Nymwars

Nymwars was a series of conflicts over policies that mandate that all users of certain social media platforms identify themselves using their legal names.

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 4 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

Nymwars was a series of conflicts over policies that mandate that all users of certain social media platforms identify themselves using their legal names. The term is mostly associated with Google's name policies on Google+ and YouTube. Nymwars is a blend word composed from (pseudo)nym and wars.

The name appears to have gained prominence as the hashtag "#nymwars" on Twitter. Conflicts regarding Google+ began by July 2011 when the social networking site began enforcing its real-name-only policy by suspending the accounts of users it felt were not following the policy.

Pseudonyms, nicknames, and non-standard real names (for example, mononyms or names that include scripts from multiple languages) were suspended. The issue was settled in 2014 when Google announced that it was ending its real-name-only policy.

A predecessor to the Google+ conflict was Blizzard's RealID which, starting in 2010, exposes the name on the player's credit card, and is mandatory to use some game features (cross-game chat) and was nearly made mandatory to post on discussion forums. These issues have existed since the beginning of online identity, and are related to the alleged online disinhibition effect.

The resulting discussions have raised many issues regarding naming, cultural sensitivity, public and private identity, privacy, and the role of social media in modern discourse.…

Nymwars was a series of conflicts over policies that mandate that all users of certain social media platforms identify themselves using their legal names. The term is mostly associated with Google's name policies on Google+ and YouTube. Nymwars is a blend word composed from (pseudo)nym and wars.

The name appears to have gained prominence as the hashtag "#nymwars" on Twitter. Conflicts regarding Google+ began by July 2011 when the social networking site began enforcing its real-name-only policy by suspending the accounts of users it felt were not following the policy.

Pseudonyms, nicknames, and non-standard real names (for example, mononyms or names that include scripts from multiple languages) were suspended. The issue was settled in 2014 when Google announced that it was ending its real-name-only policy.

A predecessor to the Google+ conflict was Blizzard's RealID which, starting in 2010, exposes the name on the player's credit card, and is mandatory to use some game features (cross-game chat) and was nearly made mandatory to post on discussion forums. These issues have existed since the beginning of online identity, and are related to the alleged online disinhibition effect.

The resulting discussions have raised many issues regarding naming, cultural sensitivity, public and private identity, privacy, and the role of social media in modern discourse. The debate has been covered widely in the press including Wired, The Atlantic, and The New York Times.

Criticism

A number of high-profile commentators have publicly criticized Google's policies, including technologists Violet Blue, Jamie Zawinski, Kevin Marks, and Robert Scoble and organisations such as the Electronic Frontier Foundation. Criticisms have been wide-ranging, for example: The policy fails to acknowledge long-standing Internet culture and conventions.

Using real names online can disadvantage or endanger some individuals, such as victims of violence or harassment. Using a pseudonym is different from anonymity, and a pseudonym used consistently denotes an "authentic personality". Google's arguments fail to address the financial gain represented by connecting personal data to real-world identities.

Google has inconsistently enforced their policy, especially by making exceptions for celebrities using pseudonyms and mononyms. The policy as stated is insufficient for preventing spam. The policy may run afoul of legal constraints such as the German "Telemediengesetz" federal law, which makes anonymous access to online services a legal requirement.

The policy does not prevent trolls. It is up to social media to encourage the growth of healthy social norms, and forcefully telling people how they must behave cannot be efficient.

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1339738126 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

35 named source(s) extracted from the cited revision. A source with no author is shown by its publication; nothing is invented.