Nuclear reprocessing

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 20 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

nuclear reprocessing site, UK Nuclear reprocessing is the chemical separation of fission products and actinides from spent nuclear fuel. Originally, reprocessing was used to extract plutonium for producing nuclear weapons. With commercialization of nuclear power, reprocessed plutonium was recycled into MOX nuclear fuel for thermal reactors. Reprocessed uranium can in principle be re-used as fuel. Nuclear reprocessing may include the reprocessing of other nuclear reactor material, such as Zircaloy cladding. The high radioactivity of spent fuel means that reprocessing must be controlled and executed in advanced facilities by specialized personnel. Numerous processes exist, dominated by the chemical-based PUREX process. Alternatives include heating to drive off volatile elements, oxidation, and fluoride volatility (which uses reactive fluorine gas). Each process results in some form of refined nuclear product, with radioactive waste as a byproduct. Because this could allow production of weapons grade nuclear material, nuclear reprocessing is a concern for nuclear proliferation. Spent fuel reprocessing is relatively expensive compared to the once-through fuel cycle, but fuel use can be increased and waste volumes decreased. Reprocessing is performed routinely in Europe, Russia, and Japan.…

nuclear reprocessing site, UK Nuclear reprocessing is the chemical separation of fission products and actinides from spent nuclear fuel. Originally, reprocessing was used to extract plutonium for producing nuclear weapons. With commercialization of nuclear power, reprocessed plutonium was recycled into MOX nuclear fuel for thermal reactors. Reprocessed uranium can in principle be re-used as fuel. Nuclear reprocessing may include the reprocessing of other nuclear reactor material, such as Zircaloy cladding. The high radioactivity of spent fuel means that reprocessing must be controlled and executed in advanced facilities by specialized personnel. Numerous processes exist, dominated by the chemical-based PUREX process. Alternatives include heating to drive off volatile elements, oxidation, and fluoride volatility (which uses reactive fluorine gas). Each process results in some form of refined nuclear product, with radioactive waste as a byproduct. Because this could allow production of weapons grade nuclear material, nuclear reprocessing is a concern for nuclear proliferation. Spent fuel reprocessing is relatively expensive compared to the once-through fuel cycle, but fuel use can be increased and waste volumes decreased. Reprocessing is performed routinely in Europe, Russia, and Japan. The United States halted commercial reprocessing plans in the 1970s but has continued to pursue reprocessing-related scientific research. Most nuclear fuel does not require reprocessing. Breeder reactors can use recycled plutonium and uranium as well as other actinides, closing the nuclear fuel cycle and potentially multiplying the energy extracted from natural uranium by ~60-fold and dramatically reducing long-lived high-level radioactive waste. Spent nuclear fuel contains abundant fertile uranium and traces of fissile materials. Methods such as the PUREX process can be used to remove useful actinides for the production of active nuclear fuel. Another option is to reuse specific isotopes. Caesium-137, strontium-90 and other isotopes are extracted for food irradiation and radioisotope thermoelectric generators. While re-use does not eliminate the need to manage radioisotopes, it can reduce the quantity of remaining waste.

History

The first large-scale nuclear reactors were built during World War II. These reactors were designed for the production of plutonium for use in nuclear weapons. The only reprocessing required, therefore, was the extraction of the plutonium (free of fission-product contamination) from the spent natural uranium fuel. In 1943, several methods were proposed for separating the relatively small quantity of plutonium from the uranium and fission products. The first method selected, a precipitation process called the bismuth phosphate process, was developed and tested at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) between 1943 and 1945 to produce quantities of plutonium for evaluation and use in the US weapons programs. ORNL produced the first macroscopic quantities (grams) of separated plutonium with these processes. The bismuth phosphate process was first operated on a large scale at the Hanford Site, in the later part of 1944. It was successful for plutonium separation in the emergency situation existing then, but it had a significant weakness: the inability to recover uranium. The first successful solvent extraction process for the recovery of pure uranium and plutonium was developed at ORNL in 1949. The PUREX process is the current method of extraction. Separation plants were also constructed at Savannah River Site and a smaller plant at West Valley Reprocessing Plant which closed by 1972 because of its inability to meet new regulatory requirements. Reprocessing of civilian fuel has long been employed at the COGEMA La Hague site in France, the Sellafield site in the United Kingdom, the Mayak Chemical Combine in Russia, and at sites such as the Tokai plant in Japan, the Tarapur plant in India, and briefly at the West Valley Reprocessing Plant in the United States. In October 1976, concern of nuclear weapons proliferation (especially after India demonstrated nuclear weapons capabilities using reprocessing technology) led President Gerald Ford to issue a Presidential directive to indefinitely suspend the commercial reprocessing and recycling of plutonium in the U.S. On 7 April 1977, President Jimmy Carter banned the reprocessing of commercial reactor spent nuclear fuel. The key issue driving this policy was the risk of nuclear weapons proliferation by diversion of plutonium from the civilian fuel cycle, and to encourage other nations to follow the US lead. After that, only countries that already had large investments in reprocessing infrastructure continued to reprocess spent nuclear fuel. President Reagan lifted the ban in 1981, but did not provide the substantial subsidy that would have been necessary to start up commercial reprocessing. In March 1999, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) reversed its policy and signed a contract with a consortium of Duke Energy, COGEMA, and Stone & Webster (DCS) to design and operate a mixed oxide (MOX) fuel fabrication facility. Site preparation at the Savannah River Site (South Carolina) began in October 2005. In 2011 the New York Times reported "...11 years after the government awarded a construction contract, the cost of the project has soared to nearly $5 billion. The vast concrete and steel structure is a half-finished hulk, and the government has yet to find a single customer, despite offers of lucrative subsidies." TVA (currently the most likely customer) said in April 2011 that it would delay a decision until it could see how MOX fuel performed in the nuclear accident at Fukushima Daiichi.

Separation technologies

Water and organic solvents

PUREX

PUREX is the standard method as of 2026. It is an acronym standing for Plutonium and Uranium Recovery by EXtraction. The PUREX process is a liquid-liquid extraction method used to separately extract uranium and plutonium. When used on power reactor fuel, the plutonium extracted typically contains too much to be considered weapons-grade plutonium. Nevertheless, reliable nuclear weapons can be built at all sophistication levels using reactor-grade plutonium. Moreover, reactors that are capable of frequent refueling can be used to produce weapons-grade plutonium, which can be recovered using PUREX.

UREX

UREX (URanium EXtraction) process is a modified form of PUREX that can save space inside disposal sites by removing the uranium that makes up the majority of the mass and volume and recycling it. UREX avoids separating pure plutonium. This can be done by adding a plutonium reductant before the first extraction step. In the UREX process, ~99.9% of the uranium and >95% of technetium are separated. The key is the addition of acetohydroxamic acid (AHA) to the extraction and scrub sections of the process. The addition of AHA diminishes the extractability of plutonium and neptunium, providing somewhat greater proliferation resistance than with PUREX.

TRUEX

Adding a second extraction agent, octyl(phenyl)-N, N-dibutyl carbamoylmethyl phosphine oxide (CMPO) in combination with tributylphosphate, (TBP), PUREX can become TRUEX (TRansUranic EXtraction). TRUEX was invented by Argonne National Laboratory and is designed to remove the transuranic metals (Americum/Curium) from waste. The idea is that by lowering alpha activity, the majority can be disposed of more easily. Like PUREX TRUEX operates by solvation.

DIAMEX

The DIAMEX (DIAMide EXtraction) process avoids the formation of organic materials that contains elements other than carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, and oxygen. Such organic waste can be burned without the formation of acidic gases. The French CEA works on DIAMEX. The process is sufficiently mature that an industrial plant could be constructed. DIAMEX operates by a solvation mechanism.

SANEX

Selective ActiNide EXtraction. As part of the management of minor actinides it has been proposed that the lanthanides and trivalent minor actinides should be removed from the PUREX raffinate by a process such as DIAMEX or TRUEX. To allow the actinides such as americium to be either reused in industrial sources or used as fuel, the lanthanides must be removed. Several lanthanides have large neutron cross-sections and poison a neutron-driven nuclear reactions. To date the extraction system has not been defined, but research groups are working towards a process. For instance CEA is working on a bis-triazinyl pyridine (BTP) process. Other systems such as dithiophosphinic acids are under investigation.

UNEX

The UNiversal EXtraction process was developed in Russia and the Czech Republic; it is designed to remove the most troublesome radioisotopes (strontium, caesium and minor actinides) from the raffinate remaining after the extraction of uranium and plutonium. The chemistry is based upon Cs and Sr interaction with polyethylene glycol and a cobalt carborane anion (known as chlorinated cobalt dicarbollide). The actinides are extracted by CMPO, with diluents such as a polar aromatic such as nitrobenzene. Other diluents such as meta-nitrobenzotrifluoride and phenyl trifluoromethyl sulfone have been suggested.

Obsolete methods

Alternatives to PUREX

Some alternatives are compatible with PUREX (i.e. the residue from one process could be used as feedstock for the other) while others are wholly incompatible. None of these had (as of the 2020s) reached widespread use, although large scale tests and firm commitments point towards their future implementation.

Electrolysis

The electrolysis methods are based on the difference in the standard potentials of uranium, plutonium and minor actinides in a molten salt. The standard potential of uranium is the lowest, therefore when a potential is applied, the uranium will be reduced at the cathode out of the molten salt solution before the other elements.

PYRO-A and -B for IFR

These processes were developed by Argonne National Laboratory and used in the Integral Fast Reactor project. PYRO-A is a means of separating actinides (elements within the actinide family, generally heavier than U-235) from non-actinides. The spent fuel is placed in an anode basket which is immersed in a molten salt electrolyte. An electric current is applied, causing the uranium metal (or sometimes oxide, depending on the spent fuel) to plate out on a solid metal cathode while the other actinides (and the rare earths) can be absorbed into a liquid cadmium cathode. Many of the fission products (such as caesium, zirconium and strontium) remain in the salt. As alternatives to the molten cadmium electrode it is possible to use a molten bismuth cathode, or a solid aluminium cathode. As an alternative to electrowinning, the wanted metal can be isolated by using a molten alloy of an electropositive metal and a less reactive metal. Since the majority of the long term radioactivity, and volume, of spent fuel comes from actinides, removing the actinides produces waste that is more compact, and not nearly as dangerous over the long term. The radioactivity of this waste will then drop to the level of various naturally occurring minerals and ores within a few hundred, rather than thousands of, years. The mixed actinides produced by pyrometallic processing can be used again as nuclear fuel, as they are virtually all either fissile, or fertile, though many of these materials would require a fast breeder reactor to be burned efficiently. In a thermal neutron spectrum, the concentrations of several heavy actinides (curium-242 and plutonium-240) can become quite high, creating fuel that is substantially different from the usual uranium or mixed uranium-plutonium oxides (MOX) that most current reactors were designed to use. Another pyrochemical process, the PYRO-B process, has been developed for the processing and recycling of fuel from a transmuter reactor ( a fast breeder reactor designed to convert transuranic nuclear waste into fission products ). A typical transmuter fuel is free from uranium and contains recovered transuranics in an inert matrix such as metallic zirconium. In the PYRO-B processing of such fuel, an electrorefining step is used to separate the residual transuranic elements from the fission products and recycle the transuranics to the reactor for fissioning. Newly generated technetium and iodine are extracted for incorporation into transmutation targets, and the other fission products are sent to waste.

Voloxidation

Voloxidation (for volumetric oxidation or volatile oxidation ) involves heating oxide fuel with oxygen, sometimes with alternating oxidation and reduction, or alternating oxidation by ozone to uranium trioxide with decomposition by heating back to triuranium octoxide. A major purpose is to capture tritium as tritiated water vapor before further processing where it would be difficult to retain the tritium. Tritium is a difficult contaminant to remove from aqueous solution, as it cannot be separated from water except by isotope separation. However, tritium is also a valuable product used in industry science and nuclear weapons, so recovery of a stream of hydrogen or water with a high tritium content can make targeted recovery economically worthwhile. Other volatile elements leave the fuel and must be recovered, especially iodine, technetium, and carbon-14. Voloxidation also breaks up the fuel or increases its surface area to enhance penetration of reagents in following reprocessing steps.

Disadvantages

Further processing is needed if the resulting product is to be used for re-enrichment or fabrication of MOX-fuel. If volatile fission products escape to the environment this presents a radiation hazard, mostly due to , Tritium and . Their safe recovery and storage requires further equipment. An oxidizing agent / reducing agent has to be used for reduction/oxidation steps whose recovery can be difficult, energy consuming or both.

Volatilization in isolation

Simply heating spent oxide fuel in an inert atmosphere or vacuum at a temperature between and as a first reprocessing step can remove several volatile elements, including caesium whose isotope caesium-137 emits about half of the heat produced by the spent fuel over the following 100 years of cooling (however, most of the other half is from strontium-90, which has a similar half-life). The estimated overall mass balance for 20,000 g of processed fuel with 2,000 g of cladding is:

Advantages

Requires no chemical processes at all. Can in theory be done "self heating" via the decay heat of sufficiently "fresh" spent fuel. Caesium-137 has uses in food irradiation and can be used to power radioisotope thermoelectric generators. However, its contamination with stable and long lived reduces efficiency of such uses while contamination with in relatively fresh spent fuel makes the curve of overall radiation and heat output much steeper until most of the has decayed. Can potentially recover elements like ruthenium whose ruthenate ion is particularly troublesome in PUREX and which has no isotopes significantly longer lived than a year, allowing possible recovery of the metal for use. A "third phase recovery" can be added to the process if substances that melt but don't vaporize at the temperatures involved are drained to a container for liquid effluents and allowed to re-solidify. To avoid contamination with low-boiling products which melt at low temperatures, a melt plug could be used to open the container for liquid effluents only once a certain temperature is reached by the liquid phase. Strontium, which is present in the form of the particularly troublesome mid-lived fission product is liquid above . However, Strontium oxide remains solid below and if strontium oxide is to be recovered with other liquid effluents, it has to be reduced to the native metal before the heating step. Both Strontium and Strontium oxide form soluble Strontium hydroxide and hydrogen upon contact with water, which can be used to separate them from non-soluble parts of the spent fuel.. As there are little to no chemical changes in the spent fuel, any chemical reprocessing methods can be used following this process

Disadvantages

At temperatures above the native metal form of several actinides, including neptunium (melting point: ) and plutonium (melting point: ), are molten. This could be used to recover a liquid phase, raising proliferation concerns, given that uranium metal remains a solid until . While neptunium and plutonium cannot be easily separated from each other by different melting points, their differing solubility in water can be used to separate them. If "nuclear self heating" is employed, the spent fuel with have much higher specific activity, heat production and radiation release. If an external heat source is used, significant amounts of external power are needed, which mostly go to heat the uranium. Heating and cooling the vacuum chamber and/or the piping and vessels to collect volatile effluents induces thermal stress. This combines with radiation damage to material and possibly neutron embrittlement if neutron sources such as californium-252 are present to a significant extent. In the commonly used oxide fuel, some elements will be present both as oxides and as native elements. Depending on their chemical state, they may end up in either the volatalized stream or in the residue stream. If an element is present in both states to a significant degree, separation of that element may be impossible without converting it all to one chemical state or the other. The temperatures involved are much higher than the melting point of lead ( ) which can present issues with radiation shielding if lead is employed as a shielding material. If filters are used to recover volatile fission products, those become low- to intermediate level waste.

Chloride volatility and solubility

Many of the elements that form volatile high-valence fluorides will also form volatile high-valence chlorides. Chlorination and distillation is another possible method for separation. The sequence of separation may differ usefully from the sequence for fluorides; for example, zirconium tetrachloride and tin tetrachloride have relatively low boiling points of and . Chlorination has even been proposed as a method for removing zirconium fuel cladding, instead of mechanical decladding. Chlorides are likely to be easier than fluorides to later convert back to other compounds, such as oxides. Chlorides remaining after volatilization may also be separated by solubility in water. Chlorides of alkaline elements like americium, curium, lanthanides, strontium, caesium are more soluble than those of uranium, neptunium, plutonium, and zirconium.

Advantages of halogen volatility

Chlorine (and to a lesser extent fluorine ) is a readily available industrial chemical that is produced in mass quantity. Fractional distillation allows many elements to be separated from each other in a single step or iterative repetition of the same step. Uranium will be produced directly as Uranium hexafluoride, the form used in enrichment. Many volatile fluorides and chlorides are volatile at relatively moderate temperatures reducing thermal stress. This is especially important as the boiling point of uranium hexafluoride is below that of water, allowing to conserve energy in the separation of high boiling fission products (or their fluorides) from one another as this can take place in the absence of uranium, which makes up the bulk of the mass. Some fluorides and chlorides melt at relatively low temperatures allowing a "liquid phase separation" if desired. Those low melting salts could be further processed by molten salt electrolysis. Fluorides and chlorides differ in water solubility depending on the cation. This can be used to separate them by aqueous solution. However, some fluorides violently react with water, which has to be taken into account.

Disadvantages of halogen volatility

Many compounds of fluorine or chlorine as well as the native elements themselves are toxic, corrosive and react violently with air, water or both. Uranium hexafluoride and Technetium hexafluoride have very similar boiling points ( and respectively), making it hard to completely separate them from one another by distillation. Fractional distillation as used in petroleum refining requires large facilities and huge amounts of energy. To process thousands of tons of uranium would require smaller facilities than processing billions of tons of petroleum however, unlike petroleum refineries, the entire process would have to take place inside radiation shielding and there would have to be provisions made to prevent leaks of volatile, poisonous and radioactive fluorides. Plutonium hexafluoride boils at this means that any facility capable of separating uranium hexafluoride from Technetium hexafluoride is capable of separating plutonium hexafluoride from either, raising proliferation concerns. The presence of alpha emitters induces some (α,n) reactions in fluorine, producing both radioactive and neutrons. This effect can be reduced by separating alpha emitters and fluorine as fast as feasible. Interactions between chlorine's two stable isotopes and on the one hand and alpha particles on the other are of lesser concern as they do not have as high a cross section and do not produce neutrons or long lived radionuclides. If carbon is present in the spent fuel it'll form halogenated hydrocarbons which are extremely potent greenhouse gases, and hard to chemically decompose. Some of those are toxic as well.

Radioanalytical separations

To determine the distribution of radioactive metals for analytical purposes, Solvent Impregnated Resins (SIRs) can be used. SIRs are porous particles, which contain an extractant inside their pores. This approach avoids the liquid-liquid separation step required in conventional liquid-liquid extraction. For the preparation of SIRs for radioanalytical separations, organic Amberlite XAD-4 or XAD-7 can be used. Possible extractants are e.g. trihexyltetradecylphosphonium chloride(CYPHOS IL-101) or N,N0-dialkyl-N,N0-diphenylpyridine-2,6-dicarboxyamides (R-PDA; R = butyl, octy I, decyl, dodecyl).

List of sites

See also

Nuclear fuel cycle Breeder reactor Nuclear fusion-fission hybrid Spent nuclear fuel shipping cask Taylor Wilson's nuclear waste-fired small reactor Global Nuclear Energy Partnership announced February 2006

References

Notes

Further reading

OECD Nuclear Energy Agency, The Economics of the Nuclear Fuel Cycle, Paris, France, 1994. I. Hensing and W Schultz, Economic Comparison of Nuclear Fuel Cycle Options, Energiewirtschaftlichen Instituts, Cologne, Germany, 1995. Cogema, Reprocessing-Recycling: the Industrial Stakes, presentation to the Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung, Bonn, Germany, 9 May 1995. OECD Nuclear Energy Agency, Plutonium Fuel: An Assessment, Paris, France, 1989. National Research Council, "Nuclear Wastes: Technologies for Separation and Transmutation", National Academy Press, Washington, D.C., 1996.

External links

Processing of Used Nuclear Fuel, World Nuclear Association PUREX Process, European Nuclear Society Mixed Oxide Fuel (MOX) – World Nuclear Association Disposal Options for Surplus Weapons-Usable Plutonium – Congressional Research Service Report for Congress Brief History of Fuel Reprocessing Annotated bibliography for reprocessing spent nuclear fuel from the Alsos Digital Library for Nuclear Issues

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1372399703 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

21 named source(s) extracted from the cited revision. A source with no author is shown by its publication; nothing is invented.