Non-linear effects

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 10 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

In enantioselective synthesis, a non-linear effect refers to a process in which the enantiopurity of the catalyst (or the chiral auxiliary) does not correlate linearly with the enantiopurity of the product produced. This deviation from linearity is described as the non-linear effect, NLE. The linearity can be expressed mathematically, as shown in Equation 1. Stereoselection (i.e. the ee product ) that is higher or lower than the enantiomeric excess of the catalyst (ee catalyst , relative to the equation) is considered non-routine behavior. : ee_\text{product}=ee_{\max}ee_\text{catalyst} For an ideal asymmetric reaction, the ee product may be described as the product of ee max multiplied by the ee catalyst . This is not the case for reactions exhibiting NLE's. In 1976, Wynberg and Feringa observed different chemical behavior in the reaction of an enantiopure and racemic substrate in a phenol coupling reaction. In 1981, Kagan and collaborators described the first non-linear effects in asymmetric catalysis and gave rational explanations for these phenomena. General definitions and mathematical models are essential for understanding nonlinear effects and their application to specific chemical reactions. In recent decades, the study of nonlinear effects has helped elucidate reaction mechanism and guide synthetic applications.

In enantioselective synthesis, a non-linear effect refers to a process in which the enantiopurity of the catalyst (or the chiral auxiliary) does not correlate linearly with the enantiopurity of the product produced. This deviation from linearity is described as the non-linear effect, NLE. The linearity can be expressed mathematically, as shown in Equation 1. Stereoselection (i.e. the ee product ) that is higher or lower than the enantiomeric excess of the catalyst (ee catalyst , relative to the equation) is considered non-routine behavior. ee_\text{product}=ee_{\max}ee_\text{catalyst} For an ideal asymmetric reaction, the ee product may be described as the product of ee max multiplied by the ee catalyst . This is not the case for reactions exhibiting NLE's. In 1976, Wynberg and Feringa observed different chemical behavior in the reaction of an enantiopure and racemic substrate in a phenol coupling reaction. In 1981, Kagan and collaborators described the first non-linear effects in asymmetric catalysis and gave rational explanations for these phenomena. General definitions and mathematical models are essential for understanding nonlinear effects and their application to specific chemical reactions. In recent decades, the study of nonlinear effects has helped elucidate reaction mechanism and guide synthetic applications.

Types of non-linear effects

Modeling non-linear effects

In 1986, Henri B. Kagan and coworkers observed a series of known reactions that followed a non-ideal behavior. A correction factor, f, was adapted to Equation 1 to fit the kinetic behavior of reactions with NLEs (Equation 2). ee_\text{product}=f\,ee_{\max}ee_\text{catalyst} Equation 2: A general mathematical equation that describes non-linear behavior Unfortunately, Equation 2 is too general to apply to specific chemical reactions. Due to this, Kagan and coworkers also developed simplified mathematical models to describe the behavior of catalysts which lead to non-linear effects. These models involve generic ML n species, based on a metal (M) bound to n number of enantiomeric ligands (L). The type of ML n model varies among asymmetric reactions, based on the goodness of fit with reaction data. With accurate modeling, NLE may elucidate mechanistic details of an enantioselective, catalytic reaction. {{image frame|content= \begin{align} & \begin{matrix} \mathrm{M}+\mathrm{L}_R+\mathrm{L}_S\quad\rightleftharpoons\quad & \mathrm{ML}_R\mathrm{L}_R & + & \mathrm{ML}_S\mathrm{L}_S & + & \mathrm{ML}_R\mathrm{L}_S & \\ & x & & y & & z & \left\}\quad\overset{}{\text{concentrations}}\right. \\ & \\ & \left\downarrow \begin{matrix} \\ \mathrm{r}_{RR} \\ \\ \end{matrix} \right. && \left\downarrow \begin{matrix} \\ \mathrm{r}_{SS} \\ \\ \end{matrix} \right. && \left\downarrow \begin{matrix} \\ \mathrm{r}_{RS} \\ \\ \end{matrix} \right. & \left\}\quad\overset{}{\text{rates}}\right.\qquad\qquad \\ \end{matrix} \\ \\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\;\;\;\;\;\text{reaction products} \\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\;\;\;\;\;\text{ee}_\text{product} \\ \\ & \text{Equilibrium constant: }K=\frac{z^2}{xy} \end{align} |align=center|width=550|caption=The basic scheme of an ML 2 model developed by H. B. Kagan }} The equilibrium constant that describes this equilibrium, K, is presumably independent on the catalytic chemical reaction. In Kagan's model, K is determined by the amount of aggregation present in the chemical environment. A K=4 is considered to be the state at which there is a statistical distribution of ligands to each metal complex. In other words, there is no thermodynamic disadvantage or advantage to the formation of heterochiral complexes at K=4. Obeying the same kinetic rate law, each of the three catalytic complexes catalyze the desired reaction to form product. As enantiomers of each other, the homochiral complexes catalyze the reaction at the same rate, although opposite absolute configuration of the product is induced (i.e. r RR =r SS ). The heterochiral complex, however, forms a racemic product at a different rate constant (i.e. r RS ). ee_\text{product}=ee_\text{max} ee_\text{auxiliary} (1+\beta)/(1+g\,\beta) In the correction factor, Kagan and co-workers introduced two new parameters absent in Equation 1, β and g. In general, these parameters represent the concentration and activity of three catalytic complexes relative to each other. β represents the relative amount of the heterochiral complex (ML R L S ) as shown in Equation 3. It is important to recognize that the equilibrium constant K is independent on both β and g. As described by Donna Blackmond at Scripps Research Institute, "the parameter K is an inherent property of the catalyst mixture, independent of the ee catalyst . K is also independent of the catalytic reaction itself, and therefore independent of the parameter g." \beta=z/(x+y) Equation 3: The correction factor, β, may be described as z, the heterochiral complex concentration, divided by x and y, the respective concentrations of the complex concentration divided by x and y, the respective concentrations of the homochiral complexes The parameter g represents the reactivity of the heterochiral complex relative to the homochiral complexes. As shown in Equation 5, this may be described in terms of rate constants. Since the homochiral complexes react at identical rates, g can then be described as the rate constant corresponding to the heterochiral complex divided by the rate constant corresponding to either homochiral complex. g=r_{rs}/r_{rr} Equation 4: The correction parameter, g, can be described as the rate of product formation with the heterochiral catalyst ML R L S divided by the rate of product formation of the homochiral complex (ML R L R or ML S L S ). If β=0 or g=1, the ML 2 equation simplifies to the Equation 1. No meso catalyst complex is present or active. Therefore, the simple additive properties should apply to such a scenario to establish a linear relationship between product enantioselectivity and the enantiopurity of the chiral catalyst. If the correction factor is greater than one, the reaction displays an asymmetric amplification, also known as a positive non-linear effect. Under the ML 2 model, a (+)-NLE infers a less reactive heterochiral catalyst. In this case, the equilibrium constant K also increases as the correction factor increases. Although the product enantioselectivity is relatively high compared to the enantiopurity of the chiral catalyst, this comes at a cost of the overall reaction rate. In order to achieve an asymmetric amplification, there must be a relatively large concentration of the heterochiral complex. In addition, this heterochiral complex must have a substantially slower rate of reactivity, r RS . Therefore, the reactive catalytic species should decrease in concentration, leading to an overall slower reaction rate. If the correction factor is less than one, the reaction displays an asymmetric depletion, also known as a negative non-linear effect. In this scenario, the heterochiral catalyst is relatively more reactive than the homochiral catalyst complexes. In this case, the (−)-NLE may result in an overall faster although less selective product formation. iv. Reaction Kinetics with the ML 2 Model: Following H.B. Kagan's publication of the ML 2 model, Professor Donna Blackmond at Scripps demonstrated how this model could be used to also calculate the overall reaction rates. With these relative reaction rates, Blackmond showed how the ML 2 model could be used to formulate kinetic predictions which could then be compared to experimental data. The overall rate equation, Equation 6, is shown below. r=(x+y+gz)r_{RR} In addition to the goodness of fit to the model, kinetic information about the overall reaction may further validate the proposed reaction mechanism. For instance, a positive NLE in the ML 2 should result in an overall lower reaction rate. By solving the reaction rate from Equation 6, one can confirm if that is the case. {{image frame|content= \ce{{M} + {L_R} + L_S }\ \underbrace\ce{ML_R L_R L_R}_x + \underbrace\ce{ML_S L_S L_S}_y + \underbrace\ce{ML_R L_R L_S}_z + \underbrace\ce{ML_S L_S L_R}_w |align=center|width=550|caption=Figure 7: The equilibrium between the unbound species and the reactive catalytic species in the ML 3 model.}} EE_\text{prod}=EE_0 ee_\text{aux}\frac{3+3\,g\,EE'_0/EE_0+(1-3\,g\,EE'_0/EE_0)ee_\text{aux}^2}{1+3\,g+3(1-g)ee_\text{aux}^2} Figure 8: The mathematical formula describing an ML 3 system. The ee product is calculated by multiplying the ee max by the correction factor developed by Kagan and co-workers.

Early Examples of the Non-Linear Effect

Prebiotic Catalysis and the Non-linear Effect

In pre-biotic chemistry, autocatalytic systems play a significant rule in understanding the origin of chirality in life. An autocatalytic reaction, a reaction in which the product acts as a catalyst for itself, serves as a model for homochirality. The asymmetric Soai reaction is commonly referred to as chemical plausibility for this pre-biotic hypothesis. In this system, an asymmetric amplification is observed during the process of autocatalytic catalysis. Professor Donna Blackmond has studied the NLE of this reaction extensively using Kagan's ML 2 model. From this mathematical analysis, Blackmond was able to conclude that a dimeric, homochiral complex was the active catalyst in promoting homochirality for the Soai reaction.

Notes

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1379011775 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Provenance

snapshot enwiki-001379011775 · captured 1791362382.0 · version history

Cite this page as: encyclopegia.org, “Non-linear effects”, snapshot enwiki-001379011775. https://encyclopegia.org/a/non-linear-effects

Sources cited in this revision

4 named source(s) extracted from the cited revision. A source with no author is shown by its publication; nothing is invented.