Patriot Act
The USA PATRIOT Act (commonly known as the Patriot Act) is a landmark Act of the United States Congress, signed into law by President George W.
≈ 22 min read
Patriot Act. encyclopegia.org, snapshot enwiki-001378286489. /a/patriot-act
Names in other languages
No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.
Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.
The USA PATRIOT Act (commonly known as the Patriot Act) is a landmark Act of the United States Congress, signed into law by President George W. Bush. The formal name of the statute is the Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism (USA PATRIOT) Act of 2001, and the commonly used short name is a backronym that is embedded in the name set forth in the statute.
The Patriot Act was enacted following the September 11 attacks and the 2001 anthrax attacks with the stated goal of tightening U.S. national security, particularly as it related to foreign terrorism. In general, the act included three main provisions: Expanded surveillance abilities of law enforcement, including by tapping domestic and international phones; Easier interagency communication to allow federal agencies to more effectively use all available resources in counterterrorism efforts; and Increased penalties for terrorism crimes and an expanded list of activities which would qualify for terrorism charges.
The law is extremely controversial due to its authorization of indefinite detention without trial of immigrants, and due to the permission given to law enforcement to search property and records without the owner's consent or knowledge. Since its passage, several legal challenges have been brought against the act, and federal courts have ruled that a number of provisions are unconstitutional.
It contains many sunset provisions beginning December 31, 2005, approximately four years after its passage. Before the sunset date, an extension was passed for four years which kept most of the law intact. In May 2011, President Barack Obama signed the PATRIOT Sunset Extensions Act of 2011, which extended three provisions.
These provisions were modified and extended until 2019 by the USA Freedom Act, passed in 2015. In 2020, efforts to extend the provisions were not passed by the House of Representatives, and as such, these provisions have expired.
Legislative history
Final House vote: Final Senate vote:
Sami Al-Arian
Sami Al-Arian was a Palestinian-American tenured computer engineering professor at the University of South Florida, who also actively promoted dialogue between the West and the Middle East, especially about the plight of Palestinians. He was indicted in February 20031 on 17 counts under the Patriot Act, based largely on transcripts of wiretapped calls and faxes from the mid-1990s.
Al-Arian was accused of using an academic think tank as a fundraising front for the Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ), a U.S.-designated terrorist organization. The indictment was described by then-Attorney General John Ashcroft as an early success of the Patriot Act.
For much of his pretrial detention, Al-Arian was held in almost solitary confinement in a maximum security prison, prompting Amnesty International to raise concerns about the conditions of his imprisonment, including heavy shackles during attorney visits and restrictions on exercise and family contact. A jury eventually acquitted him on 8 counts, while remaining deadlocked on the 9 others.
He later struck a plea deal that included admitting to one of the last charges of providing services to the PIJ (filing immigration-related assistance to members) in exchange for being released and deported by April 20071. However, a Federal Judge sentenced him to an additional 19 months past time served, calling him an active leader in the organization.
Instead of being released, he was held under house arrest from 20081 until 2014 when federal prosecutors filed a motion to dismiss charges against him. He was deported to Turkey on February 4, 2015.
Following his deportation, Al-Arian said in interviews that he had helped mobilize Muslim-American support for George W. Bush's 2000 presidential campaign in Florida in exchange for a promised policy commitment against the use of secret evidence. This promise was unfulfilled once the September 11 attacks reshaped the political atmosphere.
Immigration
One controversial aspect of the Patriot Act is the immigration provisions that allow for the indefinite detention of any alien who the Attorney General believes may cause a terrorist act. Before the Patriot Act was passed, Anita Ramasastry, an associate professor of law and a director of the Shidler Center for Law, Commerce, & Technology at the University of Washington School of Law in Seattle, Washington, accused the Act of depriving basic rights for immigrants to America, including legal permanent residents.
She warned that "Indefinite detention upon secret evidence—which the Patriot Act allows—sounds more like Taliban justice than ours. Our claim that we are attempting to build an international coalition against terrorism will be severely undermined if we pass legislation allowing even citizens of our allies to be incarcerated without basic U.S. guarantees of fairness and justice."
Many other parties have also been strongly critical of the provision. Russell Feingold, in a Senate floor statement, claimed that the provision "falls short of meeting even basic constitutional standards of due process and fairness [as it] continues to allow the Attorney General to detain persons based on mere suspicion".
The University of California passed a resolution condemning (among other things) the indefinite detention provisions of the Act, while the ACLU has accused the Act of giving the Attorney General "unprecedented new power to determine the fate of immigrants ... Worse, if the foreigner does not have a country that will accept them, they can be detained indefinitely without trial."
Illegal Money Transfers
The Patriot Act’s prohibitions against illegal money transfers were used against major credit card companies in 2003. Lisa and Andrew Harding lost over $100,000 at illegal gambling websites between 2002-2003. Both Hardings were later named in a lawsuit for failure to pay their credit card bills.
The Hardings subsequently filed a countersuit against Visa Inc. and its USA Division, Discover Financial and Mastercard International, alleging that the companies violated the Patriot Act by facilitating the illegal transfers to the gambling sites. Discover Card and Visa eventually agreed to relieve some of the accrued debt.
Fahrenheit 9/11 Film
The sheer magnitude of the Act itself was noted by Michael Moore in his controversial film Fahrenheit 9/11. In one of the scenes of the movie, he records Representative Jim McDermott (D-WA) alleging that no Senator had read the bill and Representative John Conyers, Jr. (D-MI) as saying, "We don't read most of the bills.
Do you really know what that would entail if we read every bill that we passed?" Conyers answers his own question, saying that if they did read every bill, it would "slow down the legislative process". As a dramatic device, Moore then hired an ice-cream van and drove around Washington, D.C., with a loudspeaker, reading out the Act to puzzled passers-by, including a few senators.
Moore was not the only commentator to notice that not many people had read the Act. When Dahlia Lithwick and Julia Turne for Slate asked, "How bad is PATRIOT, anyway?", they decided that it was "hard to tell" and stated:
Susan Lindauer
One prime example of how the Patriot Act has stirred controversy is the case of Susan Lindauer. Lindauer is a former Congressional staffer and antiwar activist who was charged under the Patriot Act with "acting as an unregistered agent of a foreign government," then ruled by a court mentally unfit to stand trial.
Lindauer has emphatically denied both on many occasions, saying that she in fact had been a CIA agent serving as a link between the U.S. and Iraqi governments. In 2010 she wrote a book called Extreme Prejudice: The Terrifying Story of the Patriot Act and the Cover-Ups of 9/11 and Iraq to that effect. The charges were dropped in 2009.
Brandon Mayfield
In 2004, FBI agents used this provision to search and secretly examine the home of Brandon Mayfield, who was wrongfully jailed for two weeks on suspicion of involvement in the Madrid train bombings. While the U.S. Government did publicly apologize to Mayfield and his family, Mayfield took it further through the courts.
On September 26, 2007, Judge Ann Aiken found the law was, in fact, unconstitutional as the search was an unreasonable imposition on Mayfield and thus violated the Fourth Amendment.
National Security Letters
Perhaps one of the biggest controversies involved the use of National Security Letters (NSLs) by the FBI. Because they allow the FBI to search telephone, email, and financial records without a court order, they were criticized by many parties, including the American Civil Liberties Union.
Although FBI officials have a series of internal "checks and balances" that must be met before the issue of an NSL, Federal Judge Victor Marrero ruled the NSL provisions unconstitutional. In November 2005, BusinessWeek reported that the FBI had issued tens of thousands of NSLs and had obtained one million financial, credit, employment, and in some cases, health records from the customers of targeted Las Vegas businesses.
Selected businesses included casinos, storage warehouses and car rental agencies. An anonymous Justice official claimed that such requests were permitted under section 505 of the Patriot Act and despite the volume of requests insisted "We are not inclined to ask courts to endorse fishing expeditions".
Before this was revealed, however, the ACLU challenged the constitutionality of NSLs in court. In April 2004, they filed suit against the government on behalf of an unknown ISP who had been issued an NSL, for reasons unknown.
In ACLU v. DoJ, the ACLU argued that the NSL violated the First and Fourth Amendments of the U.S. Constitution because the Patriot Act failed to spell out any legal process whereby a telephone or Internet company could try to oppose an NSL subpoena in court. The court agreed, and found that because the recipient of the subpoena could not challenge it in court it was unconstitutional.
Congress later tried to remedy this in a reauthorization Act, but because they did not remove the non-disclosure provision a Federal court again found NSLs to be unconstitutional because they prevented courts from engaging in meaningful judicial review. , posted in a Craftsbury, Vermont library in 2005: "The FBI has not been here (watch very closely for removal of this sign)". Announcing the receipt of a national security letter would violate the associated gag order, while removing the sign would not.
Libraries
Another provision of the Patriot Act has caused a great deal of consternation among librarians. Section 215 allows the FBI to apply for an order to produce materials that assist in an investigation undertaken to protect against international terrorism or clandestine intelligence activities.
Among the "tangible things" that could be targeted, it includes "books, records, papers, documents, and other items". Supporters of the provision point out that these records are held by third parties, and therefore are exempt from a citizen's reasonable expectations of privacy and also maintain that the FBI has not abused the provision.
As proof, then Attorney General John Ashcroft released information in 2003 that showed that section 215 orders had never been used. However, the American Library Association strongly objected to the provision, believing that library records are fundamentally different from ordinary business records, and that the provision would have a chilling effect on free speech.
The association became so concerned that it adopted a resolution condemning the Patriot Act and urging members to defend free speech and protect patrons' privacy. The association urged librarians to seek legal advice before complying with a search order, and advised its members to keep records only for as long as was legally required.
Consequently, reports started filtering in that librarians were shredding records to avoid having to comply with such orders. In 2005, Library Connection, a nonprofit consortium of 27 libraries in Connecticut, known as the Connecticut Four, worked with the ACLU to lift a gag order for library records, challenging the government's power under Section 505 to silence four citizens who wished to contribute to public debate on the PATRIOT Act.
This case became known as Doe v. Gonzales. In May 2006, the government finally gave up its legal battle to maintain the gag order.
In a summary of the actions of the Connecticut Four and their challenge to the Patriot Act, Jones (2009: 223) notes: "Librarians need to understand their country's legal balance between the protection of freedom of expression and the protection of national security. Many librarians believe that the interests of national security, important as they are, have become an excuse for chilling the freedom to read."
Wiretapping
The Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) has criticized the law as unconstitutional, especially when "the private communications of law-abiding American citizens might be intercepted incidentally", while the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) held that the lower standard applied to wiretaps "gives the FBI a 'blank check' to violate the communications privacy of countless innocent Americans". Others do not find the roving wiretap legislation to be as concerning.
Professor David D. Cole of the Georgetown University Law Center, a critic of many of the provisions of the Act, found that though they come at a cost to privacy are a sensible measure while Paul Rosenzweig, a Senior Legal Research Fellow in the Center for Legal and Judicial Studies at The Heritage Foundation, argues that roving wiretaps are just a response to rapidly changing communication technology that is not necessarily fixed to a specific location or device.
Expanded Court Jurisdiction
The Patriot Act's expansion of court jurisdiction to allow the nationwide service of search warrants proved controversial for the EFF. They believe that agencies will be able to "'shop' for judges that have demonstrated a strong bias toward law enforcement with regard to search warrants, using only those judges least likely to say no—even if the warrant doesn't satisfy the strict requirements of the Fourth Amendment to the Constitution", and that it reduces the likelihood that smaller ISPs or phone companies will try to protect the privacy of their clients by challenging the warrant in court—their reasoning is that "a small San Francisco ISP served with such a warrant is unlikely to have the resources to appear before the New York court that issued it."
They believe that this is bad because only the communications provider will be able to challenge the warrant as only they will know about it—many warrants are issued ex parte, which means that the target of the order is not present when the order is issued.
Sneak and Peek Searches
For a time, the Patriot Act allowed for agents to undertake "sneak and peek" searches. Critics such as EPIC and the ACLU strongly criticized the law for violating the Fourth Amendment, with the ACLU going so far as to release an advertisement condemning it and calling for it to be repealed.
Freedom of Association
Laws governing the material support of terrorism proved contentious. It was criticized by the EFF for infringement of freedom of association. The EFF argues that had this law been enacted during Apartheid, U.S. citizens would not have been able to support the African National Congress (ANC) as the EFF believes the ANC would have been classed as a terrorist organization.
They also used the example of a humanitarian social worker being unable to train Hamas members how to care for civilian children orphaned in the conflict between Israelis and Palestinians, a lawyer being unable to teach IRA members about international law, and peace workers being unable to offer training in effective peace negotiations or how to petition the United Nations regarding human rights abuses. Another group, the Humanitarian Law Project, also objected to the provision prohibiting "expert advise and assistance" to terrorists and filed a suit against the U.S. government to have it declared unconstitutional.
In 2004 a Federal District Court struck the provision down as unconstitutionally vague, but in 2010 the Supreme Court reversed that decision.
British Columbia
Another controversial aspect of the Patriot Act is its effect on the privacy of Canadians living in the province of British Columbia (B.C.). British Columbia's privacy commissioner raises concerns that the Patriot Act will allow the United States government to access Canadians' private information, such as personal medical records, that are outsourced to American companies. Although the government of B.C. has taken measures to prevent United States authorities from obtaining information, the widespread powers of the Patriot Act could overcome legislation that is passed in Canada.
B.C. Privacy Commissioner David Loukidelis stated in a report on the consequences of the Patriot Act, "once information is sent across borders, it's difficult, if not impossible, to control". In an effort to maintain their privacy, British Columbia placed amendments on the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (FOIPPA), which was enacted as law on October 21, 2004.
These amendments aim to place more firm limitations on "storing, accessing, and disclosing of B.C. public sector data by service providers." These laws only pertain to public sector data and do not cover trans-border or private sector data in Canada.
The public sector establishments include an estimated 2,000 "government ministries, hospitals, boards of health, universities and colleges, school boards, municipal governments and certain Crown corporations and agencies." In response to these laws, many companies are now specifically opting to host their sensitive data outside the United States.
Nova Scotia
Legal action has been taken in Nova Scotia to protect the province from the Patriot Act's data collecting methods. On November 15, 2007, the government of Nova Scotia passed legislation aimed to protect Nova Scotians' personal information from being brought forward by the Patriot Act. The act was entitled "The new Personal Information International Disclosure Protection Act".
The goal of the act is to establish requirements to protect personal information from being revealed, as well as punishments for failing to do so. Justice Minister Murray Scott stated, "This legislation will help ensure that Nova Scotians' personal information will be protected.
The act outlines the responsibilities of public bodies, municipalities and service providers and the consequences if these responsibilities are not fulfilled." In the 1980s, the Bank of Nova Scotia was the center of an early, pre-Internet data-access case that led to the disclosure of banking records.
Voicemail
The Act also allows access to voicemail through a search warrant rather than through a title III wiretap order. James Dempsey, of the CDT, believes that it unnecessarily overlooks the importance of notice under the Fourth Amendment and under a Title III wiretap, and the EFF criticizes the provision's lack of notice.
However, the EFF's criticism is more extensive—they believe that the amendment "is in possible violation of the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution" because previously if the FBI listened to voicemail illegally, it could not use the messages in evidence against the defendant. Others disagree with these assessments.
Legal Scholar Orin Kerr believes that the ECPA "adopted a rather strange rule to regulate voicemail stored with service providers" because "under ECPA, if the government knew that there was one copy of an unopened private message in a person's bedroom and another copy on their remotely stored voicemail, it was illegal for the FBI to simply obtain the voicemail; the law actually compelled the police to invade the home and rifle through people's bedrooms so as not to disturb the more private voicemail." In Professor Kerr's opinion, this made little sense and the amendment that was made by the Patriot Act was reasonable and sensible.
United States v. Antoine Jones
Another example of controversy in the Patriot Act is the 2012 court case United States v. Antoine Jones. A nightclub owner was linked to a drug trafficking stash house via a law enforcement GPS tracking device attached to his car. It was placed there without a warrant, which caused a serious conviction obstacle for federal prosecutors in court.
The case eventually reached the U.S. Supreme Court, where the conviction was overturned. The court found that installing a tracking device for the purpose of long-term monitoring - caused by legislation like the Patriot Act - constituted a search that violated the defendant's constitutional rights.
NSA Call Record Collection
After suspected abuses of the Patriot Act were brought to light in June 2013 with articles about collection of American call records by the NSA and the PRISM program (see 2013 mass surveillance disclosures), Representative Jim Sensenbrenner, Republican of Wisconsin, who introduced the Patriot Act in 2001, said that the National Security Agency overstepped its bounds. He released a statement saying "While I believe the Patriot Act appropriately balanced national security concerns and civil rights, I have always worried about potential abuses."
He added: "Seizing phone records of millions of innocent people is excessive and un-American." Kerr, Orin. "Digital Evidence and the New Criminal Procedure".
Columbia Law Review (2005). Lecours, Alain P. USA Patriot Act, Extraterritorial Effects of the USA Patriot Act – Privacy Rights of Non-American Citizens Mojuyé, Benjamin, "What Banks Need to Know About the PATRIOT Act", 124 Banking L.J. 258, 258 (2007). Slovove, Daniel J. "Fourth Amendment Codification and Professor Kerr's Misguided Call for Judicial Deference".
Fordham Law Review 74 (2005). Van Bergen, Jennifer. "In the Absence of Democracy: The Designation and Material Support Provisions of the Anti-Terrorism Laws".
Cardozo Pub. [?] Law Policy & Ethics Journal 2 (2003): 107.
Wong, Kam C. "Implementing the USA PATRIOT Act: A Case Study of the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS)". Brigham Young University Education and Law Journal 2 (2006). Wong, Kam C. "The making of the USA PATRIOT Act I: Legislative Process and Dynamics".
International Journal of the Sociology of Law 34.3 (2006): 179–219. Wong, Kam C. "The making of the USA PATRIOT ACT II: Public Sentiments, Legislative Climate, Political Gamesmanship, Media Patriotism". International Journal of the Sociology of Law 34.2 (2006): 105–140.
Wong, Kam C. "USA PATRIOT Act and a Policy of Alienation". Michigan Journal of Minority Rights 1 (2006): 1–44. Wong, Kam C. "USA PATRIOT Act: Some Unanswered Questions".
International Journal of the Sociology of Law 43.1 (2006): 1–41. Harvey, Robert and Hélène Volat. De l'exception à la règle.
USA PATRIOT Act "DE L'EXCEPTION À LA RÈGLE : USA PATRIOT ACT" : Robert Harvey et Hélène Volat. Paris: Lignes, 2006. 215 p. Herman, Susan N. Taking Liberties: The War on Terror and the Erosion of American Democracy.
Oxford University Press, 2011. . Mailman, Stanley, Jeralyn Merritt, Theresa M. B. Van Vliet, and Stephen Yale-Loehr. Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism (USA Patriot Act) Act of 2001: An Analysis.
Newark, NJ and San Francisco, CA: Matthew Bender & Co., Inc. (a member of the LexisNexis Group), 2002. (Rel.1-3/02 Pub.
1271) ("An expert analysis of the significant changes in the new USA Patriot Act of 2001 [which]...track[s] the legislation by section, explaining both the changes and their potential impact with respect to: enhanced surveillance procedures;money laundering and financial crimes; protecting the border; investigation of terrorism; information sharing among federal and state authorities; enhanced criminal laws and penalties for terrorism offenses, and more.") Michaels, C. William.
No Greater Threat: America Since September 11 and the Rise of the National Security State. Algora Publishing, Completely Updated for 2005. .
(Covers all ten titles of the USA PATRIOT Act; Includes review and analysis of: Homeland Security Act, "PATRIOT Act II," Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act, Supreme Court decisions, "National Strategy" documents, 9-11 Commission recommendations, and various ongoing developments nationally and internationally in the "war on terrorism.") Phelan, James Clancy; PATRIOT ACT, Hachette, ; 2007.
Van Bergen, Jennifer. The Twilight of Democracy: The Bush Plan for America. Common Courage Press, 2004. .
(A constitutional analysis for the general public of the USA PATRIOT Act and other administrative measures, with the first half of the book spent on principles of democracy and constitutional law.) Wheeler, Theodore. In Our Other Lives.
(New York: Little A, 2020.) A fiction exploration of the effect an NSA-FBI investigation has on the family of a young man who has gone missing in Pakistan.
Wong, Kam C. The Impact of USA Patriot Act on American Society: An Evidence Based Assessment (N.Y.: Nova Press, 2007) (In print) Wong, Kam C. The Making of USA Patriot Act: Legislation, Implementation, Impact (Beijing: China Law Press, 2007) (In print) USA PATRIOT Act as enacted (details) in the US Statutes at Large on Congress.gov on Congress.gov American Library Association's resolution on the PATRIOT Act Sneak and Peek Search Warrants League of Women Voters' Resources on the USA PATRIOT Act and Individual Liberties Phillips, Heather A., "Libraries and National Security Law: An Examination of the USA Patriot Act". Progressive Librarian, Vol. 25, Summer 2005
Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378286489 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.
References
- ↩Wikipedia “Patriot Act” release date (×3) · confidence 0.95 revision URL