NSEL case
≈ 9 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
National Spot Exchange Limited (NSEL) case relates to a payment default at the National Spot Exchange Limited that occurred in 20131 involving Financial Technologies India Ltd, when a payment default took place after a commodities market regulator, the Forward Markets Commission (FMC), directed NSEL to stop launching contracts. This led to the closure of the Exchange in July 2013. Three spot exchanges, NSEL, NSPOT and National APMC were exempted by the government under Section 27 of FCRA to conduct forward trading in one day contracts.
This was done to boost volumes so that their economic viability improved. While Financial Technologies (India) promoted NSEL, it was granted general exemption on 5 June 2007, whereas, NSPOT and National APMC received exemptions under the same provisions on 23 July 2008, and 11 August 2010, respectively. On the flawed recommendations of the FMC, the Ministry of Consumer Affairs ordered NSEL to settle all existing contracts and not launch any fresh contracts, which led to the crisis.
Investigations led by the Enforcement Directorate and Economic Offences Wing (EOW) revealed the role of brokers and defaulters in the NSEL case. The brokers mis-sold NSEL products to their clients by assuring them fixed returns. The defaulters hypothecated stocks, produced fake warehouse receipts and siphoned the entire default money.…
National Spot Exchange Limited (NSEL) case relates to a payment default at the National Spot Exchange Limited that occurred in 2013 involving Financial Technologies India Ltd, when a payment default took place after a commodities market regulator, the Forward Markets Commission (FMC), directed NSEL to stop launching contracts. This led to the closure of the Exchange in July 2013. Three spot exchanges, NSEL, NSPOT and National APMC were exempted by the government under Section 27 of FCRA to conduct forward trading in one day contracts.
This was done to boost volumes so that their economic viability improved. While Financial Technologies (India) promoted NSEL, it was granted general exemption on 5 June 2007, whereas, NSPOT and National APMC received exemptions under the same provisions on 23 July 2008, and 11 August 2010, respectively. On the flawed recommendations of the FMC, the Ministry of Consumer Affairs ordered NSEL to settle all existing contracts and not launch any fresh contracts, which led to the crisis.
Investigations led by the Enforcement Directorate and Economic Offences Wing (EOW) revealed the role of brokers and defaulters in the NSEL case. The brokers mis-sold NSEL products to their clients by assuring them fixed returns. The defaulters hypothecated stocks, produced fake warehouse receipts and siphoned the entire default money. Initially, it was projected that there were 13,000 trading clients affected by the NSEL crisis. The genuineness and entitlement of these 13,000 trading clients is questionable.
The brokers have not shown the Know Your Customer details of any of the clients. The Bombay High Court suggested that brokers should furnish this data to NSEL in order to protect interest of genuine claimants. Considering this aspect, SFIO which is also investigating the case, has recently asked brokers and trading clients to provide various information in a specific format which also includes KYC related information. On 30 July 2019, The Bombay High Court summoned P. Chidambaram, the former Union Finance Minister and two other bureaucrats, K.P.
Krishnan and Ramesh Abhishek, regarding the ₹10,000 crore damage suits filed by 63 moons technologies and their role in the NSEL payment default crisis. The Bombay High Court has accepted the plea and allowed 63 Moons to sue Chidambaram and the others.
History
Pursuant to the then Prime Minister's vision to create a single market across the country for both manufactured and agricultural produce, NSEL (National Spot Exchange Limited) was conceptualized in the year 2004. According to the Economic Surveys of the government done in 2003–2006, 3 consecutive years of survey also recommended setting up a national-level, integrated market for agricultural products, as did the planning commission, which was aware of the benefits of the spot markets.
This was followed by the Rangarajan Committee, which too sought a national spot market. Following the invitation from Ministry of Consumer Affairs (MCA), the Multi Commodities Exchange Ltd. (MCX) which was earlier a sister company of NSEL, submitted a project report for establishing a nationwide spot market for commodities. NSEL was set up as a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956 on 18 May 2005 with its registered office in the State of Maharashtra. NSEL was incorporated by MCX and the nominees of FTIL.
Subsequently, in view of the regulatory concerns between regulated commodities exchanges holding equity shareholding in spot exchanges, the shareholding of MCX and nominees were transferred and consolidated later in 2005 with FTIL. On 5 June 2007, NSEL was approved as a Spot Exchange by Department of Consumer Affairs. National Spot Exchange Limited (NSEL), commenced live trading on 15 October 2008, and was the first commodity spot exchange of the country.
Within a few years, as many as six state governments issued licences under the model Agricultural Produce Market Committees (APMC) Act to NSEL, because their own APMCs mostly short-changed the poor farmers. NSEL turned out to be a boon for such farmers because they could now sell their produce at competitive rates and make better profits. The Exchange was promoted by National Agricultural Cooperative Marketing Federation of India. In August 2011, FMC was appointed as the ‘designated agency’ to fill the regulatory vacuum in the commodities market.
A series of bizarre actions by the FMC spooked the market and as a result NSEL had to suspend the trading of all contracts on 31 July 2013
Allegation on investigative agencies and the government
The investors of NSEL formed an organization by the name of NIF in the month of August 2013. However investors who were dissatisfied with brokers’ role in NIF formed a pure investors’ organization by the name of NIAG (NSEL Investors Action Group). The NIAG has written multiple letters to Enforcement Directorate and CBI alleging lax and compromised investigation. A Delhi PMLA Appellate Tribunal on 17 September 2019, directed that a provisional attachment by the Enforcement Directorate in 2016-2017 of over Rs 1,000 crore assets belonging to Jignesh Shah headed 63 moons technologies be quashed and the assets released. The action came in response to an appeal filed by the company. The order was passed by Justice Manmohan Singh, chairman of the tribunal along with member G C Mishra.
The roles of involved parties
Judgements and orders
On 21 October 2014, invoking Section 396 of the Companies Act, 1956, the Ministry of Corporate affairs announced a draft order for merger of NSEL, a subsidiary of FTIL. All stakeholders were given 60 days to report to MCA. FTIL challenged this merger in Bombay HC. Hearing an application filed by the government, the Bench comprising Justices SC Dharmadhikari and BP Colabawala granted the govt time till 15 February 2016. On 12 February 2016, the MCA passed the final order of merger between FTIL and NSEL.
The order was challenged by FTIL in Bombay High Court and it was upheld . On 30 April 2019, the Supreme Court set aside the Bombay High Court's decision and quashed the compulsory amalgamation of NSEL with FTIL. The Court held that the Central Government had failed to establish the requisite public interest for exercising its power of compulsory amalgamation under Section 396 of the Companies Act, 1956 .
Based on MCA's own circular dated 20 April 2011, it is a known fact that for any merger to materialize, permission of 100% shareholders and 90% creditors needs to be obtained. By forcing the merger on 63,000 shareholders of FTIL without so much as giving them a chance to consent/object to the amalgamation, MCA not only went against its own circular but also against Article 14 of the Constitution. The forced merger violates the sacrosanct concept of ‘limited liability’ and is not in public interest.
Third, the "corporate veil" between NSEL and FTIL cannot be lifted until the so-called "parental fraud" by FTIL is proven in a court of law. In a significant judgement, the apex court decided against the forced merger of NSEL and FTIL that was ordered by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs, which was the first ever instance of invocation of Section 396 of the Companies Act 1956.
The Union Ministry had ordered the compulsory amalgamation of National Spot Exchange Ltd (NSEL) and its parent company Financial Technologies India Ltd, currently known as 63 Moons Technology Limited. Justice Rohinton Fali Nariman and Justice Vineet Saran set aside the Bombay High Court's judgment on amalgamating the two companies. The centre had issued a final order for the merger in the light of public interest.
However, the Supreme Court reckoned that the merger doesn't satisfy the criteria of ‘public interest’ and laid down a set of guidelines on what ‘public interest’ would amount to.
References
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1376709165 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “NSEL case” date of formation (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL