Pirahã language

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 14 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

Pirahã (also spelled Pirahá, Pirahán), or Múra-Pirahã, is the indigenous language of the Pirahã people of Amazonas, Brazil. The Pirahã live along the Maici River, a tributary of the Amazon River. Pirahã is estimated to have between 250 and 380 speakers.

It is not in immediate danger of extinction, as its use is vigorous and the Pirahã community is mostly monolingual. The Pirahã language is the subject of various controversial claims: for example, that it provides evidence against linguistic relativity.

The controversy is compounded by the difficulty of learning the language; the number of linguists with field experience in Pirahã is very small. Consequently, many claims which identify Pirahã as exhibiting features contradictory to the most normative understanding of human language cognition have not as of yet engendered considerable confidence.

Pirahã (also spelled Pirahá, Pirahán), or Múra-Pirahã, is the indigenous language of the Pirahã people of Amazonas, Brazil. The Pirahã live along the Maici River, a tributary of the Amazon River. Pirahã is estimated to have between 250 and 380 speakers.

It is not in immediate danger of extinction, as its use is vigorous and the Pirahã community is mostly monolingual. The Pirahã language is the subject of various controversial claims: for example, that it provides evidence against linguistic relativity.

The controversy is compounded by the difficulty of learning the language; the number of linguists with field experience in Pirahã is very small. Consequently, many claims which identify Pirahã as exhibiting features contradictory to the most normative understanding of human language cognition have not as of yet engendered considerable confidence.

Name

Speakers refer to their language as , and to their own ethnic group as .

Phonology

The Pirahã language is one of the phonologically simplest languages known, comparable to Rotokas (New Guinea) and the Lakes Plain languages such as Obokuitai. There is a claim that Pirahã has as few as ten phonemes, one fewer than Rotokas, or even as few as nine for women, but this requires analyzing as an underlying and having /h/ invariably substituted for /s/ in female speech.

Although such a phenomenon is odd cross-linguistically, Ian Maddieson has found in studying Pirahã data that does indeed exhibit an unusual distribution in the language. When languages have inventories as small and allophonic variation as great as in Pirahã and Rotokas, different linguists may have very different ideas as to the nature of their phonological systems.

Pronouns

The basic Pirahã personal pronouns are: "I, we" or "you" "they (sg. or pl), this" These can be serially combined: or to mean "we" (inclusive and exclusive), and to mean "you (plural)", or combined with 'all', as in "we (all) go". There are several other pronouns reported, such as 'she', 'it' (animal), 'it' (aquatic animal), and 'it' (inanimate), but these may actually be nouns, and they cannot be used independently the way the three basic pronouns can.

The fact that different linguists come up with different lists of such pronouns suggests that they are not basic to the grammar. In two recent papers, Everett cites Sheldon as agreeing with his (Everett's) analysis of the pronouns.

According to Sheldon, this is the list of pronouns: Pronouns are prefixed to the verb, in the order SUBJECT-INDOBJECT-OBJECT where INDOBJECT includes a preposition "to", "for", etc. They may all be omitted, e.g., "he will send you to me". For possession, a pronoun is used in apposition (zero-marking): Thomason & Everett note the pronouns are formally close to those of the Tupian languages Nheengatu and Tenharim, which the Mura had once used as contact languages: Both the Tupian and Pirahã third-person pronouns can be used as demonstratives, as in Pirahã "I am really smart" ( "This one sees well: me").

Given the restricted set of Pirahã phonemes, the Pirahã pronouns and are what one would expect if the Tupian pronouns were borrowed, and differs only in dropping the .

Verbs

Pirahã is agglutinative, using a large number of affixes to communicate grammatical meaning. Even the 'to be' verbs of existence or equivalence are suffixes in Pirahã.

For instance, the Pirahã sentence "there is a paca there" uses just two words; the copula is a suffix on "paca": Pirahã also uses suffixes that communicate evidentiality, a category lacking in English grammar, but present in languages such as Turkish, Georgian, and Japanese. One such suffix, , means that the speaker actually observed the event in question: (The suffix -sai turns a verb into a noun, like English '-ing'.)

Other verbal suffixes indicate that an action is deduced from circumstantial evidence, or based on hearsay. Unlike in English, in Pirahã speakers must state their source of information: they cannot be ambiguous. There are also verbal suffixes that indicate desire to perform an action, frustration in completing an action, or frustration in even starting an action.

There are also a large number of verbal aspects: perfective (completed) vs. imperfective (uncompleted), telic (reaching a goal) vs. atelic, continuing, repeated, and commencing. However, despite this complexity, there appears to be little distinction of transitivity. For example, the same verb, , can mean either 'look' or 'see', and can mean either 'die' or 'kill'.

The verbs are, however, zero-marked, with no grammatical agreement with the arguments of the verb. According to Sheldon, the Pirahã verb has eight main suffix-slots, and a few sub-slots: Slot A intensive Ø Slot B causative/incompletive causative/completive inchoative/incompletive inchoative/completive future/somewhere future/elsewhere past Ø Slot C negative/optative + C1 Slot C1 preventive opinionated possible Ø positive/optative negative/indicative + C2 positive/indicative Ø + C2 Slot C2 declarative probabilistic/certain probabilistic/uncertain/beginning probabilistic/uncertain/execution probabilistic/uncertain/completion stative interrogative1/progressive interrogative2/progressive interrogative1 interrogative2 Ø Slot D continuative repetitive Ø Slot E immediate intentive Ø Slot F durative Ø Slot G desiderative Ø Slot H causal conclusive emphatic/reiterative + H1 emphatic + H1 reiterative + H1 Ø + H1 Slot H1 present past pastImmediate These suffixes undergo some phonetic changes depending on context.

For instance, the continuative reduces to after a consonant: Also an epenthetic vowel gets inserted between two suffixes if necessary to avoid a consonant-cluster; the vowel is either (before or after , , or ) or (other cases): Conversely, when the junction of two morphemes creates a double vowel (ignoring tones), the vowel with the lower tone is suppressed:

Embedding

Everett originally claimed that in order to embed one clause within another, the embedded clause is turned into a noun with the suffix seen above: The examples of embedding were limited to one level of depth, so that to say "He really knows how to talk about making arrows", more than one sentence would be needed. Everett has also concluded that because Pirahã does not have number-words for counting, does not allow recursive adjective-lists like "the green wealthy hunchbacked able golfer", and does not allow recursive possessives like "The child's friend's mother's house", a Pirahã sentence must have a length limit.

This leads to the additional conclusion that the number of different possible sentences in Pirahã with any given vocabulary is finite. Everett has also recently reinterpreted even the limited form of embedding in the example above as parataxis. He now states that Pirahã does not admit any embedding at all, not even one level deep.

He says that words that appear to form a clause in the example are actually a separate unembedded sentence, which, in context, expresses the same thought that would be expressed by a clause in English. He gives evidence for this based on the lack of specialized words for clause-formation, the pattern of coreferring tokens in the purported clause-constructions, and examples where the purported clause is separated from the rest of the sentence by other complete sentences.

Everett stated that Pirahã cannot say "John's brother's house" but must say, "John has a brother. This brother has a house." in two separate sentences.

According to Everett, the statement that Pirahã is a finite language without embedding and without recursion presents a challenge for proposals by Noam Chomsky and others concerning universal grammar—on the grounds that if these proposals are correct, all languages should show evidence of recursive (and similar) grammatical structures. Chomsky has replied that he considers recursion to be an innate cognitive capacity that is available for use in language but that the capacity may or may not manifest itself in any one particular language.

However, as Everett points out, the language can have recursion in ideas, with some ideas in a story being less important than others. He also described recursive behaviors in deer as they forage for food. So to him, recursion can be a brain property that humans have developed more than other animals.

He points out that the criticism of his conclusions uses his own doctoral thesis to refute his knowledge and conclusions drawn after a subsequent twenty-nine years of research. Everett's observation that the language does not allow recursion has also been vigorously disputed by other linguists, who call attention to data and arguments from Everett's own previous publications, which interpreted the "-sai" construction as embedding.

Everett has responded that his earlier understanding of the language was incomplete and slanted by theoretical bias. He now says that the morpheme attached to the main verb of a clause merely marks the clause as 'old information', and is not a nominalizer at all (or a marker of embedding).

In 2010 a research points to a tonal distinction in the use of "-sai" when the sentence might include embedding, but a later research by a different group also found instances of the same tonally distinct "-sai" used in simple sentences.

Vocabulary

Pirahã has a few loan words, mainly from Portuguese. Pirahã ("cup") is from the Portuguese word , and ("business") comes from Portuguese ("merchandise").

Kinship terms

Everett says that the Pirahã culture has the simplest known kinship system of any human culture. A single word, (pronounced ), is used for both 'mother' and 'father' (like English "parent", although Pirahã has no gendered alternative), and they appear not to keep track of relationships any more distant than biological siblings.

Numerals and grammatical number

According to Everett, Pirahã has words for 'one' ( ) and 'two' ( ), distinguished only by tone. In his 2005 analysis, however, Everett said that Pirahã has no words for numerals at all, and that and actually mean "small quantity" and "larger quantity" (or like English "fewer/less" and "more").

Michael Frank, Everett, and several others have described two experiments on four Pirahã speakers that were designed to test these two hypotheses. In one, ten spools of thread were placed on a table one at a time and the Pirahã were asked how many were there.

All four speakers answered in accordance with the hypothesis that the language has words for 'one' and 'two' in this experiment, uniformly using for one spool, for two spools, and a mixture of the second word and 'many' for more than two spools. The second experiment, however, started with ten spools of thread on the table, and spools were subtracted one at a time.

In this experiment, one speaker used (the word previously supposed to mean 'one') when there were six spools left, and all four speakers used that word consistently when there were as many as three spools left. Though Frank and his colleagues do not attempt to explain their subjects' difference in behavior in these two experiments, they conclude that the two words under investigation "are much more likely to be relative or comparative terms like 'few' or 'fewer' than absolute terms like 'one .

There is no grammatical distinction between singular and plural, even in pronouns. A 2012 documentary aired on the Smithsonian Channel reported that a school had been opened for the Pirahã community where they learn Portuguese and mathematics.

As a consequence, observations involving concepts like the notion of quantity (which has a singular treatment in Pirahã language) became impossible, because of the influence of the new knowledge on the results.

Pirahã and linguistic relativity

The concept of linguistic relativity postulates a relationship between the language a person speaks and how that person understands the world. According to Michael Frank, Daniel Everett, and others: A total lack of exact quantity language did not prevent the Pirahã from accurately performing a task which relied on the exact numerical equivalence of large sets.

This evidence argues against the strong Whorfian claim that language for number creates the concept of exact quantity. [...]

Instead, the case of Pirahã suggests that languages that can express large, exact cardinalities have a more modest effect on the cognition of their speakers: They allow the speakers to remember and compare information about cardinalities accurately across space, time, and changes in modality. [...]

Thus, the Pirahã understand the concept of one (in spite of having no word for the concept). Additionally, they appear to understand that adding or subtracting one from a set will change the quantity of that set, though the generality of this knowledge is difficult to assess without the ability to label sets of arbitrary cardinality using number words.

In short, in this study the Pirahã were – by and large – able to match exact quantities of objects set before them (even larger quantities), but had difficulty matching exact quantities when larger quantities were set before them and then hidden from view before they were asked to match them. Being concerned that, because of this cultural gap, they were being cheated in trade, the Pirahã people asked Daniel Everett to teach them basic numeracy skills.

After eight months of enthusiastic but fruitless daily study with Everett, the Pirahã concluded that they were incapable of learning the material and discontinued the lessons. Not a single Pirahã had learned to count up to ten or even to add 1 + 1. Everett argues that test-subjects are unable to count for two cultural reasons and one formal linguistic reason.

First, they are nomadic hunter-gatherers with nothing to count and hence no need to practice doing so. Second, they have a cultural constraint against generalizing beyond the present, which eliminates number-words.

Third, since, according to some researchers, numerals and counting are based on recursion in the language, the absence of recursion in their language entails a lack of counting. That is, it is the lack of need that explains both the lack of counting-ability and the lack of corresponding vocabulary. However, Everett does not claim that the Pirahãs are cognitively incapable of counting.

Bibliography

(Published version of University of Pittsburgh M.A. thesis.)

Piraha Alphabet (at Omniglot) Everett, Daniel. Home page ( ) Pirahã language - by Professor Marco Antonio Gonçalves (UFRJ) in Encyclopedia of Indigenous People in Brazil Pirahã Dictionary/ Dicionário Mura-Pirahã ( ) Mura-Pirahã Dictionary Etnolinguistica.Org: discussion list on native South American languages NPR: Tribe Helps Linguist Argue with Prevailing Theory Unlocking the Secret Sounds of Language: Life Without Time or Numbers — article in The Independent New Yorker article 'The Interpreter' (abstract) Brazil's Pirahã Tribe: Living without Numbers or Time — Spiegel Audio sample of sung Pirahã — two boys singing about a day's events BBC Radio 4, The Material World: The Language of the Piraha — Prof. Daniel Everett discusses the linguistic significance of the language with Prof. Ian Roberts.

(video), presentation for the Rosetta Project Sample1 and Sample2 of Pirahã, spoken by native speakers. Audio recordings of words lists in Pirahã, spoken by native speakers (UCLA Phonetics Lab Archive).

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378105733 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

Sources cited in this revision

14 named source(s) extracted from the cited revision. A source with no author is shown by its publication; nothing is invented.