McCartney II
McCartney II is the third solo studio album by the English musician Paul McCartney, released on 16 May 1980.
≈ 15 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
McCartney II is the third solo studio album by the English musician Paul McCartney, released on 16 May 19801. McCartney envisioned it as an experiment and did not intend to release it commercially, following his disillusionment with his band Wings. He recorded it in the summer of 1979 at his home studio in Peasmarsh and Campbeltown.
Like his debut solo studio album, McCartney (1970), he produced, engineered and performed all the instruments himself. Originally intended to be a double album, McCartney trimmed it to a single album for commercial reasons. One of its outtakes was the 1979 non-album single "Wonderful Christmastime".
The album was a significant departure for McCartney, relying heavily on synthesisers and studio experimentation, while its musical style embraces new wave and elements of electronica and synth-pop. McCartney's vocals were tinkered with using vari-speed effects.
Three of its songs were released as singles: "Coming Up", a UK number 2 and US number 1, "Waterfalls", a UK top 10, and "Temporary Secretary"; the first two were accompanied by music videos. Critics initially gave McCartney II largely unfavourable reviews, being dismissed as self-indulgent and disappointing.
However, retrospective reception has been more positive and the album has become a cult favourite. Some critics credit it as ahead of its time and a forerunner to the sound of 1980s pop.…
McCartney II is the third solo studio album by the English musician Paul McCartney, released on 16 May 1980. McCartney envisioned it as an experiment and did not intend to release it commercially, following his disillusionment with his band Wings. He recorded it in the summer of 1979 at his home studio in Peasmarsh and Campbeltown.
Like his debut solo studio album, McCartney (1970), he produced, engineered and performed all the instruments himself. Originally intended to be a double album, McCartney trimmed it to a single album for commercial reasons. One of its outtakes was the 1979 non-album single "Wonderful Christmastime".
The album was a significant departure for McCartney, relying heavily on synthesisers and studio experimentation, while its musical style embraces new wave and elements of electronica and synth-pop. McCartney's vocals were tinkered with using vari-speed effects.
Three of its songs were released as singles: "Coming Up", a UK number 2 and US number 1, "Waterfalls", a UK top 10, and "Temporary Secretary"; the first two were accompanied by music videos. Critics initially gave McCartney II largely unfavourable reviews, being dismissed as self-indulgent and disappointing.
However, retrospective reception has been more positive and the album has become a cult favourite. Some critics credit it as ahead of its time and a forerunner to the sound of 1980s pop. In 2011, an expanded edition of McCartney II was issued with over a dozen bonus tracks.
In 2020, the album was succeeded by McCartney III. In 2022, the trilogy was reissued in the McCartney I II III box set.
Music and lyrics
Featuring arrangements that are heavy on synthesisers, McCartney II has been said to represent McCartney's "acceptance of new wave", and has been described as "airless proto-electronica". The album is often experimental, with most of its songs having been described as strange "eccentric synthpop".
Although McCartney denies any direct influences on the album, he admired the "eccentricity" and "not-mainstream attitude" of Talking Heads' David Byrne. McCartney was also inspired by experimental composers John Cage, Cornelius Cardew and Luciano Berio; McCartney explained: "I went to their concerts in London because I had plenty of time on my hands so it was the kind of thing I would go and see.
Again, just to see what it was about, not necessarily because I was a massive fan. It was more like: what is a prepared piano? Oh, that's what it is.
You know, funky stuff like that." According to Stephen Dalton of The Quietus, parts of the album are reminiscent of krautrock and "the whole post-punk disco boom", and described most of the album as "an alluringly weird mash-up of trip-hop, Krautrock and synth-pop." McCartney said that, "rather than me emulating anyone, it was more a question of me seeing what I could do with it.
And again, not necessarily thinking I was making an album, just to have some time to experiment. These days I would say that with the Fireman project. So I've always been into that – if you go from 'Tomorrow Never Knows' through McCartney I, McCartney II, the Fireman..."
Many of the most synthesised tracks are instrumentals which have been described as ambient; journalist Stephen Thomas Erlewine compared them "to a sprightly variation" of the instrumentals from the second side of Low (1977) by David Bowie, albeit with a warmer, less menacing sound.
Release and promotion
McCartney II was released in the UK on 16 May and in the US on 22 May 1980. The album cover is a grainy, mug shot-style image of Paul photographed by Linda during a Wings photoshoot in the summer of 1979. To promote the album, Paul conducted various interviews with British journalists and music critics.
These included one with Tim Rice, which was filmed in May 1980 for the Meet Paul McCartney television special and aired by ITV in August and October; one with Nicky Horne for the programme Thames At Six; one with Paul Gambaccini for Rolling Stone magazine, published in July; and one with Vic Garbarini, which appeared as a limited-edition LP titled The McCartney Interview. The LP was released on 4 December 1980 in the US and on 23 February 1981 in the UK, where it charted at number 34 and 158, respectively.
McCartney II performed well commercially. The album debuted in the UK at number one on the UK Albums Chart, becoming McCartney's first number-one there since Venus and Mars (1975); it was certified gold by the British Phonographic Industry (BPI) for selling 100,000 copies. EMI reported that the album was on track to equal the sales of Band on the Run (1973).
In the US, initial sales were strong and the album reached number three in its second week on the Billboard Top LPs & Tapes album chart, where it remained for five weeks. The album quickly dropped down the charts and was off the Billboard chart after 19 weeks, McCartney's shortest run since Wild Life (1971). It was one of his lowest-selling albums in the US up to that point.
Nevertheless, it was certified gold by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA). Elsewhere, McCartney II reached number 2 in France, number 5 in New Zealand, Norway and Sweden, number 6 in Australia, number 7 in Spain and number 8 in Japan.
Singles
"Coming Up" was released as the lead single on 11 April 1980, with a live version of the song by Wings, recorded in Glasgow on 17 December 1979, as the B-side. Columbia Records chose the live version as the A-side, believing McCartney's vocal stylings were more recognisable; the single was packaged in copies of McCartney II in the US. The single was a major success, reaching number 2 in the UK and number 1 in the US, where it was certified gold by the RIAA.
Elsewhere, "Coming Up" reached number 1 in Canada and number 2 in Australia. The song was accompanied by a music video directed by Keith MacMillan. In it, Paul (in ten different roles) and Linda (as two backup singers) perform as "the Plastic Macs".
Paul imitates several musicians, including Hank Marvin of the Shadows, Ron Mael of Sparks, and a Beatle-era version of himself. "Waterfalls" was released as the album's second single on 13 June 1980, with "Check My Machine" as the B-side".
The song reached number 9 in the UK but failed to chart on US Billboard Hot 100, appearing only on the "bubbling under" the Billboard Hot 100 at number 106 for one week. A music video was made, which adapted the song's lyrics; it was shot on a set in Wandsworth Common and features a polar bear borrowed from Chipperfield's Circus.
"Temporary Secretary" was released in September 1980 as a 12" single in Britain, limited to 25,000 copies; it sold out within 16 hours. Jeff Cummins of Hipgnosis created the single's artwork.
Critical reception
The critical reception to McCartney II was mostly negative. Many critics found the album slight, with its experimental, synth-based compositions and its handful of instrumentals. Record World magazine described it as "arguably the least well-received solo work of any Beatle".
Some described it as self-indulgent. Marshall Fine, in the San Bernardino County Sun, called McCartney II a "terrible" album that "sets new standards for both tedium and self-indulgence". He believed it was worse than Ringo Starr and George Harrison's worst projects.
Writing for Rolling Stone, Stephen Holden said that the album was "passable" as a "novelty", ultimately arguing that it stands as "an album of aural doodles designed for the amusement of very young children". In the Los Angeles Times, Robert Hilburn called the album an embarrassment that has less impact than the original McCartney.
Still, he recommended fans not to give up on McCartney: "Remember: Band on the Run followed Wild Life." Billboard was mixed, finding McCartney II a record of "pop insignificance" like Back to the Egg and London Town (1978). The reviewer found the lyrics weak, the melodies impenetrable and most of the songs "cute throwaways".
In a very negative review for NME, Danny Baker said: "McCartney II isn't worth the plastic it's printed on. Neither is Paul, but he'll go on doodling and fooling his public because they're too frightened to ditch him and his past and he's too rich to be stopped."
In a more positive review, Rosalind Russell of Record Mirror found greater appreciation for the record's "low key approach" after a second listen. She enjoyed some of the songs' "comfortable qualit[ies]", naming "Waterfalls". She summarised by saying: "If your expectations are formulated from the sleeve, you'll find it's sailing under false colours."
Sounds magazine's Phil Sutcliffe, who disliked most of McCartney's work with Wings, believed McCartney II was an artistic improvement and succeeded because McCartney worked entirely alone. He ultimately believed he could become better by embracing deeper emotional inspection in future works.
Both Russell and Sutcliffe disliked the two instrumentals, with the former describing them as experimental throwaways.
Retrospective reviews and legacy
Retrospective reviews have rated the album more highly, and it has become a cult favourite. Some writers credit it as ahead of its time and a forerunner to the sound of 1980s pop.
Although Pitchfork Joe Tangari questioned the album's true impact on 1980s synth-pop, "its diffuse and slightly wobbly atmosphere certainly aligns with a great deal of recent music made on synths and drum machines". Ash Akhtar of The Quietus argued that while McCartney and McCartney II could be considered self-indulgent, they represented points in time where McCartney had to find himself.
In a more mixed assessment, senior AllMusic editor Stephen Thomas Erlewine believed that the album retrospectively sounds "muddled", "confused" and "forced", with its "lack of memorable melodies... accentuated by the stiff electronics [being] not innovative at the time and are even more awkward in the present". Nevertheless, Erlewine appreciated McCartney's adventurousness after years of "formulaic pop" in Wings.
John Blaney wrote that with McCartney II, McCartney's attempts at the avant-garde suffered from his knowledge of melody, resulting in a record that "sits uncomfortably between the unconventional and the commonplace". The biographer Howard Sounes believed that McCartney II was an improvement over recent Wings releases and a "generally strong" record with "less filler".
In 2003, Mojo placed the album at number 26 on their list of the "Top 50 Eccentric Albums". In 2014, NME included the album on their list of "101 Albums to Hear Before You Die", whose list entries were chosen by different musicians; McCartney II was picked by Austin Williams of Swim Deep.
In 2018, Pitchfork ranked it at number 186 in their list of "The 200 Best Albums of the 1980s". They called it a "strange, guileless wisp of a synth-pop record" and wrote that although "[o]riginally derided as a novelty, McCartney II is now remarkable in its prescience of the lo-fi and bedroom pop movements."
Influence
McCartney II was described as an influence on Hot Chip's album Made in the Dark (2008), especially with songs like "Wrestlers", "Bendable Poseable", "Whistle for Will" and "We're Looking for a Lot of Love". "Now There Is Nothing" from the band's later album In Our Heads (2012) has been described as a homage to McCartney II, with their guitarist Al Doyle explaining the song has "quite deliberately quirky time signature changes and key changes and these sort of very wandering harmonies—very typical of that period and McCartney productions."
Alexis Taylor of the group has described McCartney II as one of his favourite albums of all time. The album has also been championed by multiple other musicians such as disc jockey Erol Alkan, Chris Carter of Throbbing Gristle, Gruff Rhys of Super Furry Animals and Ty Bulmer of New Young Pony Club.
Track listing
All songs are written by Paul McCartney. Side one "Coming Up" – 3:53 "Temporary Secretary" – 3:14 "On the Way" – 3:38 "Waterfalls" – 4:43 "Nobody Knows" – 2:52 Side two "Front Parlour" – 3:32 "Summer's Day Song" – 3:25 "Frozen Jap" – 3:40 "Bogey Music" – 3:27 "Darkroom" – 2:20 "One of These Days" – 3:35 Additional tracks on the 1993 CD reissue "Check My Machine" – 5:50 "Secret Friend" – 10:31 "Goodnight Tonight" – 4:15
Reissues
McCartney II was first issued on CD in the UK on 5 October 1987, along with the Wings albums Wild Life and Red Rose Speedway. The initial issue of McCartney II featured "Check My Machine" and "Secret Friend" as bonus tracks.
In 1993, McCartney II was remastered and reissued on CD as part of The Paul McCartney Collection series with Wings' 1979 hit "Goodnight Tonight" added as a third bonus track. When the new remastered version was released on 13 June 2011 as part of the Paul McCartney Archive Collection, the album re-entered the UK charts at number 108.
McCartney and McCartney II were followed by McCartney III in 2020, which McCartney recorded in isolation during the COVID-19 pandemic. All three albums were reissued on 5 August 2022 in a box set entitled McCartney I II III, consisting of three LPs or three CDs.
Personnel
Paul McCartney – all vocals and instrumentation, engineer, mixing Linda McCartney – additional vocals Eddie Klein – mixing assistant
Weekly charts
Original release Reissue
Certifications and sales
Notes A ^ Until January 1987, the Japanese album chart had been separated into LP, CD and cassette charts. McCartney II also entered the cassette chart, peaking at number 13.
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378856192 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
6 claims could not be tied to a specific sentence and are listed in the table below instead.
- ↩Wikipedia “McCartney II” release date (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL