Platform cooperative

A platform cooperative, or platform co-op, is a cooperatively owned, democratically governed business that establishes a two-sided market via a computing platform, website, mobile app or a protocol to facilitate the sale of goods and…

Uses your system voice; voice and rate in settings.

Snapshot

≈ 13 min read

Names in other languages

No names in other languages are held for this entry yet.

Article bodies are English and are not machine-translated. A name in another language is not a translation of the article.

A platform cooperative, or platform co-op, is a cooperatively owned, democratically governed business that establishes a two-sided market via a computing platform, website, mobile app or a protocol to facilitate the sale of goods and services. Platform cooperatives are an alternative to venture capital-funded platforms insofar as they are owned and governed by those who depend on them most—workers, users, and other relevant stakeholders.

Platform cooperativism is an intellectual framework and movement which advocates for the global development of platform cooperatives. Its advocates object to the techno-solutionist claim that technology is, by default, the answer to all social problems.

Rather, proponents of the movement claim that ethical commitments such as the building of the global commons, support of inventive unions, and promotion of ecological and social sustainability as well as social justice, are necessary to shape an equitable and fair social economy. Platform cooperativism advocates for the coexistence of cooperatively owned business models and traditional, extractive models with the goal of a more diversified digital labor landscape respecting fair working conditions.

Platform cooperativism is not exactly about digital disintermediation, since a co-op, which is a legally constituted moral entity, owns the digital platform.…

A platform cooperative, or platform co-op, is a cooperatively owned, democratically governed business that establishes a two-sided market via a computing platform, website, mobile app or a protocol to facilitate the sale of goods and services. Platform cooperatives are an alternative to venture capital-funded platforms insofar as they are owned and governed by those who depend on them most—workers, users, and other relevant stakeholders.

Platform cooperativism is an intellectual framework and movement which advocates for the global development of platform cooperatives. Its advocates object to the techno-solutionist claim that technology is, by default, the answer to all social problems.

Rather, proponents of the movement claim that ethical commitments such as the building of the global commons, support of inventive unions, and promotion of ecological and social sustainability as well as social justice, are necessary to shape an equitable and fair social economy. Platform cooperativism advocates for the coexistence of cooperatively owned business models and traditional, extractive models with the goal of a more diversified digital labor landscape respecting fair working conditions.

Platform cooperativism is not exactly about digital disintermediation, since a co-op, which is a legally constituted moral entity, owns the digital platform. It is different from platform corporations like Uber, in that the governance of the digital platform is democratic.

There are some similarities with the peer-to-peer production movement, influenced by Michel Bauwens and Vasilis Kostakis, which advocates for "new kinds of democratic and economic participation" as far as it is concerned with "the free participation of equal partners, engaged in the production of common resources". Economically and institutionally it is more distant from the radically distributed, non-market mechanisms of commons-based peer production promoted by Yochai Benkler., although they share some ethical considerations.

Marjorie Kelly's book Owning Our Future contributed the distinction between democratic and extractive ownership design to this discussion. While platform cooperatives are structured as cooperatives, granting democratic control to workers, customers, users, or other key stakeholders, companies and initiatives that support the ecosystem of the cooperative platform economy are considered a part of the platform cooperativism movement insofar as they attempt to encourage, develop, and sustain its development.

It has also been argued that, as the spread of platform cooperativism "will require a different kind of ecosystem—with appropriate forms of finance, law, policy, and culture—to support the development of democratic online enterprises".

Typology

While there is no commonly accepted typology of platform cooperatives, researchers often categorize platform cooperatives by industry. Some potential categories include: transportation, on-demand labor, journalism, music, creative projects, timebank, film, home health care, photography, data cooperatives, marketplaces.

Other typologies differentiate platform cooperatives by their governance or ownership structures. Platform cooperatives are a business model that differs from platform capitalism, prioritizing fairness and sharing over profit motive. On the other hand, platform capitalists, such as Airbnb and Uber, are more traditional multi-sided businesses focusing on profit and returns to investors.

These can also be referred to as capitalist platforms, while cooperativist platforms prioritize cooperation and fairness in addition to a profit motive. Projects like Wikipedia, which rely on unpaid labor of volunteers, can be classified as commons-based peer-production initiatives, which are distinct from platform cooperatives since they don't employ the same institutional framework and governance.

Public policy

The platform cooperativism movement has seen a number of global policy proposals and successes.

United States

NYC Council Member Brad Lander of Brooklyn's 39th District, founding co-chair of the Council's Progressive Caucus, released a report in 20161 entitled, "Raising the Floor for Workers in the Gig Economy: Tools for NYC & Beyond", which analyzes the contingent work sector in New York City and "presents policy tools for cities seeking to protect gig workers from wage theft and discrimination, provide access to portable benefits, and establish new frameworks for worker organizing". Under his leadership, the NYC Council unanimously passed the "Freelance Isn't Free Act", which provides freelance workers with a right to full and timely payment, along with new tools for enforcement, and amendments to the NYC Human Rights law to clarify that employment protections apply to independent and contingent workers.

In his report, NYC Council Member Brad Lander presented platform cooperativism as a model to help laborers in the digital economy. The US Department of Agriculture appeared to offer its support for the platform cooperativism movement with a feature story in the September/October 2016 issue of its magazine, Rural Cooperatives.

"Rural Americans have been organizing cooperatives to develop countervailing economic power against larger investor-owned corporations for more than a century. This cooperative movement has now moved into the sharing economy that has been developing throughout the country.

Wherever investor-owners of software platforms are satisfying the needs of rural asset owners and users, the sharing economy will be welcomed. However, when the need arises, cooperatively-owned software platforms are proving to be a viable alternative." Furthermore, policy does not necessarily have to be tailor-made for platform cooperatives in order to enable their growth.

For example, policy changes adopted for the cooperative agriculture sector in Colorado have now made it a hub for emerging platform cooperatives of all forms, to the extent where Colorado is now often described as the “Delaware of cooperative law.” This is in large part due to the detailed and novel nature of its state legislature on cooperatives broadly, not just platform coops.

For example, Limited Cooperative Associations (LCAs) are a more flexible model that have expanded voting rights within the association beyond “members” in the traditional sense, to create a second class of membership for “investor-members,” a position more enticing to capital-holders than traditional membership, embodying a sort of halfway house between the existing dichotomy. Colorado’s Uniform Limited Cooperative Association Act (UCLAA) enables this arrangement to act as a solution to the pervasive “Capital Conundrum” helping to generate the funding needed for platform cooperatives to compete with their traditional counterparts.

While some have cautioned against this approach as fundamentally against what coops stand for, even going so far as to label it a “trojan horse” that allows for “coop washing,” it has undeniably led to the growth of the general cooperative movement and has potential to continue to do so for the digital platform iterations of it too. Another example of broader cooperative-friendly policy that will especially aid platform cooperatives is the City of Berkeley’s Worker Cooperative Revolving Loan Fund.

Passed in 2016, the Revolving Loan Fund (RLF) sets aside public funds to offer below-market-rate loans to worker-owned businesses, including those that operate via digital platforms. Although on a different scale, Berkeley’s loan fund echoes how early federal grants (from agencies like DARPA and NASA) injected seed capital into tech research labs at Stanford and UC Berkeley, leading to spin-off companies that formed the backbone of Silicon Valley.

The next step is to craft policy that encourages the link between research universities like those, and creating spaces that foster innovation with a cooperative lens, in a similar vein to the uniquely enabling environment Silicon Valley provided the original gig economy.

United Kingdom

In 2016, Jeremy Corbyn, leader of the Labour Party and the Opposition in the United Kingdom, released a digital democracy manifesto calling for, among other policies, the fostering of "the cooperative ownership of digital platforms for distributing labour and selling services". He proposed that the National Investment Bank, as well as regional banks, would "finance social enterprises whose websites and apps are designed to minimise the costs of connecting producers with consumers in the transport, accommodation, cultural, catering and other important sectors of the British economy".

Organizations

Platform Cooperativism Consortium (PCC) The Platform Cooperativism Consortium is a "think-and-do tank" for the platform cooperativism movement based at The New School in New York City. As a "global network of researchers, platform co-ops, independent software developers, artists, designers, lawyers, activists, publishing outlets, and funders", it engages in research, advocacy, education, and technology-based projects.

It was launched in November 2016 at the occasion of the "Building the Cooperative Internet" conference. The Internet of Ownership Beginning in 2016, The Internet of Ownership was a website that included a global directory of platform cooperatives and a calendar of events concerning the platform cooperativism movement. It was maintained by Nathan Schneider and Devin Balkind.

In 2020, the Internet of Ownership directory stopped being maintained and was superseded by the Platform Cooperativism Consortium's directory of platform cooperatives.

Dominance of established players

Some critics of platform cooperativism claim that platform cooperatives will have trouble challenging established, venture-capital-funded platforms. Nick Srnicek writes that, due to "the monopolistic nature of platforms, the dominance of network effects, and the vast resources behind these companies ... even if all that software would be made open-source, a platform like Facebook would still have the weight of its existing data, network effects, and financial resources to fight off any co-op arrival."

Rufus Pollock expresses similar concerns that platform coops will face major challenges reaching adequate scale, particularly given their inability to raise traditional equity capital. In addition, he argues that coops often have slow and inefficient decision-making processes which will hamper them in their ability to compete successfully.

Finally, he points out there is the risk that platform coops will go "bad" becoming an exclusive club for their members (for example, a ride-sharing coop might end up controlled only by drivers who then exploit consumers). Evgeny Morozov writes that "Efforts at platform cooperativism are worthwhile; occasionally, they do produce impressive and ethical local projects.

There is no reason why a cooperative of drivers in a small town cannot build an app to help them beat Uber locally. But there is also no good reason to believe that this local cooperative can actually build a self-driving car: this requires massive investment and a dedicated infrastructure to harvest and analyze all of the data.

One can, of course, also create data ownership cooperatives but it's unlikely they will scale to a point of competing with Google or Amazon." While this may be true in certain sectors, Arun Sundararajan claims that, "Economic theory suggests that worker cooperatives are more efficient than shareholder corporations when there isn't a great deal of diversity in the levels of contribution across workers, when the level of external competition is low, and when there isn't the need for frequent investments in response to technological change."

Using Uber as an example of a dominant platform, he continues: "Cab drivers, after all, offer a more or less uniform service in an industry with a limited amount of competition. Once the technology associated with 'e-hail' is commoditized, the potential for a worker cooperative appears to be in place, since each local market is contestable."

Regardless, the possibility of dominant platforms turning the flows of data they receive from their larger user-bases into market-securing technological innovations remains a challenge. For example, Uber seeks to use the data they currently collect from drivers using their app to automate the taxi industry, thus eliminating the need for their workforce altogether and likely dropping the value of a ride below that on which a human laborer can survive.

Difficulty securing early-stage capital

Though Sundararajan believes there are markets in which platform cooperatives might thrive, he finds their primary barrier to entry to be the initial securing of funds, especially given their ideological devaluation of the need to generate profits for investor-stakeholders. He does note, however, that a number of alternative fundraising models may pave the way for the widespread market-entry of platform cooperatives.

Among those he mentions is Fairshare, a stakeholder model that differentiates between founders, workers, users, and investors, each with distinct voting rights, payouts, and permissions to trade shares on the open market. Other models he mentions include crypto-coin crowdfunding, philanthropic investment, and "provider stock ownership programs" that mimic the traditional joint-ownership form of the "employee stock ownership program".

See also

Commons-based peer production Cooperative Sharing economy Solidarity economy Unionized cooperative Workers' self-management

Text derived from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1378528782 under CC BY-SA 4.0; modifications have been made.

References

  1. ↩Wikipedia “Platform cooperative” revision 1378528782 · retrieved 2026-10-20 release date (×1) · confidence 0.95 revision URL