Package-deal fallacy
The package-deal fallacy (also known as false conjunction) is the logical fallacy of assuming that things often grouped together by tradition or culture must always be grouped that way.
≈ 2 min read
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
The package-deal fallacy (also known as false conjunction) is the logical fallacy of assuming that things often grouped together by tradition or culture must always be grouped that way. False conjunction refers to misuse of the and operator.
It is particularly common in political arguments, such as the following imagined example from the United States: "My opponent is a conservative who voted against higher taxes and welfare, therefore he will also oppose gun control and abortion." While those four positions are often grouped together as "conservative" in United States politics, a person may believe in one "conservative" idea while not believing in another.
When it is not a fallacy
The package-deal argument does not need to be a fallacy when used to argue that things grouped by culture and tradition are likely to be grouped in a given way.
Examples
"John enjoys science fiction films, so chances are he'll enjoy Star Wars." While it is not guaranteed that John will like Star Wars, we can tell from information about him that he probably will. "There has been a serious drought in Country X for a while, and it is not very developed, so many of its inhabitants are probably starving."
Most developing countries do face famine when drought occurs, so it is likely that this is the case in Country X, even if it is not guaranteed.
See also
List of fallacies Critical thinking Psychology of reasoning Availability heuristic Illusory correlation Stereotyping
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1352988870 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.