Pentagram map

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 16 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

In mathematics, the pentagram map is a discrete dynamical system acting on polygons in the projective plane. It defines a new polygon whose vertices are obtained as the intersection points of the shortest diagonals of the initial polygon. This is a projectively equivariant procedure, hence it descends to the moduli space of polygons and defines another dynamical system (which is also referred to as the pentagram map). It was first introduced by Richard Schwartz in 1992. The pentagram map on the moduli space is famous for its complete integrability and its link with cluster algebras. It admits many generalizations in projective spaces and other settings.

In mathematics, the pentagram map is a discrete dynamical system acting on polygons in the projective plane. It defines a new polygon whose vertices are obtained as the intersection points of the shortest diagonals of the initial polygon. This is a projectively equivariant procedure, hence it descends to the moduli space of polygons and defines another dynamical system (which is also referred to as the pentagram map). It was first introduced by Richard Schwartz in 1992. The pentagram map on the moduli space is famous for its complete integrability and its link with cluster algebras. It admits many generalizations in projective spaces and other settings.

Definitions and first properties

Suppose that the vertices are in sufficiently general position, meaning that no consecutive triple of points are collinear. Taking the intersection of two consecutive "shortest" diagonals defines a new point w_k := \overline{v_{k-1} v_{k+1}} \cap \overline{v_{k} v_{k+2}}. This procedure defines a new n -gon T(P)=(w_1,\dots,w_n) . The labeling of the indices of T(P) is not canonical. In most papers, a choice is made at the beginning of the paper and the formulas are tuned accordingly. The pentagram map on polygons is a birational map T:(\mathbb P^2)^n (\mathbb P^2)^n . Indeed, each coordinate of w_k is given as a rational function of the coordinates of v_{k-1},\dots,v_{k+2} , since it is defined as the intersection of lines passing by them. Moreover, the inverse map is given by taking the intersections \overline{w_{k-2} w_{k-1}} \cap \overline{w_{k} w_{k+1}} , which is rational for the same reason. The pentagram map is defined by taking lines and intersections of them. The biggest group which maps lines to lines is the one of projective transformations, denoted by \mathbb P \mathrm{GL}_{3} . Such a transformation M acts on a polygon P by sending it to M \cdot P:=(Mv_1,\dots,Mv_n) . The pentagram map commutes with this action, and thereby induces another dynamical system on the moduli space of projective equivalence classes of polygons, whose dimension is 2n-8 .

Twisted polygons

on the real plane.]] The pentagram map naturally generalizes to the larger space of twisted polygons (see the example of heptagon in the figure). For any integer n\geq5 , a twisted n -gon P is the data of: a bi-infinite sequence of points (v_k)_{k\in\mathbb Z} in the projective plane (called the vertices), a projective transformation M \in \mathbb P \mathrm{GL}_3 (called the monodromy), such that for any k \in \mathbb Z , the property v_{k+n}=Mv_k is satisfied. The dimension of the space of twisted n -gons is 2n+8 . When M is the identity, this gives back the initial definition of polygons (which are said to be closed). The space of closed n -gons is of codimension 8 in the space of twisted ones. The action of projective transformations over the space of closed polygons generalizes to the space of twisted ones (the monodromy is changed by conjugation). This provides again a moduli space, of dimension 2n . There exists a constant 0 , depending on P , such that for any N \in \mathbb N , the diameters of the iterates verify the inequality \operatorname{diam}(T^N(P))\leq\eta_P^N \operatorname{diam}(P). Hence, by Cantor's intersection theorem, the sequence of polygons collapses toward a point. The behavior on the moduli space is very different, since the dynamics is recurrent. It is even a quasiperiodic motion, as discussed in the section about integrability. This operator was reinterpreted in as the infinitesimal monodromy of the polygon. The scaling symmetry is used to deform a closed polygon P into a family of twisted ones (P_z)_{z\in \mathbb C^*} with monodromy M_z . The infinitesimal monodromy is defined to be: \left.\frac{dM_z}{dz}\right|_{z=1}.

Pentagons and hexagons

The following two facts are proved by checking cross-ratio equalities, so they are true for polygons in any projective plane (not just the real one). The pentagram map T is the identity on the moduli space of pentagons. The second iterate T^2 is the identity on the space of labeled hexagons, up to a shift of labeling (see the figure). This phenomenon doesn't generalize to generic polygons with at least seven sides, for which the motion is quasiperiodic.

Coordinates for the moduli space

The moduli space can be described by different coordinate systems. The following ones give simple expressions for the dynamics, as presented in the next section. [a,b,c,d]=\frac{(a-b)(c-d)}{(a-c)(b-d)}. The corner invariants are a system of coordinates on the space of twisted polygons, constructed by taking intersections as in the figure. The left and right invariants are respectively defined as the following cross-ratios: x_k:=[v_{k-2},v_{k-1},\overline{v_{k-2}v_{k-1}}\cap\overline{v_{k}v_{k+1}},\overline{v_{k-2}v_{k-1}}\cap\overline{v_{k+1}v_{k+2}}], y_k:=[\overline{v_{k+1}v_{k+2}}\cap\overline{v_{k-2}v_{k-1}}, \overline{v_{k+1}v_{k+2}}\cap\overline{v_{k-1}v_{k}},v_{k+1},v_{k+2}]. Since the cross-ratio is projective invariant, the sequences (x_k)_{k \in \mathbb Z} and (y_k)_{k \in \mathbb Z} associated to a twisted n -gon are n -periodic. The corner invariants are elements of \mathbb{P}^1\smallsetminus\{0,1,\infty\} , and they realize an isomorphism of varieties between the moduli space of twisted n -gons and (\mathbb{P}^1\smallsetminus\{0,1,\infty\})^{2n} .

ab-coordinates

There is a second set of coordinates for the moduli space of twisted n -gons defined over any field F satisfying \mathrm{SL}_3(F)\cong \mathbb P\mathrm{GL}_3(F) , and such that n is not divisible by 3 . The vertices v_k in the projective plane \mathbb P^2(F) can be lifted to vectors V_k in the affine space F^3 so that each consecutive triple of vectors spans a parallelepiped having determinant equal to 1 . This leads to the relation defining the ab -coordinates: V_{k+3} = a_k V_{k+2} + b_k V_{k+1} + V_k. This bring out an analogy between twisted polygons and solutions of third order linear ordinary differential equations, normalized to have unit Wronskian. They are linked to the corner coordinates by: x_k=\frac{a_{k-2}}{b_{k-2}b_{k-1}}, y_k=-\frac{b_{k-1}}{a_{k-2}a_{k-1}}.

Formulas on the moduli space

x_k'=x_k\frac{1-x_{k-1} y_{k-1}}{1-x_{k+1}y_{k+1}}, y_k'=y_{k+1}\frac{1-x_{k+2} y_{k+2}}{1-x_k y_k}. R_s\cdot(x_1,\dots,x_n,y_1,\dots,y_n)=(sx_1,\dots,sx_n,s^{-1}y_1,\dots,s^{-1}y_n), where R is called the scaling action and s is the scaling parameter. This action commutes with the pentagram map on the moduli space (as presented in the previous formulas). This property is called the scaling symmetry, and is instrumental in proving the complete integrability of the dynamics.

Invariant structures

Monodromy invariants

The monodromy invariants, introduced in , are a collection of functions on the moduli space that are invariant under the pentagram map. The simplest examples of them are O_n= x_1x_2\cdots x_{n}, \quad E_n = y_1y_2\cdots y_n. The other monodromy invariants can be retrieved through different points of view: through the scaling symmetry, as combinatorial objects, or as some determinants. The one involving scaling symmetry is presented here. Let M\in \mathrm{GL}_3 be a lift of the monodromy of a twisted n -gon. The quantities \Omega_1=\frac{\operatorname{trace}^3(M)}{\det(M)}, \quad \Omega_2=\frac{\operatorname{trace}^3(M^{-1})}{\det(M^{-1})}, are independent of the choice of lift and are invariant under conjugation, so they are well defined for the projective class of the polygon. They are invariant under the pentagram map, since the monodromy matrix doesn't change. Now, the quantities \tilde{\Omega}_1=O_n^2E_n\Omega_1, \quad \tilde{\Omega}_2=O_nE_n^2\Omega_2, have the same properties, but turn out to be polynomials in the corner invariants. They can be written as \tilde{\Omega}_1=\biggl(\sum_{k=0}^{\lfloor n/2\rfloor}O_k\biggr)^3, \quad \tilde{\Omega}_2=\biggl(\sum_{k=0}^{\lfloor n/2\rfloor}E_k\biggr)^3, where each O_k and E_k are homogeneous polynomials respectively of weight k and -k , meaning they change under the rescaling action on variables by R_s(O_k)= s^k O_k, \quad R_s(E_k)= s^{-k} E_k. The quantities O_1,\dots,O_{\lfloor n/2 \rfloor},O_n, E_1,\dots,E_{\lfloor n/2 \rfloor},E_n, are unchanged by the dynamics, and are called the monodromy invariants. Moreover, they are algebraically independent. Whenever P is inscribed in a conic section, one has O_k(P)=E_k(P) for all k . Moreover, if P is circumscribed about another conic, then its monodromy invariants are characterized by the pair of conics. For such odd-gons, the translation on the Jacobian variety is restricted to the Prym variety (which is a half-dimensional torus in the Jacobian).

Poisson bracket

An invariant Poisson bracket on the space of twisted polygons was found in . The monodromy invariants commute with respect to it: \{O_i,O_j\}=\{O_i,E_j\}=\{E_i,E_j\}=0 for all i,j . The Poisson bracket is defined in terms of the corner coordinates by: \begin{align} \{x_i,x_{i\pm1}\} &= \mp x_i x_{i+1}, \\ \{y_i,y_{i\pm 1}\} &= \mp y_i y_{i+1}, \\ \end{align} and \{x_i,x_j\} = \{y_i,y_j\} = \{x_i,y_j\} = 0 for all other i,j. Let \zeta be an element of the multiplicative group and P_\zeta be the polygon obtained by applying the rescaling action R_\zeta on P . A Lax matrix \hat{T}(\zeta) \in \mathrm{GL}_3 is a lift of the monodromy of P_\zeta satisfying a zero-curvature equation. Then, the spectral function is the bivariate characteristic polynomial Q(\lambda,\zeta) := \det(\lambda\operatorname{Id}-\hat{T}(\zeta)), or some renormalization of it. The spectral curve is the projective completion of the affine curve defined by the equation Q(\lambda,\zeta)=0 . It is invariant under the pentagram map, and the monodromy invariants appear as the coefficients of Q . Its geometric genus is n-1 if n is odd, and n-2 if n is even. It was first introduced in for his proof of algebro-geometric integrability.

Complete integrability

The pentagram map on the moduli space has been proved to be a completely integrable discrete dynamical system, both in the Arnold-Liouville and the algebro-geometric senses. In any case, this means that the moduli space is almost everywhere foliated by flat tori (or in the algebraic setting, Abelian varieties), where the motion is a translation. This generically induces a quasiperiodic motion on the corresponding torus.

Arnold–Liouville integrability

The proof of the integrability of the pentagram map on a real twisted polygon was achieved in . This is done by noticing that the monodromy invariants O_n and E_n are Casimir invariants for the Poisson bracket, meaning (in this context) that \{O_n,f\}=\{E_n,f\} = 0 for every smooth function f . When n is even, this is also true for the monodromy invariants O_{\lfloor n/2 \rfloor } and E_{\lfloor n/2 \rfloor } . This allows to consider the Casimir level set, where each Casimir invariant has a specified value. Because of Sard's theorem, any generic level set is a smooth manifold. This family of level sets forms a foliation in symplectic leaves, on which the Poisson bracket gives rise to a symplectic form. Each of these symplectic leaves has an iso-monodromy foliation, namely, a decomposition into the common level sets of the remaining monodromy functions. By using again Sard's theorem, they are generically Lagrangian manifolds. Moreover, they are compact. Since the monodromy invariants Poisson-commute and there are enough of them, the discrete Liouville–Arnold theorem can be applied to prove that the level sets are flat tori over which the dynamics is a translation.

Algebro-geometric integrability

In , it was shown that the pentagram map admits a Lax representation with a spectral parameter, which allows to prove its algebro-geometric integrability. This means that the space of polygons (either twisted or closed) is parametrized by its spectral data, consisting of its spectral curve, with marked points and a divisor given by a Floquet–Bloch equation. This gives an embedding to the Jacobian variety through the Abel–Jacobi map, where the motion is expressed in terms of translation. The previously defined Poisson bracket is also retrieved. This integrability was generalized in from the field of complex numbers to any algebraically closed field of characteristic different from 2. The translation on a torus is replaced by a translation on an Abelian variety (in fact, a Jacobian variety again).

Connections to other topics

The Boussinesq equation

The continuous limit of a convex polygon is a parametrized convex curve in the plane. When the time parameter is suitably chosen, the continuous limit of the pentagram map is the Boussinesq equation. This partial differential equation models water waves under some conditions, which is a classical example of integrable system. Here is a description of the geometric action of the Boussinesq equation. Given a locally convex curve C:\mathbb R\to \mathbb R^2 and real numbers x and t , consider the chord connecting C(x-t) to C(x+t) . The envelope of all these chords is a new curve C_t(x) . When t is extremely small, the curve C_t(x) is a good model for the time t evolution of the original curve C_0(x) under the Boussinesq equation. This construction is also similar to the pentagram map. Moreover, the pentagram invariant bracket is a discretization of an invariant Poisson bracket associated to the Boussinesq equation.

Cluster algebras

The pentagram map and some of its generalizations are identified as special cases of discrete dynamical systems powered by cluster algebras. Using the results from , this provides a link with the Poisson–Lie groups, dimer models and other so-called cluster-integrable systems. These methods allow to retrieve the Poisson bracket and Hamiltonians used to prove complete integrability and provide Lax representations. T_{sh}v_k:=H_k^{sh}\cap H_{k+1}^{sh}\cap \dots \cap H_{k+d-1}^{sh}. Doing this for every vertex defines a new twisted polygon. This map, denoted by T_{sh} , is again projectively equivariant. The previous procedure can be generalized. Let I=(i_1,\dots,i_{d-1}),~J=(j_1,\dots,j_{d-1}) be two sets of integers, respectively called the jump tuple and the intersection tuple. Define H_k^I to be the unique hyperplane passing through the vertices v_k,v_{k+i_1},\dots,v_{k+i_1+\dots+i_{d-1}} . A new point is given by the intersection T_{I,J}v_k:=H_k^I \cap H_{k+j_1}^I \cap \dots \cap H_{k+j_1+\dots +j_{d-1}}^I. The map T_{I,J} is called a generalized pentagram map. The original pentagram map is recovered by considering d=2,~I=(2),~J=(1) . Integrability can be numerically tested by picking a random polygon P with rational coordinates and studying the growth rate of the height of its iterates. This is called the diophantine integrability test, and some generalized pentagram maps don't seem to pass it. However, it is conjectured that the maps T_{I,I} are integrable for any I . Some of these maps are discretizations of higher dimensional counterpart of the Boussinesq equation in the KdV hierarchy. Fix an integer m\in \{1,\dots ,d-1\} . Consider the jump tuple I_m:=(1,\dots,1,2,1,\dots,1) , where the 2 is at the m -th place, and the intersection tuple J:=(1,\dots,1) . The dented pentagram map is T_m :=T_{I_m,J} . They are proved to be integrable. For an integer p \geq 2 , the deep dented pentagram map (of depth p ) T_m^p is the same map as before, but the number 2 in the definition of I_m is replaced by p . This kind of pentagram maps are integrable too. T_\text{cor}v_k:=\overline{v_k v_{k+d}}\cap \overline{v_{k+1} v_{k+d+1}}. The map T_\text{cor} yields a new corrugated polygon. This dynamics is completely Liouville-integrable. In fact, they can be retrieved as some dented pentagram map applied on corrugated polygons. Let d \geq 3, m \geq 1 be integers. The pentagram map can also be generalized to the Grassmannian space \mathrm{Gr}(m,md) , which consists of m -dimensional linear subspaces of an md -dimensional vector space. When m=1 , the linear subspaces are lines, which retrieves the definition of projective spaces \mathbb P^d . A point v\in\operatorname{Gr}(m,md) is represented by an md \times m matrix X_v such that its columns form a basis of v . Consider the action of the general linear group \mathrm{GL}_{md} by multiplication on the left of X_v . This defines an action on the Grassmannian, even though it is not faithful. Hence, the polygons of \mathrm{Gr}(m,md) and their moduli spaces are defined as before, after the change of underlying group. Depending on the parity of d , one can define linear subspaces spanned by some X_{v_k} 's such that taking their intersection generically defines a new point v\in\mathrm{Gr}(m,md) . This generalization of the pentagram map is integrable in a noncommutative sense.

Notes

Works cited

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378839398 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

No external citation was extracted for this revision. That is a statement about the source, not a claim that none exists.