Lesson plan

Paradigm case argument

In analytic philosophy, the paradigm case argument (PCA) is an argument which is applied as a rebuttal to the claim that certain concepts, such as free will or knowledge, are meaningless. The paradigm case argument is that if a term, such as "knowledge", is regularly applied to some cases and not to others, then that term (and the concept it refers to) cannot truly be undefined, as it clearly has some kind of definition in practice. The argument is so named because it often takes the form of pointing out a paradigm case—a case which unambiguously falls under the common definition of the term, and so can be taken as a definite instance of the supposedly non-existent concept. This argument was commonly applied during the flourishing of linguistic philosophy. Ian Hacking was critical of the argument structure, describing it as follows: The argument has fallen from favour. Hacking wrote, "The authoritative Encyclopedia of Philosophy (1967) devoted six careful and informative pages to the paradigm-case argument... The argument has now disappeared from sight. The current online Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy does not mention it by name anywhere in its truly encyclopedic pages."

Back to article

Article summary

In analytic philosophy, the paradigm case argument (PCA) is an argument which is applied as a rebuttal to the claim that certain concepts, such as free will or knowledge, are meaningless. The paradigm case argument is that if a term, such as "knowledge", is regularly applied to some cases and not to others, then that term (and the concept it refers to) cannot truly be undefined, as it clearly has some kind of definition in practice. The argument is so named because it often takes the form of pointing out a paradigm case—a case which unambiguously falls under the common definition of the term, and so can be taken as a definite instance of the supposedly non-existent concept. This argument was commonly applied during the flourishing of linguistic philosophy. Ian Hacking was critical of the argument structure, describing it as follows: The argument has fallen from favour. Hacking wrote, "The authoritative Encyclopedia of Philosophy (1967) devoted six careful and informative pages to the paradigm-case argument... The argument has now disappeared from sight. The current online Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy does not mention it by name anywhere in its truly encyclopedic pages."

Key claims

No claims recorded.

Discussion questions

  1. Summarise the article in your own words. Which single claim would you verify first, and why?
  2. Which claim in this article is most likely to be revised as the sources update? How would you check its current status?
  3. If two sources disagreed about one of these facts, what would you need in order to trust one over the other?

Bibliography

No sources recorded.

Key claims and bibliography are generated from the same tracked claims and sources as the article page.