Lesson plan

Non-identity problem

, who first outlined the problem in 1984. The non-identity problem (also called the paradox of future individuals ) is a problem in population ethics concerning actions that affect the existence, identity, or well-being of future people. It arises from the observation that even small changes can alter the timing and circumstances of child conception, leading to entirely different individuals coming into existence, similarly to the butterfly effect in chaos theory. Actions affecting future generations will thus not simply affect the welfare of individuals, but rather cause different individuals to come into existence. The problem was described and explored by Derek Parfit in his 1984 book Reasons and Persons. It is a challenge to person-affecting views, which are based on the intuition that "what is bad must be bad for someone". An example proposed by Parfit involves thinking of two policies: "conservation" and "depletion". In the depletion strategy, current generations have a slightly higher quality of life, but unchecked use of natural resources eventually leads to depletion, significantly degrading the welfare of future generations. Parfit argues that person-affecting views would favor the depletion policy because it benefits current generations of identifiable people, even though the conservation policy is generally considered ethically superior.…

Back to article

Article summary

, who first outlined the problem in 1984. The non-identity problem (also called the paradox of future individuals ) is a problem in population ethics concerning actions that affect the existence, identity, or well-being of future people. It arises from the observation that even small changes can alter the timing and circumstances of child conception, leading to entirely different individuals coming into existence, similarly to the butterfly effect in chaos theory. Actions affecting future generations will thus not simply affect the welfare of individuals, but rather cause different individuals to come into existence. The problem was described and explored by Derek Parfit in his 1984 book Reasons and Persons. It is a challenge to person-affecting views, which are based on the intuition that "what is bad must be bad for someone". An example proposed by Parfit involves thinking of two policies: "conservation" and "depletion". In the depletion strategy, current generations have a slightly higher quality of life, but unchecked use of natural resources eventually leads to depletion, significantly degrading the welfare of future generations. Parfit argues that person-affecting views would favor the depletion policy because it benefits current generations of identifiable people, even though the conservation policy is generally considered ethically superior.…

Key claims

No claims recorded.

Discussion questions

  1. Summarise the article in your own words. Which single claim would you verify first, and why?
  2. Which claim in this article is most likely to be revised as the sources update? How would you check its current status?
  3. If two sources disagreed about one of these facts, what would you need in order to trust one over the other?

Bibliography

No sources recorded.

Key claims and bibliography are generated from the same tracked claims and sources as the article page.