Lesson plan

Paper bag problem

In geometry, the paper bag problem or teabag problem is to calculate the maximum possible inflated volume of an initially flat sealed rectangular bag which has the same shape as a cushion or pillow, made out of two pieces of material which can bend but not stretch. According to Anthony C. Robin, an approximate formula for the capacity of a sealed expanded bag is: V=w^3 \left (h/ \left (\pi w \right ) -0.142 \left (1-10^ \left (-h/w \right ) \right ) \right ), where w is the width of the bag (the shorter dimension), h is the height (the longer dimension), and V is the maximum volume. The approximation ignores the crimping round the equator of the bag. A very rough approximation to the capacity of a bag that is open at one edge is: V=w^3 \left (h/ \left (\pi w \right ) -0.071 \left (1-10^ \left (-2h/w \right ) \right ) \right ) (This latter formula assumes that the corners at the bottom of the bag are linked by a single edge, and that the base of the bag is not a more complex shape such as a lens).

Back to article

Article summary

In geometry, the paper bag problem or teabag problem is to calculate the maximum possible inflated volume of an initially flat sealed rectangular bag which has the same shape as a cushion or pillow, made out of two pieces of material which can bend but not stretch. According to Anthony C. Robin, an approximate formula for the capacity of a sealed expanded bag is: V=w^3 \left (h/ \left (\pi w \right ) -0.142 \left (1-10^ \left (-h/w \right ) \right ) \right ), where w is the width of the bag (the shorter dimension), h is the height (the longer dimension), and V is the maximum volume. The approximation ignores the crimping round the equator of the bag. A very rough approximation to the capacity of a bag that is open at one edge is: V=w^3 \left (h/ \left (\pi w \right ) -0.071 \left (1-10^ \left (-2h/w \right ) \right ) \right ) (This latter formula assumes that the corners at the bottom of the bag are linked by a single edge, and that the base of the bag is not a more complex shape such as a lens).

Key claims

No claims recorded.

Discussion questions

  1. Summarise the article in your own words. Which single claim would you verify first, and why?
  2. Which claim in this article is most likely to be revised as the sources update? How would you check its current status?
  3. If two sources disagreed about one of these facts, what would you need in order to trust one over the other?

Bibliography

No sources recorded.

Key claims and bibliography are generated from the same tracked claims and sources as the article page.