Lorentz ether theory
What is now often called Lorentz ether theory (LET) has its roots in Hendrik Lorentz's "theory of electrons", which marked the end of the development of the classical aether theories at the end of the 19th and at the beginning of the 20th…
≈ 13 min read
Lorentz ether theory. encyclopegia.org, snapshot enwiki-001372924493. /a/lorentz-ether-theory
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
What is now often called Lorentz ether theory (LET) has its roots in Hendrik Lorentz's "theory of electrons", which marked the end of the development of the classical aether theories at the end of the 19th and at the beginning of the 20th century. Lorentz's initial theory was created between 1892 and 1895 and was based on removing assumptions about aether motion.
It explained the failure of the negative aether drift experiments to first order in v/c by introducing an auxiliary variable called "local time" for connecting systems at rest and in motion in the aether. In addition, the negative result of the Michelson–Morley experiment led to the introduction of the hypothesis of length contraction in 1892.
However, other experiments also produced negative results and (guided by Henri Poincaré's principle of relativity) Lorentz tried in 1899 and 1904 to expand his theory to all orders in v/c by introducing the Lorentz transformation. In addition, he assumed that non-electromagnetic forces (if they exist) transform like electric forces.
However, Lorentz's expression for charge density and current were incorrect, so his theory did not fully exclude the possibility of detecting the aether. Eventually, it was Henri Poincaré who in 1905 corrected the errors in Lorentz's paper and actually incorporated non-electromagnetic forces (including gravitation) within the theory, which he called "The New Mechanics".
Many aspects of Lorentz's theory were incorporated into special relativity (SR) with the works of Albert Einstein and Hermann Minkowski. Today LET is often treated as some sort of "Lorentzian" or "neo-Lorentzian" interpretation of special relativity.
The introduction of length contraction and time dilation for all phenomena in a "preferred" frame of reference, which plays the role of Lorentz's immobile aether, leads to the complete Lorentz transformation (see the Robertson–Mansouri–Sexl test theory as an example), so Lorentz covariance doesn't provide any experimentally verifiable distinctions between LET and SR. The absolute simultaneity in the Mansouri–Sexl test theory formulation of LET implies that a one-way speed of light experiment could in principle distinguish between LET and SR, but it is now widely held that it is impossible to perform such a test. In the absence of any way to experimentally distinguish between LET and SR, SR is widely preferred over LET, due to the superfluous assumption of an undetectable aether in LET, and the validity of the relativity principle in LET seeming ad hoc or coincidental.
A possible solution came in sight, when in 1889 Oliver Heaviside derived from Maxwell's equations that the magnetic vector potential field around a moving body is altered by a factor of \sqrt{1- v^2 / c^2} . Based on that result, and to bring the hypothesis of an immobile aether into accordance with the Michelson–Morley experiment, George FitzGerald in 1889 (qualitatively) and, independently of him, Lorentz in 1892 (already quantitatively), suggested that not only the electrostatic fields, but also the molecular forces, are affected in such a way that the dimension of a body in the line of motion is less by the value v^2/(2c^2) than the dimension perpendicularly to the line of motion.
However, an observer co-moving with the earth would not notice this contraction because all other instruments contract at the same ratio. In 1895 Lorentz proposed three possible explanations for this relative contraction: The body contracts in the line of motion and preserves its dimension perpendicularly to it.
The dimension of the body remains the same in the line of motion, but it expands perpendicularly to it. The body contracts in the line of motion and expands at the same time perpendicularly to it. Although the possible connection between electrostatic and intermolecular forces was used by Lorentz as a plausibility argument, the contraction hypothesis was soon considered as purely ad hoc.
It is also important that this contraction would only affect the space between the electrons but not the electrons themselves; therefore the name "intermolecular hypothesis" was sometimes used for this effect. The so-called Length contraction without expansion perpendicularly to the line of motion and by the precise value l=l_0 \cdot \sqrt{1- v^2 / c^2} (where l 0 is the length at rest in the aether) was given by Larmor in 1897 and by Lorentz in 1904.
In the same year, Lorentz also argued that electrons themselves are also affected by this contraction. For further development of this concept, see the section .
An important part of the theorem of corresponding states in 1892 and 1895 was the local time t'=t - vx / c^2 , where t is the time coordinate for an observer resting in the aether, and t ' is the time coordinate for an observer moving in the aether. (Woldemar Voigt had previously used the same expression for local time in 1887 in connection with the Doppler effect and an incompressible medium.)
With the help of this concept Lorentz could explain the aberration of light, the Doppler effect and the Fizeau experiment (i.e. measurements of the Fresnel drag coefficient) by Hippolyte Fizeau in moving and also resting liquids. While for Lorentz length contraction was a real physical effect, he considered the time transformation only as a heuristic working hypothesis and a mathematical stipulation to simplify the calculation from the resting to a "fictitious" moving system.
Contrary to Lorentz, Poincaré saw more than a mathematical trick in the definition of local time, which he called Lorentz's "most ingenious idea". In The Measure of Time he wrote in 1898: In 1900 Poincaré interpreted local time as the result of a synchronization procedure based on light signals.
He assumed that two observers, A and B, who are moving in the aether, synchronize their clocks by optical signals. Since they treat themselves as being at rest, they must consider only the transmission time of the signals and then crossing their observations to examine whether their clocks are synchronous.
However, from the point of view of an observer at rest in the aether the clocks are not synchronous and indicate the local time t'=t - vx / c^2 . But because the moving observers don't know anything about their movement, they don't recognize this.
In 1904, he illustrated the same procedure in the following way: A sends a signal at time 0 to B, which arrives at time t. B also sends a signal at time 0 to A, which arrives at time t. If in both cases t has the same value, the clocks are synchronous, but only in the system in which the clocks are at rest in the aether. So, according to Darrigol, Poincaré understood local time as a physical effect just like length contraction – in contrast to Lorentz, who did not use the same interpretation before 19061.
However, contrary to Einstein, who later used a similar synchronization procedure which was called Einstein synchronisation, Darrigol says that Poincaré had the opinion that clocks resting in the aether are showing the true time. However, at the beginning it was unknown that local time includes what is now known as time dilation.
This effect was first noticed by Larmor (1897), who wrote that "individual electrons describe corresponding parts of their orbits in times shorter for the [aether] system in the ratio \varepsilon^{-1/2} or \left(1-(1/2)v^2/c^2\right) ". And in 1899 also Lorentz noted for the frequency of oscillating electrons "that in S the time of vibrations be k\varepsilon times as great as in S 0 ", where S 0 is the aether frame, S the mathematical-fictitious frame of the moving observer, k is \sqrt{1- v^2 / c^2} , and \varepsilon is an undetermined factor. x^\prime = k\ell\left(x + \varepsilon t\right), \qquad y^\prime = \ell y, \qquad z^\prime = \ell z, \qquad t^\prime = k\ell\left(t + \varepsilon x\right) k = \frac 1 {\sqrt{1-\varepsilon^2}} A substantially extended work (the so-called "Palermo paper") was submitted by Poincaré on 23 July 1905, but was published in January 1906 because the journal appeared only twice a year.
He spoke literally of "the postulate of relativity", he showed that the transformations are a consequence of the principle of least action; he demonstrated in more detail the group characteristics of the transformation, which he called Lorentz group, and he showed that the combination x^2+ y^2+ z^2- c^2t^2 is invariant. While elaborating his gravitational theory, he noticed that the Lorentz transformation is merely a rotation in four-dimensional space about the origin by introducing ct\sqrt{-1} as a fourth, imaginary, coordinate, and he used an early form of four-vectors.
However, Poincaré later said the translation of physics into the language of four-dimensional geometry would entail too much effort for limited profit, and therefore he refused to work out the consequences of this notion. This was later done, however, by Minkowski; see "The shift to relativity".
J. J. Thomson (1881) and others noticed that electromagnetic energy contributes to the mass of charged bodies by the amount m=(4/3)E/c^2 , which was called electromagnetic or "apparent mass". Another derivation of some sort of electromagnetic mass was conducted by Poincaré (1900).
By using the momentum of electromagnetic fields, he concluded that these fields contribute a mass of E_{em}/c^2 to all bodies, which is necessary to save the center of mass theorem. As noted by Thomson and others, this mass increases also with velocity.
Thus in 1899, Lorentz calculated that the ratio of the electron's mass in the moving frame and that of the aether frame is k^3 \varepsilon parallel to the direction of motion, and k\varepsilon perpendicular to the direction of motion, where k = \sqrt{1- v^2 / c^2} and \varepsilon is an undetermined factor. And in 1904, he set \varepsilon=1 , arriving at the expressions for the masses in different directions (longitudinal and transverse): m_L=\frac{m_0}{\left(\sqrt{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}\right)^3},\quad m_T=\frac{m_0}{\sqrt{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}}, where m_0=\frac{4}{3}\frac{E_{em}}{c^2} Many scientists now believed that the entire mass and all forms of forces were electromagnetic in nature.
This idea had to be given up, however, in the course of the development of relativistic mechanics. Abraham (1904) argued (as described in the preceding section #Lorentz transformation), that non-electrical binding forces were necessary within Lorentz's electrons model.
But Abraham also noted that different results occurred, dependent on whether the em-mass is calculated from the energy or from the momentum. To solve those problems, Poincaré in 1905 and 1906 introduced some sort of pressure of non-electrical nature, which contributes the amount -(1/3)E/c^2 to the energy of the bodies, and therefore explains the 4/3-factor in the expression for the electromagnetic mass-energy relation.
However, while Poincaré's expression for the energy of the electrons was correct, he erroneously stated that only the em-energy contributes to the mass of the bodies. The concept of electromagnetic mass is not considered anymore as the cause of mass per se, because the entire mass (not only the electromagnetic part) is proportional to energy, and can be converted into different forms of energy, which is explained by Einstein's mass–energy equivalence.
It was derived by Einstein (1905) as a consequence of the relativity principle, that inertia of energy is actually represented by E/c^2 , but in contrast to Poincaré's 1900-paper, Einstein recognized that matter itself loses or gains mass during the emission or absorption. So the mass of any form of matter is equal to a certain amount of energy, which can be converted into and re-converted from other forms of energy.
This is the mass–energy equivalence, represented by E=mc^2 . So Einstein didn't have to introduce "fictitious" masses and also avoided the perpetual motion problem, because according to Darrigol, Poincaré's radiation paradox can simply be solved by applying Einstein's equivalence.
If the light source loses mass during the emission by E/c^2 , the contradiction in the momentum law vanishes without the need of any compensating effect in the aether. Similar to Poincaré, Einstein concluded in 1906 that the inertia of (electromagnetic) energy is a necessary condition for the center of mass theorem to hold in systems, in which electromagnetic fields and matter are acting on each other.
Based on the mass–energy equivalence, he showed that emission and absorption of em-radiation, and therefore the transport of inertia, solves all problems. On that occasion, Einstein referred to Poincaré's 1900-paper and wrote: Also Poincaré's rejection of the reaction principle due to the violation of the mass conservation law can be avoided through Einstein's E=mc^2 , because mass conservation appears as a special case of the energy conservation law.
References
For a more complete list with sources of many other authors, see History of special relativity#References.
Works of Lorentz, Poincaré, Einstein, Minkowski (group A)
Preface partly reprinted in "Science and Hypothesis", Ch. 12. . Reprinted in Poincaré, Oeuvres, tome IX, pp. 395–413 . Reprinted in "Science and Hypothesis", Ch. 9–10. .
See also the English translation. . Reprinted in "Science and Hypothesis", Ch. 6–7. Reprinted in Poincaré 1913, Ch. 6. .
See also: English translation. . English Translation:
Secondary sources (group B)
In English:
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1372924493 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “Lorentz ether theory” publication date (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL