overjustification effect

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Q389385Snapshot

≈ 9 min read

Names in other languages

  • Polskiefekt nadmiernego uzasadnienia
  • Nederlandsoverrechtvaardigingseffect
  • Englishoverjustification effect
  • DeutschKorrumpierungseffekt
  • 한국어과잉정당화 효과
  • 中文动机偏移
  • 简体中文动机偏移
  • 繁體中文動機偏移

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

The overjustification effect is a phenomenon in psychology in which providing expected external incentive, such as money or prizes, for an already intrinsically rewarding activity can reduce a person's intrinsic motivation to perform that activity. It is commonly understood in terms of the interaction between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, where external rewards may undermine pre-existing intrinsic interest, a process often described as motivational "crowding out".

The effect has been widely discussed in research by Edward Deci and Mark Lepper. Once rewards are no longer offered, individuals may show reduced interest in the activity, namely, cognitive re-evaluation, although the extent of this effect can vary depending on contexts.

The overjustification effect is a phenomenon in psychology in which providing expected external incentive, such as money or prizes, for an already intrinsically rewarding activity can reduce a person's intrinsic motivation to perform that activity. It is commonly understood in terms of the interaction between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, where external rewards may undermine pre-existing intrinsic interest, a process often described as motivational "crowding out".

The effect has been widely discussed in research by Edward Deci and Mark Lepper. Once rewards are no longer offered, individuals may show reduced interest in the activity, namely, cognitive re-evaluation, although the extent of this effect can vary depending on contexts.

Theoretical mechanisms

Several theoretical frameworks have been used to explain the overjustification effect, particularly focusing on the distinction between intrinsic motivation (when a person does the activity in the absence of a reward contigency or control) and extrinsic motivation (the activity with a reward contigency or control).

Experimental evidence

The overjustification effect has been widely demonstrated in many settings. These empirical research demonstrates that the impact of external rewards on intrinsic motivation relies on how rewards are structured and interpreted.

In one of the earliest demonstrations of this effect, Edward Deci and his colleagues conducted a laboratory experiment in 1971 where subjects showing baseline interest in solving a puzzle were exposed to two different conditions. The control group were not paid on all three days while the experimental group were not paid on the first day, were paid on the second day and were not paid again on the third day.

The subjects were given a break in the middle of each session and were being observed while doing whatever they wanted. The results showed that the experimental group spent significantly more time than the control group playing the puzzle during their break time on day 2 when they were paid but significantly less on day 3 when they were not paid.

This was interpreted as evidence that the extrinsic monetary reward significantly reduced their intrinsic motivation to engage in the task. Researchers at Southern Methodist University conducted an experiment on 188 female university students in which they measured the subjects' continued interest in a cognitive task (a word game) after their initial performance under different incentives.

The subjects were divided into two groups. Members of the first group were told that they would be rewarded for competence. Above-average players would be paid more and below-average players would be paid less.

Members of the second group were told that they would be rewarded only for completion. Their pay was scaled by the number of repetitions or the number of hours playing. Afterwards, half of the subjects in each group were told that they over-performed, and the other half were told that they under-performed, regardless of how well each subject actually did.

Members of the first group generally showed greater interest in the game and continued playing for a longer time than the members of the second group. "Over-performers" continued playing longer than "under-performers" in the first group, but "under-performers" continued playing longer than "over-performers" in the second group.

This study showed that, when rewards do not reflect competence, higher rewards lead to less intrinsic motivation. But when rewards do reflect competence, higher rewards lead to greater intrinsic motivation. Richard Titmuss suggested that paying for blood donations might reduce the supply of blood donors.

To test this, a field experiment with three treatments was conducted. In the first treatment, the donors did not receive compensation. In the second treatment, the donors received a small payment.

In the third treatment, donors were given a choice between the payment and an equivalent-valued contribution to charity. None of the three treatments affected the number of male donors, but the second treatment almost halved the number of female donors. However, allowing the contribution to charity fully eliminated this effect.

Overall, these findings show that the overjustification effect is not uniform, and is consistent with the explanations in Cognitive evaluation theory and Self-determination theory.

Moderating factors

There remains considerable ambiguity regarding the conditions under which the overjustification effect occurs and continue to be the subject of ongoing research. For instance, a commonly cited illustration shows a young man who initially enjoys reading, but may become to view it as ‘work’ if external rewards are introduced. The major moderators are task characteristics, reward structures, and individual differences (e.g., age group).

Education

Findings from the study suggest that presenting these extrinsic rewards poses central problems in the schooling system in that it fails to preserve the intrinsic interest in learning and exploration that a child may seem to possess during his initial phase in school. This also has severe ramifications on the education system, as it seems to almost undermine children's spontaneous interest in the process of learning itself, instead their motivation is driven by these extrinsic rewards.

Research in this area suggests that parents and educators should rely on intrinsic motivation and preserve feelings of autonomy and competence as much as possible. When the task is unattractive and intrinsic motivation is insufficient (e.g., household chores), then extrinsic rewards are useful to provide incentives for behaviour.

School programs that provide money or prizes for reading books have been criticized for their potential to reduce intrinsic motivation by overjustification. However, a study of the Pizza Hut program, Book It!, found that participation in the program neither increased nor decreased reading motivation.

Although motivating students to read by rewarding them may undermine their interest in reading, it may also encourage the reading skills necessary for developing an interest in reading.

Workplace

Cognitive evaluation theory further predicts the different types of rewards that will exert different effects. According to the theory, task non-contingent rewards like benefits that are based on things other than performance, such as employment that do not consist of any information regarding autonomy and competence, will have no effect on intrinsic motivation.

Task contingent rewards on the other hand like salary which are awarded for performing or completing a task, will be experienced as controlling and hence will have a negative effect on intrinsic motivation. The study conducted by Deckop and Cirka reported in 2000 that introducing merit pay programs in a non-profit organization led to decreased feelings of autonomy and intrinsic motivation, indicating that rewards can undermine intrinsic motivation in work settings.

Performance contingent rewards like monetary incentives that are given for good performance or meeting a certain standard will be experienced as highly controlling hence decreasing intrinsic motivation. Shirom, Westman, and Melamed found that pay-for-performance plans resulted in lower well being in blue-collar workers, and this was especially evident for those who felt that their jobs were monotonous.

However, in certain cases where the reward also conveys information about competence that will in turn reduce the negative effect.

Gamification

The term gamification refers to the application of game design elements to non-game contexts in order to drive participation, often with the goal of encouraging greater engagement with the non-game context by providing symbolic rewards such as points, badges, or virtual currency. However, a number of academics and other critics have expressed concern that these rewards may backfire via the overjustification effect.

Drawing directly on self-determination theory, these critics of gamification express concerns that gamified contexts such as foursquare might provide expected rewards for activities that do not adequately meet self-determination theory's three innate needs for intrinsic motivation—relatedness, autonomy, and competence—and therefore reduce intrinsic interest in those activities.

Crowdsourcing

Websites that rely on user-generated content sometimes offer monetary rewards or user rights for contributions, but these may cause the contributors to succumb to the overjustification effect and stop contributing. For example, Amazon Mechanical Turk allows the creator of a task to offer a monetary reward, but a survey of 431 Mechanical Turk participants showed that they are driven more by intrinsic motivations than a desire for the usually meagre monetary compensation.

The overjustification effect was also considered in a study on how to maximise contributions when crowdsourcing creative endeavours.

Volunteering

Empirical evidence shows that expected financial rewards "crowd out" intrinsic motivation, while the size of the monetary reward simultaneously provides extrinsic motivation. If the size of the monetary reward is not large enough to compensate for the loss of intrinsic motivation, overall engagement can decline.

A survey data-set revealed that small financial payments reduced volunteer hours among Swiss citizens, and that the median financial reward provided to these volunteers caused them to work less than volunteers who were not given any payment.

Sports

The overjustification effect has also been linked to professional sports. The performance of numerous athletes has diminished following the signing of a lucrative, multimillion-dollar contract. Some notable professional athletes whose performances have diminished following a large contract include Alex Rodriguez (MLB), Albert Pujols (MLB), Wayne Rooney (Premier League) and Albert Haynesworth (NFL).

See also

Attribution theory Candle problem Cognitive evaluation theory Motivation crowding theory Reinforcement Self-determination theory Self-perception Social psychology

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1377222064 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Provenance

snapshot overjustification-effect-045186-b2c1a4efbfe1cb6a · hash b2c1a4efbfe1cb6a5772d664b4beebac1cc2c31a2ed74708b703d511de63f51d · captured 1790585039.0 · version history

Cite this page as: encyclopegia.org, “overjustification effect”, snapshot overjustification-effect-045186-b2c1a4efbfe1cb6a. https://encyclopegia.org/a/overjustification-effect

Sources cited in this revision

No external citation was extracted for this revision. That is a statement about the source, not a claim that none exists.