Loop quantum gravity
≈ 29 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
Loop quantum gravity (LQG) is a theory of quantum gravity that incorporates matter of the Standard Model into the framework established for the intrinsic quantum gravity case. It is an attempt to develop a quantum theory of gravity based directly on Albert Einstein's geometric formulation, general relativity. As a theory, LQG postulates that the structure of space and time is composed of finite loops woven into an extremely fine fabric or network. These networks of loops are called spin networks. The evolution of a spin network, or spin foam, has a scale on the order of a Planck length, approximately 10 −35 meters, and smaller scales are meaningless. Consequently, not just matter, but space itself, prefers an atomic structure. The areas of research, which involve about 30 research groups worldwide, share the basic physical assumptions and the mathematical description of quantum space. Research has evolved in two directions: the more traditional canonical loop quantum gravity, and the newer covariant loop quantum gravity, called spin foam theory. The most well-developed theory that has been advanced as a direct result of loop quantum gravity is called loop quantum cosmology (LQC).…
Loop quantum gravity (LQG) is a theory of quantum gravity that incorporates matter of the Standard Model into the framework established for the intrinsic quantum gravity case. It is an attempt to develop a quantum theory of gravity based directly on Albert Einstein's geometric formulation, general relativity. As a theory, LQG postulates that the structure of space and time is composed of finite loops woven into an extremely fine fabric or network. These networks of loops are called spin networks. The evolution of a spin network, or spin foam, has a scale on the order of a Planck length, approximately 10 −35 meters, and smaller scales are meaningless. Consequently, not just matter, but space itself, prefers an atomic structure. The areas of research, which involve about 30 research groups worldwide, share the basic physical assumptions and the mathematical description of quantum space. Research has evolved in two directions: the more traditional canonical loop quantum gravity, and the newer covariant loop quantum gravity, called spin foam theory. The most well-developed theory that has been advanced as a direct result of loop quantum gravity is called loop quantum cosmology (LQC). LQC advances the study of the early universe, incorporating the concept of the Big Bang into the broader theory of the Big Bounce, which envisions the Big Bang as the beginning of a period of expansion, that follows a period of contraction, which has been described as the Big Crunch. \{ G_j , O \}_{G_j=C_a=H = 0} = \{ C_a , O \}_{G_j=C_a=H = 0} = \{ H , O \}_{G_j=C_a=H = 0} = 0, that is, they are quantities defined on the constraint surface that are invariant under the gauge transformations of the theory. Then, solving only the constraint G_j = 0 and determining the Dirac observables with respect to it leads us back to the Arnowitt–Deser–Misner (ADM) phase space with constraints H, C_a . The dynamics of general relativity is generated by the constraints, it can be shown that six Einstein equations describing time evolution (really a gauge transformation) can be obtained by calculating the Poisson brackets of the three-metric and its conjugate momentum with a linear combination of the spatial diffeomorphism and Hamiltonian constraint. The vanishing of the constraints, giving the physical phase space, are the four other Einstein equations. Many of the technical problems in canonical quantum gravity revolve around the constraints. Canonical general relativity was originally formulated in terms of metric variables, but there seemed to be insurmountable mathematical difficulties in promoting the constraints to quantum operators because of their highly non-linear dependence on the canonical variables. The equations were much simplified with the introduction of Ashtekar's new variables. Ashtekar variables describe canonical general relativity in terms of a new pair of canonical variables closer to those of gauge theories. The first step consists of using densitized triads \tilde{E}_i^a (a triad E_i^a is simply three orthogonal vector fields labeled by i = 1,2,3 and the densitized triad is defined by \tilde{E}_i^a = \sqrt{\det (q)} E_i^a ) to encode information about the spatial metric, \det(q) q^{ab} = \tilde{E}_i^a \tilde{E}_j^b \delta^{ij}. (where \delta^{ij} is the flat space metric, and the above equation expresses that q^{ab} , when written in terms of the basis E_i^a , is locally flat). (Formulating general relativity with triads instead of metrics was not new.) The densitized triads are not unique, and in fact one can perform a local in space rotation with respect to the internal indices i . The canonically conjugate variable is related to the extrinsic curvature by K_a^i = K_{ab} \tilde{E}^{ai} / \sqrt{\det (q)} . But problems similar to using the metric formulation arise when one tries to quantize the theory. Ashtekar's new insight was to introduce a new configuration variable, A_a^i = \Gamma_a^i - i K_a^i that behaves as a complex \operatorname{SU}(2) connection where \Gamma_a^i is related to the so-called spin connection via \Gamma_a^i = \Gamma_{ajk} \epsilon^{jki} . Here A_a^i is called the chiral spin connection. It defines a covariant derivative \mathcal{D}_a . It turns out that \tilde{E}^a_i is the conjugate momentum of A_a^i , and together these form Ashtekar's new variables. The expressions for the constraints in Ashtekar variables; Gauss's theorem, the spatial diffeomorphism constraint and the (densitized) Hamiltonian constraint then read: G^i = \mathcal{D}_a \tilde{E}_i^a = 0 C_a = \tilde{E}_i^b F^i_{ab} - A_a^i (\mathcal{D}_b \tilde{E}_i^b) = V_a - A_a^i G^i = 0, \tilde{H} = \epsilon_{ijk} \tilde{E}_i^a \tilde{E}_j^b F^k_{ab} = 0 respectively, where F^i_{ab} is the field strength tensor of the connection A_a^i and where V_a is referred to as the vector constraint. The above-mentioned local in space rotational invariance is the original of the \operatorname{SU}(2) gauge invariance here expressed by Gauss's theorem. Note that these constraints are polynomial in the fundamental variables, unlike the constraints in the metric formulation. This dramatic simplification seemed to open up the way to quantizing the constraints. (See the article Self-dual Palatini action for a derivation of Ashtekar's formalism). With Ashtekar's new variables, given the configuration variable A^i_a , it is natural to consider wavefunctions \Psi (A^i_a) . This is the connection representation. It is analogous to ordinary quantum mechanics with configuration variable q and wavefunctions \psi (q) . The configuration variable gets promoted to a quantum operator via: \hat{A}_a^i \Psi (A) = A_a^i \Psi (A), (analogous to \hat{q} \psi (q) = q \psi (q) ) and the triads are (functional) derivatives, \hat{\tilde{E_i^a}} \Psi (A) = - i {\delta \Psi (A) \over \delta A_a^i}. (analogous to \hat{p} \psi (q) = -i \hbar d \psi (q) / dq ). In passing over to the quantum theory the constraints become operators on a kinematic Hilbert space (the unconstrained \operatorname{SU}(2) Yang–Mills Hilbert space). Note that different ordering of the A 's and \tilde{E} 's when replacing the \tilde{E} 's with derivatives give rise to different operators – the choice made is called the factor ordering and should be chosen via physical reasoning. Formally they read \hat{G}_j \vert\psi \rangle = 0 \hat{C}_a \vert\psi \rangle = 0 \hat{\tilde{H}} \vert\psi \rangle = 0. There are still problems in properly defining all these equations and solving them. For example, the Hamiltonian constraint Ashtekar worked with was the densitized version instead of the original Hamiltonian, that is, he worked with \tilde{H} = \sqrt{\det (q)} H . There were serious difficulties in promoting this quantity to a quantum operator. Moreover, although Ashtekar variables had the virtue of simplifying the Hamiltonian, they are complex. When one quantizes the theory, it is difficult to ensure that one recovers real general relativity as opposed to complex general relativity. The classical result of the Poisson bracket of the smeared Gauss' law G(\lambda) = \int d^3x \lambda^j (D_a E^a)^j with the connections is \{ G(\lambda), A_a^i \} = \partial_a \lambda^i + g \epsilon^{ijk} A_a^j \lambda^k = (D_a \lambda)^i. The quantum Gauss' law reads \hat{G}_j \Psi (A) = - i D_a {\delta \lambda \Psi [A] \over \delta A_a^j} = 0. If one smears the quantum Gauss' law and study its action on the quantum state one finds that the action of the constraint on the quantum state is equivalent to shifting the argument of \Psi by an infinitesimal (in the sense of the parameter \lambda small) gauge transformation, \left [ 1 + \int d^3x \lambda^j (x) \hat{G}_j \right] \Psi (A) = \Psi [A + D \lambda] = \Psi [A], and the last identity comes from the fact that the constraint annihilates the state. So the constraint, as a quantum operator, is imposing the same symmetry that its vanishing imposed classically: it is telling us that the functions \Psi [A] have to be gauge invariant functions of the connection. The same idea is true for the other constraints. Therefore, the two step process in the classical theory of solving the constraints C_I = 0 (equivalent to solving the admissibility conditions for the initial data) and looking for the gauge orbits (solving the 'evolution' equations) is replaced by a one step process in the quantum theory, namely looking for solutions \Psi of the quantum equations \hat{C}_I \Psi = 0 . This is because it solves the constraint at the quantum level and it simultaneously looks for states that are gauge invariant because \hat{C}_I is the quantum generator of gauge transformations (gauge invariant functions are constant along the gauge orbits and thus characterize them). Recall that, at the classical level, solving the admissibility conditions and evolution equations was equivalent to solving all of Einstein's field equations, this underlines the central role of the quantum constraint equations in canonical quantum gravity. h_\gamma [A] . Knowledge of the holonomies is equivalent to knowledge of the connection, up to gauge equivalence. Holonomies can also be associated with an edge; under a Gauss Law these transform as (h'_e)_{\alpha \beta} = U_{\alpha \gamma}^{-1} (x) (h_e)_{\gamma \sigma} U_{\sigma \beta} (y). For a closed loop x = y and assuming \alpha = \beta , yields (h'_e)_{\alpha \alpha} = U_{\alpha \gamma}^{-1} (x) (h_e)_{\gamma \sigma} U_{\sigma \alpha} (x) = [U_{\sigma \alpha} (x) U_{\alpha \gamma}^{-1} (x)] (h_e)_{\gamma \sigma} = \delta_{\sigma \gamma} (h_e)_{\gamma \sigma} = (h_e)_{\gamma \gamma} or \operatorname{Tr} h'_\gamma = \operatorname{Tr} h_\gamma. The trace of an holonomy around a closed loop is written W_\gamma [A] and is called a Wilson loop. Thus Wilson loops are gauge invariant. The explicit form of the Holonomy is h_\gamma [A] = \mathcal{P} \exp \left \{-\int_{\gamma_0}^{\gamma_1} ds \dot{\gamma}^a A_a^i (\gamma (s)) T_i \right \} where \gamma is the curve along which the holonomy is evaluated, and s is a parameter along the curve, \mathcal{P} denotes path ordering meaning factors for smaller values of s appear to the left, and T_i are matrices that satisfy the \operatorname{SU}(2) algebra [T^i ,T^j] = 2i \epsilon^{ijk} T_k. The Pauli matrices satisfy the above relation. It turns out that there are infinitely many more examples of sets of matrices that satisfy these relations, where each set comprises (N+1) \times (N+1) matrices with N = 1,2,3,\dots , and where none of these can be thought to 'decompose' into two or more examples of lower dimension. They are called different irreducible representations of the \operatorname{SU}(2) algebra. The most fundamental representation being the Pauli matrices. The holonomy is labelled by a half integer N/2 according to the irreducible representation used. The use of Wilson loops explicitly solves the Gauss gauge constraint. Loop representation is required to handle the spatial diffeomorphism constraint. With Wilson loops as a basis, any Gauss gauge invariant function expands as, \Psi [A] = \sum_\gamma \Psi [\gamma] W_\gamma [A]. This is called the loop transform and is analogous to the momentum representation in quantum mechanics (see Position and momentum space). The QM representation has a basis of states \exp (ikx) labelled by a number k and expands as \psi [x] = \int dk \psi (k) \exp (ikx). and works with the coefficients of the expansion \psi (k). The inverse loop transform is defined by \Psi [\gamma] = \int [dA] \Psi [A] W_\gamma [A]. This defines the loop representation. Given an operator \hat{O} in the connection representation, \Phi [A] = \hat{O} \Psi [A] \qquad Eq \; 1, one should define the corresponding operator \hat{O}' on \Psi [\gamma] in the loop representation via, \Phi [\gamma] = \hat{O}' \Psi [\gamma] \qquad Eq \; 2, where \Phi [\gamma] is defined by the usual inverse loop transform, \Phi [\gamma] = \int [dA] \Phi [A] W_\gamma [A] \qquad Eq \; 3. A transformation formula giving the action of the operator \hat{O}' on \Psi [\gamma] in terms of the action of the operator \hat{O} on \Psi [A] is then obtained by equating the R.H.S. of Eq \; 2 with the R.H.S. of Eq \; 3 with Eq \; 1 substituted into Eq \; 3 , namely \hat{O}' \Psi [\gamma] = \int [dA] W_\gamma [A] \hat{O} \Psi [A], or \hat{O}' \Psi [\gamma] = \int [dA] (\hat{O}^\dagger W_\gamma [A]) \Psi [A], where \hat{O}^\dagger means the operator \hat{O} but with the reverse factor ordering (remember from simple quantum mechanics where the product of operators is reversed under conjugation). The action of this operator on the Wilson loop is evaluated as a calculation in the connection representation and the result is rearranged purely as a manipulation in terms of loops (with regard to the action on the Wilson loop, the chosen transformed operator is the one with the opposite factor ordering compared to the one used for its action on wavefunctions \Psi [A] ). This gives the physical meaning of the operator \hat{O}' . For example, if \hat{O}^\dagger corresponded to a spatial diffeomorphism, then this can be thought of as keeping the connection field A of W_\gamma [A] where it is while performing a spatial diffeomorphism on \gamma instead. Therefore, the meaning of \hat{O}' is a spatial diffeomorphism on \gamma , the argument of \Psi [\gamma] . In the loop representation, the spatial diffeomorphism constraint is solved by considering functions of loops \Psi [\gamma] that are invariant under spatial diffeomorphisms of the loop \gamma . That is, knot invariants are used. This opens up an unexpected connection between knot theory and quantum gravity. Any collection of non-intersecting Wilson loops satisfy Ashtekar's quantum Hamiltonian constraint. Using a particular ordering of terms and replacing \tilde{E}^a_i by a derivative, the action of the quantum Hamiltonian constraint on a Wilson loop is \hat{\tilde{H}}^\dagger W_\gamma [A] = - \epsilon_{ijk} \hat{F}^k_{ab} \frac{\delta}{\delta A_a^i} \frac{\delta}{\delta A_b^j} W_\gamma [A]. When a derivative is taken it brings down the tangent vector, \dot{\gamma}^a , of the loop, \gamma . So, \hat{F}^i_{ab} \dot{\gamma}^a \dot{\gamma}^b. However, as F^i_{ab} is anti-symmetric in the indices a and b this vanishes (this assumes that \gamma is not discontinuous anywhere and so the tangent vector is unique). With regard to loop representation, the wavefunctions \Psi [\gamma] vanish when the loop has discontinuities and are knot invariants. Such functions solve the Gauss law, the spatial diffeomorphism constraint and (formally) the Hamiltonian constraint. This yields an infinite set of exact (if only formal) solutions to all the equations of quantum general relativity! This generated a lot of interest in the approach and eventually led to LQG. The easiest geometric quantity is the area. Let us choose coordinates so that the surface \Sigma is characterized by x^3 = 0 . The area of small parallelogram of the surface \Sigma is the product of length of each side times \sin \theta where \theta is the angle between the sides. Say one edge is given by the vector \vec{u} and the other by \vec{v} then, A = \| \vec{u} \| \| \vec{v} \| \sin \theta = \sqrt{\| \vec{u} \|^2 \| \vec{v} \|^2 (1 - \cos^2 \theta)} = \sqrt{\| \vec{u} \|^2 \| \vec{v} \|^2 - (\vec{u} \cdot \vec{v})^2} In the space spanned by x^1 and x^2 there is an infinitesimal parallelogram described by \vec{u} = \vec{e}_1 dx^1 and \vec{v} = \vec{e}_2 dx^2 . Using q_{AB}^{(2)} = \vec{e}_A \cdot \vec{e}_B (where the indices A and B run from 1 to 2), yields the area of the surface \Sigma given by A_\Sigma = \int_\Sigma dx^1 dx^2 \sqrt{\det \left(q^{(2)}\right)} where \det (q^{(2)}) = q_{11} q_{22} - q_{12}^2 and is the determinant of the metric induced on \Sigma . The latter can be rewritten \det (q^{(2)}) = \epsilon^{AB} \epsilon^{CD} q_{AC} q_{BD} / 2 where the indices A \dots D go from 1 to 2. This can be further rewritten as \det (q^{(2)}) = {\epsilon^{3ab} \epsilon^{3cd} q_{ac} q_{bc} \over 2}. The standard formula for an inverse matrix is q^{ab} = {\epsilon^{bcd} \epsilon^{aef} q_{ce} q_{df} \over 2!\det (q)}. There is a similarity between this and the expression for \det(q^{(2)}) . But in Ashtekar variables, \tilde{E}^a_i\tilde{E}^{bi} = \det (q) q^{ab} . Therefore, A_\Sigma = \int_\Sigma dx^1 dx^2 \sqrt{\tilde{E}^3_i \tilde{E}^{3i}}. According to the rules of canonical quantization the triads \tilde{E}^3_i should be promoted to quantum operators, \hat{\tilde{E}}^3_i \sim {\delta \over \delta A_3^i}. The area A_\Sigma can be promoted to a well defined quantum operator despite the fact that it contains a product of two functional derivatives and a square-root. Putting N = 2J ( J -th representation), \sum_i T^i T^i = J (J+1) 1. This quantity is important in the final formula for the area spectrum. The result is \hat{A}_\Sigma W_\gamma [A] = 8 \pi \ell_{\text{Planck}}^2 \beta \sum_I \sqrt{j_I (j_I + 1)} W_\gamma [A] where the sum is over all edges I of the Wilson loop that pierce the surface \Sigma . The formula for the volume of a region R is given by V = \int_R d^3 x \sqrt{\det (q)} = \int_R dx^3 \sqrt{\frac{1}{3!} \epsilon_{abc} \epsilon^{ijk} \tilde{E}^a_i \tilde{E}^b_j \tilde{E}^c_k}. The quantization of the volume proceeds the same way as with the area. Each time the derivative is taken, it brings down the tangent vector \dot{\gamma}^a , and when the volume operator acts on non-intersecting Wilson loops the result vanishes. Quantum states with non-zero volume must therefore involve intersections. Given that the anti-symmetric summation is taken over in the formula for the volume, it needs intersections with at least three non-coplanar lines. At least four-valent vertices are needed for the volume operator to be non-vanishing. Assuming the real representation where the gauge group is \operatorname{SU}(2) , Wilson loops are an over complete basis as there are identities relating different Wilson loops. These occur because Wilson loops are based on matrices (the holonomy) and these matrices satisfy identities. Given any two \operatorname{SU}(2) matrices \mathbb{A} and \mathbb{B} , \operatorname{Tr}(\mathbb{A}) \operatorname{Tr}(\mathbb{B}) = \operatorname{Tr}(\mathbb{A}\mathbb{B}) + \operatorname{Tr}(\mathbb{A}\mathbb{B}^{-1}). This implies that given two loops \gamma and \eta that intersect, W_\gamma [A] W_\eta [A] = W_{\gamma \circ \eta} [A] + W_{\gamma \circ \eta^{-1}} [A] where by \eta^{-1} we mean the loop \eta traversed in the opposite direction and \gamma \circ \eta means the loop obtained by going around the loop \gamma and then along \eta . See figure below. Given that the matrices are unitary one has that W_\gamma [A] = W_{\gamma^{-1}} [A] . Also given the cyclic property of the matrix traces (i.e. \operatorname{Tr} (\mathbb{A} \mathbb{B}) = \operatorname{Tr}(\mathbb{B} \mathbb{A}) ) one has that W_{\gamma \circ \eta} [A] = W_{\eta \circ \gamma} [A] . These identities can be combined with each other into further identities of increasing complexity adding more loops. These identities are the so-called Mandelstam identities. Spin networks certain are linear combinations of intersecting Wilson loops designed to address the over-completeness introduced by the Mandelstam identities (for trivalent intersections they eliminate the over-completeness entirely) and actually constitute a basis for all gauge invariant functions. As mentioned above the holonomy tells one how to propagate test spin half particles. A spin network state assigns an amplitude to a set of spin half particles tracing out a path in space, merging and splitting. These are described by spin networks \gamma : the edges are labelled by spins together with 'intertwiners' at the vertices which are prescription for how to sum over different ways the spins are rerouted. The sum over rerouting are chosen as such to make the form of the intertwiner invariant under Gauss gauge transformations. There are however severe difficulties with this particular approach, for example the Hamiltonian operator is not self-adjoint, in fact it is not even a normal operator (i.e. the operator does not commute with its adjoint) and so the spectral theorem cannot be used to define the exponential in general. The most serious problem is that the \hat{H} (x) 's are not mutually commuting, it can then be shown the formal quantity \int [d N] e^{i \int d^3 x N (x) \hat{H} (x)} cannot even define a (generalized) projector. The master constraint (see below) does not suffer from these problems and as such offers a way of connecting the canonical theory to the path integral formulation. B_{ab}^{IJ} = {1 \over 2} \left(E^I_a E^J_b - E^I_b E^J_a\right) (tetrads are like triads but in four spacetime dimensions), one recovers general relativity. The condition that the B field be given by the product of two tetrads is called the simplicity constraint. The spin foam dynamics of the topological field theory is well understood. Given the spin foam 'interaction' amplitudes for this simple theory, one then tries to implement the simplicity conditions to obtain a path integral for general relativity. The non-trivial task of constructing a spin foam model is then reduced to the question of how this simplicity constraint should be imposed in the quantum theory. The first attempt at this was the famous Barrett–Crane model. However this model was shown to be problematic, for example there did not seem to be enough degrees of freedom to ensure the correct classical limit. It has been argued that the simplicity constraint was imposed too strongly at the quantum level and should only be imposed in the sense of expectation values just as with the Lorenz gauge condition \partial_\mu \hat{A}^\mu in the Gupta–Bleuler formalism of quantum electrodynamics. New models have now been put forward, sometimes motivated by imposing the simplicity conditions in a weaker sense. Another difficulty here is that spin foams are defined on a discretization of spacetime. While this presents no problems for a topological field theory as it has no local degrees of freedom, it presents problems for GR. This is known as the problem triangularization dependence. W (x_1, \dots , x_n) = \langle 0 | \phi (x_n) \dots \phi (x_1) |0 \rangle , completely determine the theory. In particular, one can calculate the scattering amplitudes from these quantities. As explained below in the section on the Background independent scattering amplitudes, in the background-independent context, the n- point functions refer to a state and in gravity that state can naturally encode information about a specific geometry which can then appear in the expressions of these quantities. To leading order, LQG calculations have been shown to agree in an appropriate sense with the n- point functions calculated in the effective low energy quantum general relativity. \{ O , \{ O , M \} \}_{M = 0} = 0, is where O is at least a twice differentiable function on phase space is equivalent to O being a weak Dirac observable with respect to the constraints in question. So the master constraint does capture information about the observables. Because of its significance this is known as the master equation. That the master constraint Poisson algebra is an honest Lie algebra opens the possibility of using a method, known as group averaging, in order to construct solutions of the infinite number of Hamiltonian constraints, a physical inner product thereon and Dirac observables via what is known as refined algebraic quantization, or RAQ. \hat{M} := \int d^3x \widehat{\left( \frac{H}{\sqrt[4]{\det (q(x))}} \right)}^\dagger(x) \widehat{\left(\frac{H}{\sqrt[4]{\det (q(x))}} \right)} (x). Obviously, \widehat{\left( \frac{H}{\sqrt[4]{\det (q(x))}} \right)} (x) \Psi = 0 for all x implies \hat{M} \Psi = 0 . Conversely, if \hat{M} \Psi = 0 then 0 = \left \langle \Psi , \hat{M} \Psi \right \rangle = \int d^3x \left\| \widehat{\left( \frac{H}{\sqrt[4]{\det (q(x))}} \right)} (x) \Psi \right\|^2 \qquad Eq \; 4 implies \widehat{\left( \frac{H}{\sqrt[4]{\det (q(x))}} \right)} (x) \Psi = 0. First compute the matrix elements of the would-be operator \hat{M} , that is, the quadratic form Q_M . Q_M is a graph changing, diffeomorphism invariant quadratic form that cannot exist on the kinematic Hilbert space H_{Kin} , and must be defined on H_{Diff} . Since the master constraint operator \hat{M} is densely defined on H_{Diff} , then \hat{M} is a positive and symmetric operator in H_{Diff} . Therefore, the quadratic form Q_M associated with \hat{M} is closable. The closure of Q_M is the quadratic form of a unique self-adjoint operator \hat{\overline{M}} , called the Friedrichs extension of \hat{M} . We relabel \hat{\overline{M}} as \hat{M} for simplicity. Note that the presence of an inner product, viz Eq 4, means there are no superfluous solutions i.e. there are no \Psi such that \widehat{\left( \frac{H}{\sqrt[4]{\det (q(x))}} \right)} (x) \Psi \not= 0, but for which \hat{M} \Psi = 0 . It is also possible to construct a quadratic form Q_{M_E} for what is called the extended master constraint (discussed below) on H_{Kin} which also involves the weighted integral of the square of the spatial diffeomorphism constraint (this is possible because Q_{M_E} is not graph changing). The spectrum of the master constraint may not contain zero due to normal or factor ordering effects which are finite but similar in nature to the infinite vacuum energies of background-dependent quantum field theories. In this case it turns out to be physically correct to replace \hat{M} with \hat{M}' := \hat{M} - \min (spec (\hat{M})) \hat{1} provided that the "normal ordering constant" vanishes in the classical limit, that is, \lim_{\hbar \to 0} \min (spec(\hat{M})) = 0, so that \hat{M}' is a valid quantisation of M . M_E = \int_\Sigma d^3x {H (x)^2 - q^{ab} V_a (x) V_b (x) \over \sqrt{\det (q)}} . Setting this single constraint to zero is equivalent to H(x) = 0 and V_a (x) = 0 for all x in \Sigma . This constraint implements the spatial diffeomorphism and Hamiltonian constraint at the same time on the Kinematic Hilbert space. The physical inner product is then defined as \langle\phi, \psi\rangle_{\text{Phys}} = \lim_{T \to \infty} \left\langle\phi, \int_{-T}^T dt e^{i t \hat{M}_E} \psi\right\rangle (as \delta (\hat{M_E}) = \lim_{T \to \infty} \int_{-T}^T dt e^{i t \hat{M}_E} ). A spin foam representation of this expression is obtained by splitting the t -parameter in discrete steps and writing e^{i t \hat{M}_E} = \lim_{n \to \infty} \left [e^{i t \hat{M}_E / n} \right]^n = \lim_{n \to \infty} [1 + i t \hat{M}_E / n]^n. The spin foam description then follows from the application of [1 + i t \hat{M}_E / n] on a spin network resulting in a linear combination of new spin networks whose graph and labels have been modified. Obviously an approximation is made by truncating the value of n to some finite integer. An advantage of the extended master constraint is that we are working at the kinematic level and so far it is only here we have access semiclassical coherent states. Moreover, one can find none graph changing versions of this master constraint operator, which are the only type of operators appropriate for these coherent states. S_{\text{BH}} = \frac{k_{\text{B}}A}{4\ell_{\text{P}}^2}, where A is the area of the hole's event horizon, k_{\text{B}} is the Boltzmann constant, and \ell_{\text{P}} = \sqrt{G\hbar/c^{3}} is the Planck length. The fact that the black hole entropy is also the maximal entropy that can be obtained by the Bekenstein bound (wherein the Bekenstein bound becomes an equality) was the main observation that led to the holographic principle. An oversight in the application of the no-hair theorem is the assumption that the relevant degrees of freedom accounting for the entropy of the black hole must be classical in nature; what if they were purely quantum mechanical instead and had non-zero entropy? This is what is realized in the LQG derivation of black hole entropy, and can be seen as a consequence of its background-independence – the classical black hole spacetime comes about from the semiclassical limit of the quantum state of the gravitational field, but there are many quantum states that have the same semiclassical limit. Specifically, in LQG it is possible to associate a quantum geometrical interpretation to the microstates: These are the quantum geometries of the horizon which are consistent with the area, A , of the black hole and the topology of the horizon (i.e. spherical). LQG offers a geometric explanation of the finiteness of the entropy and of the proportionality of the area of the horizon. These calculations have been generalized to rotating black holes. or quantized amount of curvature. These deficit angles add up to 4 \pi . It is possible to derive, from the covariant formulation of full quantum theory (Spinfoam) the correct relation between energy and area (1st law), the Unruh temperature and the distribution that yields Hawking entropy. The calculation makes use of the notion of dynamical horizon and is done for non-extremal black holes. A recent success of the theory in this direction is the computation of the entropy of all non singular black holes directly from theory and independent of Immirzi parameter. The result is the expected formula S=A/4 , where S is the entropy and A the area of the black hole, derived by Bekenstein and Hawking on heuristic grounds. This is the only known derivation of this formula from a fundamental theory, for the case of generic non singular black holes. Older attempts at this calculation had difficulties. The problem was that although Loop quantum gravity predicted that the entropy of a black hole is proportional to the area of the event horizon, the result depended on a crucial free parameter in the theory, the above-mentioned Immirzi parameter. However, there is no known computation of the Immirzi parameter, so it was fixed by demanding agreement with Bekenstein and Hawking's calculation of the black hole entropy.
Hawking radiation in loop quantum gravity
A detailed study of the quantum geometry of a black hole horizon has been made using loop quantum gravity. Loop-quantization does not reproduce the result for black hole entropy originally discovered by Bekenstein and Hawking, unless one chooses the value of the Immirzi parameter to cancel out another constant that arises in the derivation. However, it led to the computation of higher-order corrections to the entropy and radiation of black holes. Based on the fluctuations of the horizon area, a quantum black hole exhibits deviations from the Hawking spectrum that would be observable were X-rays from Hawking radiation of evaporating primordial black holes to be observed. The quantum effects are centered at a set of discrete and unblended frequencies highly pronounced on top of Hawking radiation spectrum.
Citations
Works cited
(available here as of 2 May 2017) Introduction to Loop Quantum Gravity Online lectures by Carlo Rovelli Covariant Loop Quantum Gravity by Carlo Rovelli and Francesca Vidotto "Loop Quantum Gravity" by Carlo Rovelli Physics World, November 2003 Quantum Foam and Loop Quantum Gravity Abhay Ashtekar: Semi-Popular Articles. Some excellent popular articles suitable for beginners about space, time, GR, and LQG Loop Quantum Gravity: Lee Smolin Loop Quantum Gravity Lectures Online by Lee Smolin Spin networks, spin foams and loop quantum gravity Wired magazine, News: "Moving Beyond String Theory" April 2006 Scientific American Special Issue, A Matter of Time, has Lee Smolin LQG Article "Atoms of Space and Time" September 2006, The Economist, article "Looping the loop" Gamma-ray Large Area Space Telescope: The Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope Zeno meets modern science. Article from Acta Physica Polonica B by Z.K. Silagadze. Did pre-big bang universe leave its mark on the sky? – According to a model based on "loop quantum gravity" theory, a parent universe that existed before the present universe may have left an imprint (New Scientist, 10 April 2008)
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378817209 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.