Matthew effect

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Q1337985Snapshot

≈ 9 min read

Names in other languages

  • PolskiEfekt św. Mateusza
  • EnglishMatthew effect
  • Françaiseffet Matthieu
  • EspañolEfecto Mateo
  • עבריתאפקט מתי
  • 简体中文马太效应
  • 繁體中文馬太效應
  • 中文馬太效應

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

of the Christian Bible The Matthew effect, sometimes called the Matthew principle or cumulative advantage, is the tendency of individuals to accrue social or economic success in proportion to their initial level of popularity, friends, wealth, and natural advantages. It is sometimes summarized by the adage or platitude "the rich get richer and the poor get poorer". Also termed the "Matthew effect of accumulated advantage", taking its name from the Parable of the Talents in the Christian-biblical Gospel of Matthew, it was coined by sociologists Robert K. Merton and Harriet Zuckerman in 1968. Early studies of the Matthew effect focused primarily on inequality in how scientists were recognized for their work. However, Norman W. Storer of Columbia University led a new wave of research . He believed he had discovered that the inequality in the social sciences also existed in other institutions. Later, in network science, researchers discovered a form of the Matthew effect in internet networks, terming it "preferential attachment". Researchers later reapplied the mathematics used for this network analysis to the Matthew effect more generally, where wealth or credit is distributed among individuals according to how much they already have.…

of the Christian Bible The Matthew effect, sometimes called the Matthew principle or cumulative advantage, is the tendency of individuals to accrue social or economic success in proportion to their initial level of popularity, friends, wealth, and natural advantages. It is sometimes summarized by the adage or platitude "the rich get richer and the poor get poorer". Also termed the "Matthew effect of accumulated advantage", taking its name from the Parable of the Talents in the Christian-biblical Gospel of Matthew, it was coined by sociologists Robert K. Merton and Harriet Zuckerman in 1968. Early studies of the Matthew effect focused primarily on inequality in how scientists were recognized for their work. However, Norman W. Storer of Columbia University led a new wave of research . He believed he had discovered that the inequality in the social sciences also existed in other institutions. Later, in network science, researchers discovered a form of the Matthew effect in internet networks, terming it "preferential attachment". Researchers later reapplied the mathematics used for this network analysis to the Matthew effect more generally, where wealth or credit is distributed among individuals according to how much they already have. This has the net effect of making it increasingly difficult for low-ranked individuals to increase their totals because they have fewer resources to risk over time, and increasingly easy for high-ranked individuals to preserve a large total because they have more to risk.

Etymology

The concept is named after two parables of Jesus in the Synoptic Gospels (Table 2 of the Eusebian Canons). The concept concludes both synoptic versions of the parable of the talents: The concept concludes two of the three synoptic versions of the parable of the lamp under a bushel (which is absent in the version by the Matthean author): The concept is presented again in Matthew outside of a parable during Jesus's explanation to his disciples of the purpose of parables:

Sociology of science

Cumulative advantage

In the sociology of science, the first description of the Matthew effect was given by Derek J. de Solla Price in 1976. (He referred to the process as a "cumulative advantage" process.) His work was also the first application of the process to network growth, producing what is now called a scale-free network. It is in the context of network growth that the process is most frequently studied today. Price also promoted preferential attachment as a possible explanation for power laws in many other phenomena, including Lotka's law of scientific productivity and Bradford's law of journal use.

Coining the "Matthew effect"

"Matthew effect" was a term coined by Robert K. Merton and Harriet Anne Zuckerman to describe how, among other things, eminent scientists will often get more credit than a comparatively unknown researcher, even if their work is similar; it also means that credit will usually be given to researchers who are already famous. For example, a prize will almost always be awarded to the most senior researcher involved in a project, even if all the work was done by a graduate student. This was later formulated by Stephen Stigler as Stigler's law of eponymy—"No scientific discovery is named after its original discoverer"—with Stigler explicitly naming Merton as the true discoverer, making his 'law' an example of itself. Merton and Zuckerman further argued that in the scientific community the Matthew effect extends beyond reputation to influence the wider communication system, shaping social selection processes and concentrating resources and talent. They gave the example of the disproportionate visibility given to articles from acknowledged authors, at the expense of equally valid or superior articles written by unknown authors. They also noted that concentrating attention on eminent individuals can increase their self-assurance, pushing them to pursue research in important but risky problem areas. The Matthew effect also relates to broader patterns of scientific productivity, which additional sociological concepts in science can explain, such as the sacred spark, cumulative advantage, and search costs minimization by journal editors. The sacred spark paradigm suggests that scientists differ in initial abilities, talent, skills, persistence, work habits, etc., which give some individuals an early advantage. These factors have a multiplicative effect, which helps these scholars succeed later. The cumulative advantage model argues that initial success helps a researcher gain access to resources (e.g., teaching release, top graduate students, funding, facilities, etc.), which in turn leads to further success. Search-cost minimization by journal editors occurs when editors try to save time and effort by consciously or subconsciously selecting articles from well-known scholars. Although the exact mechanism underlying these phenomena remains unknown, research shows that a minority of academics produce most research output and attract most citations. Beyond its influence on recognition and productivity, the Matthew effect also appears in the distribution of scientific resources, such as funding. A large Matthew effect was found in a study of science funding in the Netherlands, where winners just above the funding threshold accumulated more than twice as much funding over the next eight years as non-winners with near-identical review scores just below the threshold.

Education

In education, the term "Matthew effect" has been adopted by psychologist Keith Stanovich and popularised by education theorist Anthony Kelly to describe a phenomenon observed in research on how new readers acquire the skills to read. Effectively, early success in acquiring reading skills usually leads to later successes in reading as the learner grows, while failing to learn to read before the third or fourth year of schooling may be indicative of lifelong problems in learning new skills. This is because children who fall behind in reading would read less, increasing the gap between them and their peers. Later, when students need to "read to learn" (where before they were learning to read), their reading difficulty creates difficulty in most other subjects. In this way they fall further and further behind in school, dropping out at a much higher rate than their peers. This effect has been used in legal cases, such as Brody v. Dare County Board of Education. Such cases argue that early education intervention is essential for disabled children, and that failing to do so negatively impacts those children. A 2014 review of Matthew effect in education found mixed empirical evidence, where Matthew effect tends to describe the development of primary school skills, while a compensatory pattern was found for skills with ceiling effects. A 2016 study on reading comprehension assessments for over 99,000 students1 found a pattern of stable differences, with some narrowing of the gap for students with learning disabilities.

Network science

In network science, the Matthew effect was noticed as preferential attachment of earlier nodes in a network, which explains that these nodes tend to attract more links early on. The application of preferential attachment to the growth of the World Wide Web was proposed by Barabási and Albert in 1999. Barabási and Albert also coined the name "preferential attachment", and suggested that the process might apply to the growth of other networks as well. For growing networks, the precise functional form of preferential attachment can be estimated by maximum likelihood estimation. Due to preferential attachment, Matjaž Perc writes "a node that acquires more connections than another one will increase its connectivity at a higher rate, and thus an initial difference in the connectivity between two nodes will increase further as the network grows, while the degree of individual nodes will grow proportional with the square root of time." The Matthew Effect therefore explains the growth of some nodes in vast networks such as the Internet.

See also

Ability grouping Anchoring effect Attention inequality Boots theory Capital accumulation Convergence Google Scholar effect The internal contradictions of capital accumulation Lindy effect Matilda effect Metcalfe's law Network effect Pareto distribution Positive feedback Preferential attachment Snowball effect Social network analysis Tracking (education) Virtuous circle and vicious circle Wealth concentration

References

Further reading

Cunningham, A. E., & Chen, Y.–J. (2014). Rich-get-richer effect (Matthew Effects). In P. Brooks & V. Kempe (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Language Development. New York: Sage. Rigney, Daniel (2010). The Matthew Effect: How Advantage Begets Further Advantage. Columbia University Press. Stanovich, Keith E. (2000). Progress in Understanding Reading: Scientific Foundations and New Frontiers. New York: Guilford Press.nningham, A. E., & Chen, Y.–J. (2014). Rich-get-richer effect (Matthew Effects). In P. Brooks & V. Kempe (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Language Development. New York: Sage.

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1375139167 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

References

  1. ↩Wikipedia students (×1) · confidence 0.95 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1375139167

Sources cited in this revision

Extracted from the cited revision's reference blocks; absent citations are not invented.