary results in different phases, where some of the resulting fragments were responsive to magnetic fields, and other fragments were not. The first synthesis to produce pure crystals found them to be diamagnetic insulators.

Compound name

The name LK-99 comes from the initials of Lee and Kim, and the year they first started working with the material (1999). The pair had worked with Tong-Seek Chair ( ) at Korea University in the 1990s. In 2008, they founded the Quantum Energy Research Centre (퀀텀 에너지연구소; also known as ) with other researchers from Korea University. Lee would later become CEO of , and Kim would become director of research and development.

Public response

The claims in the 22 July papers by Lee et al. went viral on social media platforms the following week. The viral nature of the claim resulted in posts from users using pseudonyms from Russia and China claiming to have replicated LK-99 on both Twitter and Zhihu.

Other viral videos described themselves as having replicated samples of LK-99 "partially levitating", most of which were found to be fake. Scientists interviewed by the press remained skeptical, because of the quality of both the original preprints, the lack of purity in the sample they reported, and the legitimacy of the claim after the failure of previous claims of room temperature superconductivity did not show legitimacy (such as the Ranga Dias affair).

The Korean Society of Superconductivity and Cryogenics expressed concern on the social and economic impacts of the preliminary and unverified LK-99 research. A video from Huazhong University of Science and Technology uploaded on 1 August 2023 by a postdoctoral researcher on the team of Chang Haixin, apparently showed a micrometre-sized sample of LK-99 partially levitating.

This went viral on Chinese social media, becoming the most viewed video on Bilibili by the next day, and a prediction market briefly put the chance of successful replication at 60%. A researcher from the Chinese Academy of Sciences refused to comment on the video for the press, dismissing the claim as "ridiculous".

In early August, people began to create memes about "floating rocks", and there was a brief surge in Korean and Chinese technology stocks, despite warnings from the Korean stock exchange against speculative bets in light of the excitement around LK-99, which eventually fell on August 8. Following the publication of the Nature article on August 16 that proclaimed LK-99 is not a superconductor, South Korean superconductor stocks fell further, as the interest about LK-99 from investors in previous weeks disappeared.

Replication attempts

After the July 2023 publication's release, independent groups reported that they had begun attempting to reproduce the synthesis, with initial results expected within weeks. Some replication efforts gained global visibility, with the aid of online replication trackers that catalogued new announcements and status updates. no replication attempts had yet been peer-reviewed by a journal.

Of the non-peer-reviewed attempts, over 15 notable labs published results that failed to observe any superconductivity, and a few observed magnetic response in small fragments that could be explained by normal diamagnetism or ferromagnetism. Some demonstrated and replicated alternate causes of the observations in the original papers: Copper-deficient copper (I) sulfide has a known phase transition at from a low-temperature phase to a high-temperature superionic phase, with a sharp rise in resistivity and a λ-like-feature in the heat capacity.

Furthermore, Cu 2 S is diamagnetic. Only one attempt observed anything that could have been a sign of superconductivity: Southeast University claimed to measure very low resistance in a flake of LK-99, in one of four synthesis attempts, below a temperature of .

Doubts were expressed by experts in the field, as the study saw no dropoff to zero resistance, had large measurement artifacts, and used crude instruments that could not measure resistance below 10 μΩ (too high to distinguish superconductivity from less exotic low-temperature conductivity). Lanthanum decahydride: Superconductivity at T c = at 150 GPa Salvatore Pais – Inventor with a patent referenced in the LK-99 patent Unconventional superconductor

This effect is a conductive copper plate induced by a magnetic. List of replication claims, regularly updated: Compilation of Known Replication Attempt Claims. Guderian2nd, Spacebattles Forums.

Retrieved 2 August 2023. LK-99#Online Claims. Eiri Sanada.

Retrieved 2 August 2023.

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1369652662 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

23 named source(s) extracted from the cited revision. A source with no author is shown by its publication; nothing is invented.