Lesson plan
Maconochie
Maconochie was a brand of canned stew containing sliced turnips, carrots, potatoes, onions, haricot beans, and beef in a thin broth, named after the Aberdeen-based Maconochie Company that produced it. The stew gained recognition as a widely-issued military ration for British soldiers during the Boer War and World War I. Although the stew was said to be tolerable, most soldiers detested it. As one British soldier put it, "warmed in the tin, Maconochie was edible; cold, it was a man-killer." Others complained that the potatoes appeared to be unidentifiable black lumps. The congelation of fat above indistinguishable chunks of meat and vegetables led one reporter to describe it as "an inferior grade of garbage". A soldier named Calcutt claimed "the Maconochie's stew ration gave the troops flatulence of a particularly offensive nature." Some product versions that contained turnips were said to possess an unpleasant smell when combined with beans. Barbara Buchan from the Fraserburgh Heritage Centre confirmed that their records contain only a single positive response to the product. An alternative view is voiced by Lance-Corporal Henry Buckle in his diary of April 1915: "Had a glorious meal today, got a Machonachie [sic] ration from some engineers in the wood, a round tin containing meat, spuds carrots, beans and gravy, enough for two in a tin.…
Article summary
Maconochie was a brand of canned stew containing sliced turnips, carrots, potatoes, onions, haricot beans, and beef in a thin broth, named after the Aberdeen-based Maconochie Company that produced it. The stew gained recognition as a widely-issued military ration for British soldiers during the Boer War and World War I. Although the stew was said to be tolerable, most soldiers detested it. As one British soldier put it, "warmed in the tin, Maconochie was edible; cold, it was a man-killer." Others complained that the potatoes appeared to be unidentifiable black lumps. The congelation of fat above indistinguishable chunks of meat and vegetables led one reporter to describe it as "an inferior grade of garbage". A soldier named Calcutt claimed "the Maconochie's stew ration gave the troops flatulence of a particularly offensive nature." Some product versions that contained turnips were said to possess an unpleasant smell when combined with beans. Barbara Buchan from the Fraserburgh Heritage Centre confirmed that their records contain only a single positive response to the product. An alternative view is voiced by Lance-Corporal Henry Buckle in his diary of April 1915: "Had a glorious meal today, got a Machonachie [sic] ration from some engineers in the wood, a round tin containing meat, spuds carrots, beans and gravy, enough for two in a tin.…
Key claims
No claims recorded.
Discussion questions
- Summarise the article in your own words. Which single claim would you verify first, and why?
- Which claim in this article is most likely to be revised as the sources update? How would you check its current status?
- If two sources disagreed about one of these facts, what would you need in order to trust one over the other?
Bibliography
No sources recorded.
Key claims and bibliography are generated from the same tracked claims and sources as the article page.