Magnetic sail
A magnetic sail is a proposed method of spacecraft propulsion where an onboard magnetic field source interacts with a plasma wind (e.g., the solar wind) to form an artificial magnetosphere (similar to Earth's magnetosphere) that acts as a…
≈ 60 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
A magnetic sail is a proposed method of spacecraft propulsion where an onboard magnetic field source interacts with a plasma wind (e.g., the solar wind) to form an artificial magnetosphere (similar to Earth's magnetosphere) that acts as a sail, transferring force from the wind to the spacecraft requiring little to no propellant as detailed for each proposed magnetic sail design in this article. The animation and the following text summarize the magnetic sail physical principles involved.
The spacecraft's magnetic field source, represented by the purple dot, generates a magnetic field, shown as expanding black circles. Under conditions summarized in the overview section, this field creates a magnetosphere whose leading edge is a magnetopause and a bow shock composed of charged particles captured from the wind by the magnetic field, as shown in blue, which deflects subsequent charged particles from the plasma wind coming from the left.
Specific attributes of the artificial magnetosphere around the spacecraft for a specific design significantly affect performance as summarized in the overview section.…
A magnetic sail is a proposed method of spacecraft propulsion where an onboard magnetic field source interacts with a plasma wind (e.g., the solar wind) to form an artificial magnetosphere (similar to Earth's magnetosphere) that acts as a sail, transferring force from the wind to the spacecraft requiring little to no propellant as detailed for each proposed magnetic sail design in this article. The animation and the following text summarize the magnetic sail physical principles involved.
The spacecraft's magnetic field source, represented by the purple dot, generates a magnetic field, shown as expanding black circles. Under conditions summarized in the overview section, this field creates a magnetosphere whose leading edge is a magnetopause and a bow shock composed of charged particles captured from the wind by the magnetic field, as shown in blue, which deflects subsequent charged particles from the plasma wind coming from the left.
Specific attributes of the artificial magnetosphere around the spacecraft for a specific design significantly affect performance as summarized in the overview section. A magnetohydrodynamic model (verified by computer simulations and laboratory experiments) predicts that the interaction of the artificial magnetosphere with the oncoming plasma wind creates an effective sail blocking area that transfers force as shown by a sequence of labeled arrows from the plasma wind, to the spacecraft's magnetic field, to the spacecraft's field source, which accelerates the spacecraft in the same direction as the plasma wind.
These concepts apply to all proposed magnetic sail system designs, with the difference how the design generates the magnetic field and how efficiently the field source creates the artificial magnetosphere described above. The History of concept section summarizes key aspects of the proposed designs and relationships between them as background.
The cited references are technical with many equations and in order to make the information more accessible, this article first describes in text (and illustrations where available) beginning in the overview section and prior to each design, section or groups of equations and plots intended for the technically oriented reader. The beginning of each proposed design section also contains a summary of the important aspects so that a reader can skip the equations for that design.
The differences in the designs determine performance measures, such as the mass of the field source and necessary power, which in turn determine force, mass and hence acceleration and velocity that enable a performance comparison between magnetic sail designs at the end of this article. A comparison with other spacecraft propulsion methods includes some magnetic sail designs where the reader can click on the column headers to compare magnetic sail performance with other propulsion methods.
The following observations result from this comparison: magnetic sail designs have insufficient thrust to launch from Earth, thrust (drag) for deceleration for the magsail in the interstellar medium is relatively large, and both the magsail and magnetoplasma sail have significant thrust for travel away from Earth using the force from the solar wind. A condition for applicability of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) theory, which models charged particles as fluid flows, is that to achieve maximum force the radius of the artificial magnetosphere be on the same order as the ion gyroradius for the plasma environment for a particular mode of operation.
Another important condition is how the proposed design affects the magnetic field falloff rate inside the magnetosphere, which impacts the field source mass and power requirements. For a radial distance r from the spacecraft's magnetic field source in a vacuum the magnetic field falls off as 1/r^{f_o} , where f_o is the falloff rate.
Classic magnetic dipole theory covers the case of f_o =3 as used in the magsail design. When plasma is injected and/or captured near the field source, the magnetic field falls off at a rate of 1 \leq f_o \leq 2 , a topic that has been a subject of much research, criticism and differs between designs and has changed over time for the plasma magnet.
The M2P2 and plasma magnet designs initially assumed f_o =1 that as shown in numerical examples summarized at the end of the corresponding design sections predicted a very large performance gain. Several researchers independently created a magnetic field model where 1 \leq f_o \leq 3 and asserted that an f_o =2 falloff rate was the best achievable.
In 2011 the plasma magnet author changed the falloff rate f_o from 1 to 2 and that is the value used for the plasma magnet for performance comparison in this article. The magnetoplasma sail (MPS) design is an evolution of the M2P2 concept that has been extensively documented, numerically analyzed and simulated and reported a falloff rate f_o between 1.5 and 2.
The falloff rate f_o has a significant impact on performance or the mode of operation accelerating away from the Sun where the mass density of ions in the plasma decreases according to an Inverse-square law with distance from the Sun (e.g., AU) increases. The illustration shows in a semi-log plot the impact of falloff rate f_o on relative force F from Equation versus distance from the Sun ranging from 1 to 20 AU, the approximate distance of Neptune.
The distance to Jupiter is approximately 5 AU. Constant force independent of distance from the Sun for f_o =1 is stated in several plasma magnet references, for example Slough and Freeze and results from the effective increase in sail blocking area to exactly offset reduced plasma mass density as a magnetic sail spacecraft accelerates in response to the plasma wind force away from the Sun. As seen from the illustration the impact of falloff rate f_o on force, and therefore acceleration, becomes grerater as distance from the Sun increases.
At scales where the artificial magnetospheric object radius is much less than the ion gyroradius but greater than the electron gyroradius, the realized force is markedly reduced and electrons create force in proportion much greater than their relative mass with respect to ions as detailed in the General kinematic model section where researchers report results from a compute intensive method that simulates individual particle interactions with the magnetic field source. The velocity distribution of ions and electrons is another important parameter but often analyses use only the average velocity for the aggregate of particles in a plasma wind for a particular plasma environment (pe) is v_{pe} .
The apparent wind velocity u_{sc} as seen by a spacecraft traveling at velocity v_{sc} (positive meaning acceleration in the same direction as the wind and negative meaning deceleration opposite the wind direction) for a particular plasma environment (pe) is u_{sc}=v_{pe}-v_{sc} . An ion or electron with charge in a plasma moving at velocity in a magnetic field and electric field is treated as an idealized point charge in the Lorentz force \mathbf{F} = q\,\mathbf{E} + q\,\mathbf{v} \times \mathbf{B} .
This means that the force on an ion or electron is proportional to the product of their charge and velocity component v perpendicular to the magnetic field flux density , in SI units as teslas (T). A magnetic sail design introduces a magnetic field into a plasma flow which under certain conditions deflects the electrons and ions from their original trajectory with the particle's momentum transferred to the sail and hence the spacecraft thereby creating thrust. An electric sail uses an electric field that under certain conditions interact with charged particles to create thrust.
A plasma environment has fundamental parameters, and if a cited reference uses cgs units these should be converted to SI units as defined in the NRL plasma formulary, which this article uses as a reference for plasma parameter units not defined in SI units. The major parameters for plasma mass density are: the number of ions of type i per unit volume n_i the mass of each ion type accounting for isotopes m_i and the number of electrons n_e per unit volume each with electron mass m_e . An average plasma mass density per unit volume for charged particles in a plasma environment pe ( sw for stellar wind, pi for planetary ionosphere, im for interstellar medium) is expressed in equation form from magnetohydrodynamics as \textstyle \rho_{pe} = n_e m_e + \sum_{i}n_i m_i . Note that this definition includes the mass of neutrons in an ion's nucleus.
In SI Units per unit volume is cubic metre (m −3 ), mass is kilogram (kg), and mass density is kilogram per cubic metre (kg/m 3 ). The figure depicts the MHD model as described in Funaki and Djojodihardjo.
Starting from the left a plasma wind in a plasma environment (e.g., stellar, ISM or an ionosphere) of effective velocity v_{pe} with density \rho_{pe} encounters a spacecraft with time-varying velocity v_{sc} that is positive if accelerating and negative if decelerating. The apparent plasma wind velocity from the spacecraft's viewpoint is u_{pe}=v_{pe}-v_{sc} .
The spacecraft and field source generate a magnetic field that creates a magnetospheric bubble extending out to a magnetopause preceded by a bow shock that deflects electrons and ions from the plasma wind. At the magnetopause the field source magnetic pressure equals the kinetic pressure of the plasma wind at a standoff shown at the bottom of the figure.
The characteristic length L is that of a circular sail of effective blocking area S=\pi \, R_{mp}^2 where R_{mp} \approx L is the effective magnetopause radius. Under certain conditions the plasma wind pushing on the artificial magnetosphere bow shock and magnetopause creates a force F_w on the magnetic field source that is physically attached to the spacecraft so that at least part of the force F_w causes a force F_{sc} on the spacecraft, accelerating it when sailing downwind or decelerating when sailing into a headwind.
Under certain conditions and in some designs, some of the plasma wind force may be lost as indicated by F_{loss} on the right side. All magnetic sail designs assume a standoff between plasma wind pressure p_w and magnetic pressure p_B with SI units of Pascal (Pa, or N/m 2 ) differing only in a constant coefficient C_{SO} as follows: {{NumBlk2|:| p_w=\rho u^2 =p_B=\frac{B_{mp}^2}{C_{SO} \mu _0} |MHD.1}}where u is the apparent wind velocity and \rho is the plasma mass density for a specific plasma environment, B_{mp} the magnetic field flux density at magnetopause, μ 0 is the vacuum permeability (N A −2 ) and C_{SO} is a constant that differs by reference as follows for C_{SO}=2 corresponding to p_w modeled as dynamic pressure with no magnetic field compression, C_{SO}=1 for p_w modeled as ram pressure with no magnetic field compression and C_{SO}=1/2 for p_w modeled as ram pressure with magnetic field compression by a factor of 2 Equation can be solved to yield the required magnetic field B_{mp} that satisfies the pressure balance at magnetopause standoff as: {{NumBlk2|:| B_{mp}=u \sqrt{\rho \, \mu_0 \, C_{SO} } |MHD.2}}The force with SI Units of Newtons (N) derived by a magnetic sail for a plasma environment is determined from MHD equations as reported by principal researchers Funaki, Slough, Andrews and Zubrin, and Toivanen as follows: where C_d is a coefficient of drag determined by numerical analysis and/or simulation, \rho u^2/2 is the wind pressure, and S=\pi R_{mp}^2 is the effective blocking area of the magnetic sail with magnetopause radius R_{mp} \approx L . Note that this equation has the same form as the drag equation in fluid dynamics.
C_d is a function of coil attack angle on thrust and steering angle. The power (W) of the plasma wind is the product of velocity and a constant force{{NumBlk2|:| P_w= u \, F_w = C_d\ \rho \frac{u^3}{2} \pi R_{mp}^2 = \frac {C_d u \pi}{2 \mu_0 C_{SO} } R_{mp}^2 B_{mp}^2 |MHD.4}} where equation was used to derive the right side.
As summarized in the overview section, an important condition for a magnetic sail to generate maximum force is that the magnetopause radius be on the order of an ion's radius of gyration. Through analysis, numerical calculation, simulation and experimentation an important condition for a magnetic sail to generate significant force is the MHD applicability test, which states that the standoff distance L must be significantly greater than the ion gyroradius, also called the Larmor radius or cyclotron radius: {{NumBlk2|:| r_g=\frac {m_i v_\perp}{\mid q \mid B_x C_{Li} } |MHD.5}} where m_i is the ion mass, v_\perp is the velocity of a particle perpendicular to the magnetic field, |q| is the elementary charge of the ion, B_x is the magnetic field flux density at the point of reference x and C_{Li} is a constant that differs by source with C_{Li}=1 and C_{Li}=2 .
For example, in the solar wind with 5 ions/cm 3 at 1 AU with m_i the proton mass (kg), v_\perp = v_{sw} = 400 km/s, B_x=B_{mp} = 36 nT with C_{SO} =0.5 from equation at magnetopause and C_{Li} =2 then r_g \approx 72 km. The MHD applicability test is the ratio r_g/L . The figure plots C_d on the left vertical axis and lost thrust on the right vertical axis versus the ratio r_g/L . When r_g/L , C_d=3.6 is maximum, at r_g/L\approx 1 , C_d=2.7 , a decrease of 25% from the maximum and at r_g/L\approx 2 , C_d\approx 1.5 , a 45% decrease.
As r_g/L increases beyond one, C_d decreases meaning less thrust from the plasma wind transfers to the spacecraft and is instead lost to the plasma wind. In 2004, Fujita published numerical analysis using a hybrid PIC simulation using a magnetic dipole model that treated electrons as a fluid and a kinematic model for ions to estimate the coefficient of drag C_d for a magnetic sail operating in the radial orientation resulting in the following approximate formula: The lost thrust is T_{loss}=(1-C_d(r_g/L))/3.6 .
For a coil with radial orientation (like a Frisbee) the attack angle \alpha _t = 0° and with axial orientation (like a parachute) \alpha _t =90°. The Nishida 2005 results reported a coefficient of drag C_d that increased non-linearly with attack angle from a minimum of 3.6 at \alpha _t =0 to a maximum of 5 at \alpha _t =90°.
The steering angle of the thrust vector is substantially less than the attack angle deviation from 45° due to the interaction of the magnetic field with the solar wind. Torque increases from \alpha _t = 0° from zero at to a maximum at \alpha _t =45° and then decreases to zero at \alpha _t =90°. A number of magnetic sail design and other papers cite these results.
In 2012 Kajimura reported simulation results that covered two cases where MHD applicability occurs with r_g/L =1.125 and where a kinematic model is applicable r_g/L =0.125 to compute a coefficient of drag C_d and steering angle. As shown in Figure 4 of that paper when MHD applicability occurs the results are similar in form to Nishida 2005 where the largest C_d occurs with the coil in an axial orientation.
However, when the kinematic model applies, the largest C_d occurs with the coil in a radial orientation. The steering angle is positive when MHD is applicable and negative when a kinematic model applies.
The 2012 Nishida and Funaki published simulation results for a coefficient of drag C_D , coefficient of lift C_L and a coefficient of moment C_M for a coil radius of R_c =100 km and magnetopause radius R_{mp} =500 km at 1 AU. In a design, either the magnetic field source strength or the magnetopause radius R_{mp}\approx L the characteristic length must be chosen.
A good approximation from Cattell and Toivanen for a magnetic field falloff rate f_o, 1\leq f_o \leq3 for a distance R_0 \leq r \leq R_{mp} from the field source to magnetopause starts with the equation: where B(R_0) is the magnetic field at a radius R_0 near the field source that falls off near the source as 1/r^3 as follows: where C_0 is a constant multiplying the magnetic moment (A m 2 ) \mathbf m to make B(r) match a target value at r>>R_0 . When far from the field source, a magnetic dipole is a good approximation and choosing the above value of B(R_0) with C_0 =2 near the field source was used by Andrews and Zubrin.
The Amperian loop model for the magnetic moment is \mathbf m = I_c S , where I_c is the current in amperes (A) and S= \pi \, R_c^2 is the surface area for a coil (loop) of radius R_c . Assuming that R_0 \approx R_c and substituting the expression for the magnetic moment \mathbf m into equation yields the following: When the magnetic field flux density B(R_0) is specified, substituting B_{mp} from the pressure balance analysis from equation into the above and solving for R_{mp} yields the following:{{NumBlk2|:| L \approx R_{mp} \approx R_0 \biggl(\frac {B(R_0)}{B_{mp} } \biggr)^{1/f_o} |MFM.4}} This is the expression for L when f_o=3 with C_{SO}=1/2 and C_{SO}=2 and is the same form as the magnetopause distance of the Earth. Equation shows directly how a decreased falloff rate f_o dramatically increases the effective sail area S=\pi R_{mp}^2 for a given field source magnetic moment \mathbf m and B_{mp} determined from the pressure balance equation .
Substituting this into equation yields the plasma wind force as a function of falloff rate f_o , plasma density \rho , coil radius R_c \approx R_0 , coil current I_c and plasma wind velocity u as follows:{{NumBlk2|:| F_w(f_o)=\frac {C_d}{2} \rho u^2 \, \pi \, R_0^2 \, \biggl(\frac {B(R_0)}{B_{mp} } \biggr)^{2/f_o} = \frac {C_d}{2} \rho u^2 \, \pi \, R_0^2 \, \biggl(\frac {\sqrt{\mu_0} I_c C_0}{4 R_0 \, u \sqrt{\rho \,C_{SO} } } \biggr)^{2/f_o} |MFM.5}} using equation for B(R_0) and equation for B_{mp} . This is the same expression as equation (10b) when f_o=3 and C_{SO}=1/2 and the right hand side from equation (20) specifically applied to M2P2 with other numerical coefficients grouped into the C_d term.
Note that force increases as falloff rate decreases. For the solar wind case, substituting into and using the function for the solar wind plasma mass density \rho_{sw}(a_\odot)=\rho_{sw}(1)/a_\odot ^2 , with a_\odot the distance from the sun in Astronomical units (AU) results in the following expression: where C_{f_o}= \frac {C_d}{2} \biggl(\frac {B(R_0)^2}{\mu_0 C_{SO}}\biggr)^{1/f_o} , \mathsf{and} \, S = \pi \, R_{mp}^2 , the effective sail blocking area.
This equation explicitly shows the relationship upon solar wind plasma mass density \rho_{sw}(a_\odot) as a function of distance from the Sun a_\odot . For the case f_o =1 the expansion of the magnetopause radius R_{mp} exactly matches the decreasing value of \rho_{sw}(a_\odot) exactly as the distance from the Sun a_\odot increases, resulting in constant force and hence constant acceleration inside the heliosphere.
Note that C_{f_o} includes the term B(R_0)^{2/f_o} , which means that as f_o increases that the magnetic field near the field source B(R_0) must increase to maintain the same force as compared with a smaller value of f_o . The example in the overview section set C_{f_o} =1, u =1, R_0 =1, and S =1 so that the force at a_\odot =1 was equal to 1 for all values of f_o at 1 AU. When the MHD applicability test of r_g/L A_e S=\pi L^2 .
The left axis of the figure is for plots of magnetic sail force versus characteristic length L . The solid black line plots the MHD model force F_{MHD} from equation . The green line shows the value of ion gyroradius r_g \approx 72 km at 1 AU from equation . The dashed blue line plots the hybrid MHD/kinematic model from equation from Fujita04.
The red dashed line plots a curve fit to simulation results from Ashida14. Although a good fit for these parameters, the curve fit range of this model does not cover some relevant examples. Additional simulation results from Hajiwara15 are shown for the MHD and kinematic model as single data points as indicated in the legend.
These models are all in close agreement. The kinematic models predict less force than predicted by the MHD model. In other words, the fraction T_{loss} of thrust force predicted by the MHD model is lost when r_g/L as plotted on the right axis.
The solid blue and red lines show T_{loss} for Fujita04 and Ashida18 respectively, indicating that operation with L less than 10% of r_g will have significant loss. Other factors in a specific magnetic sail design may offset this loss for values of L . Important measures that determine the relative performance of different magnetic sail systems include: mass of the field source generator and its power and energy requirements; thrust achieved; thrust to weight ratio, any limitations and constraints, and propellant system exhausted, if any.
Mass of the field source M_{fs} in the Magsail design was relatively large and subsequent designs strove to reduce this measure. Total spacecraft mass is M_{sc}=M_{fs}+M_p , where M_p is the payload mass. Power requirements are significant in some designs and add to field source mass.
Thrust is the plasma wind force F_w for a particular plasma environment with acceleration a=F_w/M_{sc} . The thrust to weight ratio F_w/M_{sc} is also an important performance measure. Other limitations and constraints may be specific to a particular design.
The M2P2 and MPS designs, as well as potentially the plasma magnet design, exhaust some plasma as part of inflating the magnetospheric bubble and these cases also have a specific impulse and effective exhaust velocity performance measure. Analysis of magsail performance was done using a simulation and a fluid (i.e., MHD) model with similar results observed for one case.
The magnetic moment of a current loop (A m 2 ) is \mathbf m= I_c \pi R_c^2 for a current of I_c A and a loop of radius R_c m. Close to the loop, the magnetic field at a distance z along the center-line axis perpendicular to the loop is derived from the Biot-Savart law as follows. {{NumBlk2|:| B_{cl} (z)=\frac {\mu_0 I_c R_c^2}{2(z^2 +R_c^2)^{3/2} } |MS.1}} At a distance far from the loop center the magnetic field is approximately that produced by a magnetic dipole. The pressure at the magnetospheric boundary is doubled due to compression of the magnetic field and stated by the following equation at a point along the center-line axis or the target magnetopause standoff distance L_Z . {{NumBlk2|:| p_{mb}=\frac {B_{cl}(0)^2}{2 \mu_0} \Biggl(\frac {R_c}{L_Z}\Biggr)^6 |MS.2}} Equating this to the dynamic pressure for a plasma environment p_{mb}=\rho \, u_{pe}^2 /2 , inserting B_{cl}(0) from equation and solving for L_Z yields {{Numbered block 2|:| L_Z=1.26 \, C_Z, where \, \, C_Z = R_c \Biggl( \frac {B_{cl}(0)}{u_{pe} \sqrt{\rho \mu_0} } \Biggr)^{1/3} |MS.3}} Andrews and Zubrin derived the drag (thrust) force of the sail F_D that determined the characteristic length L_Z for a tilt angle, but according to Freeland an error was made in numerical integration in choosing the ellipse downstream from the magnetopause instead of the ellipse upstream that made those results optimistic by a factor of approximately 3.1, which should be used to correct any drag(thrust) force results using Instead, this article uses the approximation for a spherical bubble that corrects this error and is close to the analytical formula for the axial configuration as the force for the Magsail as follows{{NumBlk2|:| F_{MS} = 1.214 \, \, \frac{\rho u_{pe}^2}{2} \pi \, L_Z^2 |MS.4}} In 2004 Toivanen and Janhunen did further analysis on the Magsail that they called a Plasma Free MagnetoPause (PFMP) that produced similar results to that of Andrews and Zubrin. where J_e is the superconductor critical current density (A/m 2 ) and \delta_c is the coil material density, for example J_e = 1×10 11 A/m 2 and \delta_c = 6,500 kg/m 3 for a superconductor in Freeland The physical mass of the coil is where r_c is the radius of the superconductor wire, for example that necessary to handle the tension for a particular use case, such as deceleration in the ISM where r_c = 10 mm.
The N_{tether} factor (e.g., 3) accounts for mass of the tether (or shroud) lines to connect the coil to a spacecraft. Note that _{phy} M_c with N_{tether} =0 must be no less than _{min}M_c in order for the coil to carry the superconductor critical current I_{cc}=J_e \pi r_c^2 amperes for a coil wire of radius r_c , for example I_{cc} = 7,854 kiloampere (kA.)
Setting equation with N_{tether} =0 equal to equation and solving for r_c yields the minimum required coil radius If operated within the solar system, high temperature superconducting wire (HTS) is necessary to make the magsail practical since required current is large, millions of amperes. Protection from solar heating is necessary closer to the Sun, for example by highly reflective coatings.
If operated in interstellar space low temperature superconductors (LTS) could be adequate since the temperature of a vacuum is 2.7 Kelvins (K), but radiation and other heat sources from the spacecraft may render LTS impractical. The critical current I_{cc} of the HTS YBCO coated superconductor wire increases at lower temperatures with a current density J_e of 6×10 10 A/m 2 at 77 K and 9×10 11 A/m 2 at 5 K. where F_{MKM} N is force predicted by this model, n_p m −3 is the proton number density, m_p kg is the proton mass, \rho = m_p n_p kg/m 3 the plasma density, and A_G(v) m 2 the effective reflection area.
This equation assumes that the spacecraft encounters A_G(v) n_p v particles per second and that every particle of mass m_p is completed reflected. Note that this equation is of the same form as with C_d =4, interpreting the C_d term as just a number.
Gros numerically determined the effective reflection area A_G(v) by integrating the degree of reflection of approaching protons interacting with the superconducting loop magnetic field according to the Biot-Savart law. The reported result was independent of the loop radius R_c . An accurate curve fit as reported in Figure 4 to the numerical evaluation for the effective reflection area for a magnetic sail in the axial configuration from equation (8) was where \pi R_c^2 is the area enclosed by the current carrying loop, c the speed of light, and the value I_G=1.55\cdot10^{6} A determined a good curve fit for I =10 5 A, the current through the loop.
In 20201, Perakis published an analysis that corroborated the above formula with parameters selected for the solar wind and reported a force no more than 9% less than the Gros model for I =10 5 A and R_c =100 m with the coil in an axial orientation.. That analysis also reported on the effect of magsail tilt angle on lift and side forces for a use case in maneuvering within the solar system.
For comparison purposes, the effective sail area determined for the magsail by Zubrin from equation with the 3.1 correction factor from Freeland applied and using the same velocity value (resolving the discrepancy noted by Gros) as follows: The figure shows the normalized effective sail area normalized by the coil area \pi R_c^2 for the MKM case from Gros of equation and for Zubrin from equation for I \approx I_G , R_c =100 km, and n_p =0.1 cm −3 for the G-cloud on approach to Alpha Centauri corresponding to ISM density \rho_{im}=1.67\times10^{-22} kg/m 3 consistent with that from Freeland plotted versus the spacecraft velocity relative to the speed of light \beta =v/c . A good fit occurs for these parameters, but for different values of R_c and I the fit can vary significantly. Also plotted is the MHD applicability test of ion gyroradius divided by magnetopause radius r_g/R_{mp} v/c C_d as a function of r_g/R_{mp} from the MHD applicability test section is also plotted.
Note that the Gros model predicts a more rapid decrease in effective area than this model at higher velocities. The normalized values of A_G(v) and A_Z(v) track closely until \beta = v/c \approx 10% after which point the Zubrin magsail model of Equation becomes increasingly optimistic and equation is applicable instead.
Since the models track closely up to \beta \approx 10%, with the kinematic model underestimating effective sail area for smaller values of \beta (hence underestimating force), equation is an approximation for both the MHD and kinematic region. The Gros model is pessimistic for \beta A_G(v) from equation for explicit solution for the required distance x_f m to decelerate to final velocity v_f \approx 0.013 c m/s from given an initial velocity v_0 m/s for a spacecraft mass m_{tot} kg as follows: {{NumBlk2|:| x_{f}= \frac {m_{tot} \, [g(v_0)-g(v_f)] }{0,081 \, m_p \, n_p \pi \, R_c^2} |MKM.4}} where g(v)=ln^{-2}(\frac {v \, I_G}{c \, I}) .
When v_f =0 the above equation is defined in as x_{max} , which enabled a closed form solution of the velocity at a distance x, v(x) in with numerical integration required to compute the time required to decelerate. Equation (16) The optimal current that minimized x_{max} as I_{opt}=e \beta_0 I_G where \beta_0=v_0/c . In 2017 Crowl optimized coil current for the ratio of effective area A(v) over total mass m_{tot} and derived the result I_{opt}=e^3 \, \beta_0 I_G . That paper used results from Gros for the stopping distance x_{max} and time to decelerate.
The figure plots the distance traveled while decelerating x_d and time required to decelerate t_d given a starting relative velocity \beta_0 = v_0/c and a final velocity v_f=0.013 c m/s consistent with that from Freeland for the same parameters above. Equation gives the magsail mass M_s as 97 tonnes assuming payload mass M_p of 100 tonnes using the same values used by Freeland of J_e = 10 11 A/m 2 and \delta_c =6,500 kg/m 3 for the superconducting coil.
Equation gives Force for the magsail multiplied by C_d =4 for the Andrews/Zubrin model to align with equation definition of force from the Gros model. Acceleration is force divided by mass, velocity is the integral of acceleration over the deceleration time interval t_d and deceleration distance traveled x_d is the integral of the velocity over t_d . Numerical integration resulted in the lines plotted in the figure with deceleration distance traveled plotted on the primary vertical axis on the left and time required to decelerate on the secondary vertical axis on the right.
Note that the MHD Zubrin model and the Gros kinematic model predict nearly identical values of deceleration distance up to \beta_0 ~ 5% of c, with the Zubrin model predicting less deceleration distance and shorter deceleration time at greater values of \beta_0 . This is consistent with the Gros model predicting a smaller effective area A(v) at larger values of \beta_0 .
The value of the closed form solution for deceleration distance x_f from for the same parameters closely tracks the numerical integration result. Dana Andrews and Robert Zubrin first proposed the magnetic sail concept in 1988 for interstellar travel for acceleration by a fusion rocket, coasting and then deceleration via a magsail at the destination that could reduce flight times by 40–50 years In 1989 details for interplanetary travel were reported In 1990 Andrews and Zubrin reported on an example for solar wind parameters one AU away from the Sun, with n_i = 5 \times 10^{6} m −3 with only protons as ions, apparent wind velocity u_{sw} =500 km/s the field strength required to resist the dynamic pressure of the solar wind is 50 nT from equation .
With radius R_c =100 km and magnetospheric bubble of L = reported a thrust of 1980 newtons and a coil mass of 500 tonnes. For the above parameters with the correction factor of 3.1 applied to equation yields the same thrust and equation yields the same coil mass. Results for another 4 solar wind cases were reported, but the MHD applicability test of equation fails in these cases.
In 2015, Freeland documented a use case with acceleration away from Earth by a fusion drive with a magsail used for interstellar deceleration on approach to Alpha Centaturi as part of a study to update Project Icarus with R_c =260 km, an initial R_{mp} of 1,320 km and ISM density \rho_{im}=1.67\times10^{-22} kg/m 3 , almost identical to the n(H I) measurement of 0.098 cm −3 by Gry in 2014. The Freeland study predicted deceleration from 5% of light speed in approximately 19 years.
The coil parameters J_e =10 11 A/m 2 , r_{sc} = 5 mm, \rho_{sc} =6,500 kg/m 3 , resulted in an estimated coil mass of M_c(phy) =1,232 tonnes. Although the critical current density J_e was based upon a 2000 Zubrin NIAC report projecting values through 2020, the assumed value is close to that for commercially produced YBCO coated superconductor wire in 2020.
The mass estimate may be optimistic since it assumed that the entire coil carrying mass is superconducting while 2020 manufacturing techniques place a thin film on a non-superconducting substrate. For the interstellar medium plasma density \rho_{im} =1.67×10 −22 with an apparent wind velocity 5% of light speed, the ion gyroradius is 570 km and thus the design value for R_{mp} meets the MHD applicability test of equation .
Equation gives the required coil current as I_c ~7,800 kA and from equation M_c(min) = 338 tonnes; however, but the corresponding superconducting wire minimum radius from equation is r_c(min) =1 mm, which would be insufficient to handle the decelerating thrust force of F_{MS} ~ 100,000 N predicted by equation and hence the design specified r_{sc} = 5 mm to meet structural requirements. In a complete design, the mass of infrastructure, including coil shielding to maintain critical temperature and survive abrasion in outer space, must also be included.
Appendix A estimates these as 90 tonnes for wire shielding and 50 tonnes for the spools and other magsail infrastructure. Freeland compared this magsail deceleration design with one where both acceleration and deceleration were performed by a fusion engine and reported that the mass of such a "dirty Icarus" design was over twice that of a magsail used for deceleration.
An Icarus design published in 2020 used a Z-pinch fusion drive in an approach called Firefly that dramatically reduced mass of the fusion drive and made fusion only drive performance for acceleration and deceleration comparable to the fusion for acceleration and magsail for deceleration design. In 2017, Gros reported numerical examples for the Magsail kinematic model that used different parameters and coil mass models than those used by Freeland.
That paper assumed hydrogen ion (H I) number densities of 0.05-0.2 cm −3 (9×10 −23 - 3×10 −22 kg/m 3 ) for the warm local clouds and about 0.005 cm −3 (9×10 −23 kg/m 3 ) for voids of the local bubble. Patches of cold interstellar clouds with less than 200 AU may have large densities of neutral hydrogen up to 3000 cm −3 , which would not respond to a magnetic field.
For a high speed mission to Alpha Centauri with initial velocity before deceleration v_0=c/10 using a coil mass of 1500 tons and a coil radius of R =1600 km, the estimated stopping distance x_{max} was 0.37 light years and the total travel time of 58 years with 1/3 of that being deceleration. In 2017, Crowl documented a design for a mission starting near the Sun and destined for Planet nine approximately 1,000 AU distant that employed the Magsail kinematic model.
The design accounted for the Sun's gravity as well as the impact of elevated temperature on the superconducting coil, composed of meta-stable metallic hydrogen, which has a mass density of 3,500 kg/m 3 about half that of other superconductors. The mission profile used the Magsail to accelerate away from 0.25 to 1.0 AU from the Sun and then used the Magsail to brake against the Local ISM on approach to Planet nine for a total travel time of 29 years.
Parameters and coil mass models differ from those used by Freeland. Another mission profile uses a magsail oriented at an attack angle to achieve heliocentric transfer between planets moving away from or toward the Sun. In 2013 Quarta and others used Kajimura 2012 simulation results that described the lift (steering angle) and torque to achieve a Venus to Earth transfer orbit of 380 days with a coil radius of R_c ~1 km with characteristic acceleration a_c =1 mm/s 2 .
In 2019 Bassetto and others used the Quarta "thick" magnetopause model and predicted a Venus to Earth transfer orbit of approximately 8 years for a coil radius of R_c ~1 km. with characteristic acceleration a_c =0.1 mm/s 2 . In 2020 Perakis used the Magsail kinematic model with a coil radius of R_c =350 m, current I_c =10 4 A and spacecraft mass of 600 kg that changed attack angle to accelerate away from the Earth orbit and decelerate to Jupiter orbit within 20 years.
The figure based upon Winglee, Hajiwara, Arita, and Funaki illustrates the M2P2 design, which was the basis of the subsequent Magneto plasma sail (MPS) design. Starting at the center with a solenoid coil of radius R_H of N_t =1,000 turns carrying a radio frequency current that generates a helicon wave that injects plasma fed from a source into a coil of radius R_c that carries a current of I_c , which generates a magnetic field.
The excited injected plasma enhances the magnetic field and generates a miniature magnetosphere around the spacecraft, analogous to the heliopause where the Sun injected plasma encounters the interstellar medium, coronal mass ejections or the Earth's magnetotail. The injected plasma created an environment that analysis and simulations showed had a magnetic field with a falloff rate of 1/r as compared with the classical model of a 1/r^3 falloff rate, making the much smaller coil significantly more effective based upon analysis and simulation.
The pressure of the inflated plasma along with the stronger magnetic field pressure at a larger distance due to the lower falloff rate would stretch the magnetic field and more efficiently inflate a magnetospheric bubble around the spacecraft. Parameters for the coil and solenoid were R_H =2.5 cm and for the coil R_c = 0.1 m, 6 orders of magnitude less than the magsail coil with correspondingly much lower mass.
An estimate for the weight of the coil was 10 kg and 40 kg for the plasma injection source and other infrastructure. Reported results from Figure 2 were B_0 \approx T at R_{mp} \approx 10 km and from Figure 3 an extrapolated result with a plasma injection jet force F_{jet} \approx 10 −3 N resulting in a thrust force of F_{M2P2} \approx 1 N. The magnetic-only sail force from equation is F_w =3×10 −11 N and thus M2P2 reported a thrust gain of 4×10 10 as compared with a magnetic field only design.
Since M2P2 injects ionized gas at a m_{in} mass flow rate (kg/s) it is viewed as a propellant and therefore has a specific impulse (s) I_{sp}=F_{M2P2}/m_{in}/g_0 where g_0 is the acceleration of Earth's gravity. Winglee stated m_{in} =0.5 kg/day and therefore I_{sp} =17,621. The equivalent exhaust velocity v_e=g_0 \, I_{sp} is 173 km/s for 1 N of thrust force.
Winglee assumed total propellant mass of 30 kg and therefore propellant would run out in 60 days. In 2003, Khazanov published MagnetoHydroDynamic (MHD) and kinetic studies that confirmed some aspects of M2P2 but raised issues that the sail size was too small, and that very small thrust would result and also concluded that the hypothesized 1/r magnetic field falloff rate was closer to 1/r^2 .
The plasma density plots from Khazanov indicated a relatively high density inside the magnetospheric bubble as compared with the external solar wind region that differed significantly from those published by Winglee where the density inside the magnetospheric bubble was much less than outside in the external solar wind region. A detailed analysis by Toivanen and others in 2004 compared a theoretical model of Magsail, dubbed Plasma-free Magnetospheric Propulsion (PFMP) versus M2P2 and concluded that the thrust force predicted by Winglee and others was over ten orders of magnitude optimistic since the majority of the solar wind momentum was delivered to the magnetotail and current leakages through the magnetopause and not to the spacecraft.
Their comments also indicated that the magnetic field lines may not close near enough to the coil to achieve significant transfer of force. Their analysis made an analogy to the Heliospheric current sheet as an example in astrophysics where the magnetic field could falloff at a rate of between 1/r and 1/r^2 .
They also analyzed current sheets reported by Winglee from the magnetopause to the spacecraft in the windward direction and a current sheet in the magnetotail. Their analysis indicated that the current sheets needed to pass extremely close to the spacecraft to impart significant force could generate significant heat and render this leverage impractical.
In 2005, Cattell and others published comments regarding M2P2 that included a lack of magnetic flux conservation in the region outside the magnetosphere that was not considered in the Khazanov studies. Their analysis concluded in Table 1 that Winglee had significantly underestimated the required sail size, mass, and required magnetic flux.
Their analysis asserted that the hypothesized 1/r magnetic field falloff rate was not possible. The expansion of the magnetic field using injected plasma was demonstrated in a large vacuum chamber on Earth, but quantification of thrust was not part of the experiment. The accompanying presentation has some good animations that illustrate physical principles described in the report.
A 2004 Winglee paper focused on usage of M2P2 for electromagnetic shielding. Beginning in 2003, the Magneto plasma sail design further investigated the plasma injection augmentation of the magnetic field, used larger coils and reported significantly more modest gains.
In 2003 Funaki and others proposed an approach similar to the M2P2 design and called it the MagnetoPlasma Sail (MPS) that started with a coil R_c =0.2 m and a magnetic field falloff rate of f_o =1.52 with injected plasma creating an effective sail radius of L =26 km and assumed a conversion efficiency that transferred a fraction of the solar wind momentum to the spacecraft. Simulation results indicated a significant increase in magnetosphere size with plasma injection as compared to the Magsail design, which had no plasma injection.
Analysis showed how adjustment of the MPS steering angle created force that could reach the outer planets. A satellite trial was proposed. Preliminary performance results were reported but later modified in subsequent papers.
Many MPS papers have been published on the magnetic sail contributing to the understanding of general physical principles of an artificial magnetosphere, its magnetohydrodynamic model, and the design approach for computing the magnetopause distance for a given magnetic field source are documented in the linked sections of this article. In 2004 Funaki and others analyzed MPS cases where R_c =10 m and R_c =100 m as summarized in Table 2 predicting a characteristic length L of 50 and 450 km producing significant thrust with mass substantially less than the Magsail and hence significant acceleration.
This paper detailed the MHD applicability test of equation that the characteristic length must be greater than the ion gyroradius r_g to effectively transfer solar wind momentum to the spacecraft. In 2005 Yamakawa and others further described a potential trial.
An analogy with the Earth's magnetosphere and magnetopause in determining the penetration of plasma irregularities into the magnetopause defines the key parameter of a local kinetic plasma beta as the ratio of the dynamic pressure p_{dyn} of the injected plasma over the magnetic pressure p_{dyn} as follows {{NumBlk2|:| \beta_k = \frac {p_{dyn} }{p_{mag} }= \frac {\rho_{l} u_{l}^2}{B_{l} ^2 /\mu_0} |MPS.1}}where \rho_l kg/m 3 is the local plasma density, u_l m/s is the local velocity of the plasma and B_l T is the local magnetic field flux density. Simulations have shown that the kinetic beta is smallest near the field source, at magnetopause and the bow shock.
The kinetic \beta_k differs from the thermal plasma beta \beta_i=p_{plasma}/p_{mag} which is the ratio of the plasma thermal pressure to the magnetic pressure, with terms: p_{plasma}=n \, k_B \,T is the plasma pressure with n the number density, k_B the Boltzmann constant and T the ion temperature; and p_{mag} = B^2/(2 \mu_0) the magnetic pressure for magnetic field flux density B and \mu_0 vacuum permeability. In the context of the MPS, \beta_k determines the propensity of the injected plasma flow to stretch the magnetic field while \beta_i specifies the relative energy of the injected plasma.
In 2005 Funaki and others published numerical analysis showing f_0 =1.88 for \beta_k =0.1. In 2009 Kajimura published simulation results with \beta_k =5 and \beta_i ranging from 6 to 20 that the magnetic field falloff rate f_0 with argon and xenon plasma injected into the polar region was f_0 =2.1 and with argon plasma injected into the equatorial region was f_0 =1.8.
If \beta_k>1 then the Injection of a high-velocity, high-density plasma into a magnetosphere as proposed in M2P2 freezes the motion of a magnetic field into the plasma flow and was believed to inflate the magnetosphere. However experiments and numerical analysis determined that the solar wind cannot compress the magnetosphere and momentum transfer to the spacecraft is limited since momentum is transferred to injected plasma flowing out of the magnetosphere, similar to another criticism of M2P2.
An alternative is to reduce the plasma injection velocity and density to result in \beta_k to achieve a plasma in equilibrium with the inflated magnetic field and therefore induce an equatorial diamagnetic current in the same direction as the coil current as shown in the figure, thereby increasing the magnetic moment of the MPS field source and consequently increasing thrust. In 2013 Funaki and others published simulation and theoretical results regarding how characteristics of the injected plasma affected thrust gain through creation of an equatorial ring current.
They defined thrust gain for MPS as G_{MPS}=F_{MPS}/F_{mag} : the ratio of the force generated by low beta plasma injection F_{MPS} divided by that of a pure magnetic sail F_{mag} from equation with f_o =3 and C_{SO}=0.5 for r_g\leq L or from equation for r_g>L . They reported G_{MPS} of approximately 40 for magnetospheres less than the MHD applicability test and 3.77 for a larger magnetosphere where MHD applicability occurred, larger than values reported in 2012 of 20 and 3.3, respectively. Simulations revealed that optimum thrust gain occurred for \beta_k and \beta_i \approx 10 .
In 2014 Arita, Nishida and Funaki published simulation results indicating that plasma injection created an equatorial ring current and that the plasma injection rate had a significant impact on thrust performance, with the lowest value simulated having the best performance of a thrust gain G_{MPS} of 3.77 with \beta_i \approx 25 . They also reported that MPS increased the height of the magnetosphere by a factor of 2.6, which is important since it increases the effective sail blocking area.
In 2014 Ashida and others documented Particle In Cell (PIC) simulation results for a kinematic model for cases where r_g >> L where MHD is not applicable. Equation (12) of their study included the additional force of the injected plasma jet F_{jet} consisting of momentum and static pressure of ions and electrons and defined thrust gain as F_{MPS}/(F_{mag}+F_{jet}) , which differs from the definition of a term by the same name in other studies.
It represents the gain of MPS over that of simply adding the magnetic sail force and the plasma injection jet force. For the values cited in the conclusion, F_{MPS}/F_{mag} is 7.5 in the radial orientation.
Since a number of results were published by different authors at different times, the figure summarizes the reported thrust gain G_{MPS} versus magnetosphere size (or characteristic length L ) with the source indicated in the legend as follows for simulation results Arita14, Ashida14, Funaki13, and Kajimura10. Simulation results require significant compute time, for example it took 1024 CPUs 4 days to simulate the simplest case and 4096 CPUs one week to simulate a more complex case.
A thrust gain between 2 and 10 is common with the larger gains with a magnetic nozzle injecting plasma in one direction in opposition to the solar wind. The MHD applicability test of equation for the solar wind is L \approx 72 km.
Therefore, the estimated force of the MPS is that of equation multiplied by the empirically determined thrust gain G_{MPS} from the figure multiplied by the percentage thrust loss T_{loss} from equation For example, using solar wind parameters \rho =8×10 −21 kg/m 3 and u =500 km/s then r_g =72 km and B_{mp} =4×10 −8 T. With L =10 5 m for f_o =3 then r_g and T_{loss}\approx 11% from equation . The magnetic field only force with a coil radius of R_c =6,300 m and coil current I_c =1.6×10 6 A yields B_0 =1.6×10 −4 T from equation and with C_d =5 the magnetic force only is 175 N from equation .
Determining G_{MPS} \approx 4 from the figure at L =10 5 m as the multiplier for the magnetic-only force then the MPS force F_{MPS} \approx 700 N. Since MPS injects ionized gas at a rate of m_{in} that can be viewed as a propellant it has a specific impulse I_{sp}=F_{MPS}/m_{in}/g_0 where g_0 is the acceleration of Earth's gravity. Funaki and Arita stated m_{in} =0.31 kg/day.
Therefore I_{sp} =28,325 s per newton of thrust force. The equivalent exhaust velocity v_e=g_0 \, I_{sp} is 278 km/s per newton of thrust force. In 2015 Kajimura and others published simulation results for thrust performance with plasma injected by a magnetic nozzle, a technology used in VASIMR.
They reported a thrust gain G_{MPS} of 24 when the ion gyroradius r_g (see equation ) was comparable to the characteristic length L , at the boundary of the MHD applicability test. The optimal result occurred with a thermal \beta_i \approx 1 with some decrease for higher values of thermal beta.
In 2015 Hagiwara and Kajimura published experimental thrust performance test results with plasma injection using a magnetoplasmadynamic thruster (aka MPD thruster or MPD Arcjet) in a single direction opposite the solar wind direction and a coil with the axial orientation. This meant that F_{jet} provided additional propulsive force.
Density plots explicitly show the increased plasma density upwind of the bow shock originating from the MPD thruster. They reported that F_{MPS}>>F_{mag}+F_{jet} showing how MPS inflated the magnetic field to create more thrust than the magnetic sail alone plus that of the >.
The conclusion of the experiment was that the thrust gain G_{MPS} was approximately 12 for a scaled characteristic length of L = 60 km. In the above figure, note the significant improvement in thrust gain at L = 60 km.as compared with only plasma injection.
In this example, using solar wind parameters \rho =8×10 −21 kg/m 3 and u =500 km/s then r_g =72 km and B_{mp} =4×10 −8 T. With L =60 km for f_o =3 then r_g \approx L and T_{loss}\approx 28% from equation . The magnetic field only force with a coil radius of R_c =2,900 m and coil current I_c =1.6×10 6 A yields B_0 =3.5×10 −4 T from equation and with C_d =5 the magnetic force only is 51 N from equation .
Given G_{MPS} =12 as the multiplier for the magnetic only force then the MPS force F_{MPS} \approx 611 N. In 2017 Ueno published a design proposing use of multiple coils to generate a more complex magnetic field to increase thrust production. In 2020 Murayama and others published additional experimental results for a multi-pole MPD thruster.
In 2017 Djojodihardjo published a conceptual design using MPS for a small (~500 kg) Earth observation satellite. In 2020 Peng and others published MHD simulation results for a magnetic dipole with plasma injection operating in Low Earth orbit at 500 km within the Earth's Ionosphere where the ion number density is approximately 10 11 m −3 .
As reported in Figure 3, the magnetic field strength initially falls off as 1/r and then approaches 1/r 2 at larger distances from the dipole. The radius of the artificial mini-magnetosphere could extend up to 200 m for this scenario.
They reported that the injected plasma reduced magnetic field fall off rate and created of a drift current, similar to earlier reported MPS results for the solar wind. The magnetic field falloff rate was assumed in 2001 and 2006 to be f_o =1.
However, as described by Khazanov in 2003 and restated by Slough, Kirtley and Pancotti in 2011 and Kirtley and Slough in a 2012 NIAC report that f_o =2 as demanded by conservation of magnetic flux. Several MPS studies concluded that f_o is closer to 2. The falloff rate f_o is a critical parameter in the determination of performance.
The RMF-induced rotating disc of electrons has current density (A m −2 ) j_\theta(r) at distance r from the antenna for f_o=1 and for f_o=2 , which states that flux conservation requires this falloff rate, consistent with a criticism of M2P2 by Cattell as follows: {{NumBlk2|:| j_\theta(r,f_o)=\frac{2 f_o \, B(R_0) \, R_0^{f_o} }{\mu_0 \, r^{f_o+1} } \, \, ,r>R_0 |PM.1}} where B(R_0) T is the magnetic field flux density at radius R_0 \approx R_c m near the antenna coils. Note that the current density is highest at r=R_0 and falls off at a rate of f_o+1 .
A critical condition for the plasma magnet design provides a lower bound on the RMF frequency \omega_{RMF} rad/s as follows so that electrons in the plasma wind are magnetized and rotate but the ions are not magnetized and do not rotate: where \omega_{ci} is the ion gyrofrequency (s −1 ) in the RMF near the antenna coils, Z is charge number of the ion, e is the elementary charge, and m_i kg is the (average) mass of the ion(s). Specifying the magnetic field near the coils at radius R_0 is critical since this is where the current density is greatest. Choosing a magnetic field at magnetopause yields a lower value of \omega_{RMF} but ions closer to the coils will rotate.
Another condition is that \omega_{RMF} be small enough such that collisions are extremely unlikely. The required power to generate the RMF P_{RMF} is derived by integrating the product of the square of the current density from equation and the resistivity of the plasma \eta_p from R_0 to R_{mp} with the result as follows: where \eta_p is the Spitzer resistivity (W m) of the plasma of ~1.2×10 −3 T_e^{-3/2} where T_e is the electron temperature assumed to be 15 eV, the same result for f_o=1 and for f_o=2 .
Starting with the definition of plasma wind force from equation , noting that P_w=F_w u rearranging and recognizing that equation gives the solution for B(R_0) , which can be substituted and then using equation for B_{mp} yields the following expression {{NumBlk2|:| P_w = \frac{C_d}{2\, C_{SO} } \rho \, u^3 \, \pi \, R_0^2 \, \biggl(\frac {P_{RMF} }{u^2\, R_0 \, \rho \, \mu_0} \biggr)^{1/f_o} \biggl(\frac {\mu_0^2}{4 \pi \eta_p} \frac {2f_o-1}{f_o^2} \biggr)^{1/f_o} |PM.4}} which when multiplied by C_d/2 with C_SO=1 is the same as for f_o=1 Note that solution for P_{RMF} and R_0 must also satisfy equation , to which the comments following regarding a "tremendous leverage of power" do not address. Note that a number of the examples cited in assume a magnetopause radius R_{mp} that do not meet the MHD applicability test of equation .
From the definition of power in physics a constant force is power divided by velocity, the force generated by the plasma magnet (PM) sail is as follows from equation {{NumBlk2|:| F_{PM} = \frac {P_w}{u} = \frac{C_d}{2\, C_{SO} } \rho \, u^2 \, \pi \, R_0^2 \, \biggl(\frac {P_{RMF} }{ u^2 \, R_0 \, \rho \, \mu_0} \biggr)^{1/f_o} \biggl(\frac {\mu_0^2}{4 \pi \eta_p} \frac {2f_o-1}{f_o^2} \biggr)^{1/f_o} |PM.5}}Comparing the above with Equation , note the dependence on plasma mass density \rho is of the same form \rho ^{1-1/f_o} . Note from Equation that as the falloff rate f_o increases that the force derived from the plasma wind decreases, or to maintain the same force P_{RMF} and/or R_0 must increase to maintain the same force F_{PM} .
Equation gives the mass for each physical coil of radius R_c m. Since the RMF requires alternating current and semiconductors are not efficient at higher frequencies, aluminum was specified with mass density \delta_c = 2,700 kg/m 3 . Estimates of the coil mass are optimistic by a factor of 4 \pi since only one coil was sized and the coil circumference was specified as R_c instead of 2 \pi R_c . The coil resistance is the product of coil material resistivity (Ω m) \eta_c (e.g., ~3×10 −8 Ωm for aluminum) and the coil length 2 \pi R_c divided by the coil wire cross sectional area where r_c is the radius of the coil wire as follows: Some additional power must compensate for resistive loss but it is orders of magnitude less than P_{RMF} .
The peak current carried by a coil is specified by the RMF power and coil resistance from the definition of electrical power in physics as follows: {{NumBlk2|:| I_c = \sqrt{\frac {P_{RMF} }{\Omega_c} } |PM.7}} The current induced in the disc by the RMF I_{ic} is the integral of the current density j(r,f_o) from equation on the surface of the disc with inner radius R_c and outer radius R_{MP} with result: the same result for f_o =1. Laboratory experiments validated that the RMF creates a magnetospheric bubble, electron temperature near the coils increases indicating presence of the rotating disc of electrons and that thrust was generated.
Since the scale of a terrestrial experiment is limited, simulations or a flight trial was recommended. Some of these concepts adapted to an ionospheric plasma environment were carried on in the plasma magnetoshell design.
In 2022 Freeze, Greason and others published a detailed design for a plasma magnet based sail for a spacecraft named Wind Rider that would use solar wind force to accelerate away from near Earth and decelerate against the magnetosphere of Jupiter in a spaceflight trial mission called Jupiter Observing Velocity Experiment (JOVE). This design employed a pair of superconducting coils each with radius R_c of 9 m, an alternating current of I_c of 112 A with \omega_{RMF}/(2\pi) and a falloff rate of f_o=1 .
A transit time to Jupiter of 25 days was reported for a 21 kg spacecraft design launched in a 16 U Cubesat format. Using f_o =1 creates very optimistic performance numbers, but since Slough changed this to f_o =2 in 2011 and 2012, the case of f_o=1 is not compared in this article.
An example for f_o =2 using solar wind parameters \rho =8×10 −21 kg/m 3 , u =500 km/s then r_g =72 km and B_{mp} =4×10 −8 T with R_{mp} =10 5 m results in r_g where MHD applicability occurs. With a coil radius of R_c =1,000 m yields B_0 =4×10 −4 T from equation .
The required RMF power from equation is 13 kW with a required AC coil current I_c =10 A from equation resulting in an induced current of I_{ic} =2 kA from equation . With C_d =5 the plasma magnet force from equation is 197 N. The magnetic force only for the above parameters is 2.8 N from equation and therefore the plasma magnet thrust gain is 71.
The performance comparison section gives and optimistic estimate using constant acceleration for f_o =2 results in a transit time of ~100 days. In 2017, Kelly described using a single-coil magnet with 1/r 3 magnetic field falloff rate and more experimental results. In 2019 Kelly and Little published simulation results for magnetoshell performance scaling.
A magnet with radius R_c =1 m was tethered to a spacecraft with batteries for 1,000 seconds of operation (longer than aerocapture designs). The simulations assumed a magnet mass M_c =1,000 kg and total magnetoshell system mass of 1,623 kg, suitable for a Cassini–Huygens or Juno size orbiter.
The planet's mass and atmosphere atomic composition and density determine a threshold velocity where magnetoshell operation is feasible. Saturn and Neptune have a hydrogen atmosphere and a threshold velocity of approximately 22 km/s. In a Neptune mission a \Delta v =6 km is required for a 5,000 kg spacecraft and must average 50 kN for the maneuver duration.
The model overestimates performance for N 2 (Earth, Titan) and CO 2 (Venus, Mars) atmospheres since multiple ion species are created and more complex interactions occur. Furthermore, the relatively lower mass of Venus and Mars reduces the threshold velocity below that of feasible magnetoshell operation.
The paper states that aerocapture technologies are mature enough for these mission profiles. In 2021, Kelly and Little published further details for use of drag-modulated plasma aerocapture (DMPA) that when compared to Adaptable Deployable Entry and Placement Technology (ADEPT) for drag-modulated aerocapture (DMA) to Neptune that could deliver 70% higher orbiter mass and experience 30% lower stagnation heating.
The table below compares performance measures for the magnetic sail designs with the following parameters for the solar wind (sw) at 1 AU: velocity u_{sw} = 500 km/s, number density n_i = 5×10 6 m −3 , ion mass m_i = 1.67×10 −27 kg a proton mass, resulting in mass density \rho_{sw}= m_i n_i = 8.4×10 −21 kg/m 3 , and coefficient of drag C_d =5 where applicable. Equation gives the magnetic field at magnetopause as B_{mp} ≈ 36 nT, equation gives the ion gyroradius r_g ≈ 72 km for C_{Li} =2.
Table entries in boldface are from a cited source as described in the following: Equation determines force for the Magsail (MS) divided by the Freeland correction factor 3.1, equation defines the force for the plasma magnet (PM) with the assumed magnetic field falloff rate f_o =2. The force for the magnetic sail alone F_{mag} is from equation .
Thrust gain G_T for the magneto plasma sail (MPS) is the simulation and/or experimentally determined value with force defined equation to account for thrust loss due to operation in a kinematic region. The last column headed MPS+MPD adds a magnetoplasma dynamic thruster (MPD) that has a higher thrust gain as determined by experiment and simulation.
Further details are in the section for the specific design. For designs other than MPS and MPS+MPD, the thrust gain G_T is the achieved force from the first row divided by the force of a magnetic sail alone in the second row. The magnetopause distance R_{mp} \approx L and the coil radius R_c are design parameters.
Equation with r=R_{mp} defines the magnetic field near the coil(s) as B_0=B(R_0)=B_{mp}(R_{mp}/R_0)^{1/f_o} . The superconducting coil designs used a critical current density J_c =2×10 6 A/m to account for warmer temperatures in the solar system.
The plasma magnet uses AC power for the rotating magnetic field, P RMF as specified in Equation and cannot use a superconducting coil and assumed an aluminum coil with material density \delta_c = 2,700 kg/m 3 and coil wire radius r_c =5 mm. All other designs assumed a superconducting coil with material density \delta_c =6,500 kg/m 3 , coil wire radius r_c =5 mm, and critical current \max I_c \approx 1.6 ×10 6 A, above which the coil becomes a normal conductor.
The magnetopause distance R_{mp} \approx L and coil radius R_c for superconducting-coil based designs were adjusted to meet this critical current constraint. The values for the plasma magnet used a value of R_c for f_o =2 selected to minimize time to velocity and distance.
The MPS values for R_{mp} \approx L and R_c were chosen to match the thrust gain from simulation and scaled experimental results and meet the superconducting-coil critical current constraint. Equation gives the physical coil mass M_c(phy) assuming a coil wire radius r_c =5 mm.
Equation gives the plasma magnet alternating current I_c . Equation gives the direct current I_c with C_0 =2 for all other designs. The plasma magnet RMF uses the input alternating current I_c (kA) to rotate electrons in captured plasma to create an induced direct current disc carrying I_{ic} kA as defined in equation .
Superconducting coils do not require continuous power (except possibly for cooling); however, the plasma magnet design does, as specified in equation . An estimate for the plasma magnet power supply mass assumes ~3 kg/W for nuclear power in space. Other mass was assumed to be 10 tonnes for MS and 1 tonne for PM and MPS.
Acceleration a is the thrust force F from the first row divided by the total mass (coil plus other). An optimistic approximation is constant acceleration a , for which the time to reach a target velocity V of 10% of the solar wind velocity is T_V \approx V/a and time to cover a specified distance D ≈ 7.8×10 8 km (approximate distance from Earth to Jupiter) is T_D \approx \sqrt{ 2D/a} .
For comparison purposes the time for a Hohmann transfer from Earth orbit to Jupiter orbit is 2.7 years (almost 1,000 days) but that would allow orbital insertion whereas a magnetic sail would do a flyby unless the magnetosphere and gravity of Jupiter could provide deceleration. Another comparison is the New Horizons interplanetary space probe with a 30 kg payload that flew by Jupiter after 405 days on its way to Pluto.
The best time to velocity T_V and distance T_D performance occurs for the PM and MPS designs due primarily to much reduced coil and other mass. As described in the M2P2 section, several criticisms asserted that the falloff rate f_o =1 was questionable and hence it was not included in this table.
Simulations and experiments as described in the MPS section showed that f_o =2 is valid with injection of plasma to inflate the magnetic field in a manner similar to M2P2. As described in the PM section, plasma is not injected but instead captured to achieve a falloff rate of f_o =2, with calculations assuming f_o =1 being very optimistic.
The classic Magsail (MS) design generates the most thrust force and has considerable mass but still has relatively good time performance. Parameters for the other designs were chosen to yield comparable time performance subject to the constraints previously described.
As described above and further detailed in the section for the respective design, this article contains the equations and parameters to compute performance estimates for different parameter choices.
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1371521511 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “Magnetic sail” publication date (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL